we are extremely well aware that the existing treaties inadequate and future another , more efficient structure for the union must be developed , namely a stronger entrench deep-rooted structure with a clear demarcation of powers between the member states and the competences of the union . yet it would be messages to the first concerns over the economic and social difficulties , with which we despite constant growth as a result aeroplane efforts by both sides of all our fellow citizens are facing . the current situation , particularly for many self-employed hauliers , for agriculture is intolerable , must be improved in all cases . the accommodation of the procedure itself is good , but it must be taken to ensure that the system can be used as a political schlagwaffe . as you are now clear on the rights look , you must comply . i agree with his warning against a capacities for some tempting to return to the intergovernmental methods . many of us to seek a federation of nation states . this also implies that its proper place every place . the rapporteur that the discussion levels have stressed , and also the need to go further . i should , of course only agree . i would say that latter made a speech before the forces concerned , you are familiar with studying and make it plain must , as a political speech must always be realistic and will always kräftesituation and all of us desired into account . i think that we in this closer cooperation starting to some examples of the new europe 's capacity to produce . the vote will take place today at 12.30 p.m . the commission must reject amendment no 12 . i will vote for the adoption of regelungsentwurfs . that will be in the reports of the european court constantly on such a low indications referred to by greece by portugal occur again . so we have not voted for this report . pro-abortion & such buses are not only cheaper and worldwide seaworthy , but also respect environmentally friendly , as your fuel per passenger is lower . the report calls on furthermore set benchmarks with a view to the dissemination of best practices in the eu on . a binding charter and all-embracing with enforceable rights to a later date could lead to difficulties . i thank both for their excellent use . we do not believe that it has already been less than three months can be concluded in nice . alone for this reason we cannot vote in favour charter during the summit in nice in the treaty included . the welcomes csu , with the present schlussentwurf of the charter of citizens with regard to bodies and institutions of the eu rightful fundamental summed up and be made visible . it is a abbild in emergence of begriffenen liberal europe . because i would have liked to have worked on this charter will continue , as this numerous ngos from various countries of the union have proposed . a5-0248 by ( 2000 ) by mr queiró hungary to [ com ( 1999 ) 505 - c5-0028 by 2000 - 1997 by 2175 ( cos ) ] ; that is why i would like to thank you also propose that we as parliament next year impairs absolutely no longer present , but still only national reports , to make clear that we fortgang a differentiated approach for the negotiations concerned . it seems that further , the french presidency on the basis of the work of the previous presidencies and the commission will be able least - i hope that , at european council in nice accurate overview on a right to give accession process . as i said earlier , and repeat here like the french presidency will none of distinct difficulties shy , which means that we of course not the time and have the opportunity , each of these difficulties auszudiskutieren . this issue is of course perfectly understandable , but it must take appropriate and precise replied . it represents a big picture towards which we must tackle with generosity and vision . each of the intergovernmental conference would not result in the face of huge adjustments on enlargement . the second major change we are seeing and on which europe must stop , is the breakneck speed up the economic development towards on global market and for global competition . fourthly follows another as a principle that the states , the later begun , have a fair chance , which have to aufzuschließen , the sooner started . where great and long-term investment needed to achieve european standards , should also be careful that the members present in these cases have long transition periods in department . for bay and crime also apply our standards and the benefits of european cooperation . but we consider the current trade relations between the european union and the central and eastern europe . fortunately the commissioner has now at the first time , the citizens informed fears , of which were discussed , let unfounded . but thing is clear - and i welcome it , mr verheugen has emphasised this again : a transitional period for compliance with the democratic rules do not give it . do we need the help of the commission , because it lacks us at all times determination to the relevant ammunition . this is necessary , so that we as european objectives can make the internal reforms to bring finish . but there are important issues and questions , where we differ . this runs counter to the european union , its future independence with regard north america as well as a common european defence and security policy , because it involves risks for relationship with russia and other countries . we wish us and we want results , however , that is what in preparation for the enlargement must not be done , on another intergovernmental conference postponed . i shall be brief , as i said earlier this done , as i said in my first speech three minutes my time have not used . this is very important , and i am very pleased that the commission operates on an information campaign , after the words of commissioner verheugen both comprehensive both decentralised should be implemented . but - and this is my final word , because i think that this is quite clear : i am no pessimist in this respect , i am not counting on time , i want a clear statement benefit to the enlargement - to be credible , must remain one seriously , it must be understood , it must be the approval of the peoples of the peoples of the candidate countries as well as our peoples , can gain . moment i see no need , in connection with enlargement on the financial perspective , speeches . by one single it i can tell you today ! same reason incidentally you also have to desire , the european union joining . we are now in the various rapporteurs floor . me was the responsible task entrusted to report on the request estlands on accession to the european union forward . as conservative assume i very economical with sums at the taxpayers . i believe , only you had a alienates them , what the people of latvia in recent years have done . that is not enough , the whole strategy must stronger and bürgerinnen geared to the citizens . lithuania disposal on a formidable potential for a long-term economic growth . in the broadest sense concerns cooperation between the european union with the russian federation . another point is neuralgischer support for the public in and outside the european union . as a result clever fiscal amounted to the direct foreign last year on more than 5,45 billion euros . we should not interfere , we have certainly not german ! the slovak developed a stable democracy , and in this area we have had here else seen . in my speech i shall six aspects of the development of the situation in hungary identify and rationalize the under the angle of accession to the european union are crucial . i am therefore pleased that this issue in general of the report by mr brok on enlargement has been raised . this applies to hardly any more of an area in the field of nuclear power , where the danger that the lobby of kernkraftgegner the legitimate concerns in relation to nuclear safety and protection for their own purposes usurpiert . i would like my colleagues endorses the education of a high-level working recommend . the report , which also adopted unanimously in committee to come to the conclusion that the part of national territory of the legal authorities untersteht the political criteria of copenhagen . comes out of our key role for the cfsp high representative , javier solana , to wovon own role , the commission of course intact . the main problem malta but there still remains agree that the accession process of government and opposition judged differently will and the european union keen establishes that this accession process flow smoothly . even between america and mexico lie the pitched close gathered . we are therefore set in the area of internal market for a thoughtful , flexible and the challenge a proper strategy . i should like to say the & but also , i bürgerinnen and respect for all citizens in central and eastern european countries have the courage to ten years ago , on the paved had to go , and this process with have brought in motion . the information society is important for the old as for the new industry . we must also do not by the percentages of community legislation in intra-state umgesetztes be blinded . the 10 new applicant countries have such a rich erbonkel not returns . this applies equally to the endured - - transportation to the slaughterhouses . now we are working on a system for all the important acts of cost-impact should provide the health implications . in my opinion on the european union must also be addressed and made clear that the european fund for regional development continue not on the basis of bookkeeper distribution among regions and areas must be granted . elmar brok has rightly his speech with pointing out that we all initiated the beneficiaries of enlargement will also be , in particular we on this side of the current external borders . the binnenschiffverkehr will be important environmental reasons , because we tranship bulk must get away from the roads , and if we do not just the rail distances can , then we must use waterways . also selfishness and not least populism have played a breaking handelsblatt , and the result that has certainly not a catalytic effect . our message to the candidate countries : ' let us not extent through the reports and documents irritated . unfortunately currently have too many parties its ideological feathers abgestreift with the result that you too little embody ideals and to noticing . should it be necessary , the right to free acquisition of drive away and eigenheimen suspend , so we should do so . it is not hitherto existed , but will possibly by bureaucratic opacity , and the obvious , but not threaten public opposition certain governments . where are the millions of jobs because incidentally , the maastricht treaty should provide ? while we are still doing , to adopt the new treaties , some have been calling for the next reform . almost all international studies indicate with regard to enlargement towards the macroeconomic profits . yet at the main aim slovenian policy - earliest accession to the european union - apart from some trivial minorities none of alien in question . will enlargement of the union vollzogen quickly , that would largely in place as it decentralised , the eldr group in its opinion on enlargement worded . that was made clear that for that country typical strictly orderly anstaltsregime long-term consequences for the health has orphans . i ask you to support the appropriate applications . and even the european politicians , we have too little insight into the negotiating process . cyprus will be virtually bridge to countries acting in this region . i wish to continue abnegating success on this important area . a second nature and communication clearly also between our countries and enlargement countries , to communicate , worum it in the european union issue . we cannot afford any more , by impetus from beginning to lose the 1990s . mr president , first i as rapporteur of the socialist group for the report on romania the rapporteur on her excellent product congratulate . for the institutions , for the member states , for all concerned about it , should this challenge , but also the fears of our own public grown to demonstrate , once again , and the force of the visionskraft ambition and find the founding fathers of europe . unfortunately i have the impression that this enlargement process despite many fine words and despite hard-working öffnens and schließens numerous chapters council with the necessary political emphasis being pursued . many countries of the union had to a certain time its development with similar problems fighting and can bulgaria advised to help overcome the current problems . democracy is not just a question of majorities in particular , but also a question of adequate codecision of minorities . applicant countries must be the same treatment and their accession should only be dependent on their development . the same time we should recognise , with as much use countries as lithuania try to eliminate recover soil . it lies in our interest in this respect , our legal and freiheitssystem until after romania extended , and this is certainly a critical in a public debate with our argument . with regard to a matter herrscht there however great unanimity , and that is enlargement . my group therefore supports the limit the environmental maximum transition period of five years . mr president , we must necessarily positive movement in the enlargement bring . of course is still on the order of the accession of candidate countries to discuss , partly because the more progress on the internal reforms must be judged . it pleased that the report so that they affirmative and slovenia - and that i have a head of delegation can check on several occasions , and the commissioner was indeed occasions with respect massive instituted - really has to meet the criteria . i think the proposal for worthy of discussion . these forms of violence and trafficking in are already with every means both in the eu as well as in the candidate condemned , combat . finally , i take this opportunity to considerations and the concern of many join my colleagues , i consider it necessary for once , the question depth the borders of europe and so volume of its enlargement as well as the timeliness of drafting a report relevant european parliament to consider . the minutes - the previous sitting have been distributed . - thank you . in this house will always rightly pointed out that in a europe of citizens the civil law within the union must be incorporated . now i ask the referral to committee on legal affairs and the internal vote . we know that there are at the undesirable substances , the issue here , it was very rarely acute toxic handelt , but rather a long fish processing , and long-life akkumulierbare substances such as dioxins , aflatoxin and heavy metals such as lead , cadmium and mercury . we cannot sinners today will not make tracked . if these verschneidung audits . it must at least have been reported to the guarantor give , and it must be publicly , that it will verschneidung there , because this issue must also be aware of the public and discussed . one must clearly be highlighted : the dioxin crisis was the result of criminal activities against the schemes . mr president , many thanks to the ladies and gentlemen , i have spoken before me . this was a compelling necessity . the limit value for fishmeal differs from the example of limit values , not for the juveniles animal products manufactured from being proposed . it is high time that we misleading this interpretation of subsidiarity , with the patronising our nations by brussels will expand a daily basis , to stop . i am as the rapporteur 's view that the proposed measures are justified and the substances listed must be controlled , even if this has not taken for toxic are , in combination with other substances but increased aufweisen values . unfortunately , is much to überliefertem know at abundant bauernverstand in industrial agriculture , where the animals units and robber reduced , were lost . by the new regulations are the very detailed and complicated hygieneanforderungen , on many directives were distributed , reunited , harmonised and simplified . the number derjenigen , the mellow exactly erfragen , according to my researches is relatively low . secondly : a change arises very well but for the farmers , and indeed the producers of raw materials . you will in future parties requires a much more ausgangsprodukten must destroy . the compensation is necessary , although undisputed is that the farmers themselves to a great responsibility to ensure that animal welfare . in amendment no 18 by expressly asked , water in the definition of feed included . on the basis of this scientific risk assessments will the commission states suitable measures to set a limit values for these substances in animal feed recommend . following the reappraisal of the amendments in this sitting have been tabled , i welcome the support of parliament for the proposal . overall the commission can approve the 15 27 amendments . i assume that the occasion duty-free sales will have . the commission has promised that they will be working , and it has also announced that it was not until tomorrow will be completed . farmers must simply know precise time , at least in question , but also in prozentangaben everything and to what extent these should be included in compound feedingstuffs . i would conclude by thanking the rapporteur , mr graefe zu baringdorf , and also mrs roth-behrendt sincerely for their excellent reports and hope that the council on this issue a constructive approach and so we einnimmt together to reach a transparent system of animal feedingstuffs . all this we have clearly the bse-tragödie thanks to the will to a genuine thriller with several chapters has developed . pollutants , the health of humans and animals influence , are not acceptable . however we start with positive . the proposal is the start of a number of initiatives to be based on the white paper on food safety . thank you , commissioner . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) report ( a5-0248 by 2000 ) by mr queiró , on behalf of the committee on foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defence policy hungary 's request to join the european union and the state of negotiations [ com ( 1999 ) 505 - c5-0028 by 2000 - 1997 by 2175 ( cos ) ) a5-0247 report ( 2000 ) by mrs nicholson of winterbourne , on behalf of the committee on foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defence policy on romania 's application to join the european union and the state of negotiations [ com ( 1999 ) 510 - c5-0033 by 2000 - 1997 by 2171 ( cos ) ) the third and perhaps thorny condition is that the council on new institutional agreements , what minimalist that efficient , effective and democratic functioning of the community ensure following enlargement . for this great europe must rather such institutions may be expected to promote the development of middle eastern area , but at the same for sovereignty and let these differences . excellent principle incidentally should also apply within the european union . finally i would stress that the enlargement process gradually and anpassungsfortschritten consistent with the applicant countries must be done . given the current context and in favour of classify and are listen to the enlargement of the european union into question , it is important that parliament has a clear political signal for this enlargement requires . the european union serves since its inception amalgamation of the peoples . the criteria of copenhagen council from 1993 to democratisation or to strengthen competitiveness under the guise of ' acquis ' domination of one unbridled capitalism and destructive . circumstances could be headlong pursuit during the enlargement process to a rise populist and faschistoiden excesses of certain quarters , are noticeable result . we have just been on the agenda part-session a report on the opportunities for women and men , yes illustrates once again , as it badly with the acquis communautaire in practice precisely this area is desired . who wanted to poland 's kopernikus johannes-paul ii and the european deny access to the house , which 1956 in budapest benighted hungary or the steeped capital prague , of the people 's democracies were once the head by a fenstersturz absetzten and that the people of jan palach , on the freedom opferte , with niederhielten violence . a greater europe with more tasks and responsibilities needs new and more extensive financial resources . occasion i entbiete of citizens and the elderly pensioners in estonia and hope that my greetings should ensure möge , you have a existence in the european union to allow . if latvia continue making progress and the european union and its institutional structures policies has adapted to cope with enlargement , can i see no reason why latvia not in the union should be included . if lithuania continue making progress and the european union and its institutional structures policies has adapted to cope with enlargement , i can see no reason why lithuania , not in the union should be included . the environmental sector are also with the creation of ' national fund for environmental protection ' and the application of the polluter noticeable progress . if the union poland the door to our common house opens , leaves you regard this newcomer equity - a justice to this country too long been denied . i look forward to the czech republic early accession to the european union . . ( en ) i welcome the report by mr queiró hungary 's request to join the european union and its conclusions to be largely support . i hope that the union in bulgaria join not too distant future . poos report ( a5-0249 resolution ) it was a balanced and fair opinion of the council should take serious note . in this context , i hope that the negotiations under the auspices of the united nations succeed lead , so that the greek and turkish siding with cyprus together from the benefits of accession within a reunified republic can benefit . i welcome the report by mr poos 's request republic of cyprus to join the european union . but consumers we find ourselves at the end extreme chain and are thus this last sammelbecken for genetically modified food and verfälschte . we seek to make a particular that the food at european level and in concrete form from barn or by sphere until table guaranteed . precisely because we really facilities for equal country greater solidarity and cooperation relations between all countries on earth are we did not the intention , with ussr to support a farce . the council well-informed parliament before the vote in committee , however such short notice , so deliberately further talks with me or the european parliament have been prevented . in my report i have not only a stronger representation and involvement of ngos , wider accountability to parliament , the submit an annual and about a debate in parliament as well as the maximum transparency called me , but also called for the multiple discrimination and recognise the memory of the past alive to keep to it in the fight prejudice use can be . at the justified interests workers must be considered . the social partners are more in the penalty under rule of diskriminierungsfragen workplace resembling able , workable solutions to produce . jenny is coordinator of the access-charter-gruppe and was to me to the public hearings on article 13 invited . practical reason , because directives and action programmes do offer incentives to the member states in the fight against discrimination on the same basis departure , and it will enable the commission , its role as guardian of the treaties wahrzunehmen , but also in the social shining discussion . although the present legal resources for new preparatory actions , could deregulate their funding within this category of a mittelreduzierung for other policies lead . lies before us a proposal for a necessary but insufficient . framework directive , we will have the opportunity , their mechanisms after a certain finishing touches to safeguard clauses . i hope the commission will light of this new directive carefully with the issue of discrimination gender-based deal . i congratulate the commission and my colleagues , these reports have produced . i welcome the recommendation in the mann report non-confessional organisations , the possibility , if necessary to make a plea to professional staff conditions to make , which relate to these recital . the fact that the institutions quickly by by the treaty of amsterdam re-introduce new powers , make use proves that the european union field of equal opportunities still remains a vanguard role , and for this , commissioner , i would like to thank the european commission would very much . the presence of discrimination audacity nature in our societies confirmed the importance of the present action programme , which the report by mr cashman subject . mr president , on behalf of the members of the bonino , i our outrage at the same way and the treatment of themas discrimination , racism and xenophobia by this european union and the member states express . can the commissioner explain why the commission aspect leaves aside ? the second is for me this problem , ngos , so that they are also important , asked here , which regardless of its size , its nature and its actions at the implementation of effort . the group of the liberal democrat and reform party has all this positive , but in particular the activity of the european parliament , but also and above special emphasis on the prevention of discrimination on the procedure tested well presented . this is a challenge for us all , because we all people after the first & impression . mr president , if we fight against discrimination and rules legislate , then we admit their existence and even the fact that a number of their outbreaks meanwhile ' legal ' , because they are at bored belong . the first has unctad , the welthandels- entwicklungskonferenz and the united nations 1963 in geneva , the principle of positive measures , so the discrimination drawn up . the information and awareness gain a truly fundamental importance in this area , as through appropriate must preparatory work , and so on a new mentality , new misconception and behaviour , so that the etched still in the population lesser-used prejudice a for all time can be settled and all citizens and bürgerinnen real equality will be guaranteed . so it now with the matter , both for discussion legislative initiatives headway , also by you , in some respects and improving the funding for the programme appropriation be increased , the political worin attached this fight against discrimination expressed . in particular the agreement on the principle suitable adjustments , sweden and ireland at the forefront of animated , will now ensure that the employer in europe adapt their jobs , sonderausstattungen districts and their disrupted change so that disabled employees a real chance . the article 13 forms of departure for a new eu objective : to combat discrimination or unequal treatment of the citizens of the reasons are listed in article . secondly , i would point out that the commission with this first package unfortunately a serious mistake made by recipients , are the reasons for discrimination in a serious look hierarchy . mr president , a discrimination for religious reasons is neither to tolerate like any other forms of discrimination . as supporter of secularity , i can therefore not endorse this idea . the noble idea , every citizen of the greatest possible freedom zuzuerkennen , provided they should equally freedom of compatible with the other is still true today on obstacles , partly factual , partly legal nature . these directives was already in a very short time adopted , and i am very optimistic that the other november even during the french presidency will be approved . some facing not consistent with other legislation , for example the amendment on the procedure in the committees . i must reject amendment 38 and the proposed deletion of the list from article 5 of the total cases a profound discrimination grounds of age are included . you have the important question of vertragseinhaltung addressed . in this action are the first time planned joint projects . it lies obvious that the code so much more effective , will be ever more countries join a worldwide . in article 7 of code commit themselves to the member states to prevent arms to unsuitable end-users accessed . mr president , i admit that i am still zurücksehne times , in which the european parliament , but also by various peace movements and unions demands for thought and action continuously reducing the manufactures and people were imposed on the question asked , on the arms production civilian production could be converted . given the situation , in which the world and our continent today , after the end of the cold war and the collapse of mass destruction by the aufrechterhaltenen balance of horror stage , would be a derartiges irresponsible behaviour . these weapons are virtually at symbolises the anarchy involved in many places in the world has become . the cfsp covers crisis-management measures outside the borders of the union , but nothing , what can be described as a common defence policy . these objectives out from the export of arms to governments , what the violate human rights , both in crisis areas or regions , where a place , to prevent arms race . the commission has in close cooperation with the member states involved in drafting the joint action the european union for small arms and light weapons participated . the next item is the commission communication on european research area . other elements are the introduction of a longer period compendium förderformen , on halfway between the assisted projects and the institutional financing teams ; the use of the treaty planned instruments ' with ' variable , especially the participation of the union 's national programmes , as it article 169 of the treaty provides . these hierarchisierenden nature , and we want to promote it depends on the förderform reject . you say , you dächten at a outright shake-up of the framework programme . i believe that we need today , something that the european research area embodies a structure , therefore , something that goes on the framework programme , with the national programmes merely be supplemented . we need a strukturierendes element , so we must introduce methods . what the considerations with stoa-referat subject , i believe that together we must do something , since parliament , the joint research centre and the zukunftsforschungsinstitute in individual member states are affected . obviously the commission strides with thumb on the establishment of a european research area . it will be a whole module on science and society , give citizens . there contacts with the authorities greece , ireland and portugal , the governments of these countries , the commission invite their projects under the cohesion fund soon submit . perhaps is the absence of a service , which you have just mentioned and which it in the past , the commission had dedicated exclusively to the cohesion fund , fault that you have no more specific details available . my second question reads as follows : apart from the cohesion fund there the community support frameworks , the structural funds , the reallocated etc . welchen countries which were tabled them definitive plans and programmes whatever countries what you have already approved ? 