the union must be developed , with a major institutional structure with a clear demarcation between the powers of the member states and the competences of the union is well aware that the existing treaties are inadequate and will not be a different , more efficient structure for us . it is first of all , the concern about the economic and social problems , despite a continuing growth as a result of years of effort from all of our fellow citizens are confronted with which we messages . the current situation , particularly for many self-employed hauliers , for agriculture is unacceptable to all cases , must be improved . the understanding on the procedure is good , but we must ensure that the system is not as a political schlagwaffe can be used . you now have the clear in view of the rights they must comply with . i agree with his a warning for some tempting will return to the methods of intergovernmental cooperation . many of us want a federation of nation states . it also implies that each of its proper place will take place . the rapporteurs have stressed the need to go further . i can only agree with the level of debate and of course . the latter , i would like to say that it is a familiar with them and they must be a political speech must always be realistic and is always the kräftesituation and all of us to take account of the objectives of the weigh , because the forces concerned study , speech . i would like to start a few examples of the new capacity to provide this closer cooperation , we in europe . the vote will take place today at 12.30 p.m . the commission must reject amendment no 12 . i will vote for the adoption of the regelungsentwurfs . so in the reports of the european court of auditors constantly referred to portugal , greece , the information on such low always happen again . we have therefore voted for this report . the intermediaries , not only be worldwide , but also in this respect , cheaper and more environmentally friendly , as their fuel consumption per passenger is less such buses . the report also calls on the definition of benchmarks , with a view to the dissemination of best practices in the eu . a binding charter with the rights and all-embracing recoverable could at a later date difficulties . i would like to thank both for their excellent work . we believe that it is less than three months after concluded in nice . for this reason alone we cannot vote in favour of the charter , but not at the summit in nice in the treaty . the csu-europagruppe that the citizens of the charter of fundamental rights to the eu institutions and their fundamental rights summarised made visible . welcomes this schlussentwurf it is a reflection of the emerging in liberal europe . i would have liked to further , as many ngos from various countries of the european union because of this charter will work proposed . ( a5-0248 / 2000 ) by mr queiró [ com ( 1999 ) 1997 / 2175 ( cos ) ] ; hungary to 505 - c5-0028 / 2000 - that is why i should like to propose to you that we as parliament , in the coming year , no longer present , only länderberichte , in order to make it clear that we progress of the negotiations for a differentiated generalbericht concerns . it seems to me that the french presidency on the basis of the work of the previous presidencies and the commission will be able , at least i hope that - a very accurate overview of the accession process . further at the nice european council as i have already said , and would like to repeat here , the french presidency will none of the difficulties , which would , of course , evade the time , the possibility of each of these difficulties and does not mean that we are auszudiskutieren . this question is , of course , perfectly understandable , but must be properly and precise reply . it is a great perspective , we must tackle the großherzigkeit and vision . not every outcome of the intergovernmental conference would meet the enormous anpassungsdruck of enlargement . the second major change we are seeing and europe must stop the galloping speeding up the economic development towards the global market and to the global competition . fourthly , hence , as yet another principle that the member states , later , on which , in the past have begun a fair chance of aufzuschließen started . where are necessary in order to achieve standards should be borne in mind that the current members of the large and long-term investment in these cases long transition periods are used . for border security and crime , will also be our standards and the benefits of european cooperation . but if we look at the current trade between the european union and the central and eastern european countries . fortunately , the commissioner has now finally be communicated to the citizens for the first time , the fears which , as has already been mentioned , are unfounded . but one thing is clear - and i welcome mr verheugen has stressed once again : it is not in a transitional period for the respect democratic rules . we need to help the commission , because it is sometimes determination to us in the relevant ammunition . this is necessary so that we , as the european union targets , the internal reforms to a conclusion . but there are important issues and , in which we disagree . this is damaging to the european union , its future independence in north america and a common european defence and security policy , because it involves risks for the relationship with russia and other countries . we hope , however , that what we want results , and in preparation for enlargement must be done , not a other intergovernmental conference should be postponed . i shall be brief as i have already been done earlier in my first speech , i have three minutes i have not used . this is very important , and i am very pleased that the commission an information campaign is , after the words of commissioner verheugen both comprehensive and decentralised is to be carried out . but i am not a pessimist - well , i am not at the time , i want to have a clear statement in favour of enlargement - to remain credible , we must be seriously , we must be understood , we must , of the peoples of the candidate countries and also - and this is my last word , because i would like this is quite clear : this issue in the approval of the people of our peoples , win . at the moment i see no need , in the context of enlargement on the financial perspective to discuss . it is not a single , i can say today . for the same reason , you have expressed the wish to join the european union . we shall now give the floor to the various rapporteurs . i have been responsible task , the report on the request of estonia 's accession to the european union at present . i am very careful with conservative of taxpayers ' money . i believe , then they would have an idea of what the people of latvia in recent years have done . this is not enough , the whole of the strategy must be geared more to the citizens . lithuania has a considerable potential for a long-term economic growth . in the broadest sense , the cooperation of the european union with the russian federation . another point is neuralgischer the support of the public in and outside the european union . as a result of wise fiscal policy , the foreign direct investment in the last year on more than 5,45 billion euros . we should not be involved , not even we germans ! the slovak stable , and in this area , we had already else seen developing democracy . in my speech i shall six aspects of the development of the situation in hungary and to systematisieren under the angle of joining the union are important . that is why i am pleased that this issue in the general report on the enlargement of the honourable member , mr brok . this is probably no more than in the area of nuclear power , where there is a danger of the lobby of the legitimate concerns in relation to nuclear safety and environmental protection for their own ends usurpiert kernkraftgegner area . i would like to thank mr endorses the formation of a high level group recommend . the report also unanimously approved in committee , is the part of the territory of the legal authorities , attached to the conclusion that fulfils the political copenhagen criteria . this is the key role for the cfsp high representative , javier solana , to what the role of the commission is , of course , our own unaffected . the main problem is that the accession process and the european union stresses that this accession process is constantly malta but remains government and opposition to judged differently . even the united states and between the levels close together . this is why we in the area of the single market for a sensible , flexible and the challenge of a strategy mexico are appropriate . i must say that i had the courage to go , and this process in motion , but also respect for the citizens in central and eastern european countries have ten years ago , on the strasse with brought . the information society is important for the old as for the new industry . we must not by the percentages of community law in national legislation umgesetztes merely drink . the 10 new countries of eastern europe have not seen such a rich erbonkel . this applies equally to the transport of live animals , subhuman - to the slaughterhouses . now , we are working on a system for all important health consequences for an assessment of the legislation . in my opinion , must also be made clear that the european fund for regional development , not on the basis of a purely accounting in the regions and areas can be given to the european union received and continue to distribution . elmar brok is right to his speech by pointing out that we are all the beneficiaries of enlargement , in particular , we will be taken on this side of the current external borders . the binnenschiffverkehr will be important for environmental reasons , because we must get away from the roads , and if we do not rail transport , then we must use massengüter waterways . also , not least , have played a role , and the euro exchange rate has certainly not a positive effect on the outcome of afforded selfishness and populism . our message to the candidate countries is : do not by the scale of the reports and documents upset . unfortunately , many of the parties have their ideological federn abgestreift with the result that it ideals and materialistisch little embody currently . should it be necessary , the right to free acquisition of land and eigenheimen suspend , we should do this . it is now exist , but perhaps by bureaucratic and apparent lack of transparency , but not a threat to public resistance of some governments . where are the millions of jobs in the maastricht treaty should bring ? while we are to be some of the next reform of the treaties , new demand . almost all international studies show in the context of enlargement on macroeconomic out profits . however , the main objective of the slovenian policy - the earliest possible accession to the european union - apart from some minor minorities of no political grouping called into question . the enlargement of the union quickly put in place , it would be decentralised to a large extent , as the group of the eldr formulated in its opinion on enlargement . it was clear that for the country typical long-term consequences for the health of the strictly orderly anstaltsregime orphans . i ask you to support the corresponding amendments . and even we in the european politicians , have little insight into the negotiating process . cyprus is almost as a bridge to the countries in this region to act . i wish the negotiators to success in this important area . a second type of communication between our countries and the candidate countries , in order to explain what it is , of course , also important in the european union . we cannot afford to lose from the beginning of the 1990s , the more momentum . mr president , first of all , as rapporteur i should like to congratulate the rapporteur on her excellent product of the socialist group for the report on romania . for the institutions , for the member states , for all of us , it is a question of this challenge , but also the fears of our own public grown to show the force of the founding fathers of europe and the visionskraft and again , the ambition to be found . unfortunately i have the impression that this process of enlargement despite many fine words and , despite hard-working and many of the council pressing on with the necessary political öffnens schließens chapter . many countries of the union had a certain time of its development with similar problems can be discussed in order to help to overcome the current problems and bulgaria . democracy is not just a question of majorities , but above all the appropriate codecision is also a question of minorities . the applicant countries must treatment and their accession should only be dependent on their development . at the same time , we should recognize with commitment that countries such as lithuania try to wettzumachen lost ground . in this respect , it is in our interest to extend our legal and freiheitssystem romania , and this is certainly in a critical public debate with our argument . however , there is a great deal of agreement , and that is the matter in relation to enlargement . my group therefore supports the duration of the transition periods in the area of the environment to a maximum of five years . mr president , we absolutely must have a positive movement in the enlargement . of course , is still on the order of the accession of candidate countries , for example , to discuss the progress of the internal reforms , because there should be judged . i am pleased that the report as positive and slovenia - and i have several times , and the commissioner was able to examine this several times - really massive has initiated , as chairman of the delegation to fulfil the criteria . i think that the proposal for worthy of discussion . these forms of violence and the trafficking in women are already with all the resources , both within the eu and in the candidate countries to condemn and to combat . in conclusion , i would like to take this opportunity of the considerations and the concerns of many colleagues in the preparation of this report of the european parliament to examine in detail the issue of europe 's borders , and that the size of its enlargement and the appropriateness of the finally consider it to be necessary . - the minutes of the previous sitting have been distributed . thank you . in this house rightly pointed out that the rights of citizens in a europe of the union must be enshrined in the right again . i shall now put the request to postpone the committee on legal affairs and the internal market to the vote . we know that the undesirable substances in the long term , and dioxin , and heavy metals such as cadmium and mercury , lead to toxic substances , but rather to influence consumer akkumulierbare substances such as aflatoxin which we are talking about here is a very rarely acute . we can no longer find sinners today . if we permit this , it must at least one of control , and it must be made public , because this is a problem that must also be discussed in the public know that this verschneidung registration with the verschneidung . one thing must be clarified : the dioxin crisis was the result of criminal acts against existing regulations . mr president , i thank the ladies and gentlemen , i have spoken . this was a compelling necessity . the limit value for fishmeal differs from , for example , the limit value for not marine organisms manufactured from animal products proposed . it is time that we misleading this interpretation of the principle of subsidiarity , the patronage of our nations by brussels , day after day , developed , put an end . i am not toxic substances listed in combination with other substances , however , as the rapporteur 's view , the proposed measures are justified and must be controlled , even if this in itself , in the increased values . unfortunately , is a great deal in common bauernverstand industrial agriculture , where the animals have been reduced , and commodities überliefertem know , in the production units lost . the new regulations on many directives were brought together by the very detailed and complicated hygieneanforderungen distributed , harmonised and simplified . the number of those who have exactly the ingredients , according to my question is relatively small research . secondly : a change is very well but the producers of animal feed raw materials . they are much more in the future of ausgangsprodukten for farmers , the partien destroy . the compensation is needed , although there is the farmers themselves bear a great responsibility for the welfare of animals . it is expressly requested in amendment no 18 , water in the definition of feed to be included . on the basis of this scientific risk assessments of the member states appropriate measures to fixing limit values for these substances in animal feed , the commission will recommend . after the examination of the amendments tabled in this sitting , i welcome the support of parliament for the proposal . overall , the commission can accept amendments nos 15 of the 27 . i assume that this time no success . the commission has promised that they will work , and it has also announced that it is not until tomorrow will be completed . farmers need more time , at least in question , and to what extent in these compound feedingstuffs contain . know everything prozentangaben finally , i would like to thank the rapporteur , mr graefe zu baringdorf and mrs roth-behrendt sincerely for their reports and hope that the council in a constructive attitude of this issue and we as a transparent system of futtermitteldeklaration together to achieve . all this , we have clearly tragedy with bse , thanks to a genuine novel with a number of chapters has developed . pollutants which affect the health of humans and animals are not acceptable . however , we start with the positive . the proposal before us is the beginning of a number of initiatives on the basis of the white paper on food safety . thank you very much , commissioner . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) report ( a5-0248 / 2000 ) by mr queiró , on behalf of the committee on foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defence policy , on the request to hungary 's accession to the european union and the state of the negotiations [ com ( 1999 ) 505 - c5-0028 / 2000 - 1997 / 2175 ( cos ) ) report ( a5-0247 / 2000 ) by baroness nicholson of winterbourne , on behalf of the committee on foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defence policy , on the request of romania and to join the european union and the state of the negotiations [ com ( 1999 ) 510 - c5-0033 / 2000 - 1997 / 2171 ( cos ) ) the third and perhaps most condition is that the council to reach agreement , which efficient , effective and democratic functioning of the community after enlargement ensure new institutional agreements . europe must be planned on this excellent principle should also apply to promote the development of the institutions , the east , but at the same time , room for differences . sovereignty and for the great rather such within the european union . finally , i would like to stress that the enlargement process gradual and in line with the applicant countries must be anpassungsfortschritten . in the current context and in view of the vote , and the question , it is important that this parliament send a clear political signal for this enlargement is now to hear the enlargement of the european union . the european union is since its establishment of the reunification of the peoples . the criteria of copenhagen in 1993 , or to strengthen the rule of unbridled capitalism and the council on the democratisation of competitiveness , under the guise of ' acquis ' destructive . under these circumstances , the enlargement process to an increase in the populist and faschistoiden excesses which , in a headlong could lead to . we have just on the agenda of this sitting , which illustrates once again , as it badly with the acquis communautaire in practice , just a report on the equal opportunities for women and men in this area is happening . the poland and the house , the 1956 or the people 's democracies once the head of state and the people of jan palach for the freedom of access to the european refuse hungary in budapest battered capital prague , in the symbolic violence . opferte , with niederhielten by a fenstersturz absetzten kopernikus who would johannes-paul ii . a greater europe needs new tasks and responsibilities with more and more financial resources . i take this opportunity to offer the citizens and the elderly pensioners in estonia and hope that we will ensure a existence in the european union to allow my greetings to you . if latvia has adapted to cope with enlargement , i see no reason why the union should be included in the european union and its institutional structures and policies latvia not continue to make progress . if lithuania has adapted to cope with enlargement , i see no reason why the union should be included in the european union and its institutional structures and policies to progress is not lithuania . in the environment are national fund for environmental protection and the application of the ' polluter pays ' principle , to see progress with the creation of the ' ' . if the union opens the door to our common house is on this neuankömmling equity , justice , the country for too long . denied this poland i look forward to the imminent accession of the czech republic to the european union . . ( en ) i welcome the report by mr queiró , on the request to hungary 's accession to the european union and its conclusions , the majority support . i hope that bulgaria join the union in the not too distant future . poos report ( a5-0249 / 2000 ) it is a balanced and fair , the council should take note of the opinion seriously . in this context , i hope that the negotiations on the success of the accession of cyprus to the greek and turkish republic will be able to benefit from the benefits of ethnic group under the auspices of the united nations , so that together in a reunited . i welcome the report by mr poos , on the request of the republic of cyprus to join the european union . but we are on the extreme at the end of the food chain and , therefore , the last sammelbecken modified and verfälschte food for consumers . we are , in particular , to ensure that the food safety at european level and in concrete form from stable or from the field to the table , will be guaranteed . precisely because we really country greater solidarity between all the countries of the world , we have no intention of our vote for the development and cooperation equal to support a farce . the council informed parliament before the vote in committee , but in the short term , that deliberately further talks with me or parliament have been prevented . in my report i have a debate on this in parliament and the maximum transparency , but i also said that the transfer to the memory of the past , in order to keep alive in the fight against discrimination and not just a stronger representation and the involvement of ngos , greater accountability to the parliament , the presentation of an annual report and called for the use of prejudice . at the same time , must legitimate interests of employees . as the main responsibility in the regulation of diskriminierungsfragen best able to draw up the social partners are at work , workable solutions . jenny is coordinator of the access-charter-gruppe and i hearings on article 13 of the public has been invited . in fact , directives and to offer incentives , the member states in the fight against discrimination on the basis of the same basis , and allow the commission to fulfil its role as guardian of the treaties , but also in the social gathering discussion because action programmes . although this legal basis funds for new preparatory actions releases , their funding to a mittelreduzierung for other policies within this category could . we have before us is a proposal for a necessary but insufficient framework directive . we will have an opportunity to improve its mechanisms , after a certain anwendungszeit . i hope that the commission will in the light of this new directive deal carefully with the question of sex discrimination . i congratulate the commission and my colleagues who have worked on these reports . i welcome the recommendation in the mann report , weltanschaulichen organisations to be able , if necessary , as vocational requirement in the staff conditions , on this recital refer . the fact that the institutions of the new powers , proves that the european union in the field of equal opportunities , madam commissioner , i would like to thank the european commission is still plays a leading role and to make use granted by the treaty of amsterdam as quickly . the presence of many different kinds of discrimination in our societies confirmed the importance of this action programme , which the report by mr cashman . mr president , on behalf of the members of the bonino list , i would like to express our distress at the way the subject of discrimination , racism and xenophobia by the union and the member states . can the commissioner explain why the commission on this aspect ignored ? the second is the problem that ngos , however important they are asked , whatever their size of its kind and the implementation of its actions , in order to stay here for me . the group of the european liberal , democrat and reform party has a positive view of the activities of the european parliament , the special emphasis on the prevention of discrimination and the best practices , all of this , in particular , but also and above all . this is a challenge for all of us , because we all the people after the first impression judge . mr president , if we are to combat discrimination and against enacted , then we should admit their existence and even the fact that many of your expressions ' legal ' , as they are now to the alltagsbild rules . first of all , the unctad looks , and the united nations , the principle of positive measures , the welthandels- entwicklungskonferenz 1963 in geneva discrimination established . the information and awareness gain , in fact , a fundamental importance in this area , it must be done , so that a new mentality , new misconception and kept in mind , so that the people of widespread prejudices and can be removed once and for all to all citizens real equality is guaranteed by the preparatory work still behaviour . so it is now a question of what the political importance of the fight against discrimination is expressed in some aspects improved and the financing of the programme for the budget to be increased , with the two legislative initiatives , by progress to be discussed . in particular , the agreement on the principle of adjustments to the played a leading role in sweden and ireland , will now ensure that the employer in europe , and its procedures so that disabled people to change a real chance to acquire sonderausstattungen their jobs properly . the article 13 is the point of departure for a new objective of the eu : the fight against discrimination or the unequal treatment of the citizens of the reasons that are included in this article . secondly , i would like to point out that the commission with this first package unfortunately a serious has made a mistake , by the reasons for discrimination in einordnet an order of precedence . mr president , on a tolerate discrimination on grounds of religion is as little as any other form of discrimination . a great supporter of the secularism , i can , therefore , i do not support this idea . the noble idea of every citizen in connection with the other , is still part of factual part of a legal nature , obstacles to freedom of the greatest possible freedom , if equally is compatible today . one of these directives has already been adopted , and i am very optimistic that the other in november during the french presidency will be approved in a very short space of time . some are not in line with other legislation , for example , the amendment on the procedure in the committees . i must reject amendment no 38 and the proposed deletion of the list of permitted from article 5 , in cases of inequality are included on the basis of age . you have the important issue of vertragseinhaltung taken up . in this action programme for the first time joint projects are planned . it is clear that the code of conduct to be more effective , more countries join in the world . in article 7 of the code oblige the member states to prevent endbenutzer permissible weapons to be passed on . mr president , i confess that i am for the times in which the european parliament , but also by the various demands for measures to reduce the production and put the question we have been made , as arms production could be converted into a civil peace movements and trade unions considerations and continuous zurücksehne production . given the situation in the world today , after the end of the cold war and the collapse of the weapons of mass destruction aufrechterhaltenen balance of horror , would be a type of behaviour is by our continent and the irresponsible . these weapons are almost the symbol of the anarchy in many places in the world . the cfsp includes measures to krisenbekämpfung outside the borders of the union , but nothing could be described as a common defence policy . this aim , the export of weapons to crisis regions , which is taking place to prevent governments , which violate human rights , and in or in rüstungswettlauf . the commission has participated actively in the drafting of the joint action of the european union for small arms and light weapons in close cooperation with the member states . the next item is the debate on the commission communication on the european research area . other elements for longer periods of time involved with variable geometry , especially the union 's participation in national programmes , as it article 169 of the treaty provides for the introduction of the förderformen , half way between the projektförderung and institutional funding are located ; the use of ' instruments are laid down in the treaty ' . this hierarchisierenden nature , and we want to promote this depends on the förderform . you say that you dächten to a total shake-up of the framework programme . i believe that we need something that the european research area , something that goes beyond the framework programme , with the national programmes supplemented . we need a strukturierendes element , we must introduce a structure confers on today . methods only what the considerations , i think that we need to do something , because parliament is the joint research centre and the zukunftsforschungsinstitute , together with the stoa-referat in the individual member states are affected . it is leaps and bounds with the commission on the implementation of the european research area . it is a whole chapter on science and society , citizens . there was contacts with the authorities in greece , ireland and portugal to the governments of these countries to the commission to submit their projects under the cohesion fund as soon as possible . perhaps you have just mentioned , and it was not the fault of devoted exclusively to the cohesion fund , that you more detailed information in the last commission , is the lack of a service . my second question is as follows : in addition to the cohesion fund , there are countries which have been tabled and which you have already been approved by the community support frameworks , the structural funds , and so on . regionalprogramme countries what you definitive projects programmes ? 1989 , the commission has submitted a new proposal , the more flexibility should offer . i know the disproportionately high taxation , we should remind us that this is the responsibility of the member states are subject to the effect of the competition law in this situation must not pay more than the general rules for fair competition in europe , but should also apply here . statements by mr bolkestein to appreciate and i know that one of the principles in the treaties , is that foreign companies can , if generally in cases of domestic affairs . if you want to save fuel , then this is not by levies and by other besteuerungsformen . mr purvis , i would like to say that the problem of regional , national governments , but a part of their lives up to the electorate in those outlying regions and peripheral regions . natural disadvantages probably mr president , thank you , madam commissioner , for your information . last spring summer and a general revision of the european commission has carried out their activities and their workforce . there are such tasks . they are increasingly by tourists and businessmen exploited , the remarkably often come from europe . the commission believes that all companies will be able , in time to prepare for the final changeover to the euro , including the adapting their computer systems and the software heard . the theoretical political discussion is no longer on the agenda of the dangers of a referendum in general , but perhaps we can discuss the opportunity to another . this also applies to rises . recently was sent to the french authorities erinnerungsschreiben . the candidate countries , i can tell you that on this issue meetings with them have taken place and provisional agreement were concluded . the commission criticisms of various plant types of conventional seed imported cotton , including the traces of genetically modified seeds during the frühjahrsaussaat have cases of note herself . i am , however , with his services have , i am able to inform you that computerausstattung for private use in a directive on electrical products , the so-called niedrigspannungsrichtlinie and funkanlagen and equipment are laid down in the directive on basic safety requirements in relation to official or after kurzgeschlossen . would he agree with that , in my view , we distinguishes between security and safety at work in the classroom or the safety of a child that home at the computer is wrongly ? perhaps he schüttelt the hand of president khatami . aung san suu kyi lives today de facto under house arrest . i am therefore very hesitant , trade or more involve further measures in relation to trade , or investment demand . question no 15 by ( h-0769 / 00 ) : you referred to this , for example , to wahlkampfveranstaltungen you had visited . questions nos 16 to 44 will be replied to in writing . we are calling for a consolidated report , the european parliament should be examined and published . we producing countries of the world , we should instead concentrate on the transition to civilian production rather than to compete with other weapons . the five permanent members of the security council , whose task is to ensure heed these proposals and negotiate an agreement as quickly as possible , the twenty-first century is worthy of our security should actually about . the debate today marks an important step in the process of reform , the commission under mr prodi about a year ago was introduced . i get the idea that the commission in the race for producing a proposal within the time frame laid down in the reformweißbuch it has failed , all of the individual points exactly arbitration . therefore , i suggest that both the financial controller and the internal auditor should draw up annual reports on their detailed work . in the van hulten report is the right to exacerbated a workable approach for the exchange of best practices between the institutions advocated by the commission separation and necessary . i hope that should not repeat here ! if we provisions for the meeting of the committee of wise men independence demanded by the large institutions , we must all apply . in the past we have very often seen in the decision-making process and a loss of confidence in the european institutions have led to the long applicants to disappointment . i would like to say that this report is the first step in the construction of a bridge between the current system and that we want to achieve the commissioner is only an intermediate step . this means that it is , after the reform . this is the proposal before us . only if they are in a position , the sampling , selection , which often controlled , watered down . on simple declarations , we are all aware that the certainly not an easy task . i believe that we as politicians , as technicians are able to tackle the problem alone , of course , is not at all . fortunately , but the overwhelming majority of children and young people in a environment , the none of these problemmerkmale growth . i agree with the president of the commission has drawn up , it is for me , of course , that the principle of subsidiarity must be strengthened and that the eu , many areas of policy , which has not transcend borders . similarity with a constitution that such a list , must be fully to keep functions . wissensgebieten within a short space of time to be supplied to the house , and the communicate around the world for you and all the information from all over the world everyday life . they were arrested and said : ' will be taken quickly to the police in the series strange , is not so quickly . the legislator - and i would like to finish - cannot regulate everything , but it must sometimes to the rights and duties of any out . in addition , i have to education , training is the ability of the verstehens of pictures of the awareness of the young generations , the media to be critical and not something will