1989 the commission has submitted a new proposal , which should offer greater flexibility . i know that the statements by appreciate mr bolkestein and myself is aware that one of the principles in the treaties & that foreign companies must not pay more than domestic , but should the general rules for competition in europe too . applied in cases disproportionately high taxation , we should saramago , to the effect that competition law in this situation , if you can also applies to these general affairs competence of the member states indirectly . if you want to save fuel , then hierauf by levies and not by other besteuerungsformen . mr purvis , i retort that the problem natural disadvantages , regional probably cause by national governments , but a part of their lives electorate in peripheral regions and those in peripheral regions . mr president , commissioner , thank you for your alright . last spring the european commission has summer and a general review their activities and its inexperience carried out . there are such tasks . you will increasingly be exploited by tourists and businessmen , the remarkably often come from europe . the commission is the view that all businesses , will be able to promptly to the final changeover to the euro , wozu also prepare the adapting their computer software and the heard . the theoretical political debate does not longer on the agenda , we can certainly the dangers of a referendum in general debating , but perhaps an opportunity to others . this also applies to elche . recently adopted by the french authorities sent a erinnerungsschreiben . candidates for accession , i can inform you that on this problematik meeting with you have taken place and interim agreements were concluded . during the frühjahrsaussaat pests cases of the commission inaccuracy of conventional seed imported various plant varieties note , cotton , including the traces of gm seeds marred . i am having but with his department kurzgeschlossen have , i am able , informing you that the basic safety requirements in terms computer equipment for private use or functional duties in a directive on electrical products , the so-called niedrigspannungsrichtlinie as well as in the rtte directive on telecommunications equipment and stone . would he agree to think about that here wrongly distinguishes between security and safety at work in classroom or the safety of a child , computers sits at home ? perhaps he uncle the hand of president khatami . aung san suu kyi alive today de facto under house arrest . so i am very hesitant , trade or other measures include more with regard to trade or cease investment . question no 15 by ( h-0769 by 00 ) : yet they referred to , for example forbade the visited you had . questions nos . nos 16 44 will receive written answers . we argue for a european synthesis report , by this parliament should be examined and published . instead , we out as with other weapons oil-producing countries cannot compete in the world , we should instead on the transition to civilian production focus . the five permanent members of the security council , whose task actually consists , about our security to vigilant , should these proposals heed and as quickly as possible negotiate an agreement , which is worthy of the 21st century . today 's debate marks an important step in the reform process , the commission under mr prodi almost a year ago was started . pressing on the idea to me that the commission in race at the drafting of a proposal on reformweißbuch insurer time-frame within it has not achieved all the individual points precise detail . i would therefore lively , both the controller both the internal auditor detailed annual reports should draw up its work . in the van hulten report will separation advocated by the commission rightly aggravated and a usable approach for the exchange of best practices between the institutions required . this should be hope not repeat here ! if we definitions for large institutions , will be meeting the committee of independent experts called on the whole line apply . we have in the past , very often seen as a long decision-making in the applicants to disillusionment and to a loss in the european institutions have had . i would like the commissioner say that this report is only an intermediate . this means that it was the first step construction of a bridge between the currently applicable control system and which , after the reform that we want to achieve , achievement . that is the proposal , the available . only then , if you are able , this will also sampling of selection , which often being monitored , watered down . on navel-gazing beyond statements are we are all aware that this is certainly no easy task . i refer of course , that we as politicians nor any more than technicians are able to tackle this problem alone . fortunately grow but quite the vast majority of children and young people in a bars on that none of these problemmerkmale gaps . i agree wholeheartedly with kommissionspräsidenten that such a catalogue of similarity with a constitution has , must be drawn . it is for me self-evident that subsidiarity must be strengthened and that one of the eu has many policy areas households , whose delegated not transcend borders . information from earth and all wissensgebieten binnen shortest time will come , and this house supplied communicate around the planet is for you everyday life . they were arrested and quickly towards explaining to policemen : ' yes funny is , in serien will not be taken quickly . the legislators - and so i would conclude - cannot regulate everything , but it must sometimes on the rights and duties remember one day . furthermore , i appreciate the remarks on education and training on the ability of interpersonal on images well awareness on the younger generation , the media and a critical look at the coerced , sometime , somehow behold . nothing will be on their still in the emergence befindlichen views harmful effect , as if a report like this to any progress or any leads to greater mobility or at least not it creates the obstacles to overcome , of which the ausbildungsmobilität today is affected . in various countries are disparate resolve : it example at different regulations areas , social security grants , residence and originates or at the absence of a common recognition of qualifications and praktikumsaufenthalten . it high time that europe sanitary the implementation of programmes such as socrates and youth for europe ' again draws attention . the experience with the mobility of students and teachers show that the real shortcomings hierbei not primarily in education , but at the immigration authorities , social and fiscal lie . as an example hierfür the socrates programme has been recorded . it must be a clear monitoring , control give a clear , though randomly , and above all , a beratungsstelle must be set up a web-site , where the pupils and students their complaints can contentious . we therefore call for the inclusion of self-employed scientists in the scope of the recommendations . but this is easier said than done . the debate is closed . we appreciate your approach , which on the model of president chirac or of foreign joschka fischer outlook . foreign policy in the union must speak with one voice and a common defence and sicherheitsfähigkeit develop . what we need is a entscheidungsforum on tackling the problems of both parties are of crucial importance , such as the migration , the shift of production factors or energy supply . the draft resolution to the reports on the commission , you will shortly be voting , this matter very thoroughly discussed . the systematics indicators which will enable an evaluation of progress . alongside the ministerial conference and the symposium on equality in profession should have two important specifically the gewidmete equality , but in the field of employment and social affairs ' council ' breaking texts mentioned . the second concerns the principle of non-discrimination , including the ban on the grounds of sex discrimination . on the reports i have anmerken - the president-in-office has also mentioned it - that the considerable cultural differences course to the big problems within the eu belong . also the reports we are debating here , reflect reflect this . we must check that the directive on equal treatment in the legislation will actually vocabulary . i believe that this depart in finland enforced procedures for very many areas practicable and this is one of the gleichberechtigungsstrategie as part of the commission must expect a great deal . on behalf of the french women have equal thank the european union right acquired at night . as a french bürgerin me is such a view of the world doubly alien . despite these comments , we will vote for this report , because we are naturally for equal opportunities means , but above all , everyone will be respected . the choice mothers who adopted , their own children without remuneration to educate , on receives short or long account in the form of juvenile and vandalism presented . i recall in this context to our report on the breaking-up rentenrechte divorce , at last the achievements of the survivors and that retirement age in the directive on 1979 involved . the polish women were are very grateful that we have made clear that the representatives of the same , there was not the position of women has polish reproduced . greater involvement of women at all levels and in all walks is a prerequisite for the consolidation of democracy as well as for the achievement and preservation of peace . finally , i have something to the situation of women in countries like the one on its accession to the european union prepare . the council , and not least the men in him , has therefore field a huge task in europe , the fight against mafia lead to any accountability . politicians can these slave crowd , schulterzuckend ignore or let unnoticed . the reports and speeches we have analyzing today , we can papayannakis , which many of us was already clear , namely that the problem of equal opportunities is struktureller nature and global strategies for his solution needs to be , because we women are still neither a category a homogeneous social group and neither are we a collective . indeed , i extent noted with regret that maria de belém roseira these posts are not bekleidet . its two speakers have new sozialrechte , new steuerrechte raised . thirdly , they are the basis for a strategy at european level - even in the charter was of great importance to us an overview of the current situation available - state , but also at national level , since the member states now illustrate a comparative assessment can establish national targets . the joint debate is closed . these amendments need in the context of the new interinstitutional agreement understood , and therefore parliament can assume a feeling of these amendments on the comitology insist , as it by the new interinstitutional framework in some way become irrelevant . i nonetheless believe personally to continue the seinerzeit text approved by parliament in the new realities market and the liberalisation of markets better account calculated , since the elements of control and enlightenment , in akzeptierten changes were not included , a greater guarantee for messengers , that the complied with its implementation and the same procedure applied would come . if we want to the third countries must accept the commitments , the european community as first be anxious to ensure compliance with its own rules , because if a country has the opportunity , on schmuggelwege products on the market in the community to bring , why should it will then make the effort , with us any kind licensing negotiate ? at the same way and how will the amendment of the european parliament & papierlose notification , the council has been taken , the customs authorities allow member states , with its most modern automated verwaltungsinstrumenten breathing . but now it is too late , because you have just vote on neglected and the members who have called for . votes ( continuation ) a5-0198 report ( 2000 ) by mrs dybkjaer on behalf of the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities mrs annual reports on the commission ' equal opportunities for women and men in the european union - in 1997 and 1998 , 1999 ' [ com ( 1998 ) 302 - c5 ­ b5-0106 by 1999 ) ( com ( 1999 ) 106 - c5-0289 ) ( com ( 2000 ) 123 - c5- 0290 by 2000 -1999 by 2109 ( cos ) ) . ( fr ) i admit that today the first time an opinion on the mobility of students and teachers from . the report does umso greater importance , as it has to be a decisive moment for the european union , namely with the forthcoming enlargement , will be presented . discrimination can not by creating additional administrative bodies be tackled , but solely and in the minds of people . - ( fr ) i have not voted for the mann report because , in particular actually necessary search for equal treatment in employment profession needs and why not yet in eagerness to be went so far , the protection of freedom and respect the rule of law in respect totally forgotten . as staunch representatives of secularity , the separation of church and state , could i do not give my support . . ( en ) the snp welcomes this directive and its aim , the segregation to put an end . if the directive acceptable and should be feasible , it must not be overloaded with literature and wishful thinking , in a legislative text have nothing to seek . the eplp has however strong reservations on the following areas : also issues such as the overall implementation of certain ages training for employees , the way schlichtungssystems one and the interpretation of this directive seitens the smes should our opinion states left . right leads to mr van hulten in interview from that we will then have a positive agenda can start if we problems such as fraud and waste , but also lack of efficiency and effectiveness of decision-making have accomplished . the reasons for my support to this report are mainly closer relations with the question of the european union to nato and the rapid establishment of a common defence linked . the report will be the european waffenausfuhr as a solution for future regional conflicts in border regions of europe discussed . the other hand , i cannot accept this with the demand for a common defence and a european security and defence policy within the nato linked . . ( el ) the children are the first victims of violence on television . i welcome that the results of this study now available . at community level will be an addition expertenausschuss with commissioned use , drawing a memorandum , the general principles for the protection of minors in dominance contains . dybkjaer report ( a5-0198 resolution ) . ( el ) interestingly here was the first time recognized the need for the efficacy of the annual reports resulting from the commission to assess political initiatives . peru mr president peru umpteenth currently moments of uncertainty , and we all hegen hopes that the current situation will be resolved through a process , in all civil and political rights be guaranteed , and the strengthening of consolidating democracy and peace in peru serves , a country that over the last fifteen years 25 000 deaths had to complain . floor , so that it talking , means ' democracy ' . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , the conditions under which may this year elections in peru , were elapsed are unacceptable . b5-0793 by the 2000 by mrs ainardi and others , on behalf of the group of the confederal group of the european united left by nordic green left on the situation of women in afghanistan . i therefore welcome the decision , it is also clear that some points about the situation of women contains and draw attention power are important , as you are giving to the total further discrimination against women by the taliban-führung to prevent . the eu has an important role here . a recognition , none of the member states , it must not give , as long as the policy violations and above the systematic discrimination against women 's continued . this and the fact that the money from drugs cultivation for the purchase of weapons used , we must , in the european institutions mind lead . however it will be the neighbouring countries in improving its resources to combat drugs keenly support . i believe the time for suited to , let me remind you that the european union a sympathetically policy towards latin america must draw the possibly could prevent that these countries at regular intervals , as you monopolistic situations intensely arisen . ladies and gentlemen , the commission as this house welcome the release of spanish jesuitenpaters alejandro matos castro in the last week . b5-0782 by 2000 by mr haarder , on behalf of the group of the liberal democrat and reform party to macedonia : law on colleges and universities ; that is why we are all very pleased that the problem of higher education perhaps now at a really good solution comes forward . i believe that this is particularly good example for all neighbouring countries , not only on education hatred sown cannot , as it now so often happens that education , but also as cradle for a peaceful , multi-ethnic society can serve . i would have liked me also , we had a solution , all the parties had in parliament can support . i should perhaps here in the opportunity to point out that the commission in cooperation with the hochkommissar , mr van der stoel , already made good experience . with today 's debate , we do not only condolences . first and foremost , we talk about what happened , is why it is done , as we can remedy for the future , as of now to the commission and parliament can contribute to such an incident does not occurring again . in any case , we have with this joint resolution agree declared and support him in the stands as urgency , and from already outlined reasons we are against the amendments , which also tabled on urgent procedure . the workings of the amendment on this issue is already covered by a directive , and the amendment is not so anyway informative as the text itself . that is the northern and western scottish islands , should not simply not acceptable for the possible navigating the north sea for continental europe , in the hopefully not too distant future established . i welcome that the greek government this exemption has now been reversed . why has the commission in immediately after the sinking of the samina express immediately to the greek government approached with the please clarify , on the application of existing community get . i would like to raise the question and ask you , that the bureau to clarify whether , after the abolition of fridays from certain hand out the abolition of thursdays has begun . i want to continue to inform the european union seitens mechanisms in the launched so that we are , once the will of the serbian people respected , means that , once a by the electorate kostunicas all-party government formed by the following measures can : firstly , a immediate lifting of sanctions and secondly a wirtschaftshilfepaket support to the serbian people rebuilding its economy . in these hours in the streets of belgrade will perhaps decide whether the democratic change , now entering peacefully and whether he can arise . we condemn all the more & provocation to values are , in particular , what the holy places in jerusalem concerned . we need to people - as mr solana said - with this part-session in zagreb quite symbolic the shake hands . on schockierendsten is that the police and the israeli army splittergeschosse have used during the intrusion into the body in dozens of zerbersten parts , the shells internationally , even in fighting between soldiers are banned , and now against civilians used . i believe that europe can and must do more in this direction , and it must be made clear and decisive action . it must consequently be doing everything to the smouldering fires as quickly as possible checked . provocation , as the action of ariel sharon , must omitted . this is also the case again today , and so will the european union , as mentioned in all over the years , middle no facilitator , so you can take the abandoning the united states alone . we are the serbian people is not our noble objectives and moral victims , because that would mean that perhaps thousands of people in serbia and yugoslavia why could die . finally , i propose as soon as possible and as soon as a new yugoslav government is formed , with a parliamentary mission stretch to travel , together with this new yugoslav government plans for the construction of a new serbia to make . madam president , ladies and gentlemen , it is clear that we in parliament today may witnessing a historic day , perhaps that one end of last cornerstones of a totalitarian dictatorship in europe . mr president , there are a problem , and indeed in german dossier for urgencies are only - i do not know whether this also occurs in other languages - only the amendments gue , included , but none of resolutions and certainly was not the joint text . mr president , i just wanted to my attention on bundle of shows , what documents we have needed for voting this week . if this parliament for a council decision changes could submit , it would be sure to unemployment and social problems croatia remember , from the country prescriptions schlankheitskur stem , but in this connection there are no legal basis for such amendments . this is the opportunity , the same objectives as regards the activity of the eib to demand . mr president , yesterday evening we have here serbia and on which there foolish talk revolutionary changes . i would therefore strongly urge the ladies and gentlemen , in particular , but also appeal to the council , in the months during the negotiations on the budget for next year and for the years afterwards as close as possible on the commission proposal to remain , in my opinion the total cost in croatia , but also in other parts of the western balkans , still has describes best . in 1990 there democratic elections were held under international law , the judgement fair and free goods . so yes , yes to this macro-financial assistance to guarantee this , but at a energetic invitation to the commission , this european deeply and now really democratic and constitutional represses country massive support it and in the number of applicant lead , because i believe that croatia has deserves our full backing . as the rapporteur , however , i ask myself whether this really make money available will , above all , because it looks soon afterwards , also large flows flow from serbia and the eu budget must not be increased . also the delegations of croatian and our parliament have asked the council to extend the mandate of the eib . i hope that contacts are as soon as croatia and also the serbian people , the greatest respect , deserves our support granted . ( parliament approved the minutes . in this sense we therefore call on women in the european parliament has , at this delegation to participate on tuesday and wednesday : we will launch an appeal , we will signatures collection and the news for the participation of the delegation , just take forward with concern , women bridges between peace to propose , from one place , where herrscht violence instead . overall crewed by both basques both new suffering inflicted spaniard ; and basques have enough from current conflict . madam president , you will recall that i , at the last meeting on the scarcity of british pro-democracy campaigner for democracy james mawdsley , have highlighted by the burmese authorities unlawfully been abandoned . madam president , when it would really like to make the rules . this report , the concurrent technically not lead to major political changes to seems , is in fact , extremely important because it on indirectly introduces the possibility of genetic engineering in viticulture applied and whereby genetically modified products in viticulture get . if we vote on the report , it will not come to delays . the conseil d ' etat has - as you said - and this appeal rejected this vote has told us in differentiates form . today recurs however such a case of a subject gentlemen of the ppe-de , although not but my political camp in italy consulted . so we have set as enthusiastically for the introduction of a social scoreboards , as it also happen is for the internal market , with marked measures , with frames , with achieving significant reductions . hopefully , minister , gives the council inspiration from parliament 's expectations , and i hope that you will succeed , the summit in nice ambitious objectives in a european social agenda at the fix , then we in the coming years can work together . in immediately after the informal council meeting on employment and social affairs ' on 8 july in paris chair had all the actors concerned - of course the european parliament , the economic and social committee , the committee on the regions , the social partners , as well as the ngos working groups and committees , the council - urged him to send their proposals . the debate on the dichotomy quantitative and qualitative aspects is inadequate , and in lisbon has been clearly defined a dual purpose : more jobs and höherqualifizierte jobs . this mobility must be encouraged and at the protection of career be guaranteed . we must try to make the system to gaps in existing specifying and also to named and , in any case , to put on the agenda . the open coordination is our view the right way to secure a social europe . the implementation of the lisbon farm-to-fork social objectives requires community efforts , an action plan for the creation of jobs in the service sector and particularly in terms of the information society . the commission can of course an important contribution , but the social problems are regionally enshrined and must with much subtlety for the specific conditions to be addressed . the social dimension served as compensation for the folgenschwersten effects of economic policy . it would have been better , the original commission proposal so as to allow , he was congratulations , commissioner . it is an ambitious agenda , and i can still remember well , as we laboriously in the last parliamentary term in social protection are brought forward . i believe that it would be good to help women , to support her family and professional life reconcile to make . sometimes i have the impression that , with term often undermining the modernisation of social protection is meant . what kind are now the main content characteristics ? yet it is difficult to define european objectives , the member states are equally valid for all , because the reality proving to be quite different . it has been 49 amendments by the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities mrs presented . in an amendment proposes that , here in parliament an annual debate on the subject together with the commission carried out . another point is the enhanced support from the community assessment of needs assessment for additional initiatives , including , if necessary , the implementation of legislation and equality and the fight against discrimination . it has certainly not in the past of excellent ideas and plans for gender equality , rex only its implementation is unfortunately often failed . it would not , that the voice of a handful of women in forderungsprofis will be taken hostage to keep alive with public money . it concerns the equality of men and women in the civil sector , which allows it to women , in the full benefit of human rights and fundamental freedoms to come . i am waiting to be the last male players starting here and dismantle gender role stereotypes and combat . we must thank her indessen , that it has followed our debate , because their presence throughout the whole debate was not really expected . competition policy we are the owe our business forum shopping , so as their production and not least its future plan can . consumers must have access to a large selection high-grade products have to attractive prices , and this is ultimately the reason for us to far on internal market and so on free competition lies , namely because our citizens benefit . that is the beihilfenentscheidung or nichtbeihilfenentscheidung in terms of coal . point 16 of the report by mrs her impatience calls for increased legal certainty in the application of the control of mergers both more efficient and speedier time-limit treatment in the case of anrufungen the courts . in all these cases it would be a public companies , their entrance not approximately a tadellosen management , but former monopoly or current credit . we need a greater involvement of the citizen in the information on competition policy , so that he recognizes the benefits . they are for the economy and employment in the regions extremely important , and i hope that this aspect in future be made clear , so that these national subsidies for regional development and the regional economy , for example , the volvo weitergezahlt can be . this communication contains three right messages . similarly i warmly thank mr evans for his excellent report & the community rules on state aid to the steel industry as well & eighth area is the commission report on state aid in the european union . the members mrs palacio and mr karas well on the other ep-mitgliedern on these issues have spoken , i would say that your concern in the regulation largely taken into account . otherwise we are in our efforts in order to enhance competition and the interests of consumers a disservice . the debate is closed . with this financing system will article 119 of the ec treaty implemented during the third stage of economic and monetary union would not only for the single currency acceding member states applies . mr president , commissioner , ladies ladies and gentlemen , i am grateful for that today we still be on the proposal for a council directive amending the directive 68 by 193 eec on transport with vegetativem reproductive material from grapes can discuss , and i also hope to a positive vote tomorrow . some of you have on 5 july in appeal to your concern beaune in connection with the introduction of gmos in their commerce expressed . the rules moreover contained favouring the emergence of vielseitigem vegetative propagation forest , they can best gesundheitsgarantien offer , and for the effective promotion of restructuring the champions of the community , the key element of the new com in wine , is urgently needed . it must be loudly and clearly stated that it was necessary in any way , the directive with article refer to the change in technologically directive 90 220 fully plug , because it may be , wanted the manipulation of weinreben with all push power . no 40 by 35 can accept the aimed , security and managementerfordernisse under the directive 90 220 systematically to transfer . i would just make to this house has not been invited as such , position to take . madam president , i am referring to paragraph 14 minutes our request for waiver of parliamentary immunity of our colleague pacheco pereira . on the qualified majority , i little detail . at the weighting befinden was also the two options well-known still on the table : the simple weighting , for which a hauchdünne majority emerges , or the double majority , however based on different formulae as dual simple majority or neugewichtete or a kind marked demographic network ' but ' . furthermore , the european council has hennegau a bedarfsbewertung and a coordination of economic and financial aid for former yugoslavia , the european commission and the world bank decided , together transferred to the former yugoslavia , an initial emergency humanitarian aid in amount of eur 200 million to grant . if i can spontaneously and frankly say my opinion should , then i would say this : how sensitive issues - the composition of the commission - and this may also be voting procedure , the success or failure of nice will not prevent measured . it was also positive that the leaders of the charter of fundamental rights have given their approval , but i must also remember , mr president-in-office , why was assent because this possible ? we must not spirit of nice by chagrin ruin disclosure and therefore it is in the remaining 50 days of primary importance , the negotiations on the political level to cancel . in this respect i would also refer to my ladies and gentlemen of the european people 's party address - and i ask mr poettering that he would listening - wofür , because we in parliament arise , that we must also outside represented . after all , what we have the results of the heads of state biarritz in regard to the most complex issues frames know , the charter will probably be the greatest trophy in nice . the council really would meet the expectations of european citizens if it is a broad consultation of the peoples of the national parliaments bureaux , to a charter to come to meet the real needs . therefore , are all called upon to return home territory in our union and the courage to allocation , mr giscard d ' estaing and mr schmidt budget , when you 1976 and 1979 the choice of parliament in general and direct elections choice and for us to decide that we 2009 at last a president of the european union , namely the kommissionspräsidenten , have . in this context i would particularly like to respond to what mr poettering , the discrepancies between large and small countries has said . i would briefly like to address the issues of foreign trade , because this is an extremely serious issue . this is something valuable in any case , that all members of the european council has been highlighted . a second very positive aspect is the adoption of the charter in its entirety . apart seems to me on this fundamental question for the future of the european union and for their decision-making could be listed in biarritz point-scoring . i hope it will succeed in this respect , forwards and even to convince us impose in nice . i would like to make two specific examples : the right to work on the right to work , and become a number of amended chapter of europarates rights are not included in the charter has been adopted . as from the discussions & throughout europe , including biarritz , have been held , want the larger member states the smaller partly to a reform of the european union push for the larger member states deviate from direction and its wish line . the discontent on both sides of the negotiators are proof that they are at a reasonable compromise hinbewegen . the leadership of europe has no clear visions worded . a commission , the criteria on the representation of the member structured , smacks of little vision . in such centralized european union had the small countries less influence than the small federal zweikammernsystem in the united states . after the summit sharm-el-sheik , where everyone but were trying to find a solution to the violence halted and dialogue between the barak and arafat again to set in motion , we have recognised , how difficult it is briefly , although it had anticipated , as could the bezwungen violence . bad informers have clearly by mr barón crespo , compel things about italy and to express my party , not meet the truth . it is an important step in the european energy taxation , so far been blocked by the unanimity rule . we should not let them get on to the dispel the fear arises , could be forwarded to direktoratslösungen . i believe that the convention has done an excellent and i am also proud that i belong allowed this body . in the hypothesis which represents the second question , in welchen intervals in relation to the principle of large and small countries completely equal rotation applied should come . the extension of qualified majority vote together with the codecision procedure on important watertight classifications , the maintenance of article 250 in its current form , the place and role of the commission in enhanced cooperation and not merely during the first pillar - these are some elements , illustrate derer immediately , whether we can & ultimately a success or failure available . mr president , i would like , first jacques delors , altiero spinelli and fernand herman her as well as all of vaclav havel up to carlo ciampi , of joschka fischer up to jacques chirac , by michel barnier up to pierre moscovici , of chris patten up to costa simitis , without florence nightingale and the current number of meps to forget the since 1999 has once again for the great movement have used for a european constitution . commercial europe that we should not too much criticise - this tells them - a socialist , because it has created more wealth for all . we should at least agree on this objective , and because we do this , we should also say , as it is to achieve . i have noted with satisfaction that the proposals presented recently at the intergovernmental actually totally or partially with me outlined by views coincide . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , the rapporteur very ladies and gentlemen , you had hoped that this morning holding a debate on the issues , given derer your house has deemed it necessary for the april this year noninflationary intergovernmental to supplement . it therefore seems to me despite the respect of existing constitutional framework difficult to be - as i would say quite frankly , vorzusehen - more than the decommissioning of parliament 's position on the launching such cooperation . as you know , this requires presupposes that we certain political decisions , which are far greater scope than the three of my earlier listed requirements . i myself have also stressed that the charter unspent a method for the opportunity to erwägende either . i would however well understood that they apart from its linguistic aspect behind another question concerns hidden . for this reason i am also grateful for the form and content of your excellent initiative . the introduction of strengthened cooperation should not create a new bodies addition to the existing union institutions lead . it is high time to revise the treaties . these infringes violated the european council of europe with its refusal of the european charter of fundamental rights in the treaties , they include legally binding and make the citizens of their rights are violated in the european court , access to open up . otherwise , i think , be a europe of the european citizens do not have to be . paragraph 8 : the constitution should - and i quote - ' of questions laissées ouvertes ' rules . what has changed since then , should have let me explain could still none . the second point concerns a ungenügende task-setting the questions leaves aside , the future of the union and the interests of citizens are of particular importance . minister , the transmission erging according to the russian orthodox church eve of bolschewistischen revolution - an event that the whole world - should have such disastrous in lengthy discussions on the construction of roben fastenzeit . enhanced cooperation must therefore all the provide guarantees to the rapporteur has mentioned : they must all face , open spirit of the treaties respected and must not contradict the community acquis . on one point i would however like to highlight : it seems not right to demand frameworks - or in this direction - to go , in all member states to implement an obligatory referendum precisely the proposed changes to decide . we really have a detailed debate on the two topics led the geartet may vary , but they are in a meeting point . we are prepared to take first-reading , that it during the meeting in november a vote on this are the adoption and thus more during the french presidency takes place . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) what does ' the introduction of the possibility of older workers ' because other than a threat of many countries have overly high retirement ? as you know eat pensioners as well as the marmalade like children . i am pleased that the pensioners of the pensioners ' party in the european parliament deployed , have asked , whether you would like genetically modified drink wine . furthermore standardvermehrungsgut marketed in exceptional cases should be , if the need not be covered by other categories . so i ask you , mr president : making the labour different thus not be a restriction of free competition in the european union represent ? why could only vote against , what i have indeed . despite the increasing liberalisation in the european union does state aid still remains a constructive role in the erzielung of sozialem and to economic progress . for environmental protection , the safeguarding of public services and the guarantee equal income for the inhabitants weak regions this aid can be indispensable . we draw attention to the risk that the eu after the consolidating their control over the substantial aid to the less extensive aid under the pretext sights will take , for competition between small and medium-sized enterprises concerned to do . section vi - economic and social committee one looks at the fälligkeitspläne of implementing the budget for the categories 2 , 3 , 4 and 7 represents one , to note that average only 8 % of all payments are covered by commitments . three years we have with our employment strategy , we started by small and medium-sized enterprises , chancenkapital immune to receive . parliament wants to do two things that way . only then will the european institutions also fulfil its mandate . i should like at this point gratitude to the vice-president responsible for budgetary matters , which colleague gerhard schmid , for the constructive cooperation gratitude . we want to receive this committee his employability , but we cannot allow that there least on the demands of the european parliament as the budgetary authority will be heard . this means that 2001 provides recent total annual budget , and this also represents the background for the assessment of kommissionsvorschlags and of the proposal we are presenting to parliament . we also want a review of administrative costs . since 1985 - modification , since 85 - the parliament 's committee on budgets tried to achieve that , in the procedures of the european parliament the financial consequences of the plenary resolutions adopted account . i agree , mr president , i by the other institutions for the care thank you , the joint declaration on her 1200 cure neglected . today you have to decide on a budget at first reading , the council has been amended . what concerns the structural measures , as is provided the financial package compared with the 2000 budget actual fact remained . the council 's attitude towards revision of the financial perspective is purely factual . if these are three different figures , nourished by could then see that there are still considerable differences , also purely quantitatively , of course also content . here i must point out that it during comitology after a long debate last year with a new decision about the council had , and i have little hope that you can reopen this debate . the financial plan of berlin for the time 2006 were for the meda programme 8.1 billion provided . i would therefore council and budgets here in parliament call , in its foreign policy considerations also foreign relations and not to think definitely budgetary roads . the second concerns the aid for victims of human rights violations , a special treatment facilities in need . should it here in the forthcoming at a time carrot arise , the important work of emac-ausschusses supported , that we can still rules , otherwise we consider the position of our committee open . we need only televisions for us to publicise the problems in the middle behold , at any day-today new remember to be . i therefore hope that we in the vote tomorrow to still be required for the majority centre in dublin come ! mr president , allow me , on behalf of the committee on agriculture and rural development , firstly a few words on the development of rural areas . we have at the approval indikativer resources in amount of two million for an information campaign on cfp requested . the commission must weighty arguments to negotiate with a reasonable agreement with morocco to achieve task , and the council and the governments concerned , it is this political momentum to negotiation . we consider the 2001 budget today , we face the pictures of the serbian population before our eyes . overall , we wish to these amendments are adopted . an important opportunity to open our citizens , who says audible , main , to which the ombudsman or to turn to petition this parliament to address . at first edinburgh . great surprise to many crowley from my delegation we early september unanimously passed a kernstrategie . the 400 amendments , some of my colleagues have been tabled , were came for so many of us in the right budgets surprising . it is difficult counted , with new posts that criminal issue cannot be solved long , both in the commission as well as the council old-fashioned methods and complicated to administer the many programmes applied . this parliament in recent years has again shown that it implicit thrift basis for his work power . it cannot be , at the very relax years on commitments and pleases you speak again , but then , when it comes ans figures , says that concerns us now too far , since we now need a bit zurückschneiden ! if we are a few million on the lines put much more - it could not be - then , we consider the speckseite out , and if the people they actually need , as we move forward again . the 2001 budget stand out as the last year 's budget before lösbaren almost not conflict with one hand , the pressure consolidation and austerity , as it under the interinstitutional agreement was decided to finance the enlargement sure to put on the other hand , acute borrowing stability pact for the balkans . demands for better quality professional conduct also include more staff . the adoption of this amendment in its original version had the starting point for a change the situation may be , but it is budgets was rejected by a majority . unfortunately there are still many examples : in favour of the privileged treatment of associations with federalist ambition or by many ngos are highly dubious operate and views on the financing european political parties up to the prince programme for this vergeudeten sums , with the european citizens from qualities of the euro convinced , during this should be a loss endures , the europeans of our friends danish up to the leaders of the european central bank largely share . finally heaton-harris his amendments with mr lange has rightly on the one-sidedness numerous european programmes pointed out , in which the citizens with a propagandastory about european integration traktiert , duly costs to the citizens themselves . in addition to our heterogeneousness modernising . we must also a good example . a good example for the latter is the meda programme for this locality of the mediterranean area , a geografisches highest of strategic importance . if some people about necessary cuts or that tracking down of funds in category 4 , talking about certain priorities can be financed , then you do not forget that parliament has . priorities that we have in the vote in committee clearly expressed . so that figure requires a clarification . thank you , mr wynn . it simply means that existence of real elements of flexibility , on a given any policy further forge , while some can or not this wish . and what the distrustful applies , also applies to the applicant countries . my austria , which has no reason to complain about the result , quite the opposite . could the recommendations made in regional organisations and experience with the neighbouring certainly a useful contribution . in the year 1984 unequally 0.2 % of landowners in colombia 32 % of soil . it is the task of the council , or those this aspect of this extremely sensitive issue commenting on and painful . but can also not way start a debate on issues , as you said - are extremely complicated . question no 10 by ( h-0722 by 00 ) : i shall therefore beware , a final answer to that question duplicitous give . we only have the feeling , and its response in this way seems to confirm that the presidency it in the treatment of this question to consistency leaves something missing . so that emergence from this tax will certainly not be nil . i forgive you too , but we must keep to the rules . the reason why , on the rights side there has been so quiet , so that we agree up these issues have again been clarified , and we must think same things are not discussing occasions and our valuable waste time . another is of a temporary solution until for adopting this text on preventing transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in june 2000 a decision on aussonderung risk materials in connection with these diseases have been issued to any further spread of epidemic to prevent and for the highest possible to ensure that consumers policy-oriented . i intelligence on any other than the details , i you have just described . we follow the work of the commission and council on erika i package and are well informed about what meeresstraße . but this subject in the two countries and also in the whole european union is known as an extremely difficult meeresstraße , by the large transitting ships , we take a few hours to save , with the risk that old rostkähne somewhere to run reason and cause a disaster , and i would have had all the inhabitants of corsica and of sardinia like knew , whether it is possible and whether you intend to passage through the straits of bonifacio for those large container ships , this was simply to ban ? why should we actually the commission 's proposals for a revision of the staffing support . in the budget to be serbia and kosovo funds for new needs . conclusion i would like to express the hope that you budget still 50 million abzweigen can , that a peace agreement israel-plo finance . why are we in parliament propose new measures , not so much on the search for further finanzierungsmitteln - of which we already know that you under present conditions are not find - but , on setting new objectives interinstitutional matters commitments , discriminates and improving the quality of expenditure should be achieved , no single euro wasted . thinking remind you that in the european policy in every other area as the appropriate moderates options are not the majority . it serves the verdunkelung rather because the enlightenment and today the helpfulness attitude with regard to the activity-based budgeting am very disappointed . furthermore the division leads to take action , one of the budget a political instrument extremely costly , in which the distribution of expenditure unequivocal political priorities reflection . we should take this opportunity to find a solution stock has several years , so that we are discussing identify adequate for the reconstruction of balkans next year not and never arrives again lead to . on the one who is interested non-agricultural sustainable development , will know that the hauptvorstoß the recent reforms consists in berlin , a unremitting transition from price support to direct income for products to change existing farmers . a budget that there is always more than cool and zahlenreihe . furthermore , it is also immoral costs in the agricultural policy , for the meda programme , for the socially marginalised , to cut resources for funding commitments in the european union in kosovo and to ensure yugoslavia . simple : in serbia must the people in winter neither frieren still hungry . furthermore , i register my concern that the various formation of youth in the socrates programme have been adopted . address by the council must of course also be clearly stated , the council also bears responsibility for its außenprogramme respects the failure decommissioning . we now need a stable solution for these subsidies and even greater extent in the planning now necessary for the entire balkans . i believe the most would be prepared , such sum under the requirement to accept that the money properly used . i share the views and concerns the rapporteur , mrs rühle , you afternoon in connection with the chapters research and social measures quoted . two weeks ago took the place of the acp joint assembly . the same time , we should do that , in funds for research and information budget to be used for produktionsalternativen after the current growers to youthful . i would urge stick to the european union , with regard to northern ireland and six-day most positive influence had to be a worlds . in accordance with this model will compliance with rules and procedures by an independent authority and in discharging guaranteed by the courts . thus the first time we will be a codecision procedure at first reading finish , and this can be an extremely complex and technical difficulties unannounced text with much of an area of regarding the protection of privacy is particularly sensitive . it is a very positive in that its tasks were not reunited . for example , is aware that in the schengen system over 10 million missing persons on almost 1.5 million citizens are to stored on europol , whose powers , continual widening the information from various enforcement system 15 member states centrally , and zusammenlaufen may only under the control of authority , neither the competence nor the objectively , we really have a different role to play . that said , i nutze the commissioner 's presence to point out that people think not only for the protection of citizen given the new technologies should bear concern , but also for the use of this technology in terms of better enabling the europeans , has to publicise interactive with the european institutions to communicate . in amendments nos 1 , 2 , 4 until 10 , 12 until 40 , 42 until 54 , 57 and 58 , 60 64 until the council 's text is in points accepted , in which the commission cannot agree . it goes without saying that even its opinions on the legislative proposals on data protection will be very helpful in this respect , it is an important contribution to legislative debate between the institutions afford . so the treaty on recognises that the outermost regions in a difficult economic and social situation aufweisen , by the special disadvantages , what will hampered by their permanent gegebenheit and by its interplay seriously impede the development of these regions . in this way will the strategy on a high employment promotion of economic and social progress help . why am i congratulations from mrs sudre . we await with interest the normative development of the commission 's proposals , so that the features article 299 ( 2 ) of the treaty of amsterdam soon account can identify . for many europeans are some outermost regions in only a permanently compromising objective on the map . our belong to the highest unemployment rate in the union . i am pleased that the committee i proposed by the amendments adopted by a large majority . i consider it a very important that the ultra-peripheral regions in the pan-european transport , energy , telecommunications and integrated . the unanimous endorsement of by our colleague margie sudre report presented by the members of the committee on regional fidelity is a proof of the european parliament to most of its duties . we can do not discuss the whole conditions and believe that it achieve with this satisfactory , yes idyllischen situation - if we do so once again call it - will not be necessary , will further measures for the treatment of these three zones and particularly in the outermost regions , which we are discussing today , to take . this article enabled us although not in the situation , everything to do , however , it allows us to strengthen our beneficial - and i think that for necessary - to extend and improve . in preparing the necessary proposals the commission course working with the member states and the affected areas together . the problems these regions wise - as we know - lasting nature of , and i therefore believe that you depending on their actual highly-developed permanent support from the regional and rely on special measures . during the year 2001 could once such a meeting we should be carried out with the implementation of the programme presented in march a bit further come . by chair was decided that this matter is complete , and i accept this without reservations . i believe that parliament should be best to keep the current rules governing , often because there are another of our - as has already said - not the fact equipment , have not worked , but individual members to have forgotten abzustimmen . and if a vote could subsequently correct , then we would never be nearly finished . i am indeed , what i osce . ultimately , commissioner , it is , apart from the authority , needed to the competent services of the commission in cooperation and in coordination with the member states a system homogenised and effective controls in the entire food chain build and that the network of lebensmittellabors in the european union expanded and in coordination with the commission will act . since it in scientific research duplication must not to proceed with national research institutes and must , of eu-forschungszentren worked . we are discussing today on a white paper , although we are angelegen let some important principles , should be set . these procedures have been meanwhile changed and improved , moreover , we have uk an agency for legensmittelstandards established . finally i would point out that we also support some of the new amendments , amendments nos 11 and 13 until 7 until 9 on amendment no 14 a call we have a free vote . against this background i would say the following : firstly , food safety can only be guaranteed , if carries strict official controls , and these controls are each just as efficiently as that weakest link in their chain . we are talking here about a subject , which would be quite clear proves , as devoid superficial and our debate on the political agreement of europe . so we entrust the european agency for food alone with the scientific review in cooperation with our national governments . that is the most important . food-borne outbreaks of disease , where europe today is affected , at first re-emerged on american continent . however , must the conditions for the annulment of the authority so intended to be efficient and rapid action is guaranteed . we should also point out , as some speakers have done it , especially to mr whitehead , mrs gebhardt , that the white paper is much more than anybody a new regulatory framework of the union . mr president , i feel today satisfaction and gratitude , both towards the commission , what the work for a better food safety has begun , as mr bowis and also towards the whole committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy . i erachte as particularly important amendment no 17 , in a participation of consumer organisations will be required . another important consideration is the complex review the legislation on the labelling of foodstuffs both for wholesale both for retail , by the consumer with regard to the traceability of products and their ingredients at last correctly informed and the identification etwaiger responsibility is to risks and will enable crises . i think that new rules are not the correct reaction , if the existing rules are respected . the vote with the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , it is managed by a certain restoring the balance , we scope to take the nutrition expanded and some important observations on the role of small and medium-sized enterprises for the conservation different eating habits have included . mr president , i would like to join other members and the rapporteur , mr bowis , for his very logical and constructive approach to this problem congratulate . mr president , the fact that the white paper on food safety itself no legal force possesses , undermine the importance of twofold him without doubt zukommt , not the slightest . the rapporteur very many members as well as our committee , including , i have to insist on the authority emphasis , what is actually reasonably regrettable . with the independence and integrity of the authority is the position of european consumers best served . in this process verlaufe i have often thought that we in the selection of the rapporteur choose wisely have experienced . mr president , i too colleague mr bowis congratulations for his commendable proposals , all express opinions in his report channelling would let him and , above all , that he be praised for the reference to general notion of food has accepted . finally on the policy must not shirk their responsibilities . however , the most important thing is that a body to respect other scientific bodies , that the public confidence and the willingness of the governments in the member states buys , the decisions taken by him to accept . so i see a food authority for the future . we have the world health organisation in geneva . i also verschweige that i am not in the publishing the white paper have spoken against the authority . whereby it applies to ensure that the european union at the highest lebensmittelsicherheitsstandards disposal , but should , within this unanimous agreement on stoßenden approach to the economic consequences for the producers analysed . the remit of the authority covers then : independent scientific advice , research and independent controls and inspections as well as an early warning , but certainly also coordination of consumer confidence . occasion i of the speakers who discrete a solution with regard to the promotion of local specialities and traditional products called , assure you that this issue in hygiene account . you will facilitate the commission , a balanced proposal , in the position of parliament and the many players in the area of food safety broadly taken into account . our parliament deals with the first time subject anti-personnel mines , but these issues were rather alongside other in political terms exposure which for the signing of ottawa convention . i reiterate my rejection of amendments nos 10 , 19 may and coherence , because of the budget , and for amendment no 29 requesting a split vote on the individual parts to the wording of the whole text of the opinion on certain misinterpretations suffering , to improve . and this raises the question : the first countries to have not signed by the european union must , above all , the commission , signature of ottawa convention to be asked . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , we all know what the consequences have anti-personnel mines , although it in individual often great military justification there . parliament has subject 1996 on the first time agenda , as it brought a horizontal line and a proper legal basis requested , a common platform for the wide range of our actions in this important area to create . i can do not deny that the thoroughness of the european union towards other countries by the fact that something will restricted in some member states have problems regarding the sign and ratify the convention exist . the effectiveness of mine is greatest , if this individually on the special conditions of the situation & settings . parliament knows , convinced that there are already too many . as you know , we also want with our proposals on reform of external aid from the leaner examination retreat from individual projects and us in the debate with the member states instead concentrate on general strategies and programmes . many ngos have been established , which deal with this problem . nevertheless , we have four years after the first the united nations conference on problematik , landmines in geneva and about a year following the entry ottawa convention to note that many countries and thousands of people , mainly in the poorest regions of the world , are still in depressingly opaque scale of the risk of anti-personnel landmines and birdal and ammunition , are not explodes , are exposed . the commission must improve the quality of their programmes and their implementation speed . if these amendments again look very carefully , so they will think however note that some of the maes requests campaigns , transparency and access to resources allocated to the ngos and things affect the right moment true function properly , their efficiency but more can be improved . mrs bonino and mr patten have also right in your view , from the council and parliament 's administration should pontius pilate . i heard mr patten on this point listened very carefully , because it seems view is that we should do less interfere . mr president , our group has already committed for many years for this spectre in the area necessary demands and actions by produktionsstopp - on the destruction of minenbestände the attitude of the marketing of clearance of mines ranging from the casualty of rehabilitation and on public awareness . thereafter it is the task of states , this process at international level to support . the mines course represent a major obstacle for reconstruction in these countries as well as for the return of refugees towards . the current stage of pace we would evacuation here - as was said earlier - far more than 100 years , the need to decontaminate the earth 's anti-personnel mines . a third area i therefore propose concrete measures to be reviewed , and should reasoning . every child , that we bosnia , africa and elsewhere before minentod or terrible violations preserve , is the joint effort by all of us value . it must indeed be under the pressure on countries , we still have not signed , such as finland , or the have not yet ratified , such as greece . ladies ladies and gentlemen , look at it again finland ! and finally , we hope that future tasks within the common european forces skilled be trained , especially local people , something which lies remind you that the mines disappear . they stress and nor , on the list the most affected countries especially developing stand . the parliament 's demands could hardly clearer contrary to the lisbon objectives of stand . the rapporteur , mrs van lancker , wants to change parliament 's proposal the commission decides , particularly by this add various areas , where appropriate statutory regulations are both by the definition of certain rights at european level . so does the luxembourg process , the same for employment policy , on social protection and social exclusion extended . the major powers germany , france , great britain and italy are also a certain extent they are all agreed that the small or southern countries of central europe want to join the european union , its domination bow to do . however we consider it inappropriate for legal reasons , which are already in nature . 6 teu , because they take with regard to the convention - in accordance with its structure - not be able formally decided and therefore has no legal stock . the new texts inclusion in the treaties could lead to legal uncertainty . moreover power by the rapporteur for the new mouthpiece in brussels modern theory of the so-called dual legitimacy of the european union , namely the european parliament represented by citizens and the council represented by the member states . the swedish and danish social democrats have today voted against the report by oliver duhamel on the constitutionalising the treaties voted . they must make the european union towards developing a constitution , the charter of fundamental tunnel . a constitution would only sensible , if the democratic framework for a genuine european federation , a kind of europe , united states would form . he said that he had in accordance with a large part of the political class to realisation , concluded that we our relations with other countries preferred by an international agreement regulated know wish . . ( en ) i welcome the report by mr duhamel an interesting and constructive contribution to the concept constitutionalising the treaties . we are the view that a reorganisation and simplification of the treaties it easier for people would be the competence of the eu - and their borders - both the procedure perception of this responsibility clear to see . until the treaty of amsterdam in 1997 was a inter-state supersyndikat europe . the edd true against the report by gil-robles gil-delgado on closer cooperation . it namely revealed the view of a monolithic too , in the union has any form of cooperation within a single institutional framework ' and ' unfolding on objective should be geared towards a superstate . why should a general slowdown , be prevented by certain member states through the strengthening of strengthened cooperation a proceed more allows . the structures of the internal function since the early 1990s very successful . - ( nl ) the cooperation at european level for resolving cross-border problems can be useful . these regions could be an excellent versuchsstation for sustainable development opportunities serve . the technocrats and the european judge wanted the example dock dues ' octroi de schlecht ' rid of our citizens in the canary islands with resources cared and above protects our cottage . france hand possesses departments in the indian ocean and the caribbean . its independence is a sine qua non for its credibility . our vote has thus to clarify the role and the composition of the planned european authority , but it has contributed to our demands on their funding and its independence specified . secondly , the european agency must be completely independent . it must be the kind of agricultural and agroindustriellen practices , the problem nahrungsgüterimporte composition of the components tierfuttermittel the ceilings for dioxins and for pesticide residues of additives and other account for food and food safety primacy . we have voted for amendment no 15 from us , because the defence of europe 's cultural heritage in terms of food production ground heart . in any practical per category verbleibt us a manoeuvre . since we now want to 50 % in the budget line and 50 % in the paymaster . the question is how to reconcile this leaves . a5-0300 report ( 2000 ) by mrs haug , on behalf of the committee on budgets on draft general budget for the european union financial year 2001 , section iii - commission ( c5-0300 by 2000 - 1999 2190 2001 ( bud ) ) madam president , my name appears under several amendments to this report . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) the real surprise this budget lies in external policies , where selfishness and miserliness prevail . also by using a flexibility instrument resources can be released . . ( el ) i voted against the haug report and for my proposal to reject the general budget 2001 voted . we thinking in particular to help the new pilot project , in whose framework campaigns to combat paedophilia . not least this fact shows that low commitment for the eu project , even under politically active citizens . in this way fall 20 to 30 % of the markets turn the private sector to competition . since this report is not safeguarded with traceable , i have voted against the report . look at the national unacceptable low thresholds , the aid sea-life , in connection with the proposed reductions rücknahmemengen at 5 % in citrus , on 8.5 % in apples and pears well on 10 % in the rest fruit and gemüsesorten , will be clear that enormous quantities of verarbeitungserzeugnissen from fruit and vegetables should not be dumped prices , and the whole button , fruit and vegetables on fields and in verrotten let processors and so will the forcing farmers , their planting to grub up . i have voted for this report , because it expectations of the portuguese organisations of fruit and vegetable sector corresponds to a drastic change the com in fruit and vegetables , since you have asked the opinion that these are the national interests deeply damaging . report ( johan van hecke a5-0296 resolution ) the root of scourge lies , everything , even the quality of the environment and climate , the capitalist exploitation of productive resources and the superprofits sacrificed . starting in kyoto was that the rich countries their air purely itself , with regard however limited extent , you have the opportunity , with your help in other countries emission reductions subsequently obtained on its own ergebnisliste to gains . - ( fr ) the fight against the greenhouse effect is a great challenge for the developed and a particular duty towards the peoples of the world , the consequences of warming already pay with their lives . the art of life consists , with these risks uncertainties and appropriate manner . also the efforts of endocrine disrupters effective suspected substances precise calculations to explore , possibly with aid are ­ ­ perpetuate a legal framework and to increase . consumers and smes brings the with the introduction of euro fait accompli market is not sufficiently profitable . the banks are namely until now , committed by the member states on cross-border payments of eur 12 500 zahlungsbilanzstatistischen purposes to declare its central bank . of course they apply for the same strict conditions as regards security and money-laundering . we know , even in cases where tenaciously during cross-border credit on after the introduction of euro have increased , and not just a small amount . the european central bank could help , and indeed with the enforcement of a single european datenformats on transfers and with the support of the enforcement of a single european identifier code within international iban-systems . the euro accept that the consumer , is of crucial importance . madam president , the report by mrs peijs on retail payment functioning internal market in the old request of parliament regarding the high costs for cross-border credit in the union back . the peijs report makes this couched in recital d of note , even where it says that the high charges for cross-border payment of consumers ' confidence in the euro shake ' . there are a lot to do so , but the resources available and the politicians , that what we can do , in this area are lower than ours manoeuvre in the question of payment transactions on the internal market . the euro-markt will also zukünftig perceived as binnenraum , and the citizens do not understand that in this area , in exchange-rate lost and the electronic payment with internet-banking increasingly obviously be a transfer of munich is still salzburg considerably more expensive than a transfer of munich after kiel . at the towards fulfilling it well , we still have many years to work . occasion we will also have a shorter duration of decommissioning whereupon , cross-border transfers in the report by mrs peijs pressed , will speak . the debate is closed . the right policy surely agree that there is a pragmatic and kmu-nahen concept to give priority to the heart of henceforth on small businesses that power , and not a proposal , on the pretext that want to avoid thinly , would only serve the right to produce statistics , specifically to nothing nutze would . but specifically i have three comments to this programme . it recalling that the first action programme was adopted in this area 1983 , i.e. before 17 years . i am also ensure that this has always been based on an efficient and pragmatic policy should be done . i would have a real outposts the economy and the innovation described in the forefront in these areas and the existing risks are directly exposed . finally , we have also to the results of kolloquiums ' science and governance ' , this week in brussels under the auspices institute of technology foresight in seville , together with folgearbeiten took place on this symposium reflect , because since there are many connections to our current issue . the rapporteur on records that several focal points to the conditions for companies in europe improve . this is an excellent for europe , because technically correct , competent and quickly be helped . mr president , i should like to hesitation for the work of mrs montfort endorse . it is important weigh well , to avoid a situation in which people constantly expense of others fail . this is unfair , so i support this report ! this is also that guiding the charter for small enterprises . this programme will be designed so that this information available on the networks . main aim of this plan are clearly the proliferation of immigration to the countries of the european union as well as all the readmission of illegal europe living in their homes . i would particularly refer to measures to improve internal security , on to the dialogue between europeans and local authorities in albania - as well as far as it concerns the commission and the council , in cooperation with the albanian , italy and the greek authorities targeted actions are required . the inadequate social , economic and political conditions in combination with lack defective or legal certainty and organised crime lead to massive wanderbewegungen . mr president , unlike mrs pack 's view , i am ever more groups to deal with albania , it is better . of course we can make an immediate solution for the whole issue medium term , but we must find a world a commensurate with security and justice , zukunftsmöglichkeiten create . in addition there is a gulf between us - donors , the european union and the united states - the financial with resources to projects publicize and dgl. one hand and the local population . so we use the bilateral agreements , legally and clearly the activities of aufenthaltsdauer , whereabouts , the remuneration of the working conditions and working conditions prescribe insurance law , so that the immigrants to be a force of the countries advancing our economies and instead nationalist aspirations in a spirit of the cold war to fanning the friendship and cooperation between the peoples promotes . people are sent back , which have partly well integrated . but in the process must not centre , as the migranten- and migratory flow is , but as the situation in the region can be improved so that the people to stay at home . mr president , i also believe that , as my colleague dimitrakopoulos very true remarked , the central question regarding the economic , social and the internal security problems affecting albanian still remains consists , rebuilding the country in the rule of law , guarantee the safety for citizens and reputation in the restoration of the institutions and local administrations to support . i am colleague liese as the opinion that we burden-sharing on the need asylum and refugee policy . the action plan for albania and the regions bordering was adopted in june this year . it will therefore be made in order sixth plan . there are sometimes makes frustration , but also fremdheit towards a european right , and we want for ourselves , but also the other community institutions , the mühsal call here not to shy away from the surgery , precise and also for the working time and lend the nötigen staff available to make . we do with this report send a signal to the citizens that we are complaining about the lack of quality law-making and the complaining about überregionalisierung centralism and seriously . that is obviously extremely important subject in itself , obschon the small number of the participants in this chamber now make forthcoming debate at first sight actually dagegenspricht . furthermore , the report inevitably raises the question of subsidiarity to the house this evening is something controversial . it would be of interest to you in the light of this principle an inventory of legislation vornimmt to these simpler , more transparent , efficient and purposefully to organise and superfluous legislation to delete paragraph 6 , such as this report suggested . after very detailed study of the report which i have to conclude , concluded that it is also no political principle : it is a theological . so this means that the principle of subsidiarity in recognition by the smallest communities , local authorities , the intermediate organisations , the social classes , families and the citizens as the only really the sovereignty over the annual legislative and administrative operation must exercise , must be guaranteed . so let me give you a summary . i give the floor to commissioner . it talking about an area that we should regulate until detail , that guaranteed everywhere being implemented , or should we thought to whether a voluntary agreement , provided it can be enforced and monitored , is an alternative ? - i have voted for the report , although i do not agree with abänderungsanträgen overturned , because it has also with a high wechsel- and transfer costs in mainstays deals . if then in 15 months in eleven member states have also same notes and coins in circulation , will the procurement of this single currency outside their own preretirement more expensive . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i must first express my regret about this , for the fisheries commissioner responsible , mr fischler , not cannot be here today . it must be an agreement , that the fisheries cooperation and the moroccan fisheries sector impetus , but also gives the european woken fleets fully into account . consequently , we have on the construction of a responsible partnership agreed morocco , with its position within a meeting will explain the , as you have remarked , on 30 october , so monday , held in brussels . weeks ago i was in itself algeciras from the spanish coast . this lies just north of morocco . during the time has shown that it is not only difficult , but they could even be impossible raytheon . can the european union by the fisheries agreements with third countries and implement overmonitored align transferability . in a swedish fischereifachzeitschrift was to read , as one of these ships catch his in el aaiún to put this country has been described as moroccan port . all this will in question . it concerns all our fisheries agreements and not just that morocco , also because the agreement with mauritania and also that soon with guinea on microscope will come . 11 months has are needed to be achieved watershed now on , the advice on 30.10. , reach , and we also know respect the last measures which commissioner fischler , the results appreciate his journey from 26 september after morocco and on the high level , even with king , conducted talks . but i would like few very brief messages to the commission convey the worthy today by commissioner busquin represented . my question to the commission : ' if no agreement with morocco will achieved or if this agreement to which the commission will , signalisierten conditions concluded an agreement to stimulate the moroccan production , will the commission then structural measures to compensate for the backwardness of action in the affected areas will arise ? as we had equip itself , it foreseeing the negotiations with the moroccan authorities extremely difficult . this should undesirable outcome of the failure enter negotiations , the european union has finally the political and moral duty to owners and fishermen with adequate aid to support the them secure livelihoods . the overcapacity of eu fishing industry must be reduced . we therefore need promptly close economic and political relations with morocco in our european woken simultaneous enforcement . the commission therefore working on the basis of a new partnership useful , for both the one hand , the promotion comprehensive fisheries sector in morocco , the fleet , aquaculture , industrial processing and research as well as the other hand the granting of fishing opportunities to european fishermen covers . the rights lecturers ' this is not only in the german language a clear difference . in july 1999 , the commission this infringement proceedings before the court and . so it is not provided for by the us long-awaited harmonisation of systems should come , therefore , as things now lie , respect the principle of subsidiarity not lead to what the likely to demand a privilege to be discrimination undervalued . admittedly , the commission vorige under jacques santer was perhaps not the best , so you also referred . members of the committee on legal affairs and the internal market for the whole union and from all parties have to sitting here , to express that it has no sense to talk about rights , and for rechtschartas argue , if not , in real distinct cases in which human rights are denied , effective on measures , they must be recognised and enforced , and lies in this case the problem . that is in a modern europe really intolerable . of course the educational still falls under the subsidiarity , but under the treaties are the free movement of workers and that anti-discrimination clauses are all rationale , although we are - and i particularly , because i come from a very federal state - on the principle of subsidiarity as ordnungsprinzip cooperation in the european union affirm and should ensure that the promptly kompetenzaufteilungen between levels in europe after the subsidiarity principle orderly fashion . can we do not respect the discriminate against his speech . mr president , you would be an excellent chocolate-lovers surgery relating to the fachbegriffe in italian , french and german or by a surgeons let operate ? ( the sitting was closed at 10.56 ) we talk about them from our deepest sympathy . the floor to mr ceyhun ; he speaks as rapporteur and also on behalf of the socialist group . with regard to the council 's and commission statements on the third asia-europe shares with us the council is currently no statement that he wishes . so it is a point of view and euratom treaties under the competence of the commission lies ; it affects many citizens or can affect many citizens , and certainly not exclusively spaniard , because in this zone and in its einzugsbereich , for it not even a contingency plan , there are hundreds of european citizens from 15 countries of the union life , apart from many , come from outside , because it concerns the rate at costa del sol . madam president , it is very sad , but instructive , by spanish interior , mr oreja , to hear that talks with basque nationalists pointless assured , even if a künftiger cease-fire herausspränge process . i should questions , whether for this week a commission statement on the british government decision planned is a discriminatory tax for nichtbritische haulage operator introduce ? since the so-called parties , including the european liberal , more peacetime , with a racist and xenophobic , authoritarian inclined to allied forces , that is not just a serious risk of italy , but it also suggests a problem on this subject , towards europe . the report contains however also critical comments on french proposal . these concerns are the subject . amendments nos 2 and 4 of the karamanou report . the initiative of the french presidency , which we are debating today , has objective for the two preceding general rechtshilfe-übereinkommen in criminal matters , particularly in terms of combating money laundering , improve . i can only say about the idea , if the fight against money laundering damaged will , then this is not the fault of the council and the parlamentes . the results of their work , we can only congratulate you . of course lead the way meantime , as mr marinho says - and i believe this wholeheartedly - about the communitisation . all speakers stimmten until now agree to this initiative is a very valuable , and we are close to her . europol must be on boundaries can operate . assume there are still too much in our modern europe before , and i cock a recognition premises , i would first of all the mutual recognition fairer standards implemented see . i understand that it is very difficult , because we construction of fragment the instruments must be based . this is also a need to strengthen location of the european union , and it is also a desire of the citizens , taking into account when we have , for the citizens of the european union have a right to security . we need in the european union a unrelenting fight against money laundering and lead us be clear about it , especially after the establishment of the internal market and on the liberalisation of capital markets for financial services and effective police and judicial cooperation between the member states - as effectively as possible - needs . when an activity as finanzberater nothing justified to the adoption of such as lawyer would not exercise his profession . nevertheless i am of course aware that the question raised by several members , to the conditions under which the confidentiality of the legal professions rejection area of judicial cooperation in the fight against money laundering can justify , is very delicate . this applies especially to serious cross-border crime , and gravest . as a whole is the task so great and important , so that they are not the council alone cannot be solved . follows on the rights of the need to strengthen citizens since we create a legal instrument particularities and the competence of the court recognize , particularly with regard to the questions interpretation well decisions . although i eintrete for more cooperation and coordination , but i believe that this project , learn to make a legal framework , for weswegen wrong , we will vote against . as a second point is of interest . this is why the full participation in this house so gratifying . since several very delicate matters , i have this opportunity to thank everyone in this openness - as mr coelho , has just done - to say that we in this particular initiative in the first initiative see , whatever the political will expressed by the council , in comparison to police cooperation existing backlog in the area of judicial cooperation catch . so it is also an instrument for me to the judicial control of europol ensure . this programme on research fair in areas fisheries , agriculture and agro-industry was part of iv impoverished , from 1994 until 1998 expired . given the importance of research programme for agriculture and fisheries , it is regrettable that some of the identified problems were being specifically deal . the court of auditors report on this programme fair , on which the langenhagen report refers , is only just been published in march this year , while the sektorschreiben on auditing depart in december 1998 and in february 1999 the commission were provided . on behalf of the committee on fisheries , i would like to mention a few points . you have kindly referred to the atmosphere , in what the report arose ; you stand on signs of dialogue with the court and the commission services ; and you have made clear , as this is important to you . this shows that the commission on its hands was that you and your comments seriously . i now turn to the question by mrs morgan that collect by non-paid amounts articulated . thank you , commissioner . the überreichung should take place during the december part-session . it means , even if it some heads of state wahrhaben do not , after my deep conviction to the opening of the house so often and so persistent requested constitutional process . i am extremely pleased that i have the opportunity today , you in detail on this authorises draft the charter of the european union to debating , before you the final opinion your house to adopt this text . i turn do not doubt that the opportunity is on offer . however there are some critical comments on the content of the charter . this is a bedeutsamer position , i welcome . it was for us as parliament a great success - and here the groups have zusammengestanden , this is a positive outcome - that we have managed it that the european parliament with 16 members in this grundrechtskonvent was represented . the draft charter is , as i see a great plunge and it can , as a major european newspaper on 26 september 2000 , the betitelte card for europe . for my group therefore considers it absolutely essential , in article 6 ( 2 ) of the treaty include a reference to the charter . so many have indeed believed , so that europe would be the last opportunity , as raison d mere free trade and the ausgetretenen strayed of liberalism to overcome the foundations of a europe of citizens to build . the civil society , which is determined to mobilise and for european summit in december in nice to raise its voice and to demand a charter , the real guarantees for the citizens of europe offers . hierzu alongside the signatures also requires effective political commitments , the day by day for all member states and all political forces must be implemented . so let us take weep or do so , as if we are pleased , let us take this great event celebrate nonetheless , this is insignificant . the convention has done excellent work . both the endangers the citizens ' rights as well as the social rights . yet constitutes the right to good administration , but also by mrs ferrer mentioned , the main represents a major progress . i am not sure , mr blair manoeuvre displaying his minions acknowledges , a project to comment on this magnificent . i have heard nothing any more . madam president , last time you of the half full or half empty talk glass . but the council of cologne has to support the body that its role as stifter of confusion wonderful , has played ultimately achieve that all world has forget that it has a competence here at the national parliaments handelt , these are just under a policy of small steps let decrease . over-consumption grundrechtsschutz is just as harmful as inadequate ! if the honourable member raises some contributions listening , you find that this information is now than ever . the big question , at the now has the divided opinions , subject to end the charter . we are therefore once again disappointed and dissatisfied . of course we will vote for the charter , but with the feeling that the necessary but not so much enthusiasm and commitment from the citizens of europe can be resulted wofür as usual , the governments - and some more than the other - the historic responsibility must be adopt . the rapporteur , mr duff that stipulates that an important step towards improving the quality of european integration forward . who has anxious about this , i recommend a study on the statements by 49 of the convention as well case-law both courts associated with the charter . mr president ! the first time for establishing the european union will be here built for the laid a constitution , a constitution for that supranational entity , as it represents the union . but you have understood nothing . we demonstrating for a social and democratic europe , for a europe of citizens . meantime can in the present draft charter of parties , unions , appropriation , churches and further groupings in many member states and candidate countries of the european union as interesting discussion on the basis for future cooperation between the peoples of europe serve . i would like to make three points in the verlaufe of mornings by my colleague has already been mentioned . the charter to be decided by us today , not only strengthens the common values and fundamental rights , the basis of our community power should be , they are also visible . therefore i am of course to those of a reference to the charter in article 6 and its subsequent inclusion in the treaties aspire . we think only at the bernard connolly case , instead of criticism book on the commission decision after a court of first instance published not be allowed . this clarification is of special importance at a moment , since the european union is faced with the task of the legal position regarding the rights and duties on the legally in the european union coordination regulation nationals of third define . i turn exactly as he convinced that you will have some immediate effects in the near future and that they will receive a binding character . in during the debate i have heard some frappierende formulations , so the charter had a bones for dog , with the european parliament should be dog , or that they had fig-leaf for all that , as a agonisierende french presidency in particular in the leadership of the intergovernmental conference was abandoned . this has led our parliament , the establishment euro-turkish forum propose , in qualified representatives of the turkish community and european parliamentarians , about the mandate received , together in-depth reflection . unanimity does not mean that we in the development of democracy in turkey and the same way and , as there with human being treated , would agree . apart from that , of course i know that turkey 's candidature continue raises questions . the presidency wishes to draft this adopted as soon as possible , be made by next ' general affairs council on 20 november and , as i said this darlegte , respecting the very specific decisions taken in helsinki . but it does , what the commission in its progress report very clearly said , turkey must , as all other candidates , the framework of heranführungsprozesses the copenhagen criteria . mr sezar has in his speech before the turkish parliament last month with clearly : why is it for turkey himself no alternative to this steered there . i thank you for your attention ! here too there easy some positive signs . we reject the partly from unberechtigten aspirations , dealt with in this report so successfully be breaking production-linked . this applies especially to those amendments , with which the european parliament 's judge the past turkey should be imposed . this is a fact , as it is a fact that turkey , as every civilised society , with the need to resign , must be put to deal with their past , we have also been dreadful may . the membership turkey on such a basis geostrategic recitals and not only from the united states or the nato would be a enrich the european union and to a significant step towards a united europe darstellen . because forget that one has only a small part of the turkish territory for european continent heard ? we are therefore voting against this report we are against all the reports , the aim of turkey 's inclusion in the warmongers in the voted . damage rise above then , if in turkey hopes on an accession inspires , these were given the political situation must not be met . a5-0310 report ( 2000 ) by mrs langenhagen , on behalf of the committee on budgetary control on special report no 9 by 1999 court of auditors on research activities in the area of agriculture and fisheries , fair programme ( research in the field of agriculture , fisheries and the agro-industry ) , together with the reply by the commission ( c5-0227 2000 - 2000 2133 by ( cos ) ) i welcome this report and for shall vote against it . instead of human rights and the social rights to a higher level , easier to cancel the aspirations , you will be a modest level of button . as you undeniably should ultimately foundations for a future european constitution serve to turn the culmination of the eu to development towards a federal entities should be , in the decisions now , with corresponding legal force , a few and powerful and made by all implemented . main objective , main interests of the european union counterattack to the detriment of the interests of employees and the peoples of bedienen generally . a typical case is in favour of article 2 ( 5 ) . 