be some understanding for the comments and to . nothing in the wake of the harmful effects , as if no progress , or at least it does not lead to eliminate the obstacles which the ausbildungsmobilität affected today is a report like this is no greater mobility , or will their views . in the various countries are different : it is a different rules in the areas of social security and tax law , or the lack of a common recognition of diplomas and praktikumsaufenthalten to solve problems , for example , grants , aufenthalts- . it is time that europe is the proper implementation of programmes such as socrates and youth for europe attention again . the mobility of students and teachers , show that the real shortcomings in education , but in the social and fiscal immigration are not talking primarily with the experience . as an example of this has been included in the socrates programme . it must be able to make a clear monitoring , control and , above all , must be set up a clear , if a beratungsstelle , a web-seite where the students their complaints . we therefore call upon the involvement of the group of people of researchers in the scope of the recommendations . but this is easier said than done . the debate is closed . we appreciate your approach , on the model of president jacques chirac or foreign minister , joschka fischer , orientation . the union must speak with one voice and a common defence and foreign policy sicherheitsfähigkeit develop . what we need is a entscheidungsforum to deal with the problems of central importance for both sides , such as the migration , the shift of production factors , or the supply of energy . in the resolution on the reports of the commission , on which you to vote later , this issue very closely dealt with . its indicators to be drawn up an assessment of the progress made possible . in addition to the ministerial conference on the profession of equality , but in the field of employment and social affairs council and the kolloquium equality in two important devoted specifically mentioned . afforded texts ' should ' the second is the principle of non-discrimination , including the ban on discrimination on grounds of sex . i would point out - the president-in-office has also mentioned - that the important cultural differences , of course of the great problems within the eu belong to the reports . the reports which we are discussing here reflect all of this . we must check that the directive on equality actually included in the legislation will take place . i believe that this is the first time in finland , for very many areas practicable and this is one of the commission must expect much gleichberechtigungsstrategie as part of the procedure followed . on behalf of the equal opportunities , the french women the right to work acquired thanks to the european union . as a french citizen is me such a point of view of the world , particularly alien . in spite of these comments , we will vote for this report , because we are , of course , for the equal opportunities , but above all , equal opportunities means that every respect . the freedom of choice mothers who adopted , without remuneration to educate , given the bill in the form of their own children in the short or long juvenile vandalism presented . i would like to remind you of our report on the rentenrechte in the event of divorce , finally , the services and the retirement age in the directive to be involved in this context splitting that for the survivors 1979 . the polish women were very grateful that we have made it clear that the representative of the attitude of the polish women was there , not reproduced . greater involvement of women at all levels of government and the deepening of democracy and for the preservation of peace and in all walks of life is essential to achieve . finally , i would like to say that the situation of women in the countries to prepare its accession to the european union . the council , and not least the men in europe , in the fight against frauenhandelsmafia . no , schulterzuckend or ignore these slave trade oust an enormous task in this area , it has therefore to politicians for good move . today , we can see from what was already clear , namely that this is a problem of equal opportunities and women are neither a category a homogeneous social group and we are a collectively , because we need global strategies for his solution to the reports and speeches we analyse many of us nor a structural nature . indeed , i have with some regret to note that maria de belém roseira these posts are not more bekleidet . two of its new sozialrechte speakers have mentioned , new steuerrechte . thirdly , they are the basis for a strategy of the european union - even in the charter of fundamental rights , it was important that we have an overview of the current situation , but also at national level , since the member states now in a comparative assessment of the national targets at the level available . the joint debate is closed . these amendments must be understood in the new context of the interinstitutional agreement , and that is why parliament cannot disregard the fact , these amendments , because it by the new interinstitutional framework in some way become irrelevant to be on comitology . i nonetheless believe that the text adopted by parliament at the time the new realities of the internal market and to guarantee that the rules of procedure to apply the same in its implementation and control and information in accepted amendments contain a greater messengers were much better account bore , since the elements of the liberalisation of the markets would continue to personally . if we want to accept the commitments must be careful to ensure compliance with its own rules , because the possibility of products on the community , why should it make any concessions to negotiate with us , then the effort to bring the european community as a first , if a country has schmuggelwege on the market that third countries ? in the same way on the application of the customs authorities in the member states , with the most modern automatisierten verwaltungsinstrumenten . it is parliament 's amendment , adopted by the council has been papierlose but now it is too late , because they took the vote in favour of it just now and the members . votes ( continuation ) a5-0198 / 2000 ) by mrs dybkjær on behalf of the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities on the annual reports of the commission in the european union - in 1997 , 1998 , 1999 ' [ com ( 1998 ) 302 / 1999 ) ( com ( 1999 ) 106 / 2000 ) ( com ( 2000 ) 123 - c5- 0290 / 2000 -1999 / 2109 ( cos ) ) - c5 ­ 0106 ' equal opportunities for men and women - c5-0289 report ( . ( fr ) i am today is not the first time an opinion on the mobility of students and teachers . this report is all the more important than it is a crucial moment for the european union , namely the forthcoming enlargement will be presented . discrimination cannot be combated through the creation of additional authorities , but only in the minds of people . - ( fr ) i have not voted for the mann report because , in particular , in fact necessary pursuit of equal treatment in employment and profession needs , therefore , not yet in excess of zeal , that the protection of the rule of law and respect for this totally forgotten went so far as to freedoms . as a representative of the secularism , the separation of church and state , i could not have my support . . ( en ) the snp welcomes this directive and its objective , to put an end to discrimination at work . if the directive should be possible , it must not be overloaded with literature and wishful thinking , in a legislative text acceptable , and nothing to do . the eplp has strong reservations , however , on the following areas : as a whole , the implementation of the training of workers and the interpretation of this directive on the part of the smes should be left to the member states in our opinion , the way in a schlichtungssystems ages for certain questions . mr van hulten in the interview with a positive agenda , but also a lack of efficiency and effectiveness in the decision-making process . managed to is right that we only then can begin , if we issues such as fraud and waste the reasons for my vote in favour of this report are mainly with the question of closer relations of the european union to achieve a common defence policy nato and the rapid linked . the report of the european waffenausfuhr as a solution for the future of regional conflicts in the border regions of europe is to be discussed . however , i cannot accept that this demand for a common defence policy and a european security and defence policy within the nato linked . . ( el ) the children are the first victims of violence on television . i welcome the fact that the results of this study now available . it is also a task to draw up a memorandum , the general principles for the protection of minors in the media contains the expertenausschuss at community level . dybkjær report ( a5-0198 / 2000 ) . ( el ) interestingly was here for the first time , the commission to assess the effectiveness of the annual reports recognise the need for the political initiatives . peru mr president , peru currently going through times of uncertainty , and we all hope that the current situation will be resolved by a process in which all civil and political rights , strengthen and consolidate the peace and democracy in a country which , in the last fifteen years 25 000 deaths had peru will have guaranteed . the word that we are dealing with here is ' democracy ' . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , the conditions under which elections in peru passed in may this year was unacceptable . b5-0793 / 2000 by mrs ainardi and others on behalf of the group of the confederal group of the european united left / nordic green left , on the situation of women in afghanistan . i therefore welcome the decision on the situation of women and contains a number of points clear support for the total by the taliban-führung to prevent further important point of power , as discrimination against women . the eu has an important task here . recognition of any of the member states , it must not , as long as the policy of the violations of human rights , and the systematic discrimination against women , will continue . this is the fact that the money to buy weapons used in the european institutions and the possible , we must eyes . however , the neighbouring countries in the improvement of their opportunities to drugs strongly support . i think the time for a suitable to remind you that the european union policy towards latin america must draw up , the possibly could prevent that these countries are , as you have occurred at regular intervals crisis situations . compassionate ladies and gentlemen , the commission as the house welcome the release of the spanish jesuitenpaters alejandro matos castro last week . b5-0782 / 2000 by mr haarder , on behalf of the group of the european liberal , democrat and reform party to macedonia : law on universities and higher education ; that is why we are all very pleased that this is a problem of higher education , at long last , perhaps a really good , contrary to the solution . in my opinion , this is a good example for all neighbouring countries , not only hatred , as it happens so often , but also for a peaceful , multi-ethnic society can serve as cradle education in particular on the education leads today . i would also like , we have found a solution in parliament would agree with all the parties . here i should perhaps take the opportunity to point out that the commission in cooperation with the high commissioner , mr van der stoel , already good experience . the debate today , we want to express our condolences to the first place , we are talking about what has happened , why is it going to happen , as we can now to the commission and the european parliament can contribute to such an incident that happened again . remedy and as for the future not only in . in any case , we are in favour of it as a matter of urgency , and for the reasons i explained earlier , we are against the amendments tabled , which is also the urgent procedure , this joint motion for a resolution and agreed in its present form . the amendment on this issue is already the subject of a directive and the amendment is , in any case , not just as the text itself . conditions : this is islands of scotland , not for the possible on the north sea crossing the european mainland , which i hope will be set up in the not too distant future for northern and western simply not acceptable . i welcome the greek government has now reversed this liberation . that is why the commission has following the sinking of the samina sank immediately put the request information on the application of existing community law , with the greek government express to obtain . i would like to raise the question of this and would ask you to clarify whether the bureau , following the abolition of the friday of the abolition of the thursdays certain side has begun . i would like to inform you that the mechanisms , so that we will continue to be able to take measures to support the serbian people in the reconstruction of the serbian people , that is , as soon as a voters will be set up , the following : firstly , the immediate lifting of sanctions and , secondly , a wirtschaftshilfepaket kostunicas government supported by the european union implemented as soon as the respect of its economy . in this hours in the streets of belgrade will perhaps decide whether the democratic change now entry and whether it should be peacefully . we condemn all acts as a provocation to values , in particular , what the holy places in jerusalem is concerned . we need people - as mr solana said - quite the symbolic zagreb hand rich in this part-session . that is the israeli army splittergeschosse have used in the intrusion into the body in parts , shells internationally , even in fighting between now and soldiers , banned against civilians are used . schockierendsten on police and the dozens of zerbersten i believe that europe can and must much in this direction , and we must act decisively and it is clear . consequently , we must all be done to reduce the schwelenden fire as quickly as possible . provocation , as the action of ariel sharon must omitted . this is the case , and that is why the european union , as in recent years , not been able to accept the usa alone is left to the role of mediator in the middle east , it all again today . we will not lofty objectives and our moral victims , because that would mean that perhaps thousands of people in serbia and yugoslavia could , therefore , the serbian people die . finally , i would like to propose a new government , with a delegation of parliament , together with this new yugoslav government plans for the construction of a new serbia as quickly as possible and as soon as yugoslav formed to travel to go there . madam president , ladies and gentlemen , it is clear that we in this parliament today may be a historic day , perhaps see the end of one of the last leg a totalitarian dictatorship in europe . mr president , there is a problem , in the german text for the topical and urgent debate , i do not know whether the other language versions of the gue group also happens - only the amendments included , but none of the motions for resolutions , and certainly not only - are the joint text . mr president , i just wanted to draw the attention of the shows what we need to vote for the colleagues on the batch of , documents this week . if parliament 's decision of the council table amendments , it would also remind you of croatia to the unemployment and social problems from the imposition of the country , but in this connection , there is no legal basis for such amendments could certainly schlankheitskur result . this is the opportunity for the same objectives in relation to the eib 's activities to demand . mr president , yesterday evening , we have here on serbia and there vollziehenden revolutionary changes spoken . i would therefore urge the ladies and gentlemen , but above all , appeal to the council , in the coming months in the negotiations on the budget for next year and then the commission proposal which , in my opinion , the entire cost , but also in other parts of the balkans , for the years as closely as possible to remain in croatia still considered best . in 1990 , the democratic elections were held in international judgment were fair and free . therefore , our full support to support it in the number of the applicant countries , because i believe that this is a profoundly european democratic and constitutional governed massive yes to this macro-financial assistance , yes to this , but at the same time , a strong request to the commission and really country and guarantee croatia has deserves . like the rapporteur , i wonder , however , whether the money available , particularly because it is then that will soon have large flows of money to serbia and the budget of the union should not really will have to be increased . the delegations of the croatian and in our parliament asked the council the mandate of the eib extend . i hope that as soon as possible and as croatia to the serbian people , the greatest respect , deserves our support contacts to be granted . ( parliament approved the minutes . in this sense , therefore , we call for women in the european parliament delegation to participate in a place where there is violence against women bridges to propose that we will launch an appeal , we will signatures collecting and the reports for participation in the delegation , precisely with the concerns of peace , to this : on tuesday and wednesday , between the instead . as a whole basques and suffering caused spaniard ; and basques have enough of the current conflict has been both new spaniards . madam president , you will recall that i have drawn attention to the plight of the british verfechters democracy james mawdsley , by the burmese authorities illegally detained at the last part-session . madam president , i really is the rules of procedure . this report , not to lead to a very important because it is the possibility of introducing the genetic engineering in production and therefore to be able to apply genetically modified products in the great political changes seems , is , in fact , on technically anmutende wine-growing . if we do not vote on the report , it will delays . the conseil - as you said - and this was rejected in properly informed rejection of this appeal d ' etat . however , such a case of the ppe group , but not to my colleagues , a political camp in italy consulted again today . this is why we are committed for the introduction of a social scoreboards , as it is for the internal market , with clear deadlines , zeitlimits with measures to be done . i hope that the council to the expectations of the parliament , and i hope there will be able , at the summit in nice ambitious objectives in a european social agenda , then we can work together in the next few years inspire you , madam minister , is to lay down . following the informal meeting of the council and the ngos working groups and committees of the council - urged him to convey your proposals - of course , the european parliament , the economic and social committee , the committee of the regions , the social partners , the presidency had all the players ' employment and social affairs ' on 8 july in paris . the debate on the quantitative and qualitative aspects and clearly defined in lisbon was a dual objective : comparison is inappropriate to more jobs and höherqualifizierte jobs . this mobility must be encouraged and at the same time , the protection career be guaranteed . we must try to gaps in existing and also to appoint and , in any case , to put the system to specify , on the agenda . the open coordination method is in our opinion , the right way to secure a social europe . the implementation of the community , a plan of action for the creation of jobs in the services sector and , especially in terms of the information society in lisbon promotes social objectives requires efforts . the commission can , of course , an important contribution , but the regional and social problems are enshrined in the specific conditions must be treated with a great deal of delicacy . the social dimension served to compensate for the folgenschwersten effects of economic policy . it would have been better to leave the original commission proposal as it was . congratulations , mr commissioner . it is an ambitious agenda , and i remember it well , as we in the last parliamentary term laborious progress in the social protection . i think it would be very well , to help women to reconcile their family and working life . i sometimes have the impression that the concept of modernisation is often the erosion of the social protection is meant . what are the main characteristics of substance ? it is difficult to establish goals , the european equally valid for all member states , because the reality is very different . it 49 amendments were tabled by the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities . in a proposed amendment annually on the subject of a debate here in parliament , together with the commission to carry out . another point is the increase in support of the community initiatives , including the implementation of legislation and the fight against discrimination in assessment of needs to additional , if necessary , and equality . it has not quite good ideas and gender equality , is unfortunately often failed in the past plans for the gemangelt their implementation . it is not that the voice of the women of a handful of forderungsprofis will be taken in the entire planet with public money , alive . it is the question of equality between men and women in the civil field , the enabling women in the full benefit of the human rights and freedoms . finally , i am that the male gender role stereotypes and combat ancient and start here players . we must thank her , however , that our debate persecuted because their present throughout the debate was actually not provided for . competition policy we are guilty of our companies the favourable conditions for their production and not least of its future planning . consumers must have access to a large range of quality products attractive prices , and that is the reason that , as far as the internal market and so on free competition is , as our citizens ultimately benefit . that is the beihilfenentscheidung nichtbeihilfenentscheidung or in the field of coal . point 16 of the report by mrs riis-jørgensen , calls for a greater control of mergers and a more effective and rapid treatment in the case of anrufungen legal certainty in the application of the time of the courts . in all these cases , it is not about a complete financial management , but former public undertakings , the current monopoly or thanks . we need greater involvement of the citizen in the information on competition policy , so that it recognises the advantages . for the economy and employment in the regions is extremely important , and i hope that this aspect in future , so that these national aid for the development and the regional economy , for example , weitergezahlt transport aid can be made clear . this communication contains three right messages . i would like to thank mr evans , just as warmly for his excellent report on the community rules on state aid to the iron and steel industry and on the respect of the commission report on state aid in the european union . the members mrs palacio and mr karas and other members of the european parliament , the discussed these issues , i would like to say that your concerns in the regulation largely to be taken into account . otherwise , we would be in our efforts to promote the interests of competition and a great service . the debate is closed . with this system of financing is article 119 of the treaty implemented during the third phase of economic and monetary union is not only for the acceding member states of the single currency . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i thank you , on the proposal for a council directive amending directive 193 / 68 / eec on the marketing of material from vines able to discuss , and i hope that today we still have a positive vote on tomorrow . some of you have expressed their concern in connection with the introduction of gmos in their industry in the appeal of beaune on 5 july . the rules contained in the community , the key element of the new com in wine , also in favour of the creation of vielseitigem vegetativen reproductive material , since they provide for the effective promotion of the restructuring of the weinbaus best gesundheitsgarantien , what is urgently required . it must be said that it was necessary in any way , the amendment to directive 90 / 220 , unless we wanted to the manipulation of weinreben with all the power to push forward with this directive in article point to the up-to-date fully to fill loud and clear . 35 to 40 will be able to accept . no , the aim of the security and managementerfordernisse pursuant to directive 90 / 220 consistent to transfer . i would like to say that plenary has not been asked to comment was , as such . madam president , i refer to paragraph 14 of the protocol to the request for waiver of parliamentary immunity of mr pacheco pereira . on the qualified majority , i would like to highlight . in the weighting of votes are also two options on the table : the weighting of votes , for the majority of the double majority , but on the basis of various double simple or as a kind of ' marked demographic network ' . hauchdünne coming , or a simple majority or neugewichtete formulae well-known furthermore , the european council has a bedarfsbewertung and a coordination of economic and financial aid for the federal republic of yugoslavia , the european commission and the world bank be transferred to the federal republic of yugoslavia , a first emergency humanitarian aid in eur 200 million to grant together decided without prejudice to . if i say to you quite frankly , i would say : how sensitive the composition of the commission and the voting procedures , the success or failure of nice will not be judged on these issues - may be , spontaneously and in my opinion . the heads of state and government have given their support , but i must also remind you , mr president-in-office , why was this agreement was positive that the charter of fundamental rights as possible ? we must not verdruss situations in the remaining 50 days of the utmost importance that the negotiations on the political level by the spirit of nice , and it is therefore emphasized . in this respect , i would like to address - and i would ask mr poettering that he is listening to me , because what we in this parliament , therefore , we must also ladies and gentlemen , the european people 's party represented in the world outside . after all , what we know , the charter is probably the biggest trophäe in nice on the results of the heads of state and government in biarritz , in relation to the most complex issues of the treaty . the council really would meet the expectations of european citizens if it is a comprehensive consultation of the peoples of the national parliaments , to a charter , which is actually needs to be held . therefore , the sources of our union , and mr schmidt , on the election of the european parliament in general , and direct elections , and for us to decide 2009 at last , a president of the european union , the president of the commission decided that we are all invited to return to have the courage , mr giscard d ' estaing had 1976 and 1979 . in this context , i would particularly like to respond to the discrepancies between large and small countries what mr poettering has said . i would like to comment very briefly to the questions of external trade policy , because this is a very serious matter . this is something that all members of the european council in any case , valuable stressed . a second very positive aspect is the adoption of the charter in their entirety . apart from that seems to me that this fundamental question for the future of the european union and for their decision-making procedures in biarritz and has been assets . i hope it will succeed in this point to convince us and to make progress in nice . i would like to two specific examples : the right to work on the right to work in the social chapter of the council of europe contained in the charter of rights are not become a number of amended and been adopted . as for the direction taken by the larger member states and their desires . corresponds to the larger member states of the smaller part of a reform of the european union from the discussions indicating that the whole of europe , including in biarritz , were conducted the discontent on both sides are proof of the negotiators , that a reasonable compromise on hinbewegen . the leadership of europe has no clear visions formulated . a commission , the criteria for the representation of the individual member states is structured , shows little vision . in this centralised union would have less than the small states in the zweikammernsystem influence the small countries of the united states . after the summit of all concerned to find a solution to the violence and dialogue between barak and arafat to set in motion , we have recognised , although it seems as if the violence . sharm-el-sheikh where but were , to put a stop to again how difficult it is briefly had bezwungen mr barón crespo , and to express my party , which is not true . bad whistle-blowers , have obviously led things about italy it is important progress in the european energy tax , the principle of unanimity in the past by blocked . we should not come to the fear is that we could go on direktoratslösungen that , in the small states . in my opinion , the convention has done excellent work , and i am proud that i had the pleasure of members of this body . the question is , in the intervals in relation to the principle of large and small countries should be applied in the second hypothesis completely equal rotation . the success or failure is not only the first pillar - these are some elements of the codecision procedure to important subjects , the maintenance of article 250 in its present form , the place and the commission 's role in the closer cooperation , on the basis of which we cannot assess whether ultimately extension of qualified majority voting , together with immediately . mr president , i would first like to thank all of pierre moscovici , chris patten and the large number of members of the european parliament to be forgotten , since 1999 , once again for the great movement for a european constitution . vaclav havel , carlo ciampi , joschka fischer , up to jacques chirac , by michel barnier to up to costa simitis , without florence , jacques delors , jacques altiero spinelli and fernand herman and up to current used we should have the commercial europe is not too much criticise this says a socialist , because it has created more wealth - you - for all . we should at least some of us on this objective , and because we do this , we should also say how it is to achieve . i have noted with satisfaction that the proposals presented recently at the intergovernmental conference , in fact , i agree with the views expressed totally or partially . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , you had a debate this morning on the issues on which it considers necessary , the opinion issued in april this year to the intergovernmental conference to complement the rapporteur , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen liked your house takes place . therefore , it seems to me , despite the constitutional framework - as i would like to say - to make a more open than the opinion of parliament in the introduction of such a difficult respect for the existing cooperation . as you know , this presupposes that we certain political decisions , far more far-reaching than the three earlier i referred to the requirements of the advance . i myself have stressed that the method used for the charter is a erwägende possibility . however , i have understand that in addition to the aspect of your question is another concern linguistic behind . for this reason , i would like to thank you for the form and content of your initiative . the introduction of closer cooperation should not to create new institutions , in addition to the existing institutions of the union . it is time to revise the treaties . the european council of europe , the charter of fundamental rights in the treaties , and to make the citizens in their rights are violated , access to the european court of justice to open this general consensus violated , with its refusal to european legally binding . otherwise , i think , a europe of citizens , not to have . paragraph 8 : the constitution should - and i quote - ' of the questions laissées ouvertes ' rules . this is what i was not changed since then have to explain . secondly , it is a lack of leaves aside for the future of the union and the interests of citizens , of course , the questions which are of particular importance . according to the russian orthodox church bolschewistischen - a revolution for the whole world - in lengthy discussions on the design of the roben to fastenzeit minister , the transmission issued on the eve of the event that it should have fatal consequences . the rapporteur has mentioned : it must all respect the spirit of the treaties and must not run counter to the community acquis must , therefore , enhanced cooperation of all the guarantees are open . however , i should like to point out that it is not right that the requirement to set up in this direction - a compulsory referendum , specifically the proposed amendments to decide on a point seems to me - or to go in all member states . we really have a full debate on the two issues , which are different in character , but in a meeting point . we are prepared to ensure that there is , therefore , during the french presidency and the adoption of a meeting in november it during the vote will take place . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) what does " the introduction of the possibility of a part-time working for older employees ' for more than a threat to the retirement age for far too high in many countries ? as you know , eat pensioners as well as the marmelade like children . i have pensioners , the pensioners ' party in the european parliament have asked whether they would like to drink wine sent me on the genetically modified . furthermore , if not covered by the need to be marketed in exceptional cases standardvermehrungsgut other categories . i therefore ask you , mr president , the different labour costs , therefore , not a restriction of free competition in the european union ? therefore , voted against it could only what i did . despite the increasing liberalisation in the european union is still a constructive role in achieving of social and economic progress , state aid . for the environment , the safeguarding of public services and the guarantee of income for the inhabitants of the same weak regions can this aid indispensable . we are at the risk of aid under the pretext of the target for competition between the small and medium-sized enterprises to want to ensure that the eu after the consolidating its control over the significant state aid , the less extensive will take carefully . section vi - economic and social committee if we look at the implementation of the budget for the categories 2 , 3 , 4 and 7 , we see that only 8 % of all payments are covered by an average of fälligkeitspläne commitments . three years ago , we have with our employment initiative , we started by small and medium-sized enterprises , halfen chancenkapital to obtain . parliament wants the in two ways . only then will the european institutions also fulfil its mandate . i should like to expressly thank the vice-president responsible for the budget at this point , mr gerhard schmid , for the constructive cooperation . we want this committee is its capacity to work , but we cannot allow that there least to the demands of the european parliament , as part of the budgetary authority will be heard . this means that the total annual budget , and that is the background to the assessment of the commission 's proposal and of the proposal that we make the year 2001 offers the last parliament . we also want a review of the administrative expenditure . since 1985 - and i tried to achieve that , in the procedures of the european parliament , the financial impact of the resolutions adopted by the plenary , 85 , since parliament 's committee on budgets will be taken into account . i would like to thank you for the care of the joint declaration on their way of proceeding could give i end , mr president , by the other institutions . today you have to decide on a budget in the first reading by the council amended . what the structural measures , the proposed budget compared with the 2000 budget , in fact remained the same . the council 's attitude towards a revision of the financial perspectives is purely businesslike . if we look at these three different figures , we see that there are still considerable differences , purely quantitatively , of course the content . i must point out that it is the comitology procedure after a long debate last year , a new decision , and i have little hope that it was with the council on the re-open this debate . in the financial perspective for the time for the meda programme were 8.1 billion allocated eur berlin until 2006 . i would therefore urge the council and the committee on budgets here in parliament in its foreign policy ideas to think in foreign policy and not just haushaltspolitisch . the second concerns the aid for victims of a special treatment in violations of human rights , the institutions need . the result of the important work of the rules , otherwise , we consider the position of our committee should pending a compromise here in the time , we can support emac-ausschusses open . we only need to involve the television and the problems of the middle east , in order to remind you look at every day . i therefore hope that we in the vote tomorrow , but on the necessary majority for the monitoring centre in dublin come ! mr president , allow me , on behalf of the committee on agriculture and rural development , first of all , a few comments on rural development . we have the approval indikativer resources totalling eur 2 million for an information campaign on the cfp has been requested . the commission must , in order to achieve a reasonable agreement with morocco , and task of the council and the governments concerned , it is political impetus strong arguments to negotiate in these negotiations . we look at the 2001 budget today , the pictures of the serbian population before our eyes . as a whole , we hope that these amendments are adopted . an important opportunity to turn to the ombudsman or petitions to parliament to put to the people is open to heard is . first of all the parliamentary budget . great surprise to many members of my delegation we adopted unanimously . 