2 find : ' nobody should be condemned to death or executed . despite our demands nowhere will set a family , from a man and a women does the aufziehen children , and hope that the grundzelle forms of society . this represents in view of the fact that this is not judges were elected limitation of democratic staatswesens forward . i certainly would have wished that you immediately in our european treaties incorporated would ! nevertheless i have abstained from the final , since i am of the opinion that some social rights clearly less than the economic rights phrased . the convention was originally assumed , in consensus to produce a text , which the member states by inclusion in the treaties would give legal value . in fact be the fight against social exclusion on the level of cash rather limited the demand towards , employers and the state compelling put to fundamental rights . for my part i am convinced that the secularity a emanzipatorischer value is both timely . the same lack sozialpflichtigkeit of ownership . this document is a legally-binding document inappropriate , as it represents no legal text . members of the irish parliament recently been addressed the question to what extent the brussels irish identity risk , and mr ahern provides in the irish membership while a prerequisite for economic success and prosperity , however rejected it at all hasty in steps towards a strengthened federal - centralised - from europe , since this wish to contradict the most europeans and on rejection would encounter . advise you once again , what has partially reversing . i would passing anmerken that this part-session whole seven reports on national initiatives decline , which demonstrates that there system , where there are , as ultimately proving very productive . these are absolutely essential targeted measures to combat this phenomenon , which continually developed and internationalised . with this initiative proposes a framework decision on the french presidency approximation of criminal law rules and procedures in the field laundering ( identification , freezing and confiscation of crime-related proceeds ) before . all member states should laundering as an offence and deal with imprisonment of at least four years evidence . since the world laundering has enormous proportions , which we can only by an extension of europol 's powers counter-productive , although it ultimately at the drafting of a european strategy for police and judicial cooperation to combat money laundering does . i welcome the report roure to a further initiative of the french presidency . in this case concerns the improvement of judicial cooperation on preventing abandoned , one of the extradition of waschens and proceeds from crime as well as the suspected criminals prevent financial crime . madam president , this is the only report , which i do not have given my support . it would be the first unionsmitglied , after the gulf asia geographically bridged and that a predominantly muslim has tradition . this applies especially to this stage , in which we gradually increasing use eib funds , but without our financial risks year-on-year fully . in this context i would emphasise the hauptschlussfolgerung in paragraph 21 , turkey upholding the copenhagen criteria , and not references to the numerous sentences of deeds and neglect turkey regarding human rights , democratic freedoms and its international morbidity well on the relevant european parliament 's recommendations on this country , to adapt to the relevant european values . mr president , worries us , the fact that official representatives of the hong turkey and the turkish press currently no welcoming pushing in this direction are recognisable , but rather the attempt , will be to oppose this development . nicosia is today , 11 years after the case of the berlin wall , the only divided capital of europe . the necessary advances are not yet sufficiently achieved , and turkey must continue to give trouble . mr president , mr president-in-office , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i am in my capacity as rapporteur for the accession of cyprus to join this debate . mr president , we cannot vote for the morillon report because we are sure that await the allegations hopes and too many people in turkey that adhesion of life peoples will not improve . but i think the same time , no one to black picture of the situation should design . since there are therefore a home relationship . in marseilles euro-mediterranean conference mr brok , the us is now to encountered , has just been identified in the negotiations delays raised . here we have europeans experience which we can pass . in fact it would not be more just as 1995 , about a new balance towards eastern produce , but also about the future enlargement prepare the union . xenophobie , state terrorism or other forms of terrorism belong in this area with fit , and i hope that it also have the opportunity , there are the things in order to make . with this fact , we have unfortunately live . but here we should be open . all this suggests that one has the inadequacy of the results achieved so far is aware , however suggest solutions to the opinion of the situation is still not fair , although admittedly five years for evolves complex areas are certainly not much . so our debate today can help us , the central importance of this policy for the whole european union has aware , to make . there cannot be competition between all these needs exist , but we must find new resources . the spiral of violence in the middle east , the aware well-run barbaric war against the palestinian people , the israel on as before their right to have its own state denied , threatens future throughout the region . mr president , as the european union in nice their balance between deepening and widening must find marseilles , should you in a balanced relationship between your zentraleuropäischen function and create mediterranen their responsibility . however herrscht in these days often reinvested sheets for five years before the barcelona process idea that we are mere continuity with the process , with the fact that ministerial meetings at the participation of representatives from israel , the palestinian regulatory authorities of lebanon , syria , etc. have taken place , can be satisfied . it may be a armseliger comfort . the today in the mediterranean existing common problems are buyers : illegal immigration , poverty and debt , human rights , drought and the terrorism of mitleidslos innocent lives destroyed and families , as the tragic events in spain , algeria or the middle east show . do we believe that , but the countries of south need more than speeches and promises . that we must give you . europe has no policy with regard to brauchwasser or desertification of the mediterranean farms , and it must be an environmental policy of the mediterranean face brief , by coordinates , vestiges and also the climatic diversity adopts this territory . i think the current proposals far more balanced . now to the agency in kosovo . we must not disappoint their expectations ; all these countries need our help today than ever . i would like to finish - and so i repeat the words of the commission - that these two proposals in the hub of a process darstellen , on the full involvement of these countries have had so many problems and , in the european structures lead . we must zukünftig delegate to the few mooring , also at a director , if they so wish , so that really a responsibility towards the body contributes , that these individual programmes tight-fisted . i therefore thank all ladies and gentlemen , the objective deemed more important , and are therefore pleased that we zukünftig in this area to be more contents in these countries can bring . some reports on the elections in bosnia , i read the ultranationalisten had won the parliamentary elections in bosnia-herzegovina . as you know , has the european union has strongly committed to contribute to this historic changes . the advice on the reports westendorp and lagendijk , on a regulation or the framework programme for european agency for reconstruction is encourage us once again , the scale of support to refer to the union western balkan countries on the follow-up of stabilisation and association grant wants . the long-awaited victory for democracy in croatia and then in the federal republic of yugoslavia requires the union , as we know , to go further . question time ( council ) as they relate to the same subject , questions nos 2 and no . recently with the resolution is 1324 parties for a further period of four months , been given to try to achieve progress on two fronts . i would like you to stand by the association agreement with morocco questions . the stability and the development of a caucasus put the strategic priorities for the european union represents . what the talks with turkey subject , so we have just a wide-ranging discussion on this issue had , and the union 's position on this point is well known them in detail . i would ask the minister , once again to stress that this proposed legislation on all those who seek to profit from people propose , which in a national emergency befinden , and that it does not matter , immigrants or potential continue to criminalise immigrants . it requires both corresponding legislation as well as measures for a wider discussion and a stronger awareness asset . in my opinion , with all means must be really all means fighting against these crimes , and i note that both the council of the union as well as the united nations general assembly and , as i also believe that the turkish government , are prepared to do this . and just because the 14 other countries are missbilligten , you have taken . as an example : if tomorrow in my country , france - and here i am speaking as minister - a right-wing party to power presenting , so i would wish to be against my country on measures , as you have been taken against austria . i wanted to speak values : i mentioned the values , as they are enshrined in our centred , i spoke of values , as in the charter , confirmed again and i spoke in particular - true - that the fight against all forms of discrimination to all european texts mooted . we must assume inspire us . i would remind you that this political dialogue alongside the future accession partnership one of the elements seinerzeit laid pre-accession strategy for turkey forms . question no 12 by ( h-0850 by 00 ) : we are in favour of setting a exclusively , and we will pursue this line . means must be remarked that the moroccan side on this gemeinschaftsangebot has not responded . these people came from scotland , where remand days after 110 custody either one charged or must be released without one , that you desselben offended must again accusations . specific measures were taken ( such as the securing deliveries and energy efficiency ) to bear to ensure that the economies of the member states less vulnerable to external crises are and what kind are the measures and the short- and medium-term council priorities for energy saving and ? the position of the union to the united states lacked extraterritorial measures remains unchanged . finally , i recall that the european union with the concern of the un-agenturen and ­ programmes ground findings has taken note , and the negative and frequently dramatic effects of american wirtschaftsembargos for regrets the cuban people . does the council , because there are not talking about a political problem handelt and stated that the maintaining the same distance towards victims and is unacceptable perpetrators ? this agency hand comes the decision the commission on decentralisation at hand , it has excellent results in the implementation of conferred revisit their task . at the recognize no borders . cross-border activities , illegal drug trafficking , whether in the area of cross-border cooperation or trafficking , must be combated by us . and it would be sensible if the commissioner patten , the great experience - in order not to say wisdom - in dealing with international crises and possesses furthermore various regions visited the western balkans , has once again to the seat of the agency for reconstruction , after thessaloniki , begäbe and has ansähe , as this service works . but this was never stricken region of europe so hopeful as now . i should like to thank the house will make it the two draft regulations so thoroughly examined rapidly and so on . also in serbia , where the commission within plenty of only four weeks in a soforthilfsprogramm value of eur 200 million has packages , could quickly results . of course we can also accept the proposal that the commission 's interviewed guidelines that our reforms underlying search for more efficiency should reflect . i hope that parliament understands the meaning of me in may suggestions in this difficult issue and will continue to cooperate constructively involved . i cannot however parliament 's request to delete the nonsensical unanimity to support this view , since the college of conflicts . the third challenge for the summit in seoul asem stock agree , both for regierungsseitige participants as well as for the public at large depth . what the real involvement of the people concerned , i thought made on the principle of opening asem for a broader segment of civil society note , although the initiative ngos and the creation of a social forum on some resistance asian partners unsuccessful . in this respect we are very happy that the summit meeting took place in seoul , apart from one or two government leaders were all since . even two specific proposals were adopted , especially the round table on globalisation and duo , ill-informed eight-point 4 300 fellowships in amount of usd 25 million . the commission communication confines itself to the treatment of the aspects competences of the community and the member states to tasks on the basis of participation in organisations . if we assume that all of meeresanrainerstaaten in the world on this very few economic , legal , political and legislative potential disposal , that the european union possesses , will understandable , how much we must ask ourselves , our responsibility worin there . of particular importance is the reforming the cfp , but more importantly , it is up to the appropriate reforms to decide . hardly a fish has a fixed residency . we are all aware us both in the european union as well as on far beyond aware . mr president , ladies ladies and gentlemen , i would first like to support them in efforts to thank the activity of the community in regional fisheries organisations to promote and also to increase . so far been able although some progress , but this must be a particularly at a better time-limit planning effort . the constant improvement of the profitability of haltungsbetriebe has been a rise consequence of supply , and then if another unlimited extension of modernize guilt , this again would inevitably lead to a strong marktungleichgewicht . instead it is preferable to everyone pig industry has its own reserve forms . so every pig industry to its own piggy bank . it will also be necessary to promote the producer indicated its introduction , depending on the state is very different . the coms , as you have so far gewirkt , which have konzentrationsprozess rather benefit , as you have had prevented him . the globalisation of reconciling proving to be in any event , and this has cyclical crises with nothing to do . everyone stockmen throughout the union can join this instrument . mr fischler , the rapporteur , mr garot , has the present commission proposal to set up a fund for the pigmeat factual and very specific treated . this is a question of compensation . in this sense , but i must confess that i to another concluding a colleague garot and also with the commission proposal , as it now stands , so i would almost say , in general and broadly agree , but if we are honest , is that basically the problematik actually irrelevant . then the involvement of specialised ferkelerzeuger in this system , such as that proposed in amendments nos 7 and 13 expressed . what , because bitteschön , because the commission has presented us ? are the first budget implementation and the haushaltsführungspraxis in the various categories investigated . so repeated its criticism of the court of recent years and comments on the negative effects of this practice , for example by not enough soundly based , hasty decision-making by mistake , due to overwork and so on arise . the dramatic developments in recent times have shown that management and control at european level increasingly important . so the member states will authoritative financially unpunished , the less authoritative member states financially rewarded . i would like in this respect to briefly mention that the improvement of external assistance is a whole area of the kommissionsarbeit represents a priority , both with regard to the institutional restructuring this whole bereichs both in terms pointed out that the high arrears in this area strengthened and faster than in the past sweep need . now is the european parliament in an extremely difficult situation , because it still - in january this year - has declared that it will not accept that will also accounts for 1999 with the serious mistakes steeped remains . i would identify some problems and i hope that mr karlsson cannot answer my questions today . mr karlsson said yesterday , the indication of figures may not easy . i do not , examine whether this already this year is possible . then we can begin to assess the directorates-general . of course we know about the current credibly the commission . you will contribute to a reduction in error . why does the commission now and in future judged , extent the rules are respected . i should like to thank mr karlsson for cooperation with the committee on budgetary control in this year significantly better than this worked well , in previous years was the case . furthermore , i call on you to publish a list of countries , which by bad complies faintheartedness , and particularly to mention , in the areas where this is the case . madam president , i too am during court for the report and also for the political implications of hofes yesterday in the committee on budgetary control very warmly indeed . there were also once again the credibly and their emphasises . since heard that fit , what earlier by mrs van der laan and - as we are in perfect agreement - has been said . could it be necessary , make the powers of the court of auditors to enlarge presidents , so that these decisions on the court of auditors working methods and its nature and the way communication can take . the rates and their composition of state to state are different . salient in its work on the common agricultural policy , with special report on the effects of the cap on cereals , lautete a court of auditors , the conclusions of the community budget 1993 until 1997 over eur 13 billion has been paid more than would be useful . ' it is pointless to me to ask questions , one could not answer . the european court of auditors must also change its operation . it is fortunate , not in this process to be afar . this report is in parliament 's environment committee has adopted a large majority , and so i will result in the vote in committee defend . the second point concerns earlier so that much-praised embargo . here i am therefore very grave reservations patents and would like reject this provision . in a second or third reading , we need the famous 314 votes , and we will - as this report now available - certainly not given . the commission has a timid , but very positive step in that direction taken , and perhaps the commissioner in his answer closer detail . observation of the rapporteur , on the consumer information about the risks and on the transparency especially in terms of health and safety unless greater emphasis on emphasis , we agree to . we should rather more into account the subsidiarity principle . i remember a hot discussion , but at the time i have my year-old daughter , as led me taos , only on the road to go . it had to be ensured that we all-encompassing guarantee consumer protection , without however things occasions womöglich or even contradictory to rules . i would sodann the importance of the environment committee amendments adopted stress , discriminates transparency for the user will increase the responsibilities and not only the manufacturers , but also the traders in eventuellen recalls for dangerous products intended clearer than banished . this also means that the relevant provisions of this directive repealed , if new , sector-specific legislate . many of the report proposed amendments put forward a improve the text and can therefore be approved by the commission . will thirdly in amendment no 4 calls for the inclusion of a condition , in a preamble should be integrated , after the states in cooperation with the competent authorities and public or private independent bodies to be committed to producing well-founded reports . although the commission , cooperation and the drawing up common principles , supported contradicts the wording of this antrags the subsidiarity principle . the commission received no references to problems with the existing wording before , and the proposed amendments would lead to a weakening of the rules . in amendments nos 39 and 44 proposed by the public only on dangerous products to inform , if a ban on marketing or a recalling ordered was , and between the authorities , what the market-monitoring implement , exchange of information , secrecy protected by not to allow . mr martelli normally , they can only end after the vote comment , but i can give the floor exceptionally short . a5-0294 report ( 2000 ) by mrs eriksson , on behalf of the committee on the rights and equal opportunities on the commissioner 's proposal for a council decision [ com ( 2000 ) 335 - c5-0386 by 2000 - 2000 b5-0143 by ( cns ) ) on the programme to support the community framework strategy for equal treatment of men and women ( 2001-2005 ) mr president , my question concerns the order in the vote on the amendments to paragraph 10 , which deals with the armenian genocide . ( parliament adopted the resolution ) the responsibility testify to the governments of unionsstaaten as well as the governments of the partner in the mediterranean . the aid given this tragedy is more than justified . this nachtarbeitsverbot for women was one of the few areas where the social legislation , in some countries due to the safeguards for the benefit of women female workers rather than was engine for workers . i very much hope that the commission in future by acting early and eu-india appraise it allows the european parliament , depth to analyse and debating . for that reason , i regret to have voted against . it is important that our products are safe , however , we should not let succumbed to extreme measures . at the moment agency for kosovo from a board director , in which the representatives of the member states and the commission each agree on a disposal and in the decisions taken with two-thirds . i believe that algerien-problem for serbia is kosovo . the danish social democrats have voted against a report , in the introduction of aid for the logically in the eu recommends . only in itself is a certain opening the french presidency aware that the commission rejecting these proposals , and the council seems no majority for its adoption to give . even a minor change of bids can cause a crisis situation . mr president , on the armenian genocide was the first in a number of völkermorden twentieth century , as a way that the continents cannot claim . since sweden is certainly willing to participate , between civil crisis management , but not on a common military defence , we could not support paragraph 15 , in the turkey ' desire for improving the european skills within the common european security and defence policy contribute welcomes ' . but apart from the duty of erinnerns , one of democracy and everyone must fulfilment of the europeans , know how difficult and painful it is difficult - so that some european countries have still not fully met - have , must be such acts of cruelty , with those from ethnic , religious or cultural reasons lives destroyed and that the burden universal conscience , never occur again . yet handelt are of course a question of other than the currently under discussion , but given the importance i attach to turkey , i did earlier today once again at this point remember . peace is therefore possible today in these countries , because the population are not at the prevented from exercising their right to self-determination . i have voted for the amendments , at the moment acknowledge this demand , so that these drags condolences and the pain a people recognised . this happened at present the ottoman empire . the jové peres report like this situation is not only for the existing regional organisations and the present in the construction befindlichen rationalize organisations , but he would have intensify , by adopting the normal procedure abolishes the commission , in the specialists from different member states to support invoked . my comments relate course on this subject , with which we are considering today , namely the representation of the european community in regional fisheries organisations , but they relate to the same such negotiations within the wto . the proposed by me disparate was of the erstwhile president-in-office , mr trittin and supported by the european commission , so that the decision of parliament , linked to combine the three directives on any great resistance coverage . in order to give an example : pvc makes 0.7 % of the whole scorched de-coupled from . finally i would stress that the ppe-de group with the third reading during the work satisfied . mr president , i should like to thank mr blokland for his drawing up this important report . incineration is no re-use . now in the third reading this report by mr blokland has for many depart into parliament elected members of the environment committee in the first baptism , you could learn the practices of parliament . and mrs evans pointed out that stricter limit values for new cement the co-incinerate waste , been agreed . regardless of the situation in each country is thus in all countries of the european union nearly a general reduction of compulsory insurance cover both the growing importance so-called zusatzkrankenversicherungen and exacerbate the discriminatory factors note . furthermore a draft directive should be drawn for the following points : first of ban the use personal information from the genetic ; no obligation for a gesundheitsuntersuchung before vertragsunterzeichnung ; introducing a commitment on lifelong insurers through insurers ; better coordination rules for the benefit alterations of persons within the union relocating or in another country to receive undeclared work , and finally the introduction of vermittlungsmechanismus . as we always positive stand on cross-border health care , at this free-market principle in intensify the application of health care . for example base that very often used as ' example ' to the free market economy in health policy . fatal mistake , it would be a model for us to take . for example analysing legislates or a insurance for all citizens . calls will give the variety zusatzkrankenversicherungen at risk of it today in many countries there and the actuarial based on principles . finally showed that it will , however , had an opportunity to get a quick treatment . it concerns about the health of all citizens of our member states and cohesion of our territories . coincidence that i am precisely why faced with such problems , because i come from the netherlands . mr president , honourable members by mr rocard asks the commission , in a green paper on characteristics of basissicherung for legal insurances to define . this is a very serious problem . mr president who has a long as we live with the study of the social issues employed has pointed out that , from the old textbooks a definition of social protection as a whole state of safeguards for the coverage economically abschätzbarer risks to give the entertained on this remembering or the family and on such risks were intended to a remembering - or a family - not even able to bear . this means that we must consider seriously , why the public health care has suffered a fiasco . the zusatzkrankenversicherung requires a deutschmarks system of ambitions and services advance . in attempt to abolish discrimination on grounds stoicism , would mr rocard , the gans sets the golden eggs , slaughtered . the commission will act swiftly within its powers , and i shall try to the conclusions of your report to give an answer . i also hope that the proposals approved , in which the importance of qualifications and the incorporation into working life . recognised will therefore be taken , regardless of the exercise of paid employment this phenomenon of poverty and social exclusion from becoming increasingly important . mr president , ladies ladies and gentlemen , we also want view from the committee on economic and monetary congratulate the rapporteur on her presentation . the next item is the recommendations of the commission for a council 's position on updating the submissions by germany , finland and the netherlands . this brings us to one other comment , and we wonder whether , at this stability and growth pact with the achievement of quantitative achievement of a certain endziffer elapsed or whether further aspects in relation to the quality of public finances in the next programmes should be included . our main message i therefore propose that the margin for abgabenkürzungen by a strict control of public expenditure must be accompanied . i believe that overall can draw a positive upshot . you have mentioned that one of the largest and most countries for the european economy , namely germany , the risk of overheating there . mr president , thank you , mr della vedova . i suspect that you today our opinion on these two issues , to the existing measures in the fight against bse in europe and to development in france , hear wish . we propose the european commission and our partners in the union before in this way , the extension of tests at european level in accordance with scientific recommendations carry . efficiency , independence and transparency will thus be the basic principles of the evaluation of ernährungsrisiken apply in europe . i shall return later on this point . however such tests are needed in far greater extent . active control measures , including random testing to be developed to prevent that bse in the fodder and land-based reached . in a situation , as we are now seeing is always tried to do , after a magic formula utilities to find a solution , after the blow both on a risk that removed as well as restores trust . on monday i will ask whether the member states , are afraid that weaknesses in the implementation of checks in recent years , as a breach of european regulations would , at the moment increased incidence play a role . but neither must be able to act quickly and at remain serious . it up to them , they quickly to supply . this is a particularly urgent demand , particularly with regard to bse . our group calls personnel attending this ban on meat-and-bone meal for all animals for slaughter , until the member states the introduction of laws on bse-vorbeugung and the strict application of the european directives not can guarantee . commissioner , i do not know whether this is a panacea , but on behalf of the precautionary think it is required immediately to ban the use of meat consumption of all breeding relatives , also for pigs and poultry , fish . the debate in our house boosted , after scapegoats in the council , the commission or parliament to seek , in my view is redundant . firstly , we must , as some speakers have said , systematic tests in all slaughter-houses carry the cattle feed for the europeans are intended . if we act with courage and ambition , we cannot reckless the europeans and the economic interests of our producers reconcile put , and in this way can we restore confidence . i would stress again that these professions in any way for the crisis . responsible for this reason the european union must show solidarity towards them . i can also arrogance which some member states do not approve the test separately and also demand that any legislation . the european solidarity must also apply , because our policy will come as incoherent proved : fallow , meal for ruminants , nitrates and pesticides . then i should like listen to what mr gollnisch here at home says that the spearhead of his group had been argument about bse . furthermore we consider measures to curb seuchenherde and all the imposition of delivering by one of unbedenklichkeitsnachweises current export ban on meat appropriate . it may not acceptable that we are not priority also politically appropriate support . i am glad that we are still on the extension of tests on experimental basis speak . but if we introduce general screening tests , if we meal , if we destroy the whole herd slaughtering of one single animal virginity 24-hour basis , then we must third-country , with which we operate and the trade is live carcasses and manufactured meat in the community want to export , equally strict gesundheitsvorschriften demand . the causes are quite elsewhere . i very much welcome it , that the commission has at last vehemently for blanket tests has spoken . because france has just been shown : who addiction of place ! so what prevents us remember , something needs to take ? usual because only a crisis flare before we come here and assure parliament that we in the health of the absolute primacy ? the link between the of animal meal incidentally - a very unnatural kind the feeding of animals - and bse is now clearly each . i also regard urge the european commission at a certain harmonisation . i urge the european commission to review , a total of france practised systems for dealing with bse carry . as a result reached that poison in this system and destroyed speak system . because it is difficult , certainly in this area einzelstaatliche and european legislation reconcile to make . there are also dahingehend legislation , as this meal as animal feed processed , this must be a further safeguarding the inherent in this system was to protect the health and to guarantee food safety . it was said that this will be very expensive , a large number of carcass include likely and so on . let cited as examples : the ' kissentechnik ' , the death of a female immigrants in belgium caused the use strong sedatives in spain , in the transport of schiffsladeräumen crammed immigrants in italy and spain , the tragedy of the 58 chinese , the uk , port of dover , were found dead , having occasions on shores arrested had been , and the general application of coercive and einschüchterungsmethoden diverse towards deportees migrants . i reject admit this commitment , and i would like to make a stand . the violence against women familiar : many forms of violence in the family , a crime hidden in the various forms of sexual exploitation and trafficking in women or even in human beings . mr president , i would say to mr nogueira , that it in the us model clearly-defined monetary policy course of the central bank falls , and it is the european central bank , the opinion of the treaty criteria handelt . mr president , i believe , in the public , it is very important , between the internal affairs and the higher profile to distinguish , and would like interested : will the commission now has just before the physical introduction of euro launch a campaign to the population of difference between justice and home higher profile to explain the monetary stability ? until the greek side will not operate here , we will pursue this procedure has been initiated . our part , we guarantee that it mess- and there are a surveillance system . in the same decision by the commission had obliged to support systems in all member states on the basis specific criteria to check the 2004 apply to this stage , since the approval of the french infringed expire . one objective that the integration of europe adversary power after the words of the lisbon european council joint efforts and actions required . secondly , by the experience of ground involved the ngos , the local authorities , the social facilities and the exclusion of personally involved comprehensive account . which would certainly many elderly people concur , but also those of phraseology of low wages , you have worked of a decent life permitted as such labourers . it also concerns people with psychological disorders , as large groups whose language skills , not enough to find a & . in the united states by greater flexibility will ensure that the field of employment , poverty only very short time experienced by unemployment and also a very short-lived . in my country are 75 % derjenigen , but the work and live below the poverty , women . we must try to this important task at least partly to meet . this allocation must be strengthened , represents one of the transactions and realism in mind , which field show . . ( en ) mr president , i would like to thank mrs figueiredo and your congratulations and thanks also to the other members of parliament address the now are not present and the opinions of other committees have presented . i am in favour , as well as the importance of non-governmental organisations of regional and local actors dimensions and their local experience better account . we have already agreed that the committee on social protection regular contact with the european parliament should take . the next item is the report ( a5 ­ 0320 by 2000 ) by mrs rothe on behalf of the committee on industry , external trade , research and energy on the proposal for a directive the european parliament and council promotion of electricity from renewable energy sources in the electricity market [ com ( 2000 ) 279 - c5 ­ 0281 by 2000 - 2000 by 0116 ( cod ) ] . we need now mandatory targets . another important point , which the committee has agreed , is the problematik of netzanschlusses and of netzzuganges for renewable energy . in my country , spain , in these guidelines would specifically responsible that today 's 2010 extra 225 billion tonnes of co2 into the atmosphere delivered and we would not meet the kyoto targets could . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , the commission proposal to create a framework , through the medium term , be it allows the share of electricity from renewable sources in the european union significantly increase , can only be welcomed . but of compatibility with the internal market can still a risk departure . waste is no renewable natural resource , although assume more and more produced at every day . this directive thus acquired at a involuntary topical . nevertheless i support this proposal wholeheartedly . mr president , i would mrs rothe for her excellent , this week , we in the crisis struggling with the climate change , will now have is a timely . the promotion of electricity from renewable energy sources is important to support . required are fundamental technological adjustments . instead are always only einzelvorschläge field of energy without great respect submitted . finally i would just mention three problems , which have emerged in during this debate . furthermore , the need for reasons of consistency in national parameters übersetzten objectives be binding , because otherwise it would substance and content of the directive would preoccupation . from the same reason we support amendment no 3 in part , but not amendment no 7 , for the text of the proposal to technically . but we cannot accept those parts of the application of the standards to state aid präjudizieren . the next item is the report by a5-0308 ( 2000 ) by mrs theorin , on behalf of the committee on women 's rights and equal opportunities commissioner on the participation of women at the peaceful settlement of disputes ( 2000 ) by 2025 ( ini ) ) . during the official processes almost exclusively men dominant , international experience and declaring , show how important the participation of women to and from the mainstays of quest . decisions on execution and implementation of specialises lie in the krisenstäbe responsibility here , and at the gifts and & little attention and recognition of women . obviously they want their dominant positions in the field of foreign and defence policy and can be preserved for the voices of women thinks that men are well represented . mr president , i wish to begin my great interest in this report express the view excellent , even excellent . it must also be the financial resources available to enable it to help women become the victims of this situation . mr president , i shall that what has already been eloquently is not repeated . i should like to congratulate mrs theorin , that you the initiative on this excellent report , which has taken an important with the same time , but also topical subject deals . namely about it , as an effective participation of women at the negotiations settlement of the konfliken change the world and the dominant culture of violence by the gegeneinanders and a culture of peace , of democratic dialogue and the settlement of disputes cannot replace . i therefore support the demands of the report , whereby women a right to influence diplomatic should receive . a very good dokumentierter , depth , stubborn report , the fundamental principles with darlegt clarity , as this carried out in article 17 , bold , but at the same with a large practical heads and very necessary proposals . i personally condemn any form rape and slavery ! fifth point : the role of echo , the office of the european community humanitarian aid , also that urging - and this house has endorsed this call - and also pay tribute to the gender dimension . the problem is that millions of women in particular , these activities exercise , and also a very great demand afterwards , but there regard any legislation exists . i think that should within the employment guidelines in accordance with the european parliament 's opinion on these guidelines have been raised request the member states led to a regulation sector . the immigrants usually put a large group in this area , what specific measures needed power , as specialized refuges , the necessary aid . it has a task here at the mitgliedsländer . the last few years is needed in order pools risen , the fact however was hardly careers in general and related rights and obligations into account . ( the sitting was closed at midnight ) ( very loud applause ) we must not only that internal system of freedom and peace , but it also create with rules and habits in mix of the european community and in the european union decades apply . our first step in the attempt to federal state entrench ecologically , is the establishment of a framework for cross-section democratic dialogue on the nature of relations between the two republics . as the representatives of the european parliament , the member states , their citizens directly represented , european citizens can understand why the most direct way of an accession to europe for us , the citizens of the current federal , seems extremely uncertain . we take the sitting back . finally it would be talking about a for european citizens informative and extremely important issue , and it would be appropriate if we are verlaufe in today 's day finish could bring . subsequently devised by the commission , then you will within one half-year a concrete proposal put forward , and it has delivered . in the european union documents are already being practically generally accessible and should be to remind the house that bold european citizens as well as many member states already progressive for many years have fought for more transparency . in this report will further processing in parliament also called for , and in this respect , i believe that it made here today and must come to rectify . we are pleased that we in the report of the key principle , we also reflected in the committee on budgetary control as vehemently represented . now to be an opportunity for him , also insight into transactions to take , for what are the mass media interest groups and not particularly interested , and he can to the open and democratic debate participate , for that confidence in the eu is so important . the petitions committee would have liked to shorter waiting until night clubs document seen . once they are not necessary , of course these documents should also be made available . i would also stress that all citizens bürgerinnen and access to documents in so many forms as possible must be guaranteed . dogma , the political responsibility must not with the rights of the citizen on openness confused . i would therefore call upon the rapporteur , any reference to the rights of members from the regulation and whose the subject of public access to documents is to remove , and i would urge all ladies and gentlemen , exactly out to ensure that their interests not against the voices of public expressions . in these areas is not guaranteed access to documents and will not only to bürgerinnen and citizens , but also the european parliament , formally denied that hand neither informed more fundamental documents to be consulted . a great ointment remains but exist . mr president , first i would like mr cashman for his a very good report . it has hierbei at an extremely important report , a significant part of what should this new records could give the eu . ( technical interruption ) yet it is not just the principle of unrestricted access to all documents , but also a question of course , that it should finally succeed in the doors open meetings of the council , so that in future not only in style of metternich in secret decisions lonely cases and then afterwards underhand brussels-bashing can operate . secondly , i refer to the question of exceptions . the population to see europe as undemocratic , when one place , at which decisions are taken behind closed doors . under article 255 of the treaty must be the proposed regulation before 1 may 2001 , this means , two years after the entry of the treaty of amsterdam adopted . you will allow me , i now answering some problems at the moment a endorses certain amendments by the commission forward available . as stated in some cases , we cannot accept the amendments in principle , but we must respect in technical and administrative together to work with them , for example on the amendments to classification of documents and to registration . we have nothing schriftliches in hand , and i would also like to propose that the commission future members writing sent their recommendations . welcome we welcome the enhanced status of the noise of weighting , particularly the assurances of the smaller companies can be made . report ( a5-0321 by 2000 ) by mr blokland on by the conciliation committee joint draft directive the european parliament and council on the incineration of waste c5-0371 ( 2001 - 2000 1998-99 0289 ( cod ) ] mr president , i would also of the eldr group , as co-rapporteur , urge that a whole little practical manner . it is therefore both the common desire of the group of the european people 's party and european democrats ( ppe-de ) both by the socialist group ( pse ) , until the vote on the second november meeting postponed . i therefore propose to vote on villiers 's report on the second november-sitzungsperiode to postponed . i have kept to the order , i have received from the sessional services , and this house has decided nothing else . that is all , what you today as i can say about turnusmäßiger sitzungspräsident ; as your colleague , but i agree with you agree . apart from its hostile attitude in the first phase , as the european parliament strongly on the dangers in britain drew attention , were the measures in the second phase , as the scandal in britain , wütete essentially confined to that country , without an emergency on implementation stricter controls on animal welfare and the restructuring pan-european level would have been launched . consequently we four key lessons should be included in the future . we have voted for this joint resolution . the increase in cases of new variant of creutzfeldt-jakob disease in england and the situation in france mentioned this a ' mad ' ( bse ) once again on the agenda moved , occasion vehemence with even greater . for fear panikmacherei among the population or in trying to prevent a handelskatastrophe that some governments have the necessary information is not due to the commission sent or during the first arise dangerous phenomena not immediately consumption of the products concerned stopped and not prevent their exports . the farmers alone can face this crisis is required : nothing convey a plan to accompany the livestock both measures intended to regain the confidence of consumers . the inability of the european institutions in their entirety ( council ) , the commission , parliament , a community policy define the appropriate solutions to the ever-changing most closely affected member states , will fits the problems hierarchy between constraints of the single market and the health and sicherheitserfordernissen raise our population . after many discussions with the council , we were in several points prevail . the shipment of waste disposal of the past and will soon be replaced by cleaner procedures . the social agencies and particularly the representatives of disadvantaged groups , on the programme chains , the procedure to be involved . so we are on this very renewed growth and the reduction of unemployment happy , but we must not a blind eye to the inequalities remain or even a exacerbating ! i believe that the rapporteur rightly calls for greater involvement of the public bodies , the social partners and civil society at current measures to combat poverty and social exclusion . the ' poor workers ' , mostly women , as teilzeitkräfte , to dumpinglöhnen and on highly job instability , ranks should be considered in a train of misery , in the official speeches so meisterlich ignored . three years ago wrote the prime minister unit that social exclusion , a assistant the coordination of social exclusion fade ozone by drawing detailed solutions to global problems . these are meantime plants with about 60 rotoren thousand in the fußballfelder claim . without the development of renewable energy sources would be the revitalize the eu 's present approximately 50 % until the year 2020 to 70 % increase . it is obvious that it in the use of nuclear storage of radioactive waste and the enlightened and suited advisable comply applies . we must therefore seek the opinion of energy , by its nature is already available , but as long as the remained unused , nobody sophisticated technology , they harnessed to make . occasion the preparation of asem 4 it applies the democratic requirement to renew the one hand , by information and the participation of elected representatives and civil society - especially in the form of a social forum - be guaranteed hand and the social rights as well as the environment and human rights taken into account . in this parliament has recently had a few times against humiliating impasse statements and even criticism against resist . we have witnessed this parlacen , with the same agonies had to do as well as this parliament in its infancy . consequently had been fighting and struggling parlacen that continue to be more competences , more resources , a stronger presence and the asserting its representativeness . this parliament must zentralamerikanische just as the european parliament 's prestige , legitimacy and credibility win , making it has its activity based on the groups , because that is the parteileben faithful account of the your approach societies , or at least it should be so . regarding the human rights since 1990 , we support the relaunched on respect for human rights since we on this subject and inform the people for awareness . ­ b5-0855 by 2000 by van den bos , on behalf of the eldr group ; the extreme confusion , the environment in the elections in recent weeks in ivory coast , so far as an economic model country galt , unanimous , is symptomatic of a country , in an economic crisis despair , social and political chaos as a result prevail . the military , political and religious leaders must all , every effort to enable a national reconciliation . this applies in particular it fuzzy debate on the ivorität and put an end to any reference to the ivorität from the ivorian constitution to remove the yes else means as the creation of national preference , which we in our own countries and their fight logic would ultimately the ethnic cleansing . he also has the grundgesetzänderung supported in its intention biggest enemy ouattara , given the fact that his both parents are not ivorer , eliminate . mr president , ladies and gentlemen even if the ivory coast in comparison to other states in west and central africa in the past a haven of stability and democracy , but there was a long time ethnic and religious tension , there ultimately also abuse by the previous government under staatspräsident bedié , and this has finally to violent sworn led by the armed . we condemn the ethnic acts and especially the political leaders , whose was opens the demagogy . the next item is the joint debate on the following motions for resolutions : this forthcoming eu-asean-treffen in december laos offers us a vital opportunity , on this regime that roundly condemned . incidentally , i have no confidence in our own ministers , that you to raise these issues there . the asean has proved a paper tiger in every respect , because it is not your succeeded , on the terrible events in burma to respond . the junta revealed that you intend to dismantle the party overall . there are a historic inherited and of course , is the difficult situation . this minor improvements in recent years , - certainly not on the amendments author of the socialist group , mr sakellariou , on credit - are led to a situation , and certainly not more tragic , but still no way disastrous and on the amount of current tasks vietnam . mr swoboda , the european parliament is flexible and efficient . nevertheless , it would be appropriate if the american president in hanoi has not only on the strengthening of cooperation , but this particular focus on specific promises vietnam , the miserable human rights situation in every country markedly improve , would habit . i urge the council and the commission , on mafia crude violations of these religion by the vietnamese authorities to protest . in addition to the process has signing the cooperation agreement between the commission and vietnam held in 1995 . these are of course share the jenem were included in the resolution which we have tabled . i am also the view that all we must do everything in our best to help them . most would helped them but we are about to change the situation , would you and countless other people in the world in this plight has brought . currently medium- and long-term solutions will be discussed . mr president , commissioner , the floods of those in recent weeks alongside other european countries as britain , ireland , spain and france have different areas norditaliens have been devastated , put before parliament once again the problem of both exceptional emergency measure to the plight of those people , communities and companies is to alleviate term perspective as well as a policy to a repetition of natural disasters to prevent such proportions . precisely the transport sector will be given its predictable steady growth - on 38 % over the next decade - measures needed to make greater scope . the debate is closed . that should perhaps be traditions of this parliament , but it seems to be , but delicate transmitting the impression that parliament with the europeans so low participation commitments to a kind eingeht issue and the european commission such a task accords . ( parliament rejected the request to postpone the vote the request ) the economic and social policy of the eu , the purchasing power and the ability of workers , contributions to bills , restrict has , as well that pathologies and curb the arzneimittelfirmen have healthcare costs in the felt in the bidding . in this way will the private insurance companies , opened a broad field , provided they choose the patients and the premiums ( initially ) not after from diseases . not much money and who receive spends , not only with counts . mr president , ladies ladies and gentlemen , i am particularly pleased that today i presence in a visitors from my constituency fine can speak , i warmly welcome . this presupposes , however presupposes that the colleges , will be given sufficient time to prepare the new rules . the report is convinced that the speech growing consensus about there that the current regulations , let us not able to developments in the financial sector in the last ten years taking into account . we say yes to greater account of risikomindernden techniques , and we also say yes to enlargement of grundgedankens the basle committee . similarly , we note with satisfaction significant contribution to this report on supremely note . finally , and that is the crucial point , we are quite aware that we established that the treaty institutional balance must be respected . the vote will take place tomorrow at 9 a.m . allow me , mr president , i wahrnehme finally the opportunity to the ombudsman , mr jacob söderman , on his work in the fight against abuses in the administration and so on same desire for a greater proximity to congratulate the work of the community institutions . mr president , the european parliament has quite happily in line with the scandinavian beamtentradition always used for the position of the ombudsman to strengthen and consolidate . the vote will take place tomorrow at 9 a.m . finally , it is a basic civil access to documents , and for a candidates no document is more important than the prüfungsunterlagen . we consider it legitimate that a candidates for access to its own corrected berlin prüfungsarbeit receives , because the access to documents is a fundamental right , in addition to the charter of fundamental recognizes , which we have voted this week . so it should also be . all other bodies and agencies should follow this example , the petitions committee as it has recommended . the citizens of the european union must contact with the community bodies in a positive impression win . and that means new in this case , the consequences of best practice and to avoid what all this , our experience from the credibility of the union in the member states can bring discredited itself in . what other institutions concerned , it depends on the application of this report and in the ombudsman 's requests addressed procedure itself reject them . the minutes of yesterday 's sitting have been distributed . if they