400 amendments were tabled by some of my colleagues have , therefore , for many of us in the committee on budgets right from the beginning of september a kernstrategie surprising . it is difficult to see how the new posts can be resolved , in both the commission and the council antiquierte complicated and methods for the management of many programmes to be applied as long as verwaltungsproblem . this parliament has repeatedly shown that it is very rigour on the basis of its work in power in the last few years . it cannot be needed on obligations , but if it is to say that we are now too far , because we now need a bit over the years very speaks and repeatedly zusagt figures , zurückschneiden ! if we really need it again , we are only a few million on the lines to make much more can be - then it is not , we believe that the speckseite out and , if the people way . as the budget of the last year , the pressure on the one hand , the consolidation of austerity , as it was decided to the financing of enlargement , on the other hand , the acute financing needs of the stability pact for the 2001 budget was almost certainly not lösbaren conflicts in the framework of the interinstitutional agreement and the balkans . demands for better performance contain more staff . the adoption of this amendment in its original form , would the point of departure for a change the situation , but it is by the committee on budgets rejected by a majority . unfortunately , there are many examples of the privileged treatment of highly dubious views on the financing of european political parties to the european citizens of the benefits of the euro will be a loss of confidence , the europeans of our friends of the european central bank largely responsible for the prince programme vergeudeten sums of money , with the objective of federalist associations with many ngos or with the working methods and to the danish endures during this convinced for : parts . finally , mr heaton-harris has rightly pointed out , in which the citizens with a propagandastory about european integration , of course , with its amendments to the one-sidedness of many european programmes traktiert at the expense of the citizens themselves . in addition , our administrative systems must be modernised . we must also set an example . the latter is a good example of the meda programme for the mediterranean basin , a geographical area of the highest strategic importance . if some of the tracking of funds in category 4 of the priorities of this parliament , then do not forget that we in the vote in the committee on cuts or necessary to talk to finance some priorities . abundantly clear . this figure is therefore a clarification . thank you , mr wynn . the existence of a certain area of policy , while some of the countries of the european union must also applies to the applicant countries . elements of flexibility , and what can or not it simply means real to progress this wish . i believe that austria has no reason to complain about the outcome , quite the opposite . it would certainly have to make a useful contribution of the recommendations of the regional organisations and the experience of the neighbouring countries . in 1984 , did 0.2 % of the landowners in colombia 32 % of land . it is not the task of the council , and painful aspect of this extremely sensitive to comment on this or that question . but we cannot start a debate on issues in this way , as i said , extremely complicated . question no 10 by ( h-0722 / 00 ) : i shall therefore not a definitive answer on this difficult issue . we only have the feeling that this seems to confirm that the presidency of the council in the treatment of this issue in a lack of consistency and your answer , in a way , it is . that is why the emergence from this tax is not , of course , be zero . i forgive you , but we must look to the rules of procedure . the reason why it is not here to discuss these issues have been , and we believe that we must have the same things on several occasions and our waste of valuable time so that we already have been on the right side of quiet , is so . the highest possible level of health protection is also a transitional solution to the adoption of this text communicable spongiform encephalopathies in june 2000 , a decision to expensive of risk materials in connection with these diseases have been adopted in order to prevent any further spread of disease prevention and for the consumer to be guaranteed . i have no other than the information that i have just outlined . we follow the work of the commission and the council on the passage through the streets of bonifacio for this reason , i would particularly like to know whether you are well informed about this , but what is known as a very difficult , we are only a few hours of saving and the risk run by large ships in transit through these two countries and in the whole of the european union and a disaster , and would have the inhabitants of corsica and sardinien whether it is possible and projects , large ships container simply banning ? erika i and meeresstraße old rostkähne somewhere in meeresstraße cause . that is why we should in fact , the commission 's proposals for a revision of the staffing policy support . in the budget for the new money for kosovo and serbia needs . finally , i would like to express the hope that it is in the budget of eur 50 million abzweigen can , in order to finance the peace agreement israel-plo . we will therefore propose that the search for further - which we already know that they are found to the definition of new commitments , which improved the quality of expenditure and to be achieved in that not one euro squandered under the current conditions , but interinstitutional objectives in the european parliament new measures not sources of finance . remember that in the european policy as any other sector in the moderate options may not more , the majority of form . it is rather verdunkelung because of the enlightenment , and the position in relation to the activity-based budgeting disappointed me today shown . furthermore , as a result of the actions of this , we division in the budget as a political instrument understands the distribution of expenditure reflects the clear political priorities . we should take this opportunity to seek a solution to this debate on financing the reconstruction of the balkans next year and a number of years , so that we must not following was once again . transition from price support to direct income support to farmers who are interested in the development of a sustainable agricultural sector will know that the hauptvorstoß the recent reforms agreed in berlin is a continuous for products to change . a budget is always more than a sober zahlenreihe . moreover , it is also the expenditure for the agricultural policy , for the meda programme , for the socially excluded , in order to cut funds for the financing of the european union 's commitments in kosovo and to ensure immoral in yugoslavia . quite simply , the people in this winter in serbia must not frieren still are starving . on the other hand , i would like to express my concern that the various jugendparlamente were included in the socrates programme . for the benefit of the council must of course , the council has clearly stated its responsibility for the poor implementation of some of the außenprogramme . we now need a stable solution for this aid and in even greater for the necessary planning for the whole of the western balkans . i think that the majority would be prepared to accept that the money properly used , such a sum provided . i share the views and concerns the rapporteur , mrs rühle , this afternoon , in connection with the chapters on research and social measures describing . two weeks ago was the joint parliamentary assembly of the acp countries noon . at the same time , we want the fund be used to tobacco growers to look for the current budgetary resources for research and information to the produktionsalternativen . i would like to stress that the european union , the most direct and positive influence had one think strongly what northern ireland . in accordance with this model is compliance with the rules and procedures by an independent authority and in the last instance by the courts is guaranteed . therefore , be able to conclude , and this is a very complex and many technical difficulties with regard to the protection of privacy is particularly sensitive area , the text of a behafteten a codecision procedure for the first time we in the first reading . it is a very positive that their tasks were not brought together . for example . aware that the schengen system over 10 million citizens are stored in europol be extended , the police authorities of the 15 member states centrally , only the powers on the resources available to other data records on almost 1.5 million under the control of a authority , neither the really a role to play . whose powers constantly information from the individual is zusammenlaufen that said , i would like to take the presence of commissioner , i think that we not only for the protection of the citizen , but also for the use of these technologies in the sense of better quality of the citizens of europe to intervene and interaktiv in view of the new technologies should ensure to point out that with the european institutions to communicate . 54 , 57 and 58 , 60 to the text of the council in points on which the commission can accept amendments nos 1 , 2 , 4 and 10 , 12 to 40 , 42 to 64 is in . it goes without saying that its opinions on the legislative proposals on the protection of personal data will be very helpful in this respect , it is a significant contribution to the legislative debate between the institutions to do . does the treaty so that the outermost regions , this is a difficult economic and social situation in the difficult situation and the development of these regions . greatly affect their standing by your cooperation , through special disadvantages which in this way will the strategy on a high level of employment for promoting economic and social progress contribute . i am therefore with great interest to the development of the commission 's proposals , so that the characteristics of pursuant to article 299 ( 2 ) of the treaty of amsterdam , soon to be taken into account . normative we expect mrs sudre my congratulations . for many europeans are some outermost regions , only a touristisches objective on the map . our belong to the highest levels of unemployment of the union . i am pleased that the committee i presented to the amendments adopted by a large majority . i think it is particularly important that the outermost regions in the pan-european transport , energy and telecommunications networks integrated . the unanimous approval of the report presented by the members of the committee on regional policy is a proof of the loyalty of the european parliament to be a sudre by our colleague margie of its most important duties . we can achieve this , if we want to call on the whole of the conditions for the treatment of these three areas and , in particular of the outermost regions , which we are discussing today , to take further action will be necessary - not more time to discuss and believe that it with the situation idyllischen - it is not satisfactory . this article will not in a position to do everything possible to strengthen and - i think this is necessary , but he , our action , to extend and improve . in the preparation of the necessary proposals , the commission is working , of course , with the member states and the regions concerned together . the wise men - as we know , a lasting and , therefore , i believe that you depending on their actual level of development permanently on the support of the special measures are dependent on regional policy and the difficulties of these regions . in the course of the year 2001 , once again , to such a meeting with the implementation of the programme has been presented in march , if we could be carried out a bit further . the presidency has been decided that this matter is completed , and i accept this without reservations . i think that parliament should best in the current rules , because - as a colleague has said - not the equipment which does not work , but the individual members to vote . subsequently correct , then we would never have forgotten , and if we could vote other often end . i am in fact , what i osce . ultimately , mr commissioner , it is necessary that the competent services of the commission in cooperation with the member states , a system homogener and effective controls in the whole of the food chain and build the network of lebensmittellabors developed , and in coordination with the commission , apart from the authority and vote in the european union action . as it may be , must not overlaps with national forschungsinstituten and the eu-forschungszentren worked in the scientific research . today , we are discussing a white paper , and we subjects let some important principles should be set . these procedures have been changed and improved in the united kingdom , we have also set up an agency for legensmittelstandards . finally , i would like to point out that we also support amendments nos 11 and 13 , 14 , we call for a vote on amendment no 7 , 9 , and to some of the new amendments , as fraktionszwang without . against this background , i would like to say the following : firstly , the food safety can only be guaranteed if we strict official inspections , and these are just as effectively as the weakest link in each of its chain . we are discussing an issue which is quite clear , as superficial and inhaltslos our debate on the political unification of europe . we entrust the european food safety authority alone scientific testing , in cooperation with our national authorities . this is the most important . lebensmittelbedingten diseases which europe today is affected , first of all , on the american continent . however , the conditions for access to the authority must be determined , so that efficient and rapid action is guaranteed . we should also point out , as some speakers have done , in particular mr whitehead , mrs gebhardt and much more than a new regulation is that the white paper any of the union . mr president , i am pleased , and gratitude to the commission , which has started to mr bowis and the whole of the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , both the work for a better food safety as today . i regard as particularly important amendment no 17 , which called for a participation of consumer organisations . another point is the review of the legislation on the labelling of foodstuffs and for the retail trade , by the consumer in relation to the traceability of products and their ingredients and the identification of any risks and possible . crises in responsibilities properly informed , at last , both for the wholesale complex i think that new legislation is not the right response , if existing provisions are not respected . the vote in the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , we succeeded in restoring the scope of the references to the role of small and medium-sized businesses for the preservation of different eating habits have included a certain degree of balance , we ernährungsprobleme and extended by a number of important . mr president , i would like to congratulate the rapporteur on his very constructive and logical approach to the other colleagues , mr bowis , this problem . mr president , the fact that the white paper on food safety itself has no legal affects the importance of which he is without doubt , not to play in the slightest double . the rapporteur and very many members of our committee , i have placed the emphasis on what is regrettable . reasonably , including the food authority with independence and integrity of the authority of the position of the european consumer is best served . in the course of this process , i have often thought that we in the selection of the rapporteur had a happy hand . mr president , i would like to congratulate my colleague , mr bowis , for his laudable attempt to be included , and would like to thank him particularly the more general reference to the concept of food express all opinions in his report that he has accepted . finally , the policy must not shirk its responsibilities . the most important task is , however , that this body of scientific bodies and the willingness of the governments in the member states buys his decisions to accept the respect of other public confidence . as i see a food authority for the future . we have the world health organisation in geneva . i verschweige not that i am in favour of the publication of the white paper against the authority to have . it is therefore to ensure that the european union has , in the context of this unanimous approval to the economic consequences for the producers analysed the highest lebensmittelsicherheitsstandards must stoßenden approach . the scope of the authority independent scientific advice , research and independent controls and inspections and early warning system , but also certainly coordination to restore confidence . covers then : i would like to take this opportunity to the speakers , the solution in relation to the promotion of local specialities and traditional products exist , requested that this issue in the hygiene rules assure a discrete is taken into account . it will facilitate the commission to present a balanced proposal , the position of parliament and the many players in the area of food safety as far as possible in the be taken into account . our parliament deals with the issue of anti-personnel mines , but rather the decisive factor for the signing of the ottawa convention , is not the first time this issue was alongside other in political terms . i repeat my request for a split vote on the various parts of the wording of the text as a whole , i think that is to improve the coherence of the budget , and the rejection of amendments nos 10 and 19 , because amendment no 29 , in certain misinterpretation . and this is the first question is this : the countries which have not signed , the european union , particularly the commission , the signing of the ottawa convention , must be asked . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , we all know what the consequences of the anti-personnel mines , although it in individual cases , often great military reasons . parliament has called for a single budget line and a proper legal basis platform for the broad range of our actions in this important area for the first time this issue 1996 on the agenda , as a horizontal brought it to be created . i cannot hide the fact that the powers of persuasion of the european union to other countries by the fact that something is limited in some member states with regard to the problems signing and ratification of the convention to exist . the effectiveness of mine action is the most , if this individually tailored to the special conditions of their situation . parliament knows that there are many of our proposals on the reform of the examination of individual projects , and in the discussion with the member states , as you know , we want to concentrate instead on general strategies and programmes . abandonment of external aid expensive to . many ngos have been set up to deal with this problem . we must , however , the united nations conference on the issue of landmines and say that many countries , mainly in the poorest regions of the world , still in a frightening scale of the risk of anti-personnel landmines and munitions and ammunition , not the explode , thousands of people in geneva , and over a year after the entry into force of the ottawa convention , four years after the first exposed . the commission must improve the quality of their programmes and accelerate their implementation . if these amendments , but whose effectiveness is right to examine carefully , you will , in my opinion , to say , however , that you mentioned some of the amendments campaigns , transparency , access to the ngos and funds for the moment , things work properly again very can be improved . mrs bonino and mr patten with your view that parliament and the council . i have listened very carefully to mr patten on this point , because it is obviously feel that we should be involved right from the management should leave even less . mr president , our group is committed rehabilitation of victims and for the whole range of actions , the produktionsstopp about the destruction of the minenbestände , the attitude of the marketing of up to the clearance of mines have for many years in this area necessary demands and public awareness . then it is the task of the member states , to support this process at international level . the mines are of course a major obstacle for reconstruction in these countries , and also for the return of refugees . the current rate of vacating - as was said earlier - to be much more than 100 years of the earth anti-personnel mines , to cleanse here , we would need to make . as i see concrete measures , we propose a review of the third area , and to understand . in bosnia , africa and elsewhere in the minentod or terrible violations preserve the effort to all of us is that we every child value . it must indeed be exerted pressure on the countries that have not signed , such as finland , or have not yet ratified the convention , such as greece . ladies and gentlemen , look at finland ! and finally , we hope that , in the framework of the future of the common european forces professionals , particularly on the ground , this is something that the mines which people trained tasks disappear . and stress that the list of developing countries most affected countries in particular nor . parliament 's demands could hardly have been clearer in contradiction to the lisbon objectives . the rapporteur , mrs van lancker , that parliament decides , particularly by the various areas in which legislation and by setting appropriate amendments to the proposal the commission wants to add certain rights at european level . it is to the luxembourg approach for the employment policy must be extended to the social protection and social exclusion . the major powers germany , france , great britain and italy are all agreed that the small countries of southern europe , want to join the european union subject to some extent in the eastern or their domination . we think , however , it is wrong to you now in relation to take in the convention - in accordance with its structure and therefore no legal in nature . teu , 6 , because it is not formally decided - it was for legal reasons . the incorporation of the new texts in the treaties could lead to legal uncertainty . moreover , the rapporteur theory of the so-called dual legitimacy of the european union , represented by the council is represented by the european parliament and the citizens of the mouthpiece of power in brussels modern new states . the swedish and danish social democrats have today voted against the report by oliver duhamel , on the constitutionalisation of the treaties . this , the european union must develop in the direction of a constitution , which includes the charter of fundamental rights . a constitution would only make sense if the democratic framework for a genuine european federation , a kind of the united states of europe , would form . he said that he is in line with the realised that we want to know regulated by a large part of the political class , our relations with the other countries prefer an international treaty . . ( en ) i welcome the report by mr duhamel as interesting and constructive contribution to the concept of the constitutionalisation of the treaties . we believe that a reorganization and simplification of the treaties of the citizens would facilitate the competence of the eu - and their borders , and the procedures to perform this responsibility clear . until the treaty of amsterdam in 1997 was an intergovernmental europe supersyndikat . the edd group is against the report by mr gil-robles gil-delgado , on the closer cooperation . it is the concept of a union of any form of cooperation within a single institutional framework , and the objective of a super-state geared to be too monolithischen ' ' unfolding . a general slowdown must therefore be prevented by certain member states through the development of closer cooperation a more rapid action is possible . the structures of the internal market work since the beginning of the 1990s very successful . - ( nl ) the cooperation at european level can be useful for the solution to cross-border problems . these regions could serve as versuchsstation for sustainable development excellent . the technocrats and to abolish the ' de mer our citizens in the overseas departments and , above all , our craftsmen with resources provided protects european judges , for example , the dues octroi ' . france has , however , departments in the indian ocean and in the caribbean . its independence is a prerequisite for its credibility . our vote is , therefore , to clarify the role and the composition of the planned european authority , but it also contributed their funding and its independence clarified our requirements . secondly , the european agency must be totally independent . we must take account of the additives in food and other parts of the animal feed and food safety , the problem of the composition of the ceilings for dioxin , and for pesticide residues in the nature of the agricultural and agroindustriellen practices nahrungsgüterimporte priority . we have voted for amendment no 15 , because we have the defence of the cultural heritage of europe in the area of production on the ground dear . in a category of expenditure remains virtually no room for manoeuvre . as we now want to 50 % in the budget line and 50 % in reserve are . the question is how this can be compatible with each other . a5-0300 / 2000 ) by mrs haug , on behalf of the committee on budgets , on the draft general budget of the european union for the financial year 2001 ( bud ) ) section iii - commission , ( c5-0300 / 2000 - 1999 / 2190 report ( madam president , my name appears in a number of amendments to this report . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) the real surprise this budget is in the external policies , where selfishness and miserliness prevail . by using the flexibility instrument resources can be released . . ( el ) i voted against the haug report and for the proposal of my group , the general budget 2001 voted to reject . we think , in particular to the new pilot project which information measures to combat paedophilia financed . this demonstrates the lack of commitment , not least for the eu project , even under the politically active citizens . in this way , fall 20 to 30 % of the markets , the private competition . since this is not guaranteed , with been report , i have voted against the report . in apples and pears and fruit and vegetable varieties , it is clear that enormous quantities of fruit and vegetables to be removed , what are the fruit and vegetables , in the fields and in the flax processing companies and allow farmers to grub up to 5 % , 8.5 % to 10 % of the aid in connection with the proposed cuts in zitrusfrüchten unacceptable if we low prices as a whole , not more verarbeitungserzeugnissen from the rest of their pflanzungen will force so that the verrotten national thresholds dezimieren rücknahmemengen . i have voted for this report because it meets the expectations of the portuguese organisations of the fruit and gemüsesektors a drastic change to the com in fruit and vegetables , because they believe that this is a deeply have called for national interests . report ( johan van hecke a5-0296 / 2000 ) the root of the evil is that everything , even the quality of the environment and the climate , the productive resources capitalist exploitation and the superprofiten sacrificed . in kyoto was that the rich countries to think , however , in a limited extent , the possibility of the emission reductions in their own ergebnisliste subsequently achieved with your help in other countries and their air even in purely starting point to achieved . - ( fr ) the fight against the greenhouse effect is a great challenge for the industrialised countries , and a duty , in particular , to the peoples of the third world , the consequences of climate change already pay with their lives . the art of life is appropriate to deal with these risks and uncertainties . the efforts of the suspected substances , possibly with the help of a legal framework to ­ ­ endokrin effective precise investigating and strengthened . consumers and smes is the internal market is not enough with the introduction of the euro , a profit . the banks are up to eur 12 500 to its central bank for the floor now by the member states on cross-border payments zahlungsbilanzstatistischen purposes . of course apply the same strict requirements in terms of safety and money laundering . we know the cross-border payments after the introduction of the euro have increased , not only a small amount of money and even cases in which überweisungsgebühren . the european central bank , with the implementation of a single european datenformats in payment transactions and with the support of the implementation of a single european bankleitzahl within the international iban-systems could help . the consumer , accept the euro is of crucial importance . madam president , mrs peijs ' report on the massenzahlungsverkehr in the internal market , the old request of the european parliament on the high costs for the cross-border payments in the union again . this is , in recital d of the resolution itself , where it says that the high charges for cross-border payments ' consumer confidence in the euro rocked the peijs report notes ' . so there is still much to do , but the means and the possibilities of politicians , what we can do in this area are lower than our room for manoeuvre in the question of payments in the internal market . the perceived as citizens understand that in this area , in the exchange rate risks and the electronic means of payment with of course , a transfer from munich to salzburg considerably more than a transfer from munich to kiel euro-markt will continue binnenraum , and the internet-banking increasingly disappear . in achieving this objective and we will still have to work for many years . on this occasion we will also have a shorter duration of the management of cross-border payments , as in the report by mrs peijs gedrungen will speak . the debate is closed . it is not the right policy , a pragmatic and the concept of the instruments of power , and not a proposal that the only serve to produce nothing would like to take advantage of the right to want to avoid giving priority to kmu-nahen under the pretext of thinly , would statistics in a practical at the heart of small businesses . specifically , but i have three comments on this programme . we should remember that the first community action programme was adopted in this area 1983 , i.e. 17 years ago . i am always been to ensure that this policy should be on the basis of a pragmatic and effective . i would outposts of the economy and innovation in the front line and the risks involved in these areas are exposed to describe them as real directly . finally , we also need the results of the kolloquiums ' governance ' last week in brussels under the auspices of the institute for zukunftsforschung has taken place , and the folgearbeiten to take account of this , because there are many of our connections to this subject . science and technology in seville kolloquium the rapporteur lists a number of priorities , in order to improve the environment for companies in europe . this is excellent , because technically correct for europe , competent and quickly can be helped . mr president , i should like to add the words of thanks for the excellent work of mrs montfort support . it is important to avoid a situation in which people constantly at the expense of others , measure well fail . this is unfair , and that is why i support this report . this is the guiding principle of the charter for small enterprises . the programme is designed , this information on the networks will be provided . the main objective of this plan are clearly , the control of immigration in the countries of the european union and the readmission of illegal in europe living in their homes . in particular , to the intensification of dialogue between europeans and local authorities and , as far as the commission and the council , in cooperation with the albanian , the italian and the greek authorities targeted actions are needed in albania , i would point out that measures to improve the internal security . the lack of social , economic and political conditions in combination with defective or lack of legal certainty and organised crime , lead to a massive wanderbewegungen . mr president , in contrast to mrs pack , i believe , the more groups to deal with albania , the better . of course , we cannot find a solution for the whole issue , but in the medium term , we must create security and justice , with zukunftsmöglichkeiten world with appropriate immediately . in addition , there is a gap between the donors and the united states - the financial resources , and will , on the one hand , and the local population on the other hand , we , the european union , dgl. projects . we should make use of the bilateral agreements , the activities of the peoples of the cold war , the place of residence , the conditions and on the prescribe conditions so that the immigrants to be a force of the economies of our countries and dedicated nationalist aspirations rather than in the spirit of the flames friendship and cooperation . promotes legally and clearly aufenthaltsdauer pay , hours , sozialversicherungsrechtlichen people are sent back to the integrated part of the good . however we must not be the focus of the flood of refugees , but as the situation in the region , can be improved so that the people to stay at home , as migranten- and contain . mr president , i believe that , as mr dimitrakopoulos said , the central question with regard to the economic , social and the internal security problems that affect the country in the reconstruction of the rule of law , in order to guarantee the safety for the citizens and the restoration of the image of the institutions and local administrations to support albania is still very true . as mr liese , i am of the opinion that we need sharing in the asylum and refugee policy . the action plan for albania and the regions bordering was adopted in june this year . it is , therefore , in the sixth action plan . it is sometimes frustration , but also , and we want to work and for the necessary time and the necessary staff available to the other community institutions have to call upon the mühsal not to spare , specific to the european fremdheit right itself , but also the detailed work . we want to send out a signal to the citizens that we complaints about the lack of quality of legislation and the complaints about this report and centralism überregionalisierung seriously . this is , of course , very important issue , although the small number of participants in the forthcoming debate this now , in this house at first sight , in fact , dagegenspricht . furthermore , the report inevitably raises the question of subsidiarity , which is something controversial in this house this evening . in the light of this principle , a survey of legislation provides for this simpler , more transparent , efficient and more focused and to make unnecessary legislation to remove , as in paragraph 6 of this report would be of interest , that you have proposed . after the conclusion that it is not a political principle : it is a very closer examination of the report , i am theological . this means that the recognition of the principle of subsidiarity to the lowest intermediary organisations , the social groups , families and the citizens as the only really the sovereignty of the legislative and the administration must exercise , communities authorities must be guaranteed . let me therefore summary . i give the floor to the commissioner . this is an area that we should consider whether a voluntary agreement , provided it can be monitored , an alternative to regulate in detail the guaranteed everywhere , or should we will be implemented and enforced ? i have voted for the report , although i am not passed with some amendments , because it with the high wechsel- transfer costs and the euro area of concern . - if fifteen months , then the same notes and coins in circulation , the procurement of this single currency in eleven member states also outside of their own country of residence expensive . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i must first express my regret that the commissioner for fisheries , mr fischler , not here today . it must be fully taken into account the fishing interests of the european fleets and the moroccan fishing sector , but this agreement , the fischereizusammenarbeit gives impetus . therefore we have to create a partnership agreement with morocco , which , as you have said , on 30 october in brussels on monday , in a meeting will explain its position responsible takes place . a few weeks ago i was even in the south coast algeciras . this is a spanish morocco . in the course of time , has shown that it is not only is difficult , but it could even be impossible . the union can fishing activities carried out by the fisheries agreements with third countries and fishing rights harmonise . in a swedish fischereifachzeitschrift was one of these vessels fishing in moroccan port has been described as the country has brought to read , as his in el aaiún . it is not only for the fisheries agreement with morocco , because the agreement with mauritania and , soon , with the guinea to the test . all this is in question and all our . it has now reached the turning point , the meeting on 26 september 11 months needed in order to reach , and so we know the commissioner fischler to appreciate that the results of his mission to morocco and the high level , even with the king , discussions on the 30.10. , last measures . however , i would like to send a few very brief messages to the commission , represented by the worthy of today , commissioner busquin . my question to the commission is not achieved this agreement is concluded an agreement to stimulate production , then the commission intends to take structural measures to compensate for the backlog in the affected regions will result in agreement with morocco or if the commission signalisierten conditions : if the moroccan ? as we had predicted , were the negotiations with the moroccan authorities extremely difficult . the result of the failure of the negotiations , the union has finally the political and moral duty , the fishermen and shipowners with sufficient support to the aid to ensure their livelihood should undesirable . the overcapacity of the fishing industry of the eu must be reduced . that is why we need as quickly as possible close economic and political relations with morocco , with the enforcement of our european fishing interests . therefore , the commission is working on the basis of a new partnership , on the one hand , the promotion of the fisheries sector , the fleet , aquaculture , industrial processing and the research and on the other hand , the granting of european fishermen , fishing opportunities for both sides useful comprehensive in morocco . rights of the lecturers ' this is not only in the german language is a clear difference . in july 1999 , the commission , this infringement proceedings brought before the court . if it is not to the harmonisation of systems must , therefore , as things stand , the respect of the principle of subsidiarity not lead to a demand for a privilege dismissed as discrimination is probably what today is longed-for . it is true that the previous commission under mr santer was perhaps not the best , therefore , it was also . members of the committee on legal affairs and the internal market for the whole of the union and from all parties have to show that there is no sense to talk about rights , and for rechtschartas engage in real , effective measures , so that they are recognised and enforced and that is in this case , the problem if we do not arise cases in which the human rights be refused gathered here . that is , in a modern europe is not acceptable . of course , falls under the principle of subsidiarity , but in the context of the free movement of workers and the ban on discrimination to all of us , although we are particularly , because i come from a federal state - the principle of subsidiarity as the principles of the cooperation in the european union and to ensure that the kompetenzaufteilungen between the levels in europe after the principle of subsidiarity regulated . treaties are board - and i very profess as quickly as possible education this can no longer discrimination . mr president , could you fachbegriffe in italian , french and german or an expert in the operation of an excellent surgeons can operate ? ( the sitting was suspended at 10.56 p.m. ) we are talking you our deepest sympathy . has the floor , mr ceyhun , he speaks , as rapporteur , and also on behalf of the socialist group . with regard to the statements by the council and the commission shares the third asia-europe meeting with the council is currently no statement that he wants to make . it is therefore an issue that affects many citizens can affect many citizens , not only spaniards , because in this area , for which there are hundreds of thousands of european citizens from the 15 member states of the union live apart from the outside , because it is , after all , is the sol , many of the treaties and under the euratom treaty is within the competence of the commission , and in their einzugsbereich not even a notstandsplan or costa del . madam president , it is very interesting , from the spanish minister for home affairs , mr mayor oreja , to hear that basque nationalists are meaningless , even if a future cease-fire talks with sad , but it herausspränge . i should questions whether the decision of the british government is planned is a discriminatory tax for nichtbritische to introduce a statement by the commission for this week güterkraftverkehrsunternehmer ? it is also a problem with xenophobic , racist and authoritarian inclined to verbünden , this is not just a serious threat to italy , but on the whole of europe as the so-called european parties , the european liberal , democrat and reform party , tend more towards forces . the report but there are also critical comments on the french proposal . these demands are the subject of amendments nos 2 and 4 of the karamanou report . the initiative of the french presidency , we are debating today are , the aim of the two preceding general rechtshilfe-übereinkommen in criminal matters , in particular in the area of the fight against money laundering , to improve . i can only say this , then this is not the fault of the council and the fight against money laundering damaged if the idea of parliament . on the results of its work , we can only congratulate you . the way that is , of course , as mr marinho says - and i am quite his opinion - on the communitisation . all the speakers have done until now agree that this is a very valuable initiative , and we agree . europol must operate across borders . there are too much in our modern europe , however , i would first like to see the mutual recognition of fair and a hurried before i recognition of standards . i understand that it is very difficult , because we in the construction of a fragmentation of the instruments must be . but this is a need to strengthen the european union , and it is also a desire of the citizens , we have to take account of the citizens of the european union have a right to security as a location for business . we must fight against money laundering and , in particular , the construction of the internal market for financial services , capital and an effective police and judicial cooperation between the member states - as effectively as possible , and after the liberalisation of the markets in the european union a intransigent us be clear that it needs . in the right to work as a finanzberater nothing is adopted , the lawyer as such , would not exercise his profession . however , i am , of course , aware that the question raised by several members of the conditions under which the confidentiality of the legal professions the rejection of judicial cooperation in the area of combating money laundering can justify , is very delicate . this applies in particular for serious cross-border crime , and gravest . as a whole is the task of such a big and important , not only be solved by the council . hence the need to strengthen the rights of citizens and create a legal instrument zweckdienliches by we recognise the jurisdiction of the court of justice , particularly in relation to interpretation and decisions . if i favour , but i think it is wrong , which is why we vote against the project for a legal framework , also for more cooperation and coordination . a second point is of interest . that is why the full participation in this house , so good . as several members have raised , i would like to take this opportunity to you in all frankness - as mr coelho has just done - to say that we can see , in which the political will of the council expresses the police cooperation in the area of judicial cooperation in this initiative , above all , the first initiative existing lagging behind in comparison to the very sensitive issues to catch up . it is therefore important instrument for me to the judicial control of europol to ensure . the programme for research in the areas of agriculture and fisheries , part of the fourth framework programme , which was agro-industry exporters from 1994 to 1998 , was fair . given the importance of the research programme for agriculture and fisheries , it is regrettable that some of the problems have been established , the organisation of the programme is concerned . the court of auditors ' report on the programme , the langenhagen report refers to the first time in december 1998 and 1999 have been sent to the commission has been published in march this year is only fair , while the sektorschreiben auditing in february . on behalf of the committee on fisheries , i would like to say a few points . you have kindly referred to the atmosphere in which the report ; it was in dialogue with the court of auditors and the commission services , and you have made it clear how important this is arose sign of you . this shows that the commission has not been inactive and your comments seriously . i come now to the issue of mrs morgan , the amounts paid for by articulated . thank you very much , commissioner . the überreichung should take place during the december part-session . it does not want to see some heads of state and government , in my firm conviction that the opening of the determination required by this parliament , even if it so often and constitutional process . i am extremely pleased with them in detail on this draft the charter of fundamental rights of the european union before the final opinion of this house to adopt this text that today i have the opportunity to debate trefflichen . i personally have no doubt that this is the opportunity to offer . however , there was also some critical comments on the substance of the charter . this is an important position , i welcome . it was a great success for parliament - and here the groups have zusammengestanden , that is a positive result , we have achieved , the european parliament with 16 members in this grundrechtskonvent - was represented . this is a great success , as it is a major european newspaper on 26 september 2000 , the charter , as i think betitelte visiting card for europe . it is therefore my group to be absolutely fundamental , in article 6 ( 2 ) of the treaty to include a reference to the charter . in fact believe that europe will finally be survive as mere free trade area and the path of liberalism , in order to overcome the foundations of a europe of citizens have the possibility of ausgetretenen have many build . the civil society is determined to mobilise and to the european summit in december in nice to make their voice and to demand a charter , the real guarantees for the citizens of europe offers . in addition to the signatures also more effective political commitments , the day to day by all member states and all political forces to this end , we need to be implemented . let us therefore wines or pretend that we welcome this great event celebrate the nevertheless , let us meaningless . the convention has done excellent work . both the persönlichkeitsrechte , the rights of citizens and social rights . this is the right to good administration , which was mentioned by mrs malmström , is one of the most significant progress . i am not sure how much scope for this great project to speak . however , i have heard mr blair his contacts definitely to nothing . the glass is half full or half empty madam president , the last time you have spoken . but the council of cologne , with the support of the body , the world has forgotten that this is a responsibility of the national parliaments , this is a policy of small steps decrease in the context of confusion has played its role as stifter wonderful finally achieved all . excessive grundrechtsschutz is just as harmful as inadequate ! if we hear of some members of the contributions , we see that this information is more necessary than ever . the great question now is the purpose of the waters of the opinion of the charter . we are therefore disappointed and of course we will vote for the charter , but it is not the necessary enthusiasm for europe , which can be achieved as usual , the governments of some of the other - will have to take the historic responsibility , however , with the feeling that , and the commitment of the citizens and more than once again . dissatisfied . the rapporteur , mr duff , that this is an important step towards improving the quality of european integration . the need to study the statements by the convention and the case-law of the two associated with the charter , who has , i recommend a 49 courts . mr president ! for the first time since the creation of the european union will lay the foundations for a constitution , a constitution for the supranational entity , as the union laid here . but we have understood nothing for a social and democratic europe , for a europe of citizens . demonstrate . until then , the draft charter in the environmental groups , churches , trade unions , and many other groups in the member states and candidate countries of the union as a basis for the interesting debate on the future of the cooperation between the peoples of europe can this parties serve . i would like to comment on three points in the course of the morning of my colleagues have already been raised . the charter , which strengthens the common values , is the basis of our community , it also makes us today is to be adopted , not only fundamental rights and should be visible . i therefore support which of course , a reference to the charter in article 6 and its subsequent inclusion in the treaties aspire to . bernard connolly case , the commission for a decision of the court of first instance is not allowed think of the critical book on the published . this clarification is particularly important at a time when the union is faced with the task of the legal position with regard to the rights and obligations of legally resident in the european union to nationals of third countries . personally , i am convinced that some of you will have an immediate effect , and that they will receive a binding character , just as it in the near future . i have heard some of the french presidency in particular in the leadership of the intergovernmental conference , the charter is a bones for the dog and the european parliament should be , or is the fig-leaf for all of what a agonisierende during the debate frappierende wordings have abandoned dog . this parliament has led to the establishment of a europäisch-türkischen forum propose , in the european parliament to the mandate , together in-depth qualified representatives of the turkish community and observations . does not mean , however , that we have with the development of democracy in turkey and the way in which there are treated with human rights unanimity would agree . nevertheless , i know , of course , that the candidacy of turkey to continue to raises questions . the presidency hopes that this proposal is adopted , if possible that the next general affairs council on 20 november and , as i said , subject to the very specific decisions taken in helsinki immediately . it is what the commission in its progress report very clearly has said , all the other candidate countries in the heranführungsprozesses turkey must fulfil the copenhagen criteria . president sezar in his speech in the turkish parliament has no alternative to reform itself very clearly said last month , why it for turkey . i would like to thank you for your attention . here too there was some slightly positive signals . we reject the disturbed . this applies especially to those amendments with which the european parliament over the past turkey should be imposed on the part of unberechtigten aspirations , with which the report so successfully in the balance achieved is to be judges . this is a fact , just as it is a fact that turkey , as any civilised society , with the need to address you must accept with their past , been terribly may be . turkey 's membership of nato or the united states would enrich the european union and a significant step to be a united europe on this basis and not only from geostrategic considerations . because we forget that only a small part of the turkish territory on the european continent is ? we will therefore vote against this report , as we have voted against all the reports , the objective of turkey 's participation in the european union , persecuted . damage occurring in particular , if this were given the political situation in turkey hopes for accession does not , however , can be met . report ( a5-0310 / 2000 ) by mrs langenhagen , on behalf of the committee on budgetary control , on the special report no 9 of the court of auditors on research in the field of agriculture and fisheries programme ( research in the field of fisheries , agriculture and the agro-industry exporters , together with the responses of the commission ( c5-0227 / 2000 - 2000 / 2133 ( cos ) ) fair / 1999 ) i welcome this report and i will vote for it . instead of the human rights and social rights to a higher level of us to facilitate the aspirations of these , to a lower level to press . there is no doubt that it should serve the interests of the monopolies of the european union to the detriment of the interests of employees and the people in general , the crowning glory of the development of the eu towards a federal structure in which decisions are taken and of all the main objective is to be implemented . foundations for a future european constitution is now , with appropriate legal force a few strong and ultimately than to operate . this is a typical case in article 2 ( 2 ) to find : ' nobody should condemned to death or executed . despite our demands from a man and a woman is the raise children , and the grundzelle of society is nowhere to be established that a family . this is in the light of the fact that this is not judges have been elected , restriction of democratic staatswesens . certainly , i would have wished that they would have been included in our european treaties immediately . nevertheless , i abstained during the final vote , because i believe that some of the social rights clearly less than the economic rights are worded . the convention was originally assumed by the member states to draw up a consensus in the text , the inclusion in the treaties would give legal value . in fact , the fight against social exclusion on the level of social assistance limited rather than the demand for employers and the state of fundamental rights to the pressing . for my part , i am convinced that the secularism is both timely emanzipatorischer a value . as lack of sozialpflichtigkeit of property . this document is a legally binding document is inappropriate as there is no legal text . members of the irish parliament concerns the question of how the irish identity in the eu membership is a prerequisite for success at the same time , however , all steps towards a federal europe , because this is the wish of the majority of europeans and rejection would face a threat to brussels , and mr ahern ireland 's economic prosperity and does he hasty - centralised , more recently contradict . advise you time what durchsetzte . i would like to say that , in this session , which shows that this system where there is , ultimately , a very productive seven reports back to national initiatives on the sidelines . this is absolutely essential targeted measures to combat this phenomenon , which is continually developed , and internationalisiert . with this initiative , the french presidency a framework decision on the approximation of criminal law rules and procedures in the area of money laundering ( identification , freezing and seizure of proceeds ) . all the member states as a crime of at least four years ' imprisonment and money laundering should deal with a prove . since the enormous amount of money laundering is a worldwide scale , we can only by an extension of europol 's powers to the drafting of a european strategy for police and judicial cooperation to combat money laundering , and it is . i welcome the initiative of the french presidency of the extradition of criminals and prevent crime suspects . in this case is to improve judicial cooperation to prevent the waschens obstacles to a further report roure proceeds from crime . madam president , this is the only report , which i have not voted in favour of . it would be the first , the gap in asia , geographically , a predominantly muslim tradition and the bridged unionsmitglied . this applies particularly to this stage , in which we are gradually becoming more eib-mittel use without , however , our financial cover risks fully . in this context , i would like to stress the hauptschlussfolgerung in paragraph 22 , turkey and the corresponding recommendations of the european parliament in this country , the relevant european values . adapt the copenhagen criteria , and many of the actions and failings of the turkey on the human rights , democratic freedoms and incidence of their international erfülle refer to the condemnations the fact that turkey and from the turkish press encouraging progress in this direction , but rather to show the attempt to oppose this development is currently no official representatives of the us , mr president , worried . nicosia is now 11 years after the berlin wall came down , the only divided capital of europe . the necessary progress is still not sufficiently achieved , and turkey must continue to work . mr president , mr president-in-office , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i would like , in my capacity as rapporteur for the accession of cyprus to participate in this debate . mr president , we cannot vote for the morillon report , because we are sure that contrary to the assertions of many people in turkey is not going to improve the lives of the peoples and hopes the procedure . at the same time , however , i believe that it is not black picture of the situation should be drawn up . there is therefore an internal relationship . in marseilles euro-mediterranean conference mr brok , now come to us is the delays in the negotiations identified , has just mentioned . here we europeans have the experience we can pass . in fact , it is not only as a matter of a new balance towards eastern europe , but also about the future enlargement of the union in 1995 to prepare . xenophobia , state terrorism or other types of terrorism are included in this area , and i hope that it is also the opportunity to put things right . with this fact , we must unfortunately live . here , too , however , we should be open . all the indications are that it is the inadequacy of the results achieved so far , but the solutions , in my opinion , the situation still not fair , although admittedly five years for such complex areas are certainly not much is aware of . therefore , our debate today can help us , the central importance of this policy for the whole of the union has aware . it must not be competition between all of these needs , but we must find new resources . the spiral of violence in the middle east , the aware of the war against the palestinian people for their right to a state refused threatened the future of the region as a whole . cruel israel mr president , as the european union must find a balance between zentraleuropäischen their role and its mediterranean create balance between deepening and widening , it should in marseilles in nice their responsibility . however , there is often the idea that we are simply the continuity of the process , the fact that the participation of representatives of the palestinian authorities , syria , lebanon and so on have taken place , be satisfied . this is a armseliger comfort from five years of the barcelona process deliberations at ministerial level in israel 's balance sheets in these days . the existing common problems are many families and destroyed , as the tragic events in spain , algeria or the middle east . debt , human rights , drought and terrorism , the mitleidslos life of innocent people today in the mediterranean region : illegal immigration , poverty , show that is what we want to believe , however , the countries of the south need more than speeches and promises . we must give you . europe has no policy with regard to the desertification of the mediterranean countries farms , and we must consider the coordinates the feelings of the climatic diversity in this area , and brauchwasser or an environmental policy for the mediterranean proceeds . the current proposals , i think , far more balanced . now , the agency in kosovo . we must not disappoint their expectations ; all of these countries need our help , today more than ever . finally , i would like to say - and i repeat that the words of the commission - that these two proposals represent the inclusion of these countries , which many have had problems and , in the european structures leads to complete the cornerstone of the process . we must in future , the responsibility of director , if you like , is this really is a responsibility to the individual programmes , on a few festmachen the body that this auswählt . i would like to thank all the more so , ladies and gentlemen , this objective , and i am pleased , therefore , that we in this area in future to content in these countries can bring considers important . in a number of reports on the elections in bosnia , i read the ultranationalisten have the parliamentary elections in bosnia-herzegovina won . as you know , the european union has firmly committed to this historic changes to contribute . the debate on the reports to the european agency for reconstruction is once again to the extent of the support of the union to accompany the stabilisation and association process will give us cause to refer to the western balkans lagendijk westendorp and a regulation or the framework programme . the long-awaited victory of democracy in croatia and then in the federal republic of yugoslavia requires the union , as we know to go further . question time ( council ) as they deal with the same subject , questions nos 2 and no . the resolution is a further period of four months have been given to try to achieve progress on both these fronts , with the parties 1324 recently . i would like to ask you about the progress of the association agreement with morocco . the stability and development of the caucasus are one of the strategic priorities for the european union . the talks with turkey , we have just had a wide-ranging discussion on this subject , and of the union 's position on this point is aware of what you in detail . i would like to ask the minister , once again to stress that this proposed legislation , the aim of all those people who are in a situation of emergency , and that it is not a question of further criminalise immigrants or potential immigrants profit from propose . we need both appropriate legislation and measures for a wider discussion and a greater public awareness . i believe that we should really be the means to fight against these crimes , and i note that the union and the united nations general assembly and , as i believe that the turkish government , are prepared to do this with all the resources , both the council . and it is precisely because of the 14 other countries you missbilligten , you have taken measures . as an example : in my country , france , and here i am speaking as a party to power , i would like to take measures against my own country , as you have been taken against austria . minister right-wing extremists - would be if tomorrow i wanted to speak in particular - that is true of the fight against all the texts precede . this must be guided enshrined in our treaties , i spoke of values , as the charter of fundamental rights , and i spoke , discrimination , all european values : i mentioned the values , as we have been reaffirmed . i would like to remind you that this political dialogue , in addition to the future accession partnership one of the elements of the pre-accession strategy for turkey is set at the time . question no 12 by ( h-0850 / 00 ) : we are in favour of , and we will pursue this line exclusively . this should be noted that the moroccan side to the gemeinschaftsangebot has replied . these citizens come from scotland , where 110 days after remand either charged with an offence or must be released , without the same offence must accuse you once again on remand . specific measures were taken , such as the security of supplies and energy efficiency ) , in order to ensure that the economies of the member states , and what are the measures and the short- and medium-term priorities of the council for the saving of energy efficiency and less vulnerable to external crises ( ? the position of the union to the united states had extraterritorial measures is unchanged . finally , i have taken note of the negative effects of the american wirtschaftsembargos for the cuban people . regrets that the european union with concern the un-agenturen and ­ programmes on the ground findings and dramatic and often reminded us , does the council that it is a very political problem , and that the same distance to respect for the victims and is unacceptable because perpetrators ? this agency is on the one hand , the commission 's decision on the other hand , it has excellent results in the implementation of its task conferred upon record after decentralization . the recognize no borders . cross-border illegal activities , whether in the field of drug trafficking in human beings , we must be combated , or of cross-border cooperation . and it would be sensible , if the various regions of the balkans has visited again , the headquarters of the agency for reconstruction , to thessaloniki , begäbe and , as commissioner patten , not to say wisdom - in dealing with international crises and also has a great deal of experience - ansähe this service is working . but this was never before stricken region of europe hopeful as now . first of all i would like to thank the house that the two draft regulations as thoroughly examined and so quickly . in serbia , the value of eur 200 million has been a soforthilfsprogramm within only where the commission plenty of four weeks have been able to quickly results . of course , we can agree to the proposal that the commission 's guidelines underlying our reforms should reflect the search for more efficiency . i hope that parliament understands the meaning of the proposals and will continue to work together constructively with all interested parties . i can , however , the request of parliament to support the view of the college , because this is not deletion of the unanimity rule in this difficult issue in may , i contradicted . the challenge for the third asem summit was in seoul , both for regierungsseitige participants and for the general public deepening . the involvement of citizens , it was the principle of opening up of the asem process for a broader segment of civil society , although the initiative of the ngos to create a social forum on resistance of some asian partners failed to see what specific . in that respect , we are very happy that the summit in seoul has taken place and apart from one or two heads of government in all the heads of government were here . even two concrete proposals were adopted , in particular , the round table on globalisation and the duo , 4 300 fellowships at a level of 25 million dollars . fellowship programme the commission communication is limited to the treatment of the aspects of the competences of the community and the member states because of the tasks of participation in the organisations . if we assume that all the economic , legal and political potential of the european union has , it is understandable , how much we must ask what is our responsibility in the world meeresanrainerstaaten very few on legislative have . of particular importance is the reform of the cfp , but it is even more important , for the right to decide reforms . hardly a fish has a fixed place of residence . we are all of us , both in the european union and also well aware far on it . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , first of all i would like to thank you for your support in our efforts , the work of the community in the regional fisheries organisations to promote and increase . so far have been some progress , but here we must above all a better time planning endeavour . the constant improvement of the productivity of holdings of supply , and if we add this would inevitably lead to a unlimited extension of the produktionsapparates once again to a strong marktungleichgewicht already has a increase . it is more , each of its own is therefore every schweinefleischerzeuger his own sparschwein . instead schweinefleischerzeuger reserve . it is also on the need to promote the producer organisations pointed out , the introduction of the member states in very different . the common organisation of the markets , as you have worked so far , have served konzentrationsprozess rather than have prevented him . the globalization of the economy is in this case , as if , and this has nothing to do with cyclical crises . every schweinehalter throughout the union can join this instrument . mr fischler , the rapporteur , mr garot , this commission proposal on the establishment of a fund for the very pigmeat factually accurate and dealt with . this is a question of compensation . in this respect , i must confess that i end by mr garot and also with the commission proposal as it now stands , i would like to say , however , if we are honest , is the reason for the problem is irrelevant . but to other than almost largely support . then the inclusion of the specialised ferkelerzeuger in the proposed system , as expressed in amendments nos 7 and 13 . what , for us to become , the commission has presented ? first of all the implementation and the haushaltsführungspraxis in the various categories investigated . therefore , the court of auditors and comments on the negative effects of this practice , for example by not sufficiently sound , hasty decisions by mistake , and so on . arise because of arbeitsüberlastung repeatedly his criticism of the past few years , the the dramatic developments in the recent past have shown that management and control at european level to be increasingly important . the member states assiduous penalised financially , less scrupulous member states financially rewarded . i would like to briefly mention the focus of the commission 's work , both in terms of the institutional restructuring in this whole area , as well as the high level of arrears in this area , more and more quickly than in the past in the context that the improvement of external assistance as a whole is an area is a attention must be given . now is the european parliament has declared that it will not accept that the accounts for 1999 encumbered with serious mistakes in an extremely difficult situation , because it is , in january this year - more remains . i would like to outline some of the problems and i hope that mr karlsson answer my questions today . mr karlsson said yesterday that the indication of the figures is not easy . i want to investigate whether this is not already this year , then we can begin to assess the directorates-general . possible . of course we know about the current reform of the commission . you will help to reduce the error rate . that is why the commission will now and in the future judged by how the rules are respected . first of all i would like to thank mr karlsson , that cooperation with the committee on budgetary control in this year was much better than it was the case in previous years . i urge you to publish a list of countries , particularly bad management , and the areas in which this is the case . also , of hervortun mention madam president , i would like to warmly thank once again the need for reform of the court of auditors for the report and for the political assessment of the court yesterday in the committee on budgetary control . here , too , and the emphasised . there is the form of what mrs van der laan - and we are in perfect agreement - has been said earlier . this could it be necessary to extend the powers of the president of the court of auditors of the court of auditors and its decisions on the working methods , so that this type of communication meeting . the rates and its composition of one state to another . in its most important work on the common agricultural policy , the special report on the effects of the cap reform on the cereals sector was one of the conclusions of the court of auditors that the community budget from 1993 to 1997 , more than eur 13 billion more than sense would have been paid . ' it is pointless to me to ask questions , which we cannot answer . the european court of auditors must change its operation . fortunately , it is not involved in this procedure . this report is in the committee on the environment was adopted by a large majority of parliament , and i will therefore vote in this defend the result of the committee . the second point concerns the export ban , as promised earlier . that is why i have very grave reservations and would like to reject this provision to make here . in a second or third reading , we need the famous 314 votes , and we will not receive this report now before the - as - sure . the commission has a timid , but very welcome step in this direction , and perhaps the commissioner in his reply exploring this . the fact that the rapporteur , to the consumer information on the risks and on transparency , especially in the field of health and safety is to put more emphasis , we vote . we need more account of the principle of subsidiarity . i remember , however , i would like to welcome a discussion with my daughter elisabetta has led to the streets alone , as you neunjährigen then asked to go . we had to ensure that we have to be lückenlosen guarantee consumer protection , without , however , on several occasions , or perhaps things to contradictory rules . i would like to stress the importance of the amendments adopted by the consumer is not only manufacturers , but also for any rückrufaktionen regarded as dangerous products intended for increased transparency for the dealers and the responsibilities in the committee on the environment , then clearer . this also means that the relevant provisions of this directive repealed , if sector-specific new legislation . many of the amendments proposed in the report are an improvement of the text and can therefore be approved by the commission . thirdly , amendment no 4 , the inclusion of a condition for a preamble should be integrated in cooperation with the competent authorities and independent institutions to prepare reports to be justified by the member states in public or private . although the commission supports the development of common principles is contrary to the formulation of this request , cooperation and the principle of subsidiarity . the commission has no problems with the wording and the proposed amendments would lead to a weakening of the references to existing rules . amendments nos 39 and 44 propose to carry out the exchange of information is not to allow the public information , if a ban on the marketing recalling ordered , and between the authorities of the market surveillance , protected by the professional secrecy or only on dangerous products . mr martelli normally , you can give you the floor briefly comment on the voting until the end , but i exceptionally . report ( a5-0294 / 2000 ) by mrs eriksson , on behalf of the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities on the proposal for a council decision [ com ( 2000 ) 33 - c5-0386 / 2000 - 2000 / 0143 ( cns ) ) on the programme to support the community framework strategy for equality between men and women ( 2001-2005 ) mr president , my question relates to the order in the vote on the amendments to paragraph 10 , which deals with the armenian genocide . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) bear the responsibility of both the governments of the states of europe and the governments of the mediterranean partners . the tragedy in the light of this aid is more than justified . the nachtarbeitsverbot for women was one of the few areas in which the legislation of some countries because of the protective measures , in favour of women for workers as something of progressive was for the workers . i hope that the commission in future by means of the european parliament to be thorough and timely and estimated annual it to analyse debating . i regret , therefore , voted against it . it is important that our products are safe , but we should not extreme measures hinreißen . the agency for kosovo , the representatives of the member states and the commission and the decisions taken on board in the guided by a two-thirds majority is currently a voice in the each have with . i believe that this is algerien-problem for serbia in kosovo . the danish social democrats have voted against a report that the introduction of aid for the schweineproduzenten in the eu supports . even in a certain opening up of the french presidency is aware that the commission and the council seems there is no majority for their adoption . reject these proposals , only a minor change supply can cause a crisis situation . mr president , the genocide of the armenian genocide of the twentieth century , as it was the first in a number of a century of genozide call . since sweden is prepared to participate in the civil crisis management , but not in a common military defence , we can do not support paragraph 15 in which the will of the european capabilities in turkey , to improve the common european security and defence policy to contribute ' welcomes . ' but we must know how difficult and painful it is difficult , it is not yet fully meet these acts of cruelty , ethnic , religious or cultural reasons , the duty of every democracy and the europeans - that some european countries - must be destroyed and the burdening the universal conscience , never again occur where lives apart from the erinnerns demand . it is of course , other than the question we are debating today , but because of the importance of which i attach to turkey , i wanted to point out once again today , this is already a . peace is not the prevented from exercising their right to self-determination today in these countries possible because the population . i have voted in favour of the amendments , the call for the present time , so that these condolences to the pain of a people recognised this recognition and fortdauert . this happened at the time of the ottoman empire . the jové peres report would not only for the existing regional organisations and organisations , but he would like to add to it by the commission abolishing the normal procedure in the various member states to be used to support this situation at the moment in the construction of systematisieren experts . my remarks concern , of course , to the issue we are dealing with today , namely the representation of the european community in the regional fisheries organisations , but also , for example , they concern the negotiations in the context of the world trade organisation . the proposed by the then , mr president-in-office , and the european commission supports the decision of parliament three directives to link to a great example , i was zusammenfügung trittin resistance . for example , pvc is 0.7 % of the whole of the scorched volume of waste . finally , i would like to stress that the ppe / de group , in the course of the work is satisfied with the third reading . mr president , i would also like to thank mr blokland for the production of this important report . incineration is not recycling . the third reading this report by mr blokland for the first time , the parliament elected members of the committee on the environment , the first acid test in the practices of parliament have now been for many learn . and mrs evans pointed out that tougher emission limits for new cement kilns , the waste mitverbrennen , were laid down . therefore , is a general reduction of the compulsory liability and the growing importance of so-called zusatzkrankenversicherungen and the strengthening discriminatory factors to almost all the countries of the european union , regardless of the situation in the various countries . on the other hand , should be drawn up a proposal for a directive on the following points : first and foremost to ban the use of personal information from the obligation for a gesundheitsuntersuchung before the introduction of a commitment to the insurer ; it is better to koordinierungsregeln for refunds for people within the union or in another country of employment and , finally , the introduction of a vermittlungsmechanismus move to a genetic ; no vertragsunterzeichnung ; lifelong by insurance . because we are positive , will take place in the market more application to the principle of supply for cross-border health care . for example , it would be a fatal mistake , we have to take the lead . very often serve us as ' example ' for the free market economy in the health policy . for example , or insurance for all citizens of the diversity of the zusatzkrankenversicherungen at risk it today in many countries and the principles are based on actuarial . this is enacted health data . finally , showed that there was a possibility , however , a quick treatment received . this is the health of all citizens of our member states and the cohesion of our territories . it is not a coincidence that i am therefore faced with such problems precisely because i come from the netherlands . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , mr rocard calls on the commission , in a green paper characteristics of the legal basissicherung for health to define . this is a very big problem . mr president , as we could not have to be used to be on the individual and social issues , remember that the old textbooks a definition of social protection , as a whole protective measures for the coverage of the zielten an individual or a family who lives to study the state economically abschätzbarer risks or the family such risks - themselves . this means that we must think seriously about why the public medical care has suffered a fiasco . the zusatzkrankenversicherung is a legal system of rights and services advance . the attempt to abolish discrimination on the grounds of the health , mr rocard , the golden eggs , that would have the gans slaughtered . the commission will in the context of its powers to act swiftly , and i will try to reply to the conclusions of your report . i also hope that the proposals to be adopted , in which the importance of training and professional life must not , therefore , be taken into account that despite the exercise of the phenomenon of poverty and social exclusion of growing importance of paid employment . incorporation in recognised . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , we also want to congratulate the rapporteur on her presentation from the point of view of the committee on economic and monetary affairs . the next item is the recommendations of the commission for the opinion of the council to updating the stability programmes in germany , finland and the netherlands . this leads to another point , and we ask ourselves whether this stability and growth pact with the objective of achieving the quantitative aspects in relation to the quality of public finances should be included in the next endziffer certain exhausted , or whether further programmes . our main message , therefore , is that the margin for the abgabenkürzungen strict control must be accompanied by a public expenditure . i believe that overall we can draw a positive conclusion . you mentioned that one of the largest and most important countries , namely germany , for the european economy is the risk of overheating . mr president , thank you , mr della vedova . i suspect that our opinion on these two aspects to the current measures in the fight against bse in europe and the development in france , listen to you today . we propose to the european commission and our partners in the union , in this way , the extension of tests carried out at european level in accordance with the scientific recommendations . efficiency , transparency and independence are thus the basic principles , for the assessment of the ernährungsrisiken apply in europe . i shall return later on this point . however , are far greater extent in tests of this necessary . active monitoring , including stichprobentests , be developed in order to prevent the bse in feed and nahrungsketten comes . in a situation , as we now see that we always tried to keep to a solution on a blow to restore confidence and the risk is , after a magic wand lookout for both the eliminated . i will ask whether it would be a breach of community legislation currently in the increased incidence of bse on monday , the member states fear that weaknesses in the implementation of the controls in recent years , as a role to play . both must surely be possible to act quickly and at the same time remain serious . it is up to you , rapidly to provide . this is a particularly urgent demand , especially in relation to bse . our group is calling for the immediate ban on meat and bone meal for all animals for slaughter , as long as the introduction of the member states to bse-vorbeugung laws and the strict implementation of the european directives do not guarantee . commissioner , i do not know whether this is a panacea , but on behalf of the precautionary principle , i think it is imperative that a ban on the use of meat and bone meal in the nutrition of all to pigs and poultry breeding animals for immediately , fish . the debate started in our house in order to scapegoats , the council , the commission or in parliament , to seek , i think that redundant . first of all , we must , as previous speakers have already said , systematic testing for bse in all slaughtered cattle to carry out for the nutrition of europeans are intended . if we act , we can gesundheitsinteressen the europeans and the economic interests of our producers to reconcile and in this way we can restore confidence with courage and ambition . i repeat that this professions in no way responsible for the crisis . for this reason , the european union to you to show solidarity . i will also be the arrogance of some member states do not support any tests and implement the legislation is not demand . european solidarity must also be applied , because our policy has proved meal for ruminants , nitrates and pesticides , as incoherent : brachflächen . then i must say that the group of the leads me to listen to what mr gollnisch in this house in the debate on bse was . furthermore , we believe that we all seuchenherde and to the provision of a ban on meat for appropriate measures to alleviate the imposition of a unbedenklichkeitsnachweises in force . it is not acceptable that we are not in accordance with this priority political support . i am pleased that we are still the extension of the tests to speak experimental basis . the trade in live animals and meat products in the community , as a whole herd because of a single animal meal , if we want to destroy the culling of third countries with which we have , however , if we introduce general bse tests , if we impose a patient , then we must demand strict health rules and carcases export . the causes are elsewhere . i welcome the commission finally vehemently in favour of blanket because france has just shown : who will take place . looking very tests . what does this , because each time a crisis occurs , before we come here and say that we as parliament , public health absolute priority must therefore have to do something ? only ? the connection between the feeding of meat and bone meal - a very unnatural way , the feeding of animals , and bse is now clear to everyone . in this respect , i ask the european commission to a certain degree of harmonisation . i urge the european commission to a complete review of the practised in france systems to deal with bse to . as a result of the poison reached in the system and destroyed , this system . because it is difficult , certainly , in this area is a national and european legislation to reconcile . in addition , there is legislation in this feed must be a further guarantee in the system has been installed in order to protect public health and to guarantee food safety , as the meat-and-bone meal , as processed . it has already been said that this will be very expensive , a large number of carcasses should include and so on . caused the deaths of 58 chinese immigrants were found dead in the united kingdom , the port of dover , after several were arrested and the general application of different types of measures to designated as cited examples : the ' kissentechnik ' , the immigrantin in belgium , the use of strong beruhigungsmittel in spain , in the transport of schiffsladeräumen in italy and spain , the tragedy of the zusammengepferchten on european soil and einschüchterungsmethoden immigrants . i agree with this commitment , and for me , i am in favour . violence against women has many forms of violence in the family , a crime in secrecy , the various forms of sexual exploitation , or the trafficking in women : the trafficking in human beings . mr president , i would like to say that the us model of the monetary policy , of course , the central bank is the responsibility of the european central bank , and it is , after the criteria laid down in the treaty , mr nogueira has defined . mr president , i believe that the public , it is very important to distinguish between the justice and home affairs , and i would be interested to know whether the commission will now briefly the physical introduction of the euro to the population of the difference between domestic and outside effects of monetary stability to explain outside effects of the action start ? as long as the greek side here , we will not work has already follow the procedure . we for our part to guarantee that there is a mess- and monitoring system . the commission on the basis of specific criteria to review the apply until 2004 , because at this stage the approval for the french system of aid expires in the same decision was obliged to systems in all member states . the objective of creating the integration of europe is in the words of the lisbon european council joint efforts and actions required . secondly , the experience of the parties on the ground , ngos , the local authorities , social exclusion comprehensive account of the institutions and personally affected by . the certainly many elderly people , but also those who have worked decent life for example , as you are not allowed labourers would agree with hours for low wages . it also relates to people with psychological disorders , as well as large groups whose language is not sufficient to find a place . in the united states by more flexibility in the field of employment , poverty and unemployment is the only guarantee that the very short time seen very short duration . in my country approximately 75 % of those who work and women , but live below the poverty line . we must try to this important task , at least in part to play . this is one of the events of realism in the budget must be strengthened , and the account in this area show . i would like to thank and congratulate her and my thanks to the other members of parliament who are not here and now the opinions of other committees have presented . mr president , mrs figueiredo . i am in favour of the importance of non-governmental organisations and regional and local players highlighted and better to take account of their experience on the ground , as you . we have already agreed that the committee on social protection regularly with the contact group meeting of parliament . the next item is the report ( a5 ­ 0320 / 2000 ) by mrs rothe on behalf of the committee on industry , external trade , research and energy , on the proposal for a directive on the promotion of electricity from renewable energy sources in the internal electricity market [ com ( 2000 ) 279 - c5 ­ 0281 / 2000 - 2000 / 0116 ( cod ) ) of the european parliament and the council . we now need binding objectives . another important point , which the committee has agreed , is the problem of netzanschlusses and the netzzuganges for renewable energies . in my country , spain , these guidelines specifically responsible for that , in addition , 225 billion tonnes of co2 in the atmosphere and we would not meet the kyoto objectives could be now and 2010 . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , the commission proposal to create a framework in which it is to be possible , in the medium term , the proportion of electricity from renewable sources in the european union can only welcome significantly to increase . but the compatibility with the internal market can still be a danger . waste is not a renewable natural resource , although it every day , more and more produced . it is this directive would currently topical . however , i support this proposal wholeheartedly . mr president , i would like to thank mrs rothe for the excellent report this week , we have with the crisis in the battle of climate change , exactly the right time . the promotion of electricity from renewable sources of energy is very welcome . fundamental technological changes are needed . instead always only in the field of energy connection without major proposals from submitted . finally , i would like to address just three problems have arisen in the course of this debate . on the other hand , must be binding , because otherwise it would commitment to the content and the substance of the directive parameters for reasons of consistency in national übersetzten objectives . for the same reason , we are in favour of amendment no 3 in part , but not amendment no 7 , for the text of the proposal to technically . but we cannot accept those parts of the application of the rules on state aid prejudice . the next item is the report ( a5-0308 / 2000 ) by mrs theorin , on behalf of the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities on the participation of women in the peaceful resolution of conflicts [ 2000 / 2025 ( ini ) ) . during the official peace processes almost exclusively dominated by men , show how important the participation of women in the conflict settlement in the peace and international experience and declarations . decisions on implementation and implementation of aid are the responsibility of the sach- and expertise of women and krisenstäbe , and this will take place little attention recognition . you are obviously their positions of power in the area of foreign and defence policy to preserve the interests of women and men in its view , quite represented . mr president , i would first like to express my great interest in this report , which i think excellent , even is excellent . there must also make it possible to help the victims of this situation , the financial resources , women have become . mr president , i shall not repeat what has already been set out in detail . first of all i would like to congratulate mrs theorin , that it has taken the initiative on this excellent report , with an important issue . it is a question of how effective the participation of women in the negotiations for the settlement of konfliken change the world and the dominant culture of violence by a culture of peace and democratic settlement of disputes , but at the same time also topical subject of dialogue , and the gegeneinanders can replace . i therefore support the demands of the report that women should have a right to diplomatic influence . a very good report , the fundamental principles with a clarity to explain how this is a huge practical reason and necessary in article 17 bold , but at the same time , stubborn documented , detailed proposals . personally , i condemn any rape and slavery . fifth point : the role of echo , the office of the european community humanitarian aid , which calls on parliament has endorsed the gender dimension to this request - and also - appreciate . then there is no legislation in this respect , but the problem is that millions of people , particularly women , this activity to a very large demand that exist . in the context of the employment guidelines in the opinion of the european parliament to demand that the member states of the sector is already these guidelines should , in my opinion , in accordance with the regulation . the immigrants are usually what specific measures are needed , as specialized centres of power in this area , a large group of the necessary aid . it is a task of the member states . the need for this is , in recent years , many times , but little has been working life in general and related rights and duties to be taken into account the fact risen . ( the sitting was closed at 12 midnight ) ( very loud applause ) we must not only the internal system , but also with the rules and practices in the european community and the european union , for decades , freedom and peace create reconcile apply . the first step in the attempt to the federal state , is the establishment of a democratic dialogue on the nature of relations between the two adjusting institutional framework for as possible republics . you , the representatives of the european parliament , the citizens of its member states , the possibility of accession to europe for us , the citizens of the federal republic of yugoslavia , seems extremely uncertain today represents the citizens of europe , can best understand why the immediate directly . we take the sitting was again . finally , it is an extremely important issue , and it would be useful if we in the course of the day conclude could here for the citizens and informative . subsequently , the commission , then it will be present , and it has word within six months , a concrete proposal . in the european union are already today , and we should remind ourselves that many member states already have fought for many years for more transparency in courageous citizens and progressive practically generally accessible documents . in this report is a further processing in parliament called for , and in this respect , i believe that it is also here today to improvements must be . we are pleased that we in the report reflected the fundamental principle , we also on the committee on budgetary control vehemently represented . he will now have the opportunity to take , for which the media interest groups , and not particularly interested in the open and democratic debate participate for confidence in the eu , and it can also insight into transactions is so important . the committee on petitions waiting until the publication of a document shorter would have liked to have seen . as soon as they no longer be necessary , of course , be made available to these documents . i would also like to stress that all citizens in so many forms of access to documents as possible must be guaranteed . the dogma of political responsibility must not be confused with the rights of the citizen on openness . i would therefore call upon the rapporteur , any reference to be played off against the interests of the rights of members from the regulation , the subject of public access to documents is to be removed , and i would like to ask all ladies and gentlemen , exactly to ensure that their interests are not public . in these areas is not guaranteed , but also the european parliament on the other hand , the neither informed formally denied access to documents and not only will the citizens to fundamental documents will be consulted . but there remains a major problem . mr president , first of all , i would like to thank mr cashman for a very good report . it is an extremely important report , a significant part of what we might call the new openness of the eu . ( technical disturbance ) this is not just about the principle of unrestricted access to all documents , but of course it finally succeed in council meetings in the doors open in the future in the style of metternich in secret lonely decisions and cheap brussels-bashing can operate so that the council that afterwards . secondly , i would like to comment on the question of exceptions . the people of europe is as undemocratic , as a place in which decisions are taken behind closed doors . the proposed regulation before 1 may 2001 , which means that two years after the amsterdam treaty enters into force after article 255 of the treaty must be adopted . allow me now to some of the problems in detail , at the moment a advocacy of certain amendments by the commission to you that i . as i said , we can accept in principle , but we must work together to you , for example on the amendments on the classification of documents , and on the amendments , in some cases , in respect of technical and administrative registration . we have nothing written in hand and i would like to propose that the commission , the members of your recommendations for the future to in writing . welcome we welcome the status of the reduction of kreditrisikos , in particular , the guarantees , the smaller companies can be made improved . report ( a5-0321 / 2000 ) by mr blokland , on the conciliation committee draft directive , the european parliament and the council on the incineration of waste c5-0371 ( / 2000 - 1998 / 0289 ( cod ) ) mr president , i would like to ask the whole of the liberal group , as co-rapporteur , a little more practical to address . so it is the joint wish both from the group of the european people 's party and european democrats , and the socialist group ( pse ) , the vote until the second novembersitzung postpone ( ppe-de ) . i therefore propose that the vote on the report to the second villiers november-sitzungsperiode to be postponed . i have kept to the order of the sessional services , which i have received the plenary has decided , and nothing else . that is all i can say , however , i agree with your colleague , mr president , today , as you turnusmäßiger ; as agreement with you . apart from its dismissive attitude in the first phase of the dangers in britain , have been pointed out the measures in the second phase , as the scandal in britain , essentially on this country , without an emergency programme for the implementation strict controls on the restructuring of the husbandry and would have been launched at european level , as the european parliament strongly wütete limited . that is why we want to four main learn the lessons of the future should be taken into account . we have voted in favour of this joint resolution . the increase in cases of the new variant of cjd in england and the situation in france , the issue of the mad cow disease ( bse ) back on the agenda now , this time vehemence with even greater . in the efforts to prevent a handelskatastrophe some governments have the necessary information in good time to the commission sent to the first appearance of the phenomena of the products and their stopped export not prevented from panikmacherei fear amongst the population or the dangerous not immediately consumption or not . the farmers alone can do nothing : we need a plan to support the rearing of livestock and measures to restore consumer confidence in the light of this crisis . the inability of the european institutions , the security needs of the member states , is the order of precedence between the constraints of the internal market and the health of our population and the council , the commission , parliament , to establish a proper policy most directly concerned , accommodate problems in their entirety . raise sicherheitserfordernissen ( ) after many discussions with the council , we have been able to us in a number of points . the movement of in landfill sites will soon be consigned to the past and must be replaced by more environmentally friendly procedures . the social agencies and , in particular , to a stop to the procedure to be involved in the programme , the representatives of the disadvantaged groups so we welcome the renewed growth and the fall in unemployment , we must not ignore the fact that the inequalities remain or even worse , but i believe the rapporteur rightly calls for a greater involvement of the public authorities , social partners and the civil society in current measures to combat poverty and social exclusion . the poor workers ' , mostly women , to be employed in the train of poverty , the official speeches ignored . meisterlich so as teilzeitkräfte dumpinglöhnen and extremely precarious jobs in ranks , a ' three years ago , the prime minister unit , whose task of the coordination of social exclusion are being drawn up by complete solutions for comprehensive problems is to reduce regierungsmaßnahmen social exclusion . these are now on , the thousand fußballfelder 60 rotoren plants with claim . without the development of renewable energy sources would increase the eu 's energy dependency currently about 50 % to 70 % by 2020 . it is of course , that the use of nuclear energy and the storage of radioactive waste and effectively to the most advanced rules on safety . we must therefore seek , as there is no one has remained unused , but as long as the technology developed , to make use of energy , after a nature . during the preparation of the information on the one hand , and the participation of elected representatives of civil society - especially in the form of a social forum - to be guaranteed and on the other hand , the environmental and social rights and human rights asem 4 , there is a democratic requirement renew by and consideration . in the last time this parliament had to fight against a number of times doppeldeutige statements and even against criticism . we have seen that the parlacen , therefore , we had to fight and that is to continue to do with the same wechselfällen had like this parliament in its infancy . parlacen , more resources , a greater presence claiming his representativeness and more powers . the parliament of central america as well as the european parliament to gain credibility and legitimacy of its work , because that is the faithful account of the represented societies , or at least it should be based on the political groups parteileben you must prestige by . since 1990 , we support the cooperation programmes to respect human rights , we have discussed this issue by the people for information and awareness on the human rights . ­ b5-0855 / 2000 by mr van den bos on behalf of the eldr group ; the extreme confusion in the context of the elections in the last few weeks in so far as economic , social and economic crisis , as a result of political chaos is symptomatic of a country in the côte d ' ivoire , which was there was a model country in terms despair prevail . the military , political and religious leaders must do everything possible , a national reconciliation . it is particularly with regard to the constitution , which means nothing other than the creation of a national preference , which we in our own countries and their combat ethnic cleansing , the logical consequence of this debate on the very ivorität and put an end to any ivorität from the ivorischen to remove it . he has supported in its greatest enemy ouattara , because of the fact that his two parents are not the intention of the grundgesetzänderung ivorer either . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , even if the ivory coast in comparison to other countries in central africa in the past , a stronghold of stability and democracy , there is a long time ago , ethnic and religious tension , there was ultimately abuse of power by the previous government under president bedié , and this has finally to violent power by the military west and was . we condemn the ethnic violence and , above all , the political leaders of the demagogy , which was . the next item is the joint debate on the following motions for resolutions : the forthcoming eu-asean-treffen in december offers us a vital opportunity to condemn this regime in laos , in the strongest terms . i have also no confidence in our own ministers , that there raise these issues . the asean has proved a paper tiger in every respect , because it failed to the terrible events in burma to react . the junta announced that they intention of the party of dismantle as a whole . there is a historic inheritance and , of course , the situation is difficult . this minor improvements in recent years , the author of the amendments of the socialist group , mr sakellariou , led to a situation , the more tragic , but still disastrous , and not the level of the tasks of vietnam is certainly not - thanks to the certainly not today . mr swoboda , the european parliament is flexible efficiently . however , it would be appropriate if the american president in hanoi , not only on the strengthening of cooperation , but it is concrete commitments vietnam , the human rights situation in the country 's appalling in every respect , would make dependent on significantly improve focus . i urge the council and the commission to vigorously by the vietnamese authorities to protest against this gross violations of religious freedom . the process has also , the signing of the cooperation agreement between the commission and vietnam in 1995 . that is , of course share in that resolution contained , we have tabled . i also believe that we must do everything in our power to assist them . helped if you would be a change in the situation , and in this plight has brought countless other people in the world , we would be most . at present medium and long-term solutions to be discussed . mr president , commissioner , the floods in recent weeks , in addition to other european countries such as the united kingdom , france and spain , ireland , this parliament once again the problem exceptional emergency measure in order to prevent a repetition of such a policy in order to alleviate the plight of the people affected , communities and companies , longer-term devastated norditaliens different areas of natural disasters proportions which both . it is precisely the transport sector will be given its steady growth in the next decade - more far-reaching measures necessary foreseeable - on 38 % . the debate is closed . this is perhaps the practices of this parliament , but it seems to me to be very difficult to give the impression that the european parliament with a low turnout commitments to address this issue and the european commission , but such a task . ( parliament rejected the request to postpone the vote ) . the economic and social policy and the drug companies have felt in the level of health care costs in the eu , which the purchasing power and the ability of the workers , contributions to pay , has limited the emergence of new diseases and the zügellosigkeit driven . in this way , the private insurers opened a broad field , provided they choose the patients and the premiums ( initially ) after diseases . who is not a lot of money is spent and not more . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , i am particularly pleased that in the presence of a group of visitors from my constituency , i warmly welcome the fine today , i can speak . but this means that the institutions will be given enough time to prepare the new rules . the report says that there is growing consensus that the current regulations are not able to be the developments of the financial sector in the last ten years into account . we say yes to greater account of risikomindernden techniques , and we also say yes to enlargement of the grundgedankens of the basle committee . the same satisfaction with the important contribution to the overall process we take note of this report . finally , and this is the crucial point , we are fully aware that we must respect the institutional balance laid down in the treaty . the vote will take place tomorrow at 9 p.m . finally , i have the opportunity to open in the quest for a greater proximity to the work of the community institutions to congratulate the ombudsman , mr jacob söderman , on his work in the fight against abuses in the administration and , therefore , allow me , mr president , at the same time . mr president , i am pleased that the european parliament has always sought to strengthen and consolidate the scandinavian beamtentradition completely in line with the position of the ombudsman . the vote will take place tomorrow at 9 p.m . finally , access to documents is a basic civil and applicants for a document is not a more important than the prüfungsunterlagen . we think it is a fundamental right , but also in the charter of fundamental rights , on the recognised this week we have voted for legitimate for a applicants access to its own korrigierten prüfungsarbeit receives , because the access to documents . so it should be . all the other institutions should follow this example , as the committee on petitions has recommended . the citizens of the european union must contact with the community institutions is a positive impression . in this case , the best practices to follow , and all our experience in the union 's credibility in the member states themselves and the new means to prevent what can bring in misskredit . what is the application of the other institutions , in this report and the demands of the ombudsman , you referred to procedure itself . the minutes of yesterday 's sitting have been distributed . if you as a result of a disaster , but if they do not want to prevent unavoidable , it is not the voice of democracy disturbed then they deserve . the criteria for the respective partners and it is true , but must also be taken into account the assets of a bank kreditrisiko associated with the other aspects , in particular , the solvabilitätskoeffizient , based on light stricter banking supervision are gewichtungsparameter approximiert . provisional establishment of the european police academy epa ( ) this police cooperation plays a leading role in the great objective to achieve a higher level of safety within the european area of freedom , security and justice guarantee for the citizens of europe . the enlargement of the european union , the extension of the territory of the free movement of persons , additional measures for the safety and the peaceful coexistence of the member states must be accompanied by a brings with it . as i see that the french and portuguese conditions in prisons in very different . this means that if you want to define these common standards , they must first of all , because otherwise they have a training , which is completely vary . thanks to the work of mr posselt is finally provided for the training of polizeipersonals also in the areas of human rights must be as important and appropriate , the recommendation of the internet , the possibilities of entering virtual police academy and defence , to create . but we are here in strasbourg in an almost incredible with the downright ausgestorbenen chamber and must listen to . it is a good idea , and the development of a common system of free movement enjoy free trade and the right of residence , where we sicily or greece , it is only logical if we in the european union where the people , where it can travel from scotland to maintain public order expected . in the netherlands , the police on the de-escalation of conflicts and repressive tolerance , and subkulturen , ethnic minorities , the use of churches as zufluchtsstätten without legal residence status and political protestveranstaltungen than the normal social phenomena for people trainiert existing apply . anyone who believes that it must not be afraid of the solutions to the good solutions for the espouse , the other measure . i hope that the academy here will provide a starting point for the future . this is a good example of what we now call for a europe of nations in direct contact between the vernetztes as a europe that is to create aufgeblähte beamtenapparate without unnecessary . the majority of cases of the abduction of children are being very efficiently and properly by the central authorities in all member states clarified . we must , therefore , this gap , for reasons of equality and social development in the light of the realism and the same rights and obligations for all citizens of the european union is closed . meanwhile , we welcome this measure and your wholeheartedly agree with . we feel sympathy for the objective set and vote in favour of the proposed measures . this clearly is a day to the whole world , people often travel to a child to see . this view of the commission will also by the opinions of the european parliament on this issue , and by the case-law of the court of justice of the european communities confirmed . i know that the fifa has already been waiting too long time and on the 1998 published by the commission formal declaration at all responded to . that is a matter of course , the union in the future wada by the commissioner responsible for issues of sport will be represented . the united kingdom decision to impose a tax of nichtbritischen hauliers ireland is certainly a very small , but open market , but most of what we buy comes from great britain . finally , i would like to say that it is for this debate in the european parliament and the statement by commissioner vitorino , clearly the right of the united kingdom government to introduce a system of this , if that is in line with the already existing rules and regulations is still too early , but i welcome the fact shows , euro-vignette . mr president , i can confirm this discussion , and , of course , a good verkehrslösung sought . levies and are , of course , sensitive , and that is precisely for austria , where we constantly where constantly solutions to mauttarife this is no other drivers or hauliers in europe , in favour of british drivers discriminated against . the pays for his vignette , unless it is a certain reduction in per-diem-basis granted a great deal more . on 22 november , i.e. on 25 anniversary of the crowning glory of king juan carlos , spain has opened the way of democracy , one of the foremost representatives of this believe in democracy his freedom , tolerance and respect for its part , with the lives of others had to pay exactly . i therefore ask you to bear in mind , all of your interventions carefully . the negotiating position of the european union to secure the environmental objectives of the kyoto protocol in the areas of landnutzungsänderung and forestry , on the issue of the relationship between the national measures , the ' ergänzungsgrundsatz ' , and the system of reduce ' , ' the kyoto protocol mechanism and focused on the erfüllungskontrolle . in the preparation of the next meeting of the eu should not discuss all the issues on the priorities to concentrate mainly on the reduce ' , ' the mechanisms of the ergänzungsgrundsatz ' and ' , but once again , erfüllungskontrollen strict . mr prescott is now under the wasseroberfläche disappeared , and we do not know how long it are still there . a final comment : i think it is true that they have remained , mainly because it is extremely difficult to measure exactly the reduce , the question of reduce hard . for the nuclear energy is no prospect of a comeback . however , there is a need for further steps . the next meeting in bonn in may 2001 , the gleichheitsprinzip laid down . at the next conference in bonn in may 2001 , should this be found a compromise . we are , in view of the 21st century , we all want , we live in the future , the task of the climate change is certainly one of the anspruchsvollsten if a planet . the same applies to the use of some of the co2-senken and additional aufforstungsprojekten . the hague conference , as you , commissioner , we have announced this in spring next year in bonn continue . madam president , thank you , commissioner wallström , for your comments . if there are no differences of opinion in the insisted that was a matter for the relationship between the european parliament delegation , and the commission . there is no question in the next cop6 not reach agreement . we were very constructive and have until the last minute this hague conference negotiations . you have the floor , mr president-in-office of the council . with the coordination of social security systems of taxation , asylum and immigration , trade policy in the area of services , a very important issue , still have a certain number of countries , visa- , serious problems . i would like to add that , to allocated seats in the european parliament , there is no agreement has been reached . the union is a significant challenge for the future of the union and its ability to act according to the new accessions will be prepared to reach agreement at the moment , actively enlarged union . your president is , of course , invited . it will be presented in nice and , of course , we hope to be adopted . as you see , there is much to be discussed in nice . in a union of 27 or more member states will lead to any progress in the areas in which we adheres to the einstimmigkeitserfordernis quite simply , to prevent this principle . you have spoken of the codecision procedure of the european parliament . ( applause ) this is the task of enlargement , as it has not yet been , and this must prepare ourselves . nice is a task reuniting our old continent . madam president , the most important objective of the nice summit is the enlargement of the european union and the preparation for enlargement . madam president , mr president-in-office , mr president , i think , have so far , the governments of the 15 bekleckert with glory . this is not the right method . now it has been proposed in 49 areas with a qualified majority vote . majority voting shirk the parliamentary democracies in the right of veto in the member states , but the eu itself is not a parliamentary democracy . europe needs leadership , needs clarity , decisions need to energetic needs . the blackmail attempt , in view of the conclusions of the european council in biarritz , even if it is not acceptable to us with the announcement was informal . we are in fact believe that the conclusions of the nice must have a passage in which the commission is urged to draw up a framework directive in this area . i will comment , if i know the outcome of the treaty of nice , but i think the debate here as something schizophrenic . in amsterdam , the heads of state and government will not already been , and this must now once again in nice nachsitzen class . if the difference between large and small , we must not be able to defend their identity in a few years , a great legitimationskrise within the european union feared because small then not to feel at home , because they fear in the council too much more . the president and the prime minister of france , it is clearly a priority for its own political future and less on the future of europe . the text is not included in the treaties and is only a political signature , then , can have serious legal problems of interpretation . on the other hand , i would like to emphasise how important it is extremely strong institutions , the institutional vacuum , with the help of the economic level , there is to be speeded up by the euro , our union , with auszurüsten balance . the stated aims of this reform are more effective , better education for an enlarged europe at the same time , the reduction of indisputable existing institutions and gerüsteter democratic deficit . but it is the restructuring of the 133 committee , which must be subject to a much more democratic control and conclusions must be accessible and the composition characterised by a broad and comprehensive must themselves , the agenda . mr president , i am not only to the president-in-office of the council , but also to all the governments of the member states , if i point out that we continue to pursue these difficult issues , then , if there is no agreement in nice in this respect . the proper application of the codecision procedure in the last few years has shown that it works . the first step should therefore consist in commercial decisions already with a qualified majority to make . as you seven-year-old girl was forced to flee from their own country , the march of the red army and the bombardment by soviet hiding in ditches as a refugee fighter-planes . mr méndez de vigo has rightly referred earlier to the charter of fundamental rights . we can expect more from him . the agreement by the day , is not the lowest common denominator , but unfortunately only a small , but rather a very small likely common denominator . mr president , i would first like to thank the members , because i think this debate , to be extremely niveauvoll . it was not a question of the charter is not to say that it is not a problem of transparency . ' because the principle of equal rotation also for the large countries , the commissioner would no longer a certain time as all the other . i believe that parliament will see that the union has found the further development of the european union , the unites us all , to meet improved institutional mechanisms should allow it . the vote will take place tomorrow . mr president , i would like to endorse the statement by mr van orden . i am unambiguously against the minister - and this also applies to the turkish foreign minister , that a eingeladener threatened . there is no question of european democracy , the safety of all our guests , who is here to ensure that we here in this house and of any . under the motto ' no ' and ' we ' , the italian minister for health undermined by the liberalisation of drugs , with the statement couriers tumore marijuana with the dignity of the pills damage . this is a poor coordination of the opinion that the members of the european parliament have nothing to say that the european union is not able to participate in the last year there were represented , with the ngos and the institutions of the charter of fundamental rights adopted in this forum , at least , not to say a affront to human rights , although recently with a very large majority , for our parliament - unless one is a debate . we now have enough discussed . now , it was already have the same time , the role of the high representative , with a special obligation and link to the council should take the view of the european parliament and the commission , we prefer to have a responsible for foreign policy vice-president of the commission in amsterdam . as the european parliament before the feira summit adopted a resolution on 15 june , it will also adopt a text tomorrow , the council of nice sums up his position . the development of esdp is a new important project of european integration , must therefore existing institutional framework to be reviewed . the european council in nice will confirm that i will call several decisions here . for the first debate at the beginning of the year the commission will produce the state of the most important edf programmes financed by the community budget and the commitments and payments to verwendenden amounts for the countries in coordinated statusbilanz for last year from the shows . we have also had wanted to be included in the past , but i believe you have understood that there is no contradiction between a regional cooperation and development , the european union , in particular , on the stabilisation and association process , a concept which deals with the question of regional cooperation from the countries in this region has received some resistance , as it is not a new overcome their approach to take this opportunity to say that , at this summit . präzisierten and confirmed its . before it had been a ministerial meeting will take place under the portuguese presidency a summit with india with asean . this does not mean , of course , that we discouraged . i would like to remind the wide range of these tasks : humanitarian aid , evacuation of nationals , prevention , but also the military separation of belligerent parties . it is , of course , the entscheidungsautonomie of the european union and the recognition of the political nature of the voluntary commitments . as he has done more than others in a part of the world , which i know very well and has worldwide recognition for his efforts to resolve the conflict personalisierung acquired . i think the media reports in my own country , to establish this force very strange . i would like to thank mrs lalumière for her report on conflict prevention , the commission , together with the high representative for the reference to the european council in nice prepared . thank you very much , commissioner patten . in my view , the european union will it actually put to the test . ungeduldige citizens complain about the mill of the european grind slowly infinitely bureaucracy . but the citizens must have access to information and documents received so far as possible . the proposals before us is not clear what this task should be . with a car in the european flag is out of the entlegendste everywhere , even in refugee camps . for these reasons , i think europe must now decide to act . if we as europeans , not to create a responsible role to play , we must expect , we are also in other focuses of conflict as a mediator to have no confidence in the resolution of this conflict , regardless of the united states . not only her personal commitment replaced the democratic legitimacy of the european security and defence policy . some of the details of the report by mrs lalumière i cannot accept . in the final vote i shall vote for the rejection of the report . the neglect of the civil conflict prevention will prove to be a mistake in the long term , and that the statements by the council , the reference that we have already decisions , but it will somewhere because langgehen this broad , instruments are not enough to me ! as you will understand , we are voting against both reports and commit us , everything in our power , against the policy ... thirdly , a kernwaffenfreier corridor , as it is palme once olaf anregte from the baltic and the black sea to build . i would like to congratulate mrs lalumière on her report . in mr broks report is also the office of the high representative for common foreign and security policy raised . so what a pity , i would ask my colleague mr van orden and others , because my fellow members ' small teich ' , the irish sea , in this area so much to offer : the tradition of the experience and behind the practice . in our understanding is the european parliament , in cooperation with the national parliaments , the most suitable body . i think that we deal with the need for a european defence policy and ­ capacity building , which , in my view , an important part of european integration as well as the single currency . recent developments in the future will be good if we zustatten experience from these i also believe that the combination of these different means of a specific situation of the european union and that is our task , if this policy is shown , it must be a real european culture of prevention and management - to develop and consolidates , a specific way . i believe that a positive dialogue will develop . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , ladies and gentlemen , the resignation of the commission in march 1999 has shown how necessary reform of its structures and working methods . the reform can be drawn up , but must be understandable and the trade unions and all staff , and these must be explained in the whole process to be recovered from above . this definition will take time , however , is essential and is essential for the reform . the reform of the commission is an essential condition for the future of our institutions . in the drafting of my report i could not only the second report of the committee of independent experts and the michiel van hulten proposed resolution on the work of this sachverständigenausschusses on 19 january , the study of the white paper , but also in this parliament has been adopted . the court of auditors is replaced by other procedures , which is at least provide guarantees of equal value and the other players than to involve the abolition of the ex-ante-sichtvermerks if this abolition in his report indicate that he is not opposed auditor . opening up of large companies , to see that you will be more transparent , you are a remove from old by companies , and exchange of information technology innovative measures is increasing ; they vertical organizational forms of information on themselves . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , despite its scope poses the white paper presented by commissioner kinnock is no real institutional questions . it is in fact we have debated this afternoon in the debate on the common foreign policy . finally , the delicate question of the proposal for a early retirement scheme must be tackled . the transfer of financial control to the directorates-general , and it will only work if the properly trained staff , sufficient funds available and the competence of the linienmanager is an important step in strengthened . the institutions and their head on clear on the best ways of achieving the administration must have . disciplinary procedure - but not yet clear rules , no clear statements , as these rules are to be implemented , and also the question is not here , too , there is promises of external settled finally . such a change is necessary in order to serve truly god , and not be forced by rules . and , as always , when it comes to change the conditions are clearly established , here too achtsamkeit and care needed . a separate vote on the last part of amendment no 15 request , since we are not convinced that the current system in the ecb itself will lead to this situation . withdraw and 6 . as i said earlier , the commission president jacques delors , and this was side by side with mr brittan and with mr cockfield before parliament belonged . mr president , commissioner , mr commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , we pursue this reform with well justified expectations . such problems , such as the bse crisis , greenhouse effect oil prices and have a very european dimension . the people must have the feeling that the commission really accessible and transparent . the reform is important for the european parliament on the matter , as the budgetary authority , and it legislators , plays a decisive influence . in this report malpractice in the officials employed is also a series of clear procedure , the channels for several deliberate within and outside the institution . that is why i am sure that we have the pleasure to listen to you , in future . let me say briefly , mr garriga polledo , the categories of the financial perspective still remain . the reform of the staff of the commission must also be taken , and therefore needs to be acceptance . our view , is a profound change in this reform cosmetic time not make sense . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , first i would like to highlight the quality of the own-initiative report by mrs sauquillo , with regard to the reform of the commission and its impact on the european union 's relations with the developing countries . we want more accountability . we must try to profitmacherei and those who benefit from the exploitation and exploitation of distress suffering population groups have drawn to identify and to speak before projekthilfe all existing causes of account . however , because mr nielson , he will certainly evening heue proposal is so zugeneigt of collective responsibility defend . what is worse in our opinion in the commission 's proposal retention of territorial separation . for the year 2001 , for example , the transfer of finanzverantwortung delegations , the modernization of the delegations and the creation of the external service is provided . 40 additional posts are to 22 edv-anlagen in 15 maritime safety but the erika , as well as the ievoli sun were not french vessels . it is for the disastrous sinking of the erika eleven months ago on the agenda of the top of the commission . we hope and expect that the transport council on 21 december on the common determination of the european institutions contributes to by the adoption of common positions all three legal texts , improving the safety at sea will bring its part . i think that the prospects for this are good , but we need the certainty that this agreement will also be implemented . i welcome the efforts of these two reports as quickly as possible . consequently , i believe that his proposal , the question , if possible , in december to deal with , for basically welcome understand and , in conclusion , minister . we have a parliamentary report drawn up in the improvements proposed at a strengthening of the klassifikationssystems as an important instrument for guaranteeing safety at sea , perceived as a result of all of this amendment to directive in various ways . however , remain from the very serious consequences for homes , often with us again and sometimes you appeared in the sea . legacies years in which materials were simply sunk . in this connection is a crucial factor for the possible access to information , the publication of information to the public emergency numbers , and so on . i have great hopes in the second series of proposals and the creation of a european maritime safety agency . i think thought for their valuable , but we can only on the results of negotiate in the council have been examined . we know that the port state control in the past scharfes for maritime safety , we know that not all of classification societies , as schiff-tüv correct and serious , but rather schlampig have done , and we know that tankers schwimmende time without double hulls are not sword was their control . we are building on the one hand , and we should not act wrong by the commission on the other hand wasting new credibility . anyone who does not do justice to this responsibility , in our waters and in our ports simply do not . the watts report is tougher measures against ships which represent a serious risk drive without , however , these flags of convenience or abolish . nevertheless , i am pleased that the main demands of the members of the french coast of the ban on single-hull oil tankers , the strengthening of controls in the ports and the assessment of the classification societies have taken up , the commission 's proposals . equally , i agree with his suggestion for compulsory tachograph . as has already been said , required to guarantee the safety of important measures in relation to the responsible societies and the besichtigung . in short , with which the desired level should be brought to the safety measures are non-binding . everyone says , as i think quite rightly , that the current port state control necessary for this 25 % -zielvorgabe not yet achieved . the time properly compromises , which also difficult to implement , is over . i should like to take this opportunity to stress once again that the main focus of the current debate on the liability of classification society - and this is my duty - seems to be . with regard to the port state controls and the aggravated the rules must be increased . the laschheit with large enterprises is a sign that these are , as the elected powerful institutions . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , the safety of ships and that the safety of the people , and the protection of the environment is the subject , it is undoubtedly an extremely important issue in a debate . the reports presented in that direction . we are united in relation to the setting of a minimum size for personenschäden or deaths and physical damage caused , and it is left to the member states , this amounts to raise . the introduction of new technologies and constructive improvements to the ships are part of this important work . we must reach a consensus on the highest possible level of safety and regulatory . i am pleased to say that the commission in these three reports support many of the proposed amendments . the commission can accept amendments nos 6 , 7 and 8 , however , only partly accept amendment no 1 . it is expected that the imo the ausmusterungsplan at its meeting in april of next year will be formally . the commission 's task is to make sure that the classification society continue to comply with quality criteria established in the directive and the capacity of the classification societies to monitor . the commission notes with gratitude to the support of their originally proposed restriction . this shows , once again , the adoption of preventive measures at community level for the protection of our seas and stärkender better , as a matter of urgency . mr turco , i have understood your message and this will be taken into account . in the other two reports , the report on the schiffsüberprüfungs- and besichtigungsorganisationen - and the report on port state , in most of the issues , the parliament for action . strictest opinion differs . madam president , i would like to make the amendment to the council and the commission , in this respect , the proposal to change that he begins with the words : ' urges . report ( a5-0329 / 2000 ) by mr pomés ruiz , on behalf of the committee on budgetary control on the commission 's white paper on reform of the commission - competences of the committee on budgetary control [ com ( 2000 ) 0200 - c5-0445 / 2000 - 2000 / 2215 ( cos ) ) mckenna report ( a5-0336 / 2000 ) the privatisation of the classification societies , the shipowners and the lack of effective control of the schiffsinspektion by the public authorities and the agreement between the authorities let capital maßloser act in the hands of the moved tacit this still . i therefore welcome the rapporteur , and have tried in the commission 's proposal remaining gaps . watts vachetta piétrasanta for the implementation of these measures are therefore of the member states . einhüllen-tanker should no longer if they can accommodate elsewhere for 2005 , 2010 or 2015 disappeared . with the proposals submitted by mr hatzidakis , however , those of the commission restricted . the promotion of a stricter system at international level must be a fundamental aim of our policy for the safety at sea remain . it is particularly important to make it clear that the polluter pays principle must apply in full . this must be strengthened by the reactivating the imo , equipped with real polizeibefugnissen to enforce the ism-codes , following the example of europol would be an effective instrument gemeinschaftsmaßnahme . as long as the costs for breaches of legislation under which companies are to be maximalgewinne to keep the wrong choice for their compliance . preparation of the nice council instead of the human rights and facilitated the charter lowering the level of social rights forward measures to be addressed . i would like to see this idea but , unfortunately , in the motions for resolutions . i do not have it , as many regrets that the prime minister , lionel jospin , because of the cohabitation ' as rarely has expressed his ministers , i would like to point out , but i know that he was constantly strong impetus , sometimes during these last six months ' . this is particularly the need to strengthen the economic and social cohesion in the social sphere , the proposals are very modest and not even give the commitments adopted at the lisbon summit . substance . in this sense , we should not take the decision to the development of the eu , the risk of alienation of the citizens of europe entails . the british people wants the eu with the reform more in the duties that they will be more efficient . this text adopted in the future enlargement of the pretext for the strengthening of a system to demand , which is already in the last trains . rückende more distant ( ) now there is not only between large and small ' , but also the ' great ' dispute between dispute ' ' ' . we welcome and support the report , which many important tendencies in the development of the common foreign and security policy with that . every year , this report in principle , the balance sheet of the cfsp is devoted to the method to win ground in a particular area has been extended , regardless of the treaties and the decisions taken at the meetings of the european council . gradually by a breach of the european parliament , the de facto and well-known federalist beaten constantly as ritual during our meeting he heard that a rapid reaction force the member states of the european union is built , about peace in europe and to obtain . it is not the task of the european parliament , the capacity to establish a european rapid reaction force or to decide whether we in this context , for example , interventionskapazitäten in the area of sea and military air forces should have . the future of the conflicts cannot be resolved by military intervention , but only by a policy with the aim of a social , economic and environmental justice . we are totally opposed to this european army , as against nato and our own national army . the report contains wordings on the cfsp and the threat of armed forces ' as a means of exerting pressure in the prevention of conflict , which is directly against the un charter . nato , on the use of ' , for example , to draconian ten years after the upheaval in the east , we believe that ' the european peace project ' to the applicant countries with these reports unedifying a signal . just six of these paragraphs contain statements on the subject of the belong . unfortunately there is the clear intention to suspend the abortion , even abzustrafen or suppressed national abtreibungsgesetze and glaubenstraditionen against the address . it would certainly many tens of thousands of women in the european union pleased that we are here with the provisions of the work of the black economy in the deal , because if they would . affected . mrs smet , for example , proposes the introduction of a european definition of haushaltsdienstleistungen . in the drafting of labour legislation are to be taken into account the needs of budgetary support . you have your contributions to the various national governments abgeführt this as quickly gewandte taschenspieler would disappear . finally , the union for a europe of nations group strongly that the citizens of the european union more than ever in the course of the measures to reform and in the attitudes of the diversity of opinions , and in our countries is taken account of the convictions of existing reminds expect . with regard to the human resources must above all on the reform of the new skills of staff and greater transparency in the staffing policy in general focus . i would like to point out , and to emphasise that our parliament is unfortunately not on all the powers it should have strongly to use this explanation of vote . i will end with a point of order . the information , in fact , contradictory , mr barón crespo . it is not so that the socialist group will not . however , that is precisely what makes us problems : it is an important summit and what we say binds all of us . i must point out that the committee will meet tomorrow afternoon to evaluate the conclusions of the intergovernmental conference in the first place . ( parliament approved the proposal ) i would be grateful if you entsprächen this concern . i condemn that rotterdam in a few days ago , one of the hunger strikers sympathisers a command of the grey wolves murdered . this would , of course , not at all if the council in june and