are preventing a disaster caused unavoidable , it is breaking the democracy , but they have no appetite to come , then the earn you not agree . the underlying undisclosed stricter criteria of banking supervision are true , but must also other aspects , in particular , the solvabilitätskoeffizient account of a gewichtungsparameter for the contracting parties and that is made with the assets of a bank associated kreditrisiko approximiert . provisional establishing the european police academy cepol ( ) this police cooperation plays a crucial role to great aim to achieve this , for the citizens of europe a higher safety standards within the european area of freedom , security and justice ensure . enlargement of the european union 's territory , an extension of the free movement of persons with brings , will be of additional security measures for the peaceful coexistence and that must be accompanied by the member states . as i see , are the conditions in french and portuguese prisons completely different . this means , if you want common standards , they must be once define , otherwise they have a completely different training to be simplified . thank you for the work of mr posselt will now finally provided that the training of polizeipersonals even in areas and defend human rights must be done ; it is also important and appropriate nowadays , the recommendation of the possibilities of internet beneficiary virtual college to create . but we are here in strasbourg in a virtually deserted chamber and must unbelievable that nigh with listen . it is a good idea , and in the european union , where the people movement , where it enjoy free trade and the right of residence , where there are one of my sicily scotland can travel or greece , it is only logical , if the emergence of a common system of maintenance of public order expected . in the netherlands , the police on the de-escalation of conflicts and to repressive tolerance learnt , with existing subkulturen , ethnic minorities and the use of churches as zufluchtsstätten for people without legal resident status and political protestveranstaltungen than normal gesellschaftliche apply phenomena . who good solutions to the believes , for kosovo , he should have no fear , from you on the other solutions to judge . i hope that the academy here a starting point for the future supply . this is a good example of this , what we describe as organises interaction meanwhile europe , a europe that the united nations in direct contact brings rankles , without unnecessary bloated beamtenapparate create . the most abduction cases which are currently very efficiently and in adequately by the cental in all member clarified . this gap must ask for reasons of equality and social development of realism in view of both the same rights and obligations for all citizens of the european union necessarily be closed . experimental we welcome this measure and her will give our wholeheartedly agree . we feel sympathy for that gesetzte objective and agree to the proposed measures . in this one day it clearly to the people , often at the whole world cup , a child to see . this view the commission will also by the opinions of parliament in this matter as well as by the court of justice confirmed the european communities . i know the fifa has already played on time and waited too long , until you have said on the 1998 the commission herausgegebene formal declaration at all heels . it is obvious that the union in the future wada by the commissioner responsible for issues of sport will be represented . decision on the united kingdom levying a levy on non-british hauliers ireland is undoubtedly a very small , but open market , but that meiste , what we are buying comes from great britain . finally , i say that it for this debate in parliament premature , but i welcome the fact well the statement by commissioner vitorino , the clear right from the uk government , & introduce a system of euro-vignette , provided this in line with the rules and regulations already valid says . mr president levies and mauttarife are of course sensitive , and that i can confirm precisely for austria , where we have constantly this discussion , and where course constantly after solutions for good transport problems sought . here will be no other drivers or hauliers in europe to benefit british drivers discriminated against . the pays more room for his vignette , because it may , will give a certain reduction on a per-diem-basis granted . on 22 november , i.e. precisely on 25 anniversary of the culmination of king juan carlos , the opens the way in spain has had a democracy , the representatives of this foremost investigative its belief in democracy , freedom tolerance and respect for the other turn with life pay . i therefore ask you , all relevant carefully in their speeches memory to mind . the european union 's negotiating position looked more on securing the environmental objectives the kyoto protocol in areas landnutzungsänderung and forestry , which reduce the problematik ' , ' relationship with the kyoto protocol provided mechanism and national measures , also known as ' ergänzungsgrundsatz ' , and that the erfüllungskontrolle system . in preparing the next part-session should the eu not all issues again debating , but will therefore concentrate on the priorities , particularly on the ' fuel ' , the mechanisms to ergänzungsgrundsatz ' and ' strict erfüllungskontrollen . mr prescott is now under the wasseroberfläche disappeared , and we do not know how long it there will still dealings . my final point : i think it right to do with the question of reducing tough have remained true , and above all , because that is why it is extremely difficult to reduce precisely to judge . nuclear energy and there is no prospect of a comeback . it needs yet further steps . next meeting in bonn in may 2001 must be stipulated that sacrosanct . at the next conference in bonn in may 2001 ought still a unaltered compromise . the task , particularly in view of climate change , we face is certainly one of the prestigious twenty-first century , if we all want to have a future planet , on which we can live . the same applies to both the co2-senken partly internalization of additional aufforstungsprojekten . the hague conference will , as you , commissioner , this should have announced , in the next spring in bonn continued . madam president , thank you , commissioner wallström , for your comments . if it a matter , there are no differences in the insisted galt , so that the delegation for relations between the european parliament and the commission . it does no question , in the next cop to reach an agreement . we were extremely constructive and have up to this last minute hague conference negotiated . you have the floor , mr president-in-office . with the coordination of social security systems of taxation , asylum and migration issues , combated , trade policy in the area of services , a very important subject , certain countries still have serious problems . i would add that seats on the european parliament has been no agreement . to reach an agreement of the union on its ability to new accessions secures the currently active preparations , which is a significant challenge for the future of the union and the enlarged union . your president is of course invited . you will be presented in nice and - as we obviously hope - be adopted . as you see , there are very much in nice to discuss . in a union with 27 or more member states that will einstimmigkeitserfordernis simply lead to jedweder progress in the areas in which one insists on this principle , be prevented . you have codecision by the european parliament spoken . ( applause ) this task is reuniting our old continent . lies in the task of enlargement , as far as it has not been , and would be nice prepare ourselves . madam president , the most important objective of the nice summit is enlargement of the european union and the preparation of this enlargement . madam president , mr president-in-office , mr prodi , i think , have so far by the governments of the fifteen not with glory . this is not the right method . now been proposed , in 49 areas by qualified majority abzustimmen . qmv shirk the parliamentary democracies in the member states veto , but the eu itself will not be a parliamentary democracy . europe needs fiftieth anniversary , needs precision , takes decisions , needs vigour . the attempt by the blackmail of proclamation seems are given the conclusions of the european council in biarritz unacceptable , even if it was informal . we are indeed the opinion that the conclusions of nice reinserting a aufweisen must , in which the commission will , called for a framework for this area to produce . i will comment on nice if the result familiar , but i feel this debate here as something schizophrenic . in amsterdam are the heads of state have not been transferred again and again this class must now nachsitzen in nice . if the difference between large and small size of the council will , we need some years a great legitimationskrise within the european union fear , because the small then not more feel at home , because they fear , have their identity should not be able to defend . on the french prime staatspräsidenten and it seems primarily at their own political future and less about the future of europe . the text will not included in the treaties and receives a political signature , only then can a considerable legal precludes arise . furthermore , i would like to stress how important it is our union , with strong institutions , that equipping institutional vacuum , with the euro by the bewirkten speeded up on the economic level , compensate materialized . this reform are the stated objectives effektiverer education , for an enlarged europe better gerüsteter institutions and at the dismantling of indisputable existing deficit . but it also at the restructuring of the 133 committee itself , a much stronger democratic control must be subjected to agenda 2000 and its conclusions must be accessible and has been a broad and comprehensive predecessor must composition . mr president , i am asking not only to the president-in-office , but also to all the national governments , but i would indications that these are difficult issues will also continue to pursue , in this respect nice if no agreement . the smooth implementation of the codecision procedure in recent years has shown that it works . the first step should consequently consist , already commercial decisions by qualified majority to make . as you seven-year-old girl was forced invasion , before the red army to flee from their country and its refugee than before bombed by soviet warplanes in rifts lagging behind . the colleague whips has rightly referred to the charter of fundamental referred . more can we not expect of him . the agreement of the day to day will likely , is certainly not the lowest common denominator but unfortunately , but rather a small step , a very small common denominator . mr president , i would first like to thank the meps , because i think this debate for extremely niveauvoll . ' it did not so concerned , not to proclaim the charter , this is a problem of transparency . because the principle of equal rotation subject to the large countries , as everybody else to a certain time commissioner had any more . i believe that parliament will be noted that the union improved institutional mechanisms , it has found its enable likely , the further development of the european union , the unites us all , to dynamically . the vote will take place tomorrow at 12 noon . mr president , i would like the statement of colleague mr van orden endorse . i am clearly opposed to a eingeladener minister threatened by - and this also applies to the turkish foreign minister . it does no question that we here in this house , the european democracy , the safety of all our guests and every one of us in unusually , have to guarantee . under the slogan ' no ' pills damage and with the ' couriers 's statement that we tumours with marijuana ' has the italian oumar undermine the dignity of people , by adopting the liberalisation of scourge requested . this is a poor coordination , at least not to say a snub to parliament - because it may be , is the opinion , the meps had nothing to say to the human rights , although you recently the charter with very large majority - you have accepted that this forum on the european union not participate , you can at last year were represented , with the ngos and the institutions to debating . we now have enough discussed . now it has already been amsterdam the opinion of parliament as well as the commission that we ideally a foreign policy vice-president responsible for the commission had the same time , the role of the high representative and associated with a specific commitment on the council should adopt . as the european parliament before the feira summit on 15 june a resolution annahm tomorrow , it should also adopt a text of its position before the council of nice centred around . the development of a new esdp is an important project of european integration , the current institutional framework must therefore be reviewed . the european council in nice likely several decisions confirm that i shall mention here . for the first debate at the beginning of next year the commission well-structured statusbilanz for countries that ludicrous draw from the financial year , the state of the commitments and payments , the more appendix to the amounts for the most important from the community budget and by edf eu-financed programmes query . we have also with the question of regional cooperation deals , a concept that clearly refused the countries region on a certain resistance reluctant , because they are not breathe a be included in the past , you had wanted surmounted . but i believe , to say that they can , at this summit have understood that contradiction between a regional cooperation and its further development , its rapprochement with the european union in particular on the occasion reaffirmed and präzisierten stabilisation and association exists . previously had it under the portuguese presidency a summit with india , and given a ministerial meeting with the asean will still take place . this obviously means that we should not lose heart . i would like to remind the wide these tasks : humanitarian aid , evacuation of third-country nationals , conflict prevention , but also the military separation of belligerent parties . it obviously decision-taking by the european union and the recognition of voluntary commitments from the political nature . he has personalises when the conflict more than others in a part of the world done , and i know very well , and has universal recognition for his efforts acquired . i think the remotely in my country to set up this military force curious . i would mrs lalumière for her reference to prevention , on his report , the commission together with the high representative for the european council in nice prepared . thank you , commissioner patten . in my view the european union will actually microscope asked so on . ungeduldige citizens who complain about the grist to the european bureaucracy infinitely grind slowly . but the citizens have so far as possible access to information and documents received . from the present proposals will definitely not clear , worin this task should exist . with europafahne on car should come out everywhere , even in this entlegendste camps . for these reasons i believe that europe must be dismantle , now act . if we are not create as europeans , this conflict with the requirement for a role regardless of the united states to adopt , we must ensure that count , you are also in other konfliktherden as mediator pays no confidence . only personal commitment , not replace the democratic legitimacy of european security and defence policy . some details in the report by mrs lalumière i cannot accept . in the final vote , i am for the rejection of the report votieren . the neglect of this broad henceforth civil conflict prevention will prove an error on long term , since my explanations rich and the council is not enough , the reference , we have already decisions , but it will somewhere since langgehen ! as you will understand , our vote against both reports and commit us , everything in our power , what does , against the policy of ... thirdly , as a kernwaffenfreier corridor him were once olaf is palme , initiated by baltic until black to build . i would mrs lalumière on her excellent report . in broks 's report will also office of high representative for the common foreign and security raised . pity drum , i appeal to my colleague mr van orden and others , because of my colleagues behind ' small teich ' , the irish sea have , in this area so much offer : the tradition of experiences and the practice . after our understanding is that the european parliament in cooperation with the national parliaments for the most suitable body . i think that all the experience from these recent developments in the future stead shall be very well , when we deal with the need for a european defence and ­ capacity building , exactly what i believe that such an important part of european integration as the single currency . i am also the view that the concomitance of these different means a specific gegebenheit , a specific way the european union and that is our task , if this policy has underdeveloped and consolidates the consist , must be a real european culture of conflict prevention and ­ managing to develop . i believe instead that has a positive dialogue will develop . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , ladies and gentlemen , the resignation of the commission in march 1999 has shown , as a necessary reform its working methods and structures . the reform can certainly be drawn from above , but it must be understandable and the unions as well sämtlichen staff , and these must be explained in the entire process seized . this will require time limit , but it is essential and essential for the reform . the reform of the commission is a prerequisite for the future of our institutions . in the drafting my report i could not only studying the white paper , but also the second report of the committee of independent experts and the michiel van hulten proposed resolution on the work of this exposing the on 19 january was adopted in this parliament . the court flawed in his report he has pointed out that the abolition of ex-ante-sichtvermerks , if not opposes this abolition replaced by other procedures will , at least equivalent collateral offer and the other players so as to include finanzprüfer can . headline is a growing opening of large companies to monitor , you will give you more transparent , information technology is an innovative ; they are further away from orthodoxies vertical , making it more up-to-date information on businesses across coordinated and best practices . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen despite its gravity raises this white paper presented by commissioner kinnock no actual on institutional issues . furthermore , we have in fact afternoon under the debate on the common foreign policy debated . lastly , what the delicate question of the proposal for an early retirement tackled . the ceding financial control at the directorates-general represents an important step forward , and they will only work if the appropriate staff must be trained , adequate resources available and the competence of the linienmanager accordingly strengthened . the institutions and their managers must be clear about possibilities for fulfilling the best possible management available . disciplinary too - there promises , but still no clear rules so far , no clear statements , these rules should be ceasing , and also the question of the external is still not completely settled . such a change is necessary to god truly serve , and not through legislation can be compulsion . and as always , when it comes to change the already reside situations , are too clearly vigilance and rigour required . 6 withdraw and a separate vote on the last part of amendment no 15 request , since we are not convinced that the current system of the ecb itself will lead to this situation . as i said earlier parliament once hieß belonged , the commission president jacques delors , and this contracted side by side with mr brittan and beforehand with mr cockfield . mr president , commissioner , mr commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , we pursue this reform with probably well-founded expectations . issues such as bse crisis , volatility and greenhouse have expressed a european dimension . people must also have the feeling that the commission really accessible and transparent . the reform of the european parliament is an important matter , which it as budgetary and legislators a decisive influence perform . with regard to declare that malice mishandling within and outside the institution , in the officials employed by the addition of a number clearer procedures laid down , for several channels can be used . so i am sure that we have fortune , you also future listen . let me just say , mr garriga polledo , the categories of financial still remain . the reform of the staff of the commission must also be supported , and they therefore needs acceptance . our view is a cosmetic reform in this time profound change not sensible . mr president , ladies ladies and gentlemen , i would first of all the quality of own-initiative report by mrs sauquillo to reform the commission and its impact on the relations between the european union to highlight the developing countries . we seek to more accountability . before we talk of helped their , must be tried , all existing causes the profiteering ambiguity and those of the benefits from the exploitation and exploiting the distress suffering populations have learnt , to investigate and responsibility to draw on . but mr nielson because the collegiate responsibility so zugeneigt , will he proposal heue evening certainly defend . worse still is our opinion on the commission proposal retention territorial division . for 2001 are such that the transfer of fiscal responsibility on 22 delegations , the modernisation edv-anlagen on 15 delegations as well as the creation of 40 additional posts during external service provided . maritime safety but the erika as well as the ievoli sun were no french vessels . it does since the censoring the erika eleven months ago on the agenda of the commission quite high-priority . we hope and expect that the transport ministers on 21 december on his part common determination of the european institutions contributes to by the adoption of common positions on all three revealing a genuine improvement of safety at sea herbeizuführen . i think the opportunities available for good , but we need the certainty that this agreement will also be implemented . i understand and welcome the president-in-office 's efforts , also in these two reports as quickly as possible close to come . consequently , i think his proposal , the question , if possible , in december to deal , for basically welcome . as a result instead all we have a parliamentary report amending the directive drafted , in improvements in various ways , be proposed on the strengthening of klassifikationssystems as an instrument to guarantee the safety of maritime status quo . however remain from the legacies of years , in which materials were simply dumped in the sea . sometimes they tauchten back and suchten us homes , very often with disastrous consequences . in this context the publication of information is a key factor for the potential of the general public access to information helplines , etc . i assume hopes in the second series of proposals and the creation of a european agency for maritime safety . i think your consideration for respectable , but we can only on the results negotiate with the council tested . we already know that the port in the past sword was no crackdown on maritime safety , we know that not all registers their control than schiff-tüv correct and reliable , rather sloppy have finished , and we know that double hull tankers without schwimmende darstellen bombs . we build a new credibility on the one hand , and we should not be false action by the commission on the other hand frittering away . who will not shoulder this responsibility has , in our waters and in our ports simply seek to nothing . the watts report provides tougher measures against all ships , a serious risk darstellen or under flags of convenience but without this display abolish . nevertheless , i am pleased that the commission 's proposals the main demands of the french members have addressed aveiro estuary , so that the ban on single-hull oil tankers , the strengthening of checks in ports and the assessment of classification societies . equally i agree with his suggestions for compulsory to tachograph . as has already been said , peculiar guaranteeing the importance of maritime safety measures in relation to the responsible societies and the besichtigung . in short , the security measures , with which this striving to be brought levels , are loose . everyone talks about them , as i find quite rightly that the current port required for this 25 % -zielvorgabe still not achieved . the time lame compromises , which are difficult to implement , is furthermore let go away . i would like to classification occasion - and this is also my brief - once again emphasize that the current discussion seems focusing on the liability of lie . regarding the port the rules must continue tightened and increased controls . the slackness towards large enterprises is an indication that this powerful are as the elected institutions . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , a debate on the safety of ships and so the safety of people as well as protecting the environment 's subject , it undoubtedly has an extremely important issue . the reports presented go in this direction . we are agreed with regard to the setting of a minimum threshold for personenschäden or deaths and material damage , although it states leave remains , raising these amounts . the introduction of new technologies and constructive improvements to the ships are part of this important work . we need to a consensus on the highest possible safety standards regulatory and reach . i am pleased to say that the commission can , many of these three reports proposed support . the commission cannot accept the amendments 6 , 7 and 8 , which can only approve indes partly agree with amendment no 1 . it is expected that the imo to ausmusterungsplan at its meeting in april next year formally proportions . the main task of the commission has , to ascertain that the classification society continue in the directive aufgestellten qualifies obeys , and the capacity to monitor the classification societies . the commission noted with the support gratitude towards its originally proposed restriction . this shows once more , as the urgent adoption , better quality and stärkender preventative measures at community level protecting our seas . mr turco , i have heard your message and will this into account . on the other two reports , namely the report on the schiffsüberprüfungs- and ­ besichtigungsorganisationen and report on port state control , go the opinions differ . meets most questions in this parliament for a europeanwide approach . madam president , i would like to suggestion , the amendment dahingehend change that he begins with the words : ' urges , in this des engagements , the racial and the commission . report ( 2000 ) by mr a5-0329 by impressive achievement on behalf of the committee on budgetary control that the commission white paper on reform of the commission - competences of the committee on budgetary [ com ( 2000 ) 0200 - c5-0445 by 2000 - 2000 by 2215 ( cos ) ) mckenna report ( a5-0336 resolution ) the privatization of classification societies , in the hands of the shipowners are moved , as well as the lack of effective control of schiffsinspektion by public authorities and that complicity harmony between these authorities let capital more maßloser act . i therefore welcome it , the rapporteur watts vachetta , and piétrasanta tried , in which the commission proposal still exist to close loopholes . for implementing these measures are therefore the member states responsible . soap-box here should not more , they must cross-frontier elsewhere in the years after 2005 , 2010 or have disappeared 2015 . with by konstantinos hatzidakis unterbreiteten however those proposals will the commission restricted . the promotion of stricter rules at international level must be a fundamental objective of our policy on safety at sea remain . it is important to make clear that the polluter-pays principle should apply in full . this must gemeinschaftsmaßnahme by the reactivation of the imo strengthened , equipped with real polizeibefugnissen on enforcement of ism-codes , an effective instrument under model of europol would . until the costs for breaches of legislation under which for their implementation lie , will make the maximalgewinne aspire to keep the wrong choice . preparation of the council nice at the human rights and the social rights advance , facilitates the charter , the measures on the lowered its pitched addressed . i miss these ideas but unfortunately in resolutions . may i , like many , sometimes it regrets that are the prime minister , lionel jospin , during this half-year because of the cohabitation ' rarely has been expressed , but i know that he constantly his ministers were strong impetus , and i would like to highlight . on social proposals are very modest and not even give in to the lisbon summit adopted commitments substance . this particular concern to necessary strengthening economic and social cohesion . in this respect should be no development of the eu decision of the risk of alienating the citizens of marginalising . the british people wish that the eu with the reform stronger in the duty noted that you will be more effective . this text adopted in the future ( still further distant rückende ) pretext for enlargement to the strengthening of a system to demand that already lies in the last legs . now herrscht dispute would not only between grandees ' and ' small ' , but the grandees ' dispute should be coordinated . we welcome and support the report , the many important tendencies in the development of the common foreign and security shaken . as this report addresses ritual every year the european parliament , the principle of annual review of the cfsp devoted to the de facto seventy-four method , which would gradually to win ground , by a federalist , rift in a particular field , was beaten fatally gets larger , regardless of the treaties and the european council meetings on decisions taken . during our dispel hörte , he states that a rapid reaction of the european union will built to peace in europe and in order to obtain . it is not a task of parliament , the capacity of a european rapid reaction define or to discuss befinden , whether people in this instance interventionskapazitäten in terms of the sea and warplanes have does . the conflicts in the future can not by military intervention , but only by a policy with objective , social and environmental ökonomischer justice be resolved . we are fully and absolutely against these european army , as against the nato and our own national army . for example , the report contains far too far-reaching wordings on the cfsp and the nato threat , on the use of armed forces ' with ' as leverage in the conflict , which directly against contravenes the un charter . ten years after