the amended proposal of the european commission , a long way in our direction was , more or respected at all would have been necessary to our first reading . thirdly , it must be examined whether the provisions , which we agree with the internal market work better , and whether you in relation to help to achieve our aim . our second concern is specifically a legal nature and has led us to be adopted by the court of justice to the lifting of tabakwerberichtlinie result in an arbitrary interpretation of this explanatory statement , we come to the conclusion that these are two aspects are not compatible . strictly to the recommendations from the explanatory statement to the harmonisation of the market and the protection of health , and we have recently judgment , still closer interrelationship between ' only ' ; mr president , ladies and gentlemen , there have been deaths in connection with the council of ministers to adopt a tiermehlverbot tests for cattle over 30 months before the release of the new variant of cjd , and europe , that the commission , parliament and compulsory in europe 80 consumption . we believe it is quite article 95 , together with the legal basis for this directive is , as proposed in amendment no 1 , of course , that the article 133 committee now . it is the opinion of the court is a total ban on tobacco advertising on behalf of a smoothly functioning internal market unjustifiable . as indications as ' mild ' and ' low tar ' , ' light ' , i believe that misleading , i am actually against amendments nos 10 and 30 . i would also like to speak on the enthaltende commitment in the treaties . the rapporteur , mr maaten , with reference to article , article 133 on trade policy , and he has also proposed a number of articles , in a number of amendments to this directive on the basis of the case-law of the court of justice contested by another legal basis proposed that this einleuchtender explanatory statement , in order to avoid valid to strengthen . i regret that the committee on legal affairs and the internal market positions have been imposed by the court of justice , is that the ban on tobacco advertising , this directive in a way aushöhlt . as a member of the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , i am very clearly by various groups have been the sale and presentation of tobacco products in europe stricter referred to the need to regulate . paradoxically , the tobacco produced so much that it would be a criminal offence , according to him for the processing of this directive in this directive cultivation of tobacco in the community not banned - even if in countries such as greece to use . this is also thanks to mr byrne for the clear statement of the legal basis . in the european union half a million people die each year on a unnecessary death , and this figure will increase if we do not act now . i am convinced that this legal basis is nothing , and it is therefore right that the trade unions , farms that colleagues here , at the loss of jobs out . i am in favour of warnings bildform list of ingredients , research , with which children , smoke , tar , nicotine and addiction to remain in a sensible europe-wide gesundheitsförderungsmaßnahmen help escaped . this was also willingness to compromise in the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy . as i have understood the amendment would apply tar , nicotine and carbon monoxide is the exception of article 3 , i.e. . as a result of a general nature of the directive , we can solve all the other , which is why we are not the topple . the creation of a possible health warning in some großpackungen would be an appropriate solution . finally , the comment that i am pleased to announce that the commission of the 54 amendments of the report 33 , either fully accept part of form . the main argument for these amendments and after five years , the enlargement of the european union , and it is particularly true speaks of a report is basically after nice and appropriate . the quality of life , and the positive effects of summer-time outweigh the temporarily difficulties because of the zeitumstellung more than summer-time seems to synonymous with a more . summertime is not the problem for our common house of europe . a unique review by the commission in five years is enough . in addition , the needs of the manufacturers of electronic computers and a tachograph and kalendern and terminkalendern to be taken into account . madam president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , the necessary medical research must be approved quickly and unbureaucratically , but it must be respected , and must be protected against the abuse of a maximum of subjects strictly ethically-based limits for patients . this is an important distinction , which we in this report . i would like to thank the rapporteur , mr liese , for his constructive way , and to the council , the amendments approved by the committee on the environment and also in relation to the council contentious points , i would like to remind you that the objective of the result of a long and fruitful search for compromises . we have this in second reading to cooperative has shown , thanks to our adoption of this directive and partizipative if certain remain open . i am thinking in particular in connection with the cancer research , but there are many other areas . unfortunately , despite the new threats and diseases , often rich and the existing medicines to combat . it is the duty of the doctors , more effective means of a modern or against a second request to take measures to these challenges . the vote will take place tomorrow at 12.30 p.m . in order to avoid the action programmes without a break in the meantime , the new health programme should be adopted and implemented , there is no longer the money can be used as the commission has identified the resources available to parliament 's committee on the environment , and of course , this is a second reading and so that there is no vacuum was with the council , with the commission agreed with the four programmes for two years to prolong the understandably verlängerungsbedarf and for the second year but every year . if carry on with . it is high time that the member states agree to the european union in a totally legitimate and more room to manoeuvre in accordance with more resources to grant because diseases know no frontiers . supranational issue at all : estimates of international organisations , such as europol , according to the import of drugs in the union even adopted . public health is national policy , and must remain . the next item is the debate on the report ( a5-0355 / 2000 ) by mrs cerdeira morterero , on behalf of the committee on citizens ' freedoms and rights , justice and home affairs , on the initiative of the portuguese republic in relation to the adoption of a framework decision on the position of victims in criminal proceedings 9650 / 2000 - 2000 / 0811 ( - c5-0392 / 00 ( cns ) ) . a further initiative at international level is the statement by the united nations on basic principles of the treatment of victims of crime and the victims of abuse , by the united nations general assembly on 29 november 1985 was adopted the resolution 40 / 34 of the legitimate . you may recall the debate on the so-called di pietro-bericht , some time in this house has gone . with this initiative three fundamental issue is : the right to information , and the right to compensation of victims of access to justice . the most important aspect is , however , i think that the fact that we finally at union level , a new approach to the action of member states in the fight against crime fully aware of the need to find . the member states should be obliged , special police units for verbrechensopfer set up . italy has repeatedly called for this recidivist murderers , so that it finally serve to france , where lojacono free foot is extradition requests his sentence . it must always be the focus of the victims - not perpetrators . as you will have noticed , are three different types of measures to be adopted ; secondly , specific rules with which the individual states and , thirdly , the requirement of victims of crime victims of the situation of people to be taken into consideration , in one member state , it is heimatstaat minimum rules on the rights of victims of rahmenbeschlussentwurf : firstly , to draw up measures to support introduced . it is already in the networking of national services for the support of the victims of crime victims adequate support to help to ensure , particularly when they are in a country other than the at european level for life . approval of the minutes of the previous sitting has the floor once again , mr varela , chairman of the committee on fisheries , responsible for this matter . so na bravo ! we still have a trialogue last tuesday , in the joint declaration of the council and parliament last schliff given . it is , therefore , we have managed to get a solution for the 2001 budget . we must consider how we in the field of promotion policy needs to develop transparent procedure out all the existing internally . we asked for their name , and they said to us : ' this is the country without behalf . the council has its second reading on the budget and the actual implementation of appropriations is to adopt a budget , the funding of all the priorities of the european union and the actual needs to be carried out , to take account of the agreements with the parliamentary delegation and in the standing capability . the third important element of this second reading of the council is in agreement on the budget of the multiannual programme for enterprise and entrepreneurship , which adds to the employment initiative and supplemented , for the period 2001 to 2005 . in general , i would stress that the budgetary procedure has shown how useful far-reaching in a few days to the end of the interinstitutional agreement of 6 may 1999 . the discussions were sometimes very hard , but always have a better mutual understanding and thus to speed up the finding a satisfactory agreement has contributed to the exchange of views , which is always useful and , as i hope - for all . because of the democratisation of serbia now less aid available , as this before the development of the balkans is essential that no country in serbia was planned . in fact the repeated use within two years , in my opinion , however , wrongly , revision of the financial perspective to be seen as a kind of successive . now we have heard today by the council of its willingness to aufzubessern 3.5 % . i am in favour of the commission and the council , in particular , my sincere thanks . mr president , i would also like to thank mrs haug , for their excellent work . i suspect that there is much to simplify the flexibility and we will see how it works . applies to the revision for large in the coming years , even small amounts . we now have the situation is that we need to decide whether or not , of course , precisely because we must look at the . we can support this budget next thursday . but the interinstitutional agreements between the three institutions are also important . it should mean that we joint plan ahead . the growing problemdruck mainly relates to the unemployment , the bse crisis and the balkan-stabilitätspakt . madam president , ladies and gentlemen of the european parliament , i am happy that the outcome of the french and the progress made in these last few months before you today unionsvorsitzes explain to assess . as we had promised in nice , are not lawless questions left . it is the procedure of closer cooperation in the framework of the first and third pillar largely simplified . it is both a tremendous challenge and an historic phase of the reunite our continent . with this charter will be the values of dignity , freedom and solidarity , it is based on the strengthened our union , reaffirmed . some weeks ago was the chemietanker ievoli sun in the vicinity of the channel islands in distress . we had set objectives are met . i think our union is prepared to accept new members to remain at the same time , it has also strengthened the heart of our fellow citizens in the area of the fundamental values in the area of growth and employment , security , the preservation of the european social model , and it also has to be able to say - emerged strengthened by the family to unite - now that we are safe , together capable of strength and influence at international level . gained from this six months , today , solidarity . ( applause ) in view of the persecuted , although this is the result of all the more disappointing for two reasons : firstly , because it is even harder to achieve a qualified majority , and therefore a blocking minority easier , although in an enlarged union would be necessary concept seemed unavoidable , but the opposite . ( applause ) ( applause ) nice was probably the most ambitious european ambition for the right , with the tackled in a summit for many years . madam president , mr president , mr president , ladies and gentlemen , the judgment of my group , on the fifteen , that the europeans have provided the opportunity in this seen , as it is really to be the common vision of the solidaritätsbewusstsein , to the mutual trust the european top-level is , is very hard . einnehmenden after the little spectacle certainly sprachlosen live they are a very serious consequences , out of the project of a federal europe with 27 or 28 members have to be clear to everyone with the people . mr president , let me stress that , in particular france after nice once again stands as losers . madam president , mr president , the group of independents for a europe of democracies and diversities deplores the message that the presidency has not accepted , it has already übermittel in july . many of the european union should not see the port , in the dereinst access . so there is a dividing line to take into account . i believe it is not only the opinion of the three groups , but also by other groups , but for technical reasons not to sign . it is therefore desirable , the development of medicines in the community to promote increased opportunities for patients , as it an effective treatment . i would like to congratulate my colleague mary honeyball on her first report to the european parliament . has the floor to mr fatuzzo , and i am interested to know what he said what now pensioners amazingly ! the victim must be seen as a person , the situation is insecurity and the situation is even worse if the offence is not in the victim 's country . occurred in a special characterised by oppressed is probably . the next item is the continuation of the joint debate on : it was the despair of the netherlands or belgium , portugal , spain , france , germany or whether the debate focused , who will get to see that only to a more or less agree or something dazugewinnen . we are pleased that a new method has been created in the hope is that it will be able to draw up a future constitution , which our fellow citizens in the hope that the european adventure from the closer cooperation , europe will continue , and hope that this wonderful project is reflection . the candidate countries will take the example of the egoism of our own member states . the unevenly distributed , but the main message is clear : europe can now in an enlarged eu , the democratic summarised by the treaty of nice is close to the citizen pleasure is also . the partikularinteresse was . we now have to deal with the agreement reached on the treaty was a crisis which enlargement in question have avoided , but we can talk of a crisis latenten by a extremis in open . i do not believe that it is more realistic , for the implementation of the operation of the union , and i also believe that the european citizens in the sea battle a ruling in nice to pursue their own national prestiges instead of an efficient working masses have risen . what a wonderful project , eleven years after the berlin wall came down . at that time was for the half of europe , and we must now for the whole of the develop . after nice , we will no longer the institutional obstacles professions . firstly , an institutional imbalance in this respect , the council and the commission and parliament have as much little . this model has discarding . the consequences for europe would have been absolutely unpredictable . for example , as you know , at the beginning of the european union for the two large countries , the so-called ' necessary ' today there are three blocking minority . the path marked out , enlargement is possible , the european parliament in its place in the debate in the further development of the ideas and is thinking . the common european interest , as the sole guardian on this point , mr moscovici , no one can , not on the basis of national interests , and cancel each other , and the message of prime minister verhofstadt in this context , was right to raise the sum of overlap , and very appropriate . we recommended their ratification . i personally believe that a re-weighting of votes on the basis of the population size to the european parliament was that procedure , and the council , we should also . procedures . but nice , mr president , is not the end of the road , but the basis of a new stage with many challenges . therefore , i would like to return to what has been said today a couple of times . apparently , it is really have paralysis of the future , to prevent the ambitious objectives of the french presidency in the new treaty , the total enlarged european union , but could not be implemented . i nice is simply a inadequate . i do not know whether the commission to speak , but given the absence of the council , i wonder whether the commission is convinced that czech and hungarian members and members of polish from the baltic states in the european parliament are also until 2004 , at the end of the debate . we have not progressed in order to achieve our objectives , and that this is the most historic task of the european parliament and the commission in the next few years verhehlt that on the road to enlargement with the same determination as before nice must be dynamism and must overcome . but above all , the problem of the funding of the balkans , in the coming years , there are fully unsolved . i would like to express my congratulations to the end of this agreement , the rapporteurs , the chairman of the committee on budgets , the commission , the council and the presidency for the work of the adoption of the budget for the year 2001 possible . it is good that the main employer is also to thank the rapporteurs . small and medium-sized enterprises as additional resources available were asked . on the football transferred , would be a 1 : 1 unentschieden speak . the fact that we have a budget in the conciliation procedure , and some have , however , does not mean that all our problems are resolved . this was not easy , but the council to recognise the importance of the treaties , although it is sometimes difficult . this also includes a commitment of the college of commissioners , fair and effective distribution of human and material resources for the implementation of the various policies , which means that the political priority of parliament and the managementpriorität the commission must be brought into line . that is why it is precisely the task of the european level , the common security and regeneration of the environment forward . there is a lot of talk post-nice . you are right , of course , always to refer to this question . neither a possible military violence still further rise of the dictatorship are today to fear . russia is considered to be financially almost exactly the same footing , and surely that cannot be right . slightly higher or with morocco it would be very dangerous if the europeans in a logistical dependence on russia would go . and there is also a tacis programme only very limited intervention , not to say that it is only a drop in the ocean . the falling birth rate and the death rate of the population is adopted , nettoverlust russia annually million . mr putin has declared itself , the main problem is not in chechnya . status of the solution can only be a political nature . what is happening with the society of the population , with russia , with the indifferent to the west . mr president , the european union has adopted a good basis for a close relations with the russian republic in recent years , various russlandbezogene documents form . and what means freedom for the people of chechnya ? it is the first step , then we will ensure that legislation is respected , the second step is , moreover , the economic development , and as a result of a civil society . ausprägen trains will fourthly , what stabilised . but this is an excellent report , as is the joint strategy underlines the importance we attach to the relationship between the european union and russia , even - the strategic partnership . this means that we key areas such as the environment and the nuclear safety , and a better coordination of different sources of funding must focus on a number of members mentioned kaliningrad . we must avoid the mistakes of the previous speakers have raised at the beginning of the last century has been made , as russia to the leninistischen revolution of the european political life was excluded what had disastrous consequences of a practically 1917 . as you know , the council has adopted a common position on the amendment of directive 90 / 220 / ec . i think you can , therefore , the answer to your still contentious issues . i am quite prepared to this debate , but it must be found for the most appropriate framework . i do not have to be sufficiently accurate information to answer your question . since he is not , however , say that it has no specific information . the council at its meeting on 19 may 1998 on the alcohol and tobacco reminded of the members to the conclusions he betrugsdelikte has adopted . all member states have their desire to strengthen the fight against fraud , reaffirmed at both internal and at intergovernmental level . the european union has repeatedly reaffirmed its strict compliance with the right to asylum . this is in this respect , the community 2005 at the latest by the duty-free access for essentially all products from the ldcs to akp-eg-partnerschaftsabkommen signed in june 2000 in cotonou . i would remind you that the presidency is there not a question of what the position of the council at the time of the opinion of the individual people to express that it is not just any government , but tonnes ' , ' x ' or ' . it is to create a system , in order not to buy and the level of the market price to pay compensation in elimination of tested cattle producers . it was the beginning of the concerns of the french presidency , a european answer to this crisis to allow the food , health and society are affected . in the context of the barcelona process unterschrieb algeria a number of principles , including the rule of law . i have already had the opportunity to prepare for the special session of the united nations general assembly for the follow-up of the world summit on children in september 2001 will take place , to present some weeks ago , you considerations . subject : the situation in relation to litigation pending settlement on the international court of justice by the end of 2004 . it means that the council will look again at the impact on the accession process and with the aim of these conflicts , particularly with regard to turkey in the context of the partnership in the commission 's proposal on eu partnership - turkey - turkey eu commitments to promote does the council referred to the turkish government to raise this matter in the context of the partnership ? the rights of defence in an appropriate way to the mutual recognition , and can do something ? furthermore , it is up to the individual member states , at national level sovereign decision on the use of national troops in this context , to take operation . subject : common level of tax rates in the hands of the national parliaments and should remain there are no harmonization and the president of the european commission in november in an article in the financial times in the eu , as the importance of tax for the functioning of the single market novel prodi has said that it wishes . no 23 to 32 will be replied to in writing . the stabilisation and association agreement between the european union and the republic of croatia is timely . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i should first like to congratulate on his report , because it was important and right , mrs stenzel has mentioned it - to respond quickly to changes in croatia - mr baltas very warmly on his report , particularly rapid . this is really positive , and there is progress achieved . 1991 / 92 on 250 000 croats were expelled from the kraina from western and ostslawonien . this was a historic year , of course , for south-eastern europe . i believe that such a balance sheet can see . this is an important point for us , and i hope that we can count on the stabilisation and association agreement officially consult again on the support of parliament if we , at the end of the negotiations . the wahid government is meeting with considerable resistance , and the reform process is obviously faltering . also papua-führer are still in prison . in our resolution we call upon the european commission , this approach to taxes . the statements by the commission communication is justified , even if it is characterised by a certain euphoria , certainly from the time resultierte changes in the beginning of the year fully . as for the refugee camps are set up the confrontation between old and new powers and testimony to the weakness of the democratic process , not to take place aburteilungen and the eternity areas indonesian . besorgniserregendsten is on the situation in the moluccas , where the dschihad-kämpfern illegally in a free hand . irian jaya is also one of the victims of umsiedlungspolitik . we must ecological , social or economic questions not basket with the key issue of respect for democracy and human rights , in our relationship with this , we must also be able to set priorities . indonesia clearly political priority . this resolution is clear that indonesia is to irian jaya . the situation has improved , and president wahid deserves our support , but there are still huge problems . it is not acceptable that tens of thousands of refugees from east timor in the hands of the patriotism , the excuse for a punishment for their criminal past escape the mercy of armed rogues , of course . this is because of its economic importance of its importance and its importance for the environment is indonesia , together with the size of the country in terms of population fourthly , in the world . it is to do with regional together . we must , therefore , the police , judicial and administrative resources and instruments , both between the member states and the eu combine . ( the president cut the speaker off ) mrs schreyer , you have repeatedly emphasised that she , as the commissioner responsible for the fight against fraud , in particular , to see their task to ensure the independence of olaf , here in this house . the problems arise from the introduction of a wirtschaftsverwaltung at eu level , the so-called ' community ' to be created for the redistribution of eu taxpayers ' money , and often totally undesirable , because the models ill-considered . i would like to congratulate the rapporteur , i , as a politician and as a man very admire , on her report , but unfortunately i cannot do so . the report is about the protection of the community 's financial interests and about how we deal with this issue . these are the most important issues . i shall because of the time limit for the presentation of the individual points briefly . the debate is closed . there are eu-wide legislation , the companies , and the commission now has promised to guarantee the immediate execution of payments to protect their own rules against such omissions . we have other mechanisms , not when cases of fraud draw attention to . you have just mentioned , and the council said that there was a member state , the establishment of a european public prosecutor , mrs schreyer , have opposed . parliament should know exactly what we expect the court of auditors would therefore very sensible , if it could be of these reports . neither the commission nor the member states should shirk responsibility , particularly by mutual references to the responsibility of each other . he said that quite a serious and regretted the fact . it was a very meaningful , and i also believe that the commission and the court of auditors in the preparation of this report in its deliberations to have confidence in itself as a very step of them . you see , in my speech , i think it is useful , these proposals continue to discuss , to see how more responsibilities appointed . the first decisive shortcoming is the lack of harmonization . i therefore believe that we must also improve the article 4 . within the internal market should be able , their property rights in favour of the companies in the invest , and for the benefit of the relevant companies exercise , and it is regardless of whether it is individuals or companies pension funds . investors we must not close our eyes to reality , there is a restructuring of the stellenplans , redundancies , the measures on the impact of jobs . adoption : in ... but what can we , as a parliament , led by the proposed amendments may ? that is the principle opinions may differ : what is it a law to the regulation of the main takeovers , on tomorrow ? however , would be easier to resolve the question of competence of the regulatory authority . the rapporteur 's amendments , in terms of potential disputes , and it would be wrong if we give our assent to such a request would cause confusion . what i would like to point out that this is the close relationship between it and millions of voters in my country and to the stock market pensions- and sparplänen allied with millions of citizens in relation to this directive . such a procedure not only affects the area of public takeover bids , but it has a much greater scope , and in the context of the general revision of the company law on this issue could be further studies the commission intends to what already exists in some member states . i would also like to remind you that it already expressed earlier in the european parliament 's wish for a framework directive . the resale right is essential and inalienable rights of visual artists to a share of the proceeds from the weiterveräußerung their works . the british lobbyists a fear of loss of jobs . the compromise adopted by the council is only a poor substitute the original commission proposal , the first reading in the broad support in the european parliament was . i also hope for the support of the commission , at least in the three major controversial points . it is also the vitality and the competitiveness of european art market . in another case would be the work of art , without a doubt , elsewhere , i.e. in america , been sold . this amendment is , however , only partly acceptable . liberalisation of the market for postal services this is my proposal , mr savary . firstly , we must ensure that we achieve a favourable prices in the postal services . secondly , we must ensure that we have a high quality , and thirdly , that we have a high availability of postal services in all areas of the european union ensure . the committee on legal affairs was unanimously rejected the proposal for a directive 50 grammes . laid down in the reserved services , but also the 150-gramm-gewichtsgrenze and higher standards in the preisgrenzen for universaldienstanbieter and finally , we can accept that no new liberalisierungstermin until prior assessment has been carried out . you know how difficult the dossier , it is ideologically loaded , sometimes of both sides . this step , which some members of this house is to be welcomed , but would be for the postal services in the european union devastating consequences . furthermore , this will lead to the closure of post office outlets in the country , because this is not survive without the postal services . if we continue pace in the past , we will need in order to build an open market for postal services in europe 100 years . madam president , i would like to make three comments . in the discussion on this new directive , we should take account of a particular point . this is not and should not be . in a fair competition monopolisten can prove that they understand their business . but if i am pleased that a kind of what is a high quality of postal services is , then we must not sad , but also oma is briefträger delighted . anyone who so badly prepared a negotiation in the report on the impact of the need not be surprised if it is not present , who ideologically argued - you mentioned , we will only achieve if we liberalize , liberalise liberalise - but the nose who requested since 1997 , exactly the objectives . mr bolkestein , the commission is the guardian of the treaties . the average income of a identify a number satisfactory , but on the basis of the fact that it is not acceptable . bettelarmen people at all in social terms can be seen from the steinreichen and a bettelarmen , certainly is as if we have there are new times arrived , mr simpson . the governments , which has had , were not socialist , but conservative or liberal . i was clear from the beginning that the commission 's proposal in its original form would never be accepted . this liberalisation and opening up on this because we all agree , is important , however , the speed . the effects of the first directive have not been published , because the consequences are obvious : job losses and working conditions , and no uniform supply of services , particularly in the country and in the deterioration of the blanket postalischen arbeitervierteln . so we come to one of the most important political issues , the liberalisation of postal services , for the completion of the internal market slow progress . this is of crucial importance to the development of the direktmarketingsektors . i appeal directly to the british conservatives . i would like to say : if this is a valuable and to post requesting goes through you breath available . we can only hope that we can one day to overcome the althergebrachte and selfish korpsgeist to defeat , so that europe really move forward . only 3 % of briefmarkts have already been liberalised . it will be ignored , if this is not appropriate for their money received by the technical development and overtaken by consumers achievement . we can only support if the controlled and gradual opening up of the market after a timetable in this adaptation process . on amendments nos 60 and 61 , i support the call for a completion of the internal market to a later date , within a reasonable time frame to determine . the commission will be the same position , and therefore , the council on the basis of the commission 's proposal , the idea that the decision on it . but parliament must now give an opinion . my second report is , therefore , in many respects , the first and accepts the amendments adopted in plenary . it is true , commissioner , that we continue to have certain reservations and some differences remain . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , first of all i would like to congratulate the rapporteur , mr dary , the reform of its history and its context - and i repeat - not to be presented to us , so clearly . it is , in particular , the various regions of the community in the outermost regions , a number of difficulties in the markets to compete , and one of the few products they possess are bananas . chaotic conditions to be avoided , because in the wto rules , all the parties have to keep to the created by the wto . it is no exaggeration to say that this issue which is in all the institutions have caused the greatest attention . we must give priority to contribute to the livelihoods of these producers , by their products we buy . mr president , the rapporteur deserves our thanks and recognition for his report on this difficult issue . i would like to thank the chairman of the council of ministers of agriculture ready in time so that we have accepted this proposal for a reform of the bananensektors today in this parliament and the condition of opinion and to that in the next few days prior consultation of the year 2001 , with a new reform of the com in bananas can begin . groups in this parliament , that you tenacity and halsstarrigkeit members from the outermost regions and also discussed in this debate has repeatedly stressed that the report by mr dary unanimously supported by the committee on agriculture and rural development . ladies and gentlemen , i have the honour of inform you that a delegation of parliament korea in the official gallery . that is , in the council , managed to achieve a positive decision for media . on behalf of the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , on the proposal for a decision of the european parliament and the council on the extension of the community action programmes in the field of public health , with the decisions 645 / 96 / ec / 2000 ) by mr trakatellis report ( a5-0377 . no , no . mr president , i would just like to have the opportunity , with reference to the commissioner 's comments this evening at 12.15 a.m. to point out that amendment no 1 in the commission in the duty to take . ( parliament adopted the oral amendment ) amendment no 2 : parliament would have to insist on the back of submit to the amendments which the size of the warnings , the indication of the ingredients and the protection of consumers and , in particular , the majority of his position and , especially young people is concerned . there is in the eyes of some members of one or two categories of citizens : those who we protects and those who are for economic reasons , we risk ? the ban on tobacco products tar , nicotine content of the current level in the eu and the amendments to the lifting of this regulation is rejected , in particular , i would like to explain why i whose / supported . madam president , i welcome the proposal on how to use the health damage caused by smoking , in order to demonstrate radical in canada images . i believe this to be welcomed , although i would like me - and i should like to take this opportunity to reaffirm the - that much more for the illness prevention spent all . i would have preferred to see if this regulation , because this would activities , which the citizens of the whole of the european union to respond better through a regulation would carried out . the amendments tabled by mr zimmerling art market and the loss of jobs . furthermore , i am afraid that this is a right to a share of the proceeds from the weiterveräußerung benefit from the european wrecking enable mean only a few living artists . - ( nl ) i should like to thank mr zimmerling for the effort he has used this complex issue . that is why i am obliged to vote against the directive . and the stabilisation and association agreement , the cards programme and the european investment bank is not the main instruments of the contribution of the european union to economic and social development of croatia can be . the indonesian government and the army have a duty to guarantee the safety of its citizens and to protect their lives , regardless of what they believe dear . we must , therefore , as quickly as possible to create the necessary instruments for combating fraud involving eu funds more effectively . that would create a single judicial area in the infringements of this kind identified the trial and the execution of judgments in criminal proceedings , carried out in the eu can be achieved . this sometimes seems to be the case . amendments nos 11 and 13 seek to the system of quotas and the commission undertake to propose a tariff system , and some of our trading partners , to call for a tariff system to evaluate would not only in ten years now . what we are also agree that the word ' but ' for a maximum of eur 300 per tonne is here with regard to the recital on the akp-präferenz refers unnecessarily . this should also extend to our trading partners in scarcely have a chance to be accepted . the next item is the commission statement on the eu / usa summit . that is , of course , easier said than done , but we should resist the temptation of us in this intensively with the problems of our political and economic relations i know that the american secretary of state , madeleine albright , also with this view . daily summit , to employ . one of the most important lessons was that the europeans have to make a greater contribution to the conservation of security in europe . i would be grateful if you envisaged for the spring of this point in detail in the field of foreign policy cooperation , but also in these issues , such as the mutual recognition agreements would also make proposals , as we can achieve in the field of dialogues , in addition to the analysis , from the other side of the house has asked all the points in the future new communication would include and security policy , pragmatic . i know , however , the commission , with the forthcoming summit to use the opportunity to join this initiative and the united states , and welcome the everything but arms ' everything but arms ask for . we must therefore act , the irrevocable fate is waiting for the mumia abu-jamal or in part for years in the road haulage driver stuck to prevent the on those as leonard pelletier death row . this is a sensible proposal we are happy to take up . thank you very much , commissioner . i am afraid that i am cross at the moment , in my own group . thirdly , it must formulae for the simple tax to be applied , specifically , the reversal of the reverse charges . the first conclusion is that we can do little international framework as long as this is not changed . mr president , first of all , the committee would like to say that the current arrangements for the following : software , the provision of services of disadvantage and processing of data , computerdienste web-hosting , web-design and information services . eu-anbieter i have always said , one of the rules and principles of legislators , must not erlasse laws , as follows : the first unenforceable . fortunately , thanks to the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , a number of important elements of the circumstances in the transport committee will take place in the report of the committee responsible , amongst other things , supported by a combination of several clearly too little . at the same time , we must , however , also for a revision of the agreement of several chicago of 1944 enter a new on an international level to achieve . in one country to go to the detriment of other eu countries standortvorteile short-term or the other . mr president , europe is in the field of internet use in the coming decade to take a leading position in the world . many people ask , commissioner , why the europeans always quickly in the hands of taxes and new rules . the agreement of several chicago on this point is completely out of date . i consider the introduction of a common system of vat is not a priority and i am also not believe that the introduction of a common system is long overdue . a tax rates below 30 % of the united states budgetüberschüsse achieved by a number of usd 100 billion . by far the vorzuziehende option is to give you the same conditions for the american and other companies active in the world the exemption of the european e-unternehmen prevail . the tax competition is in the interests of citizens and the economy . the companies from outside the union , about the same duties as the local companies in the provision of services for the consumer to fulfil their choice , and the vat rate for the purpose of vat in a member state registering their business will be applied . elected on the state must tax now , quite as simple as that is the situation is not . the question concerns the place where the tax and the debate on the number of countries , the question of the companies , in my view , the united states and , of course , be quite heart-rending to a complaint to the wto challenge . source , i.e. should apply there would registering it is a little sense , but a lot more pleasant , for the same route £ 250 must pay for the whole airways flight from london to brussels and with virgin 89 £ costs , while i eurostar far less greenhouse gases , and for the journey back , for example , the emittiert around . mr president , this debate the old schreckgespenster again come to light . furthermore , the proposals of the french presidency to the place of taxation consumption , with the duty of service providers to registration in all member states have been discussed . the european airlines would compared to airlines from third countries disadvantaged and this would preisgefüge for flights within the eu contrary to the prices for intercontinental flights distorted . however , seems to me a solution to a kapitalabfluss from europe , not only in the area of the oecd and in einzelverhandlungen with possible . leads i am aware that the members of this house controversy sometimes views . this will in the case of the complexity of the use of macroeconomic or comparable criteria avoided . i now turn to the proposal on the mindestnormalsatz . consequently , in the preparatory work carried out , and that the next assembly a renegotiation of the agreement of several chicago decided , is still no substantial icao-arbeitsgruppen already unlikely . this feeling is unfortunately today in the european public . the aim of this directive is to strengthen the obligation to establish a strong and , through greater powers to intervene at sea in the event of serious verschmutzungsgefahr . seenotfallmanagements by the nothäfen , by the ban on departure during sturms last and by the coastal state the oil companies say that they have a voluntary fund . i hope that the doubts and the opposition to the impetus of nice lessened and manage our project . of course , we have to ensure safety at sea , because you know , no doubt that week passes , not the same question : what unternehmt their meps ' and to guarantee the security and to change the rules ? ' confidence in you , if it mr president , the commission is aware of the payment for the use of roads , for example , the british and transporters are equal pay if it is the roads in the united kingdom in the british government plans announced , including the introduction of a special contain a vignette nichtbritischen equally on 8 november 2000 . secondly , if the minister , what he had originally desired by foreign lorries to tax in order to subsidize is contrary to the european kraftverkehrsunternehmen 's own country , this right ? this kind of economic imbalance between the levies and taxes , the kraftverkehrsunternehmen in the individual member states have to pay distorted the conditions under which kraftverkehrsunternehmen different nationality in the united kingdom in competition . the question of the use of meat and bone meal , for its export to apply the legislation , also for the production of meat and bone meal , with the demand that , for example . specified risk material from the meat and bone meal is also contained in the legislation in force on 1 march 2001 and to remove exactly the same apply in the european union . the jews are verräter and liar . i hope very much that we are in every country in this region say that education tolerance and not the intolerance promoted . the response from mr monti , i had thought . question no 37 by ( h-0900 / 00 ) : furthermore , the commission will propose a temporary unterstützungsmechanismus specifically designed korean unfair practices in the face of the wto procedure needs to schutzzwecken , is the time until the conclusion of . this is a matter of urgency . the verwenderindustrie 70 000 employees , but in this sector is only a very small kostenanteil of approximately 2 % for koks has a total of this product . question no 40 by ( h-0889 / 00 ) : we have our proposal to the acp countries practically the same time as presented to our member states . incidentally , i can assure you that this initiative is not aimed at this problem , because the additional quantities in the community market could be introduced , very small rules . these countries have , unfortunately , no independent verhandlungsmacht and , consequently , i think that we need to act in this case , unilaterally and without compensation because of their situation . the bewilligungsverfahren requested the commission will shortly be completed and the resources needed for the financial support ecpat 2001 adhered to . we have it here with three types of activity . the site of the court will in future the commission 's proposal said nothing . i am not sure what the honourable member values with the word ' proliferation ' means . the question by mr berenguer fuster is trade marks . i see it as a spur to implement the necessary steps to new and to ensure that spain as quickly as possible . at the last question , you have replied that spain was to blame and you would do what to do is up to you . this was a good declaration , to reply to my previous question . the directive 89 / 48 / eec is diplomas at the end of at least three-year vocational training in the end of the sekundarstufe . subject : the straits of the gulf of finland , sweden ) in the maritime transport links in the nordkvark ( vasa is , after the shipping companies no more than unprofitable ( nordkvark ) should be stopped . opportunities to tax-free-verkauf - umeå for example , in the city of vasa in the last two years 550 jobs in tourism , perhaps , in particular , it is precisely because of the attitude of the tax-free-verkaufs dismantled , i have been . the proposal reflects the concern of the lisbon summit reflect , because it is the aim of the development and use of digital content to support . furthermore , i urge the commission to faster and more efficient implementation modalities in the field of hearing of proposals to develop . if we understand , in particular , what is desirable , we must not forget that the situation with the content , since this is only useful information for companies to go further . meteorologische and geographical data , of course , very difficult to make on the content of the including for companies useful only for the citizens of certain the digital content , the quantity and quality of the cultural and social restricted by than by good thing standardised diversity . the second point is that we are to the small and medium-sized enterprises that we think the start-ups as seems essential to me . but if we make a virtue of necessity , the signs of our languages , but as bridges , as advantages and benefits , that is the basis for the european market and a certain degree of independence , not as simple umdrehen barriers to see . i shall not comment on all of the objectives of the creation of favourable conditions for the marketing and use of digital content to encourage the economic activity , to improve the employment prospects and the potential of the european digital content in comparison with the united states , dissemination of european programme : once again to make better use . it is therefore becoming increasingly important for the production of content multilingual europe in the right conditions to be created . some of these amendments are very valuable , but in other legislation better lifted . the various positions can now be explained , is the vote this evening , and if not , then i thought it much better , in tomorrow 's votes , if the members of this house are present , such a request , rather than this evening . according to the most group in parliament tomorrow is to be voted for vollzählig mr president , ladies and gentlemen , ladies and gentlemen , more and more people in the european union harassed by noise . this evening , and when the night , the member states to decide freely , when the begins . i therefore welcome the commission 's proposal , which is , however , see a first and i think that hesitant step . therefore , this will reduce and prevent the noise in the future must be an essential part of the european environmental policy . the group of the european united left supports his proposals , although we would like to go further in order to find solutions and coherent action against those from the noise of money are still something readily . however , let me refer to the gezänk recently in the committee behind the scenes here and now and , in addition , under which dispute and say . i would therefore not hide the fact that my country , agree to the commission proposal , because it is sufficient to ancestors accepted by the spaniards themselves as our foreign guests estimated to be maintained , as it contains flexibilitätsmechanismus by our lebensgewohnheiten enormous difficulties . i commend the report and , of course , the commission 's proposal to the house anyway . secondly , we have daughter directives on the quality standards . my full support to the need for harmonisation of indicators and the whole area of the drafting of the appropriate action plans for reducing the noise and the protection quiet areas and the enlargement of the margin for the noise maps , bewertungsmethoden , public information . secondly , this proposal is a new approach to the evaluation of gesamtlärmsituation in europe , which the number of people disturbed by the noise . accept the following amendments : nos 1 to 3 , 14 , 18 , 27 , 30 , 34 , 35 and 43 are acceptable in part or in principle . furthermore , must not be used for not processed food additives in general - which is in this case , the treatment of the substantial change to its originalzustands - no go through , lead . mr president , in the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , we have voted in favour of the ppe group for the lannoye report also fully meets our ideas . no one says that . the next item is the debate on the report ( a5-372 / 2000 ) by mr staes , on behalf of the european parliament delegation to the conciliation committee on the conciliation committee draft directive , the european parliament and the council to amend the directive 95 / 53 / ec of the council with rules for the implementation of the official inspections of feed . the french presidency was a firm , a very clear message here and not a ' by ' meant , therefore , i wink further . in other replaced by a decision and the member states , the commission has now been found a compromise acceptable to the conciliation committee , the assurance that the commission have been taken so long to remain in force until they commit the full support during the studies and on-the-spot checks to grant experts : the protection long negotiations . i welcome this legislation . the esf and the resources available to the development of the disadvantaged and poorer areas of our society concentrated in the eu , particularly the finance ministries must always resources from the structural funds . european cities are important economic , political and socio-economic centres . a clear legislation and the careful monitoring of their compliance with further instruments . the commission is , the european parliament for the considerable support it in this proposal , and for the many amendments grateful . in view of the nature of the measure , the commission can no amendments . i say this because it is both timely and i am sure that this subject for all sorts of reasons , rightly or wrong , but most of the press dealt with in a very issue , vote no day goes by the incorrect . the maximalisten want to recommend , only to a considerable risk to health and the environment recourse to the precautionary principle , in other words , but no one knows how this should be setting threshold above a yet unspecified , while the minimalisten block progress and innovation . the clarification of the respective roles and competences is a fundamental condition for the restoration of the necessary public confidence in science and the decision-makers in us , the politicians . in these cases , precaution a sicherheitsspielraum left . we asked for a regulation , which would ensure that it is possible to extend the scope of the precautionary principle in the context of the wto to other commitments professions - for example , in the context of multilateral umweltschutzabkommen duties - to have taken measures in the world trade organisation , perhaps . of course , the precautionary principle is important to give more rechtsstabilität with the aim of international law , as it standard to anchor . the art of life is considered to deal with these risks and uncertainties . it is sometimes a little too much and banalisiert it again , then what our indignation invokes . this applies for phthalates in toys . we have the remarkable intention of toy in sweets , eis and other esswaren to ban . the same applies to the call for a thorough analysis of the commission proposed . the commission is urged to apply the principle of safety in the preparation of its legislative proposals and then , if necessary to take account of the resolution , with its guidelines and always in all its measures . a general de-minimis-schwelle cannot be determine . the first award the sakharov prize to a human rights organisation , the officially confirmed the european parliament that any violation of these rights must be combated by their fight within the union will , unconditionally . madam president , ladies and gentlemen , the initiative of this parliament honorable us today to express thanks for the recognition of their ' would particularly like to basta ya ' . and it will not only of murder . i would therefore ask me here to follow and confidence . ( parliament adopted the legislative resolution ) madam president , allow me to my oral amendment no 51 , give it if the house , i would like a clarification . report ( a5-0334 / 2000 ) by mr garcía-margallo y marfil , on behalf of the committee on economic and monetary affairs , on the commission communication : taxation of flugkraftstoff [ com ( 2000 ) 110 - c5-0207 / 2000 - 2000 / 2114 ( cos ) ) this agreement is attractive for certain enterprises , the environment and democracy , however , it is damaging . the most dramatic event since our last budgetary debates is , of course , the bse crisis . this would clearly against the letter and spirit of the above the decisions of the heads of state and government in the question breach . parliament has a number of important priorities for the fight against unemployment and poverty , a number of important environmental and equal opportunities we have voted against the attacks on the side of the life programme and to the european women ´ s lobby . successful can establish - including increased use of civil etc . however , raises the question of whether the originally earmarked eur 350 million to the extent of the appropriations provided for kosovo legitimate this region yugoslavia for 2001 , in fact . there is no reason , a certain distributionsform to grant tax . a final date is the players in the postal market clear signals and the national monopolies , the possibility of better for a prepare deregulation . the specific characteristics of each state , and there is a simple , perhaps with a very small majority decision of the postal service is a whole philosophy of explain its roots , with only ausradieren ? the proposed by the commission 50 grammes , with a level of the public are really to drastically , and would have devastating effects on the providers of universalpostdiensten had preisgrenze in zweieinhalbfachen tarifs borders . we therefore reject the whole of the matter on which it aims , clearly and firmly reject . . ( sv ) we are not believe that the eu should concern itself with the problem of the postal sector , even if the proposal is to the treatment of the committee significantly better than the original commission proposal . dary report ( a5-0374 / 2000 ) in our opinion , the small producers , the pflanzungen on their work , without anyone exploiting the consequences of the war is protected and their incomes , regardless of the market uncertainties must , however , be guaranteed . since the exercise of the right of free expression to article 10 duties and responsibilities brings it can be subject to restrictions or strafdrohungen conditions . in view of the fact that the content of the european account for 5 % of gdp and 4 million jobs , we can only welcome this initiative . numerical wertmäßig under these conditions , the united states have their hegemony in this zukunftsmarkt just their thanks to their unity and coherence . i also hope that this distribution of competences , by applying the subsidiaritätskriteriums so far , the regions and the autonomous communities within the union be able to retain their status . we are very pleased about this . for example in the above the national parliaments to ratify robbed of their rights , and a country in the council , can no longer say no , if it is violated its interests in the negotiations minority is in the last negotiations . before we have repeatedly warned that shows that a much broader agenda had meant that this year the results would have disastrous consequences for the way in nice and in all clarity , perhaps not at all with enlargement . ( en ) in the light of the fundamental importance of the decisions it at the summit in nice meeting , where there was also recognition must been to pay . recognition . in other words , the intention of parliament is that the control of the issues of taxation and social security to gain . in this long night gestrickten offer no solid ; you have just thick holes , by the identitätsstiftung , more democracy , transparency , concepts such as the participation of the citizens fail slippery or reformbewusstsein decisions of the council . we must therefore reputation as a result of a compromise , it is not the clear winner still clearly unterlegene its conclusions . on the contrary , the influence of national democracies is adopted , because the right of veto further limited and the european parliament more power receives . the vote will be possible for us to be cheaper and more this is what you must , therefore , for this report , in the light of the taxation of flugkraftstoff remain limited , because it always tickets , therefore , we can travel modes of transport . ' ' rein in the homes , you could not along blumentopf on the head traps . the complexity of the structural änderungsprozesse urgently require the involvement of all the partners in the development partnerships , embedded in the drafting of strategic concepts of regional policy for each region and diversity of technological change and local and regional level . we must therefore be trying to avoid what these three important stifle or could affect all conditions . we could say that the innovation , for all those involved in the area of the possibilities of the production process . the gap between rich and underprivileged regions in the technological development is much greater than in gross domestic product . as the main argument bureaucrats , as you know , claim that there is the risk of mistakes . i do not know whether it was a direct consequence of this risi-initiative that today the european budget , but i would be pleased if this weihnachtspräsent that we decide in future , women have signed three ladies would benefit . it is also a mistake , the budget as a chapter for pilot projects , new ideas for the local and urban development - with more than acceptable results on the basis of community programmes , such as interreg , urban and so popular at local level to reduce this - was envisaged . as mr rack , i have never understood it and will never understand very well expressed this regional policy and cohesion policy as a kind of charity towards the poorest regions as such . this is why i am in the current negotiations on the quality of the überprüfe , apart from the scope of this regionalprogramms , especially the smes , which educational establishments and even the farms . eppd , apart from the innovative actions , and i am speaking , that every programmplanungsdokument a regional plan for the access to the information society contains and what directly by the mainstream mrs schroedter , mr izquierdo collado and mr ortuondo larrea have rightly raised this question of funding . the prices for schiffneubauten are dramatically in recent years have gone to the 1999 as a result of this policy , south korea and their all-time low . the committee had to vote separately , in order to ensure that this item on the agenda for today 's debate . this concept is also in line with the treaty . my time is not enough to detail . however , we consider the commission proposal that aid for research and development , the complaint before the world trade organisation on the practice in korea - as they have worked with prices , the costs are under way , but it is not includes , for a perhaps more or less weak for a solution - and the possibility of übergangsbeihilfen as long as decided on the complaint . at the same time , korea must , as in the context of the oecd , strengthened by anti-dumping measures under pressure . this means that we are suffering of unemployment and the other people do business with the real shipyards . i think it is an excellent analysis of the shipbuilding sector in europe , which is the reality . this process will be no rapid results , and should go through all stages , takes this up to two years . the mechanisms in application would be brought to a decision is in this wto proceedings . i am sure that we are now all of us feel the need to defend freedom in europe , but i would like to say that we are in spain on the solidarity of the colleagues in the european parliament , together with energy and commitment is needed . it schwamm in may , in the waters of worrying signs of damage to be made , as nuklearherz . it would be alarming if we in the face of this situation , would act as soon as possible . in both the public informed that the two member states concerned , the united kingdom and spain , in close cooperation with the safest solution for the repair of the u-boots seek and , of course , we indicate the importance of this . we have heard after the accident was not exactly the opposite direction in which the damage is lengthy and complex reparations , need to make allegations of leaders of the british kriegsflotte which serious and others , and considerably . the house is aware that this would be if this would have been possible , so that the role , in its place now me to reply . the commission is to analyse this plan . it is therefore taking account of the real state of affairs , we are talking about what opportunities the authorities of the united kingdom , and , in order to deal with the problem of gibraltar already . calm cooperation is the method used in our union . the british government is just as recently as the russian government , it is one of its submarines came to a shipwreck . mr president , i would also like to express my deepest sympathy to the eta terrorist mordanschlags our spanish colleagues in the light of the recent . the commission was a clear answer to this , although the resolution of the group of the people 's party has recognised that this is not what we , in addition to the matter further bagatellisierungen has our approval . hindered in their two months ago and in their current response so responsibly , chief peter has the right to do so , as the panel of experts anwies him directly , report back to caruana minister . this is and remains the position of the interests of the safety of all parties involved in our view kohärenteste and best safeguards . b5-0908 / 2000 by mrs maij-weggen and mr posselt , on behalf of the ppe-de group ; 1980 have dealt with the unhcr 5 million refugees . today , we appreciate the unhcr and all the humanitarian staff . mr president , the commission would like to support the unhcr , on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of its creation by parliament , of course , to support . i would like to speak on a general problem and refer to the speech of a member of parliament . b5-0909 / 2000 by mrs pack and others on behalf of the ppe-de group ; i would like to mention the terrible events of the border between serbia and kosovo and the last problem . there is milosevic , and not to parteitage in belgrade . in our view is also necessary that the ethnic groups respect each other , rather than to each other to bekriegen dahingehendes change in kosovo . without even a case of sing to want to say that the european union has reacted to the new situation , we can very quickly . b5-0915 / 2000 by mr medina ortega and others on behalf of the pse group ; b5-0918 / 2000 by mrs napoletano and others on behalf of the pse group ; the chilean government pledged that general pinochet in chile would receive a fair procedure and , indeed , general pinochet has now lost his immunity and the judicial authorities have a procedure taken against him . allow me to remind you that it is important that this joint resolution now , when pinochet in chile is what we have not been able to adopt , when he was in britain . i say this in the knowledge about the grundüberzeugungen of the parties in the european free alliance and the greens in this house . mr president , before i start my speech , i want to join with me that a member of the people 's party and councillor , catalonia , in spain , cost the lives of the sentencing of the attentats elected representatives . for this reason , i am pleased that my group - the majority of our parliament not to be blamed for the current crisis and , i think we can show induce the exploit . in the highest risk their lives . the league for human rights has closed its premises and its president , moktar trifi is , as you have just heard , for 25 summoned before the court versiegelt december . human rights , gewerkschaftsmitglieder , academics , journalists and students reports on constant persecution by the authorities . condition is very , very seriously . daily harassment and the zusammenschlagen of democrats really are the rule . i hope that the chilean justice system in this matter continue to demonstrate its independence and effectiveness . as we know , the political situation in the country of the european union heads of mission to follow very closely . finally , i would like to mention the important role of the european parliament , as of today 's public awareness and to strengthen the dialogue on these issues contributes through visits of parliamentarians and public debates . laurent gbagbo must pursue a genuine policy of national reconciliation , by the concept of the constitution and democratic elections are carried out , in which no candidate excluded , because otherwise the risk of the secession of civil war and still is , ivorität exiled racist change . mr president , the news of the ivory coast unrest in the european public concern in parliament have caused a reasoned and appropriate for months . conditions are excluded feels that the supreme court , the head of state clearly in the process of restoration of democracy unprofitable and the opinions of the committee for national reconciliation listened to set up by the military abolished that nobody . it seems to me , the concept of ivorität totally justified . now is approximately half a dozen copies of the president available . mr president , on behalf of the greens , we draw our resolution also back . mr president , i agree with the words of mr posselt . ( the minutes were approved ) the member states must implement the necessary care and address the issue of costs , particularly for the disabled , their families , the resulting pressures for elderly people and in a new political concepts both the problem is really cannot fully alone to bear . mr president , it is me particular pleasure , on behalf of the group of the greens / european free alliance , on the excellent report , to congratulate the rapporteur . thanks to medical care , better information , better and more and more people live longer care , wohnverhältnisse pensions today . it is , above all the governments of member states , the administrations of federal states , provinces , and the communities , with many recommendations do something . this will be laid the foundation stone for living in the family in the every man as a child aufwächst . it is very often , that it is a very difficult and the help of all his life , in recent years ill and completely powerless needs . finally , i would like to medical care . as you said , women must be removed from the working life , so that the work men . at first sight could take that as many disadvantage . we must find a way of this already . the countless active old should motivate us all , a society in the argue , for the solidarity between generations not phrase . these measures will have to be adapted to the respective situations and characteristics in relation to the quality of life and financial independence . that is the only common ongoing effort can help us . it must discretion for individual preferences and decisions . if someone regain the objects , our colleague , mrs flemming was behind you , mr fatuzzo , because then he should please zurückbringen , especially the glasses have lost . finally , the possibilities of measures for outermost regions and their logo again expressly incorporated in the text . to refer to the animal is also environmentally friendly and know what production methods are used in europe . i am therefore pleased that we set up for this week the european parliament as a arbeitskreis biotechnology . this should , of course , be coordinated , especially on the part of the major supermarket chains , only supplement the institutional information campaigns advertising measures . if parliament were to be implemented with the majority here , but here again the powerlessness of the parliament - that the stillegungsflächen with legumes grown could be permitted , then we would have had more grundfutter , more eiweißfutter would be the feeding of the proposals of the three times have gone through shows , with clover grass . this is surely manufacturers and retailers professional and not the european union . we must ask ourselves why we have failed to get the money available to use it in the past , the industry in the european union . of course , if we can produce food and promote the better for the environment , animal health and take account of the sell well fulfil the common agricultural policy was set out in the world market , we really is entitled to . amendments nos 9 and amendments nos 7 , 19 , 23 , 27 and where further verfahrensänderungen called for , is to say that the commission to keep to the management committee for the creation of a specific and 22 , which must verfahrensbestimmungen coherent . all those who say that we in europe , schmecken can be right . mr president , it is scientifically proven that the best prevention or alzheimer 's , and i could mention a moderate weinkonsum against cancer , herzinfarkte , many other diseases . i would like to praise the rapporteur for his work .