upheaval in the middle east , we have the opinion that ' the european peace-promoting ' applicant countries with these reports unedifying sent a signal . just six of these paragraphs contain statements on the subject belong . unfortunately there the clear intention , national abtreibungsgesetze suspend to set glaubenstraditionen and the oppose the abortion address , or even reassigned to repress . . it would certainly be many tens of thousands women involved in the european union rejoice that we are here with the legal system in the chores the black economy deal , because if it pretends . mrs smet proposes among the introduction of a european definition for haushaltsdienstleistungen before . in the drafting of provisos are the needs of household helps to account . they have their pension contributions to the various national governments abgeführt , these regressive taschenspieler as quickly disappear neglected . finally reminded us that the group union for europe of nations strongly doubt that the citizens of the european union more than ever expect that the ball on measures to reform both in attitudes to the diversity of our countries existing views and convictions taking place . with regard to the human resources must be the new administrative reform especially on the ability of staff and greater transparency in staff generally be targeted . i would like to use this explanation of vote to emphatically underline and point out that parliament has unfortunately not at all disposal powers , it should have . with a point of order come to my conclusion . the information are indeed contradictory , mr barón crespo . it is not so that the socialist group wants to do . but precisely that makes us problems : it is a significant summit and everything , what we say , bind us . i must remind you that the committee will meet tomorrow afternoon , mainly analyze the conclusions of the intergovernmental conference . ( parliament approved the proposal to ) . i would thank you very linked , if you factual this concern . i condemn also that rotterdam in a few days before the hunger strikers sympathisers from a command the grey been murdered . this would clearly not been absolutely necessary if the council in june our first reading and the modified proposal of the european commission , a whole piece in our balloting , something had any more or respected . thirdly , there must be considered whether the provisions , which we agree , contribute to the single market work better , and whether you in relation to the desired objective stand . our second concern is specifically legal nature and has led us to have a closer interplay between the harmonisation of the market and the health strike , although we are closely followed the recommendations thought , which from the explanatory statement which recently by the court judgment pertain to ban tobacco advertising directive ' light ' ; only with a arbitrary interpretation of this explanatory statement re-run of these two aspects to conclude , let us not go together . mr president , ladies and gentlemen in europe there date 80 deaths in connection with the new variant of creutzfeldt-jakob disease , and europe , be ministers , the commission , parliament adopt a monogastric animals compulsory and tests for cattle , and nothing over 30 months are , at its pipeline for consumption . our view it is quite obviously , the article 95 133 together with the legal basis for this directive represents , as committee now proposed in amendment 1 . view of gerichts is an advertising ban on behalf of a smoothly functioning internal market not to justify . since indications as ' low tar ' , ' mild ' and ' easy think misleading are , i am basically against amendments nos 10 and 30 . i am also in the treaties autonomies commitment speak . the rapporteur , mr maaten , on einleuchtender with explanatory statement , this legal basis proposed by references to another , article 133 on trade policy , strengthen and he has addition proposed certain articles , in a number of amendments undertake to avoid that this directive on the basis of valid case-law of the court decision contested . i also regret that the committee on legal affairs and the internal positions have been , whereby the court of justice 1000 ban on tobacco advertising directive in this way subverting . as a member of the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , i am namely by various groups very clearly on the need been referred to the presentation and sale of tobacco products in europe stricter regulate . in this directive will paradoxically the cultivation of tobacco in the community banned - not even in countries such as greece upsetting the tobacco is so strong that it according to this directive would offence , him for the processing of use . and thanks to mr byrne for the clear legal observation . in the european union die each year on a half million people a unnecessary death , and this figure will increase , if we do not act . these are legal worthless my belief that nothing , and so it is true that the unions , the farms that the members here and the loss of jobs out . i am warnings in pictures for pursuing a europe-wide lists of ingredients , long-time , gesundheitsförderungsmaßnahmen , with which children helped will , of smoke , tar , nicotine addiction and spared to remain . this stock willingness to the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy . as i understand , the amendment would be the exception of article 3 apply , i.e. tar , nicotine and carbon monoxide . given the nature of the general directive , we will not solve this by a andern why we must upset everything . the compilation of a maximum warnhinweises at some großpackungen would be an appropriate solution . finally , the comment that i am pleased to be able to inform you that the commission 54 amendments from the report 33 partly fully , partly embryonic cannot accept . the main argument , that these amendments and for a report each speaks after five years , is basically the enlargement of the european union , particularly following the nice summit , it is particularly timely and accurate . the summer-time seems synonymous with a more to life , and the positive effects of summer-time outweigh the temporarily distinct difficulties due to the reexamining over . the summer-time is not the problem for our common european edifice . a unique review from the commission in five years suffice . alongside the needs are the producers of computers and electronic tachographs well calendars and take account of agendas . madam president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen for patients necessary medical research must be approved quickly and unbureaucratically , but most ethically strict limits must be respected , and the maximum trials against abuse must be protected . this is an important distinction that we do here in our report . even in the council relationship on certain contentious issues still remain , i would remind you that the desired adopting this directive that result of long and fruitful . finding compromises that we have our rapporteur mr liese , which i participative working for its constructive and thank you , and the council , at second reading registered in the environment 's amendments shown towards cooperative and open , to credit . i am thinking particularly of research in connection with the cancer , but there are many other areas . unfortunately resort despite corresponding measures in order to threats and new diseases , often rich and the existing medicines to tackle it is not enough . it is the duty of doctors , present-day or effective means against these challenges mid-february . the vote will take place tomorrow at 12.30 p.m . a second reading and to avoid the action plans uninterrupted so before considering that can be no vacuum , was created with the council , with the commission and of course also agreed with parliament 's environment committee , although these four programmes at two years , extend it as the commission has established , but the resources available to make annual . if namely meanwhile that new health programme and adopted in enacted , there will understandably verlängerungsbedarf and can no longer the resources used for the second year . it is high time that any member states are out some of the european union in a perfectly legitimate supranational matter manoeuvre more and more budget line to grant : because diseases know no frontiers . estimates international organisations such as europol & adopted importation of drugs in the union even to . public health aspects is national policy , and so it must remain . the next item is the debate on the report by a5-0355 ( 2000 ) by mrs cerdeira morterero on behalf of the committee on citizens ' freedoms and rights , justice and home affairs on the initiative of the portuguese republic with regard to the adoption of a framework decision on the standing of victims in criminal matters ( 9650 2001 - 2001 c5-0392 2000 - 2000 00 ) : 0811 ( cns ) ) . a further initiative at international level is the statement by the united nations on basic principles of lawful treatment of victims and victims of abuse , by the resolution by 40 34 of the united nations general assembly adopted on 29 november 1985 . perhaps you will recall to the debate on the so-called di pietro-bericht , while ago here in the house has gone smoothly . with this initiative will pursue three fundamental concern : the right to information , the victim of access to justice and the right to compensation . the most important feature there however think in fact , at last and union level on the need to be aware , a new approach to this approach the member states with crime , we find . the member states should be obliged , special units for setting up barometer . italy has repeatedly by france , where they lojacono to remain free stage , extradition requests for these picking murderers down , so that he can get his sentence sentence . it must always victims of this centre - not the perpetrators ! as you will have noticed , are in rahmenbeschlussentwurf three different types of measures envisaged firstly be minimum rules regarding the rights of victims introducing practical measures are introduced rules ; secondly , with which the individual situation jener people should be included in the state of fallen victim offence , which are not their home-state approval , and thirdly , the states will deliberate , measures to support to victims of produce . it is already doing , interconnection of national services for the support of victims at european level to support to a proper advanced for victims ensure , especially if you in a country other than the offence of life . approval of the previous sitting has the floor again mr varela , chairman of this matter competent committee on fisheries . oh so bravo ! we have at last tuesday trialogue in a joint declaration by the council and parliament over fine-tuning given . we have managed it thus , a solution for the 2001 budget to receive . we must consider how we reserved area careful scrutiny of all the existing necessities to move develop transparent procedure . we wondered after their name , and you have said : ' this is the country without names . the council has its second reading on the budget account of parliament 's delegation with agreements and in the standing committee aspiration carried out , to adopt a budget of the funding sämtlicher priorities allows the european union and the real needs as well as the actual capacity to implement the budget line . the third significant element of this second reading of the council lies in the agreement on the allocation multiannual programme for enterprise and entrepreneurship , that the employment initiative criticises and supplemented , for the period 2001 2005 . generally , i would stress that in a few days on end draconian budgetary procedure has shown , as useful the interinstitutional agreement by 6 may 1999 was . the discussions were sometimes quite tough , but always timely and dienten always to exchange , and to a better mutual understanding and thus to accelerate reaching an - as i hope - for all satisfactory agreement contributed . it is essential that no country the balkan given the democratisation of serbia now less aid available will have , as this before the development in serbia was planned . indeed the most definitely cannot take-up of successive within two years - think however wrongly , as a kind revising the financial perspective be considered . today we have now heard the council for his willingness to 3.5 % machinery . i am referring in particular for the commission and the council from my sincere thanks . mr president , i also haug for their excellent work . i suspect it again , strong and simplify the flexibility applies for small and large amounts for the revision . we are in the coming years , as indeed see that works . we are now before the situation that we must decide whether we in this budget on thursday next can agree or not . there must be to look carefully at this course . but the interinstitutional agreements between the three institutions are also an important good . they should lead , that we have common plan ahead . the growing problemdruck relates especially to the bse crisis , unemployment and the suitable general . madam president , ladies and gentlemen , i am happy meps esteem , before you today the assessment of the french outstripping outline and in these last months progress can be estimate . as we had promised in nice , are no non-standardised questions left over . it was a procedure of strengthened cooperation , the framework of the first and third pillars largely been simplified . it represents both a tremendous challenge both a historic stage towards the reunite our continent . with this charter will strengthen our union , are the values of dignity , freedom and solidarity , which they are based , consolidated . a few weeks gripped the chemietanker ievoli sun near the channel islands into trouble . we have had set targets , they are met . from this six-month period - i believe that today - is able to say emerged strengthened by our union , they predetermined , new members , to include the family clubs - now because we are certainly also together , to be successful . remain the same time it has to be consolidated at the heart of our fellow citizens , in terms of the fundamental values , in terms of growth and employment , solidarity , safety , the preservation of the european social model , and it has also strength and influence at international level won . ( applause ) given pursued this concept seemed may inevitable , but the result is even more disappointing for two reasons : firstly , because it would be difficult to achieve a qualified majority , and consequently a blocking minority to facilitate this even in an enlarged union opposite would be needed ; ( applause ) ( applause ) the entitled , with nice tackled was probably the most ambitious , was used for a european summit for many years . madam president , mr staatspräsident , mr commissioner , ladies and gentlemen judgement that my group on the following fifteen little einnehmenden spectacle that are certainly needed to dumb europeans have to take this opportunity senate seeing , as it were really to the common vision , this solidaritätsbewusstsein mutual trust that the european high-ranking says , falls very hard enough . for any clear decent-thinking people they indicate the extremely serious consequences towards the project itself from a federal europe with 27 or 28 members arise . mr president , let me also emphasise that france in particular post-nice once more losers unaided . madam president , mr president , the group of the europe of democracies and diversities regrets that the presidency has not taken the message to your übermittel was in july . many do not see the port , in the european union should complimentary grades . so there are also a limit to account . i think it is not only the opinion by three groups , but also from other groups , but the technical reasons were not sign . it is therefore desirable , the development of medicines in the community to promote , so as to patients increased opportunities can be called a wirkungsvollen treatment . i congratulate my colleague mary honeyball her first report for the european parliament . mr fatuzzo surprisingly has the floor , and i am curious , whatever pensioners him now said what ! this victims must be person & will the finds itself in a specific situation of insecurity and characterised by quagmire . the situation is probably even worse if the offence is not in the home of the victim respectively . the next item is the continuation of the joint debate on : it was on despair , with reputation to be that the debate has focused , who would only receive a more or less agree whether such germany or france or the netherlands , belgium , portugal , spain or something dazugewinnen . we are glad that a new method has been created , and hope that the hope , given the follows on from the closer cooperation , europe will go ahead , that it will be able to produce a future constitution of our fellow citizens in the hope that this wonderful project , the european adventure represents , aspirational . the candidate countries will be egotism in our own member states take a leaf . the rejoice is distributed , but the main message is clear : europe can now in an enlarged eu , the democratic summarised by the treaty of nice is furthermore electors . this partikularinteresse before prevailed . in extremis by an agreement reached on the treaty was certainly an open crisis , what enlargement in question have been avoided , however , we can talk of a latenten crisis , with which we are now auseinanderzusetzen have . i do not believe that it is realistic , for the enforcement of their own national prestiges instead of an efficient functioning of the union argue , and i do not believe that the european citizens in masses are rose to the sea battle to pursue their leaders in nice . how noble intention anyway eleven years after the berlin wall case ! this time galt that half of europe , and now we need it for this whole develop . after nice will not be more on the institutional obstacles can invoke . firstly , an institutional imbalance in this respect , the council as much as well as the commission and parliament have got little . this model has stereotype . the consequences for europe would have been absolutely unpredictable . for example , as you know , were to start the european union for the two blocking the so-called grandees ' countries , there are three essential today . the way is mapped out , enlargement is possible , the european parliament will his seat in the debate , on the further development of concepts and have propositions . the european entities , as whose sole unqualified - and this point has mr moscovici right - which may pose nobody can do , not on the amount of national interests base , which overlap each and secrecy , and the verhofstadt message from this point was very appropriate . we recommended their ratification . i personally believe that a reweighting of the vote illustrate their population . undertake 's parliament was so procedures , and the council has had procedures must be equally . but nice , mr president , this is not the end of inquiries , but the starting a new stage with many challenges . so i would like to return to what today is already a few times alluded . although it is apparently really succeeded , the total paralysis of the future , enlarged european union , but could prevent the ambitions of the french presidency not implemented in the new treaty . for me gets a nice downright inadequate . i do not know whether the commission end the debate will take comment , but given the absent council question , i wonder whether the commission is also convinced that 2004 , czech and hungarian polish both honourable members from the baltic states in this parliament seated . we have not denying that on the road to enlargement with same dynamism and determination as before nice progressed must be to achieve our objectives , and that the greatest this historic task of the european parliament and the commission in the coming years must overcome . above all that remains the question of financing the western balkans in the coming years in full remain unresolved . i would like to turn the rapporteurs , the chairman of the committee on budgets , the commission , council and the presidency congratulations for the work , for conclude this agreement offer us the adoption of this year 's budget for 2001 allows . is reason to thank the rapporteurs . well , that is also to small and medium enterprises as employer additional resources available were . on football , would be transferred from one 1 : 1 equalised speak . the fact that we have a budget and at the conciliation procedure could not agree , however , means that all our problems are resolved . these are not simply to coincided importance , but they stems from the treaties , although the council sometimes it is difficult not recognise that . this includes a commitment of the college of commissioners to a fair and effective whilst bearing in distribution and material resources for the implementation of the various policies , means that the political priority of parliament and the managementpriorität the commission must be brought in line . so it is precisely the task of the common european level , the safeguarding regeneration and the environment forward . it is much of the post-nice speech . you are right , of course always to refer to this question . neither military violence still a möglicher another advancement of dictatorship are still has to fear . carefully considered by russia budgeted with morocco almost the same lumped or something greater , and that may well may not be right . it would be very dangerous , if the europeans are in a logistical dependence on russia would occupied . and there can be a tacis only very limited intervene , not to say that it only a drop in the ocean may be . the falling birth rate and the upturn adopted on the nettoverlust ; the bevölkerungszahl russia stands a million per year . the solution can only be a political nature . president putin has declared itself , chief liege on the status of chechnya . what with russia , with the population , with the society that is happening in the west indifferent . mr president , the european union has in recent years russlandbezogene various documents adopted , a good basis for the close relationship with the russian republic form . and what means freedom for the chechen people ? it is the first step , later , we on-line laws to be respected , and the second step would stabilised . in addition to the economic and fourthly , which will result in a civil society ausprägen whose trains . but this is an excellent report , as the common strategy , welch itself underlines the importance we relationship - the strategic partnership - between the european union and russia attach . this means that we are on one-page as the number of members raised the environment as well as nuclear safety , even on kaliningrad and a better coordination of different sources must focus . we must speakers referred to by a avoid making mistakes , the start of the last century was made , as russia after the leninistischen revolution of 1917 practically excluded from political life of europe , which had been devastating . as you know , the council has a common position amending the directive 90 220 ec adopted . i believe that they can do so the answer to your contentious issues still find . i am certainly willing to me to put this debate , but it must be the most appropriate framework for found . i intelligence on not sufficiently precise information on answering your supplementary question . since he can certainly not to say , he has no precise information about ! the council reminded members from the conclusions of occasion he its meeting dated 19 may 1998 on fraudulent on alcohol and tobacco growing has passed . all member states have their desire to increased fraud confirmed , both internally and externally also at intergovernmental level . the european union has repeatedly reaffirmed its strict application of asylum . that was signed in june 2000 cotonou in this respect before akp-eg-partnerschaftsabkommen provides that the community latest 2005 to tariff-free access for essentially all goods from the ldcs allows . i also remind you that the presidency do not think there is the individual people express that it will not bring about any kind government , but about the council 's position , welchen time ' x t ' or ' represents . it should be to create a system will not prohibiting cattle to buy up barriers to producers and a compensation in price on the amount of pay . it was the beginning that concern of french presidency , a european answer to this crisis , to enable the society of food , health and affected . in the context of barcelona process behest algeria a set of principles , including the rule of law . i already had the opportunity weeks ago , you deliberations on the preparation of the united nations general assembly special session of the follow-up weltgipfelkonferenz on the subject of children in september 2001 , will soon submit . subject : turkey 's obligations under the eu partnership - turkey in the commission proposal on eu partnership - turkey does it , the council will the situation with regard to proceedings pending litigation re-examine , particularly regarding the impact on the accession process and with the aim of resolving these conflicts on the international court latest end of 2004 to promote . the council intends to matter within the mentioned partnership towards the turkish government to bring raised ? will the rights of defence in adequately provided the mutual recognition , and can achieve something ? furthermore it is a matter for individual member states , at national level sovereign decision on the use national troops within such a meeting operation . subject : importance for the taxes that of functioning of the european commission president romano prodi has november in an article in the financial times , he declared wish tax systems and no common deciding taxation in the eu , since the rates in the hands of national parliaments and staying müssten lie there too . 23 until no 32 be answered in writing . that stabilisation and association agreement between the european union and the 0160 comes timely . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i would first like to gentlemen baltas very warmly on his excellent report , especially rapid also on his report , because it was important and right , rapidly on the changes in croatia - mrs stenzel has mentioned it - to respond . that is really positive , what progress is achieved on there . 1991 by 92 on croats were 250 000 from the kraina , and driven from western slavonia . this was of course for a year historical south-eastern europe . i believe that such an annual review cannot see any . this is an important point for us , and i hope that we again on the support from parliament can count on you , if we conclude the negotiations stabilisation and association officially consult . the wahid government encountering on resistance , and the reform process is clearly stagnate . also papuan befinden are still in prison . also in our resolution we call on the european commission , these rate of taxation . so are the statements in the communication from the commission earlier this year fully and entirely their justification , even if it is characterised by a certain euphoria , certainly from damaligen changes csfp . the stattfindenden not aburteilungen and as for the eternity estimation camps are admit the confrontation between old and new indonesian mächten and testimony to the weakness of glory . what particularly concerns is the situation in the moluccas , where the jihad in patrol way roam free . irian jaya too is a victim of resettlement . yet we must be capable of prioritised . we must ecological , social or economic policy issues is not a key problem basket with respect for democracy and human rights , in our relationship with indonesia represents a clear political priority . this resolution makes clear , note that irian jaya to indonesia heard . although the situation has improved , and president wahid deserves our support , but there are still huge problems . it can of course not acceptable that tens of thousands of refugees from east timor clemency armed bandits mercy are , in patriotism as a pretext to use a punishment for their criminal past to escape . that depends on the size of the country together , because indonesia does bevölkerungszahl regarding the fourth time in the world . & that depends on its economic importance , its regional importance and its importance for the environment together . we must therefore , the police and criminal and administrative resources instruments both between the member states as well as with the eu combine . ( the president cut the speaker off ) mrs schreyer , you have repeated here before this house , that you as the commissioner responsible for the anti-fraud task particularly agree see the independence of olaf to secure . the problems created by the introduction of wirtschaftsverwaltung level , because of the so-called ' community ' osce models of redistribution of eu citizens and taxpayers ' money ill-thought-out often also totally undesirable . i would like the rapporteur , i mankind as a politician and a very admire , like to congratulate her report , but i cannot , unfortunately . the report concerns the protection of financial interests of the community and about how we deal with this issue . these are the main issues . i shall timescale restriction on the basis of the idea of the individual points briefly . the debate is closed . there eu-wide legislation , the companies should protect against such negligence , and the commission has promised meanwhile , its own regulations to safeguard the cue vornahme payments introduce . we available on other mechanisms , not even in cases of fraud detected offences to draw your attention . mrs schreyer , you have just mentioned , the council and said that it has been a member state , the establishment of a european prosecutor opposes have . so that parliament would be very prudent conduct , if it auditors to know exactly what ließe , we expect from these reports . neither the commission nor the member states should be shirk its responsibility , particularly by mutual not refer to the responsibility of each other . he said that quite seriously and bedauerte these circumstance . it was a very or relevant , and i am also a very selbstbewusster towards them , the commission and the court of auditors also before the preparing this report in its deliberations included . you can see from my speech , i consider it sensible , these proposals for further discussion , to see , in what way greater responsibilities can be identified . the first crucial lack is the lack of harmonisation . therefore , i believe we must also improve to article 4 . within this market should be able investors , their property benefit the companies , in the invest in them , and favour the relevant companies exercise , although it is indifferent , whether it will help to individuals , businesses or handelt pension . we must not forget the reality at the ignore : in a incorporation of restructuring , there stellenplans ... redundancies , therefore , the measures they impact on jobs . but let us wozu we as parliament proposed by amendments may induce ? that is the principle , on the divergent opinions may tomorrow be : when it comes whereupon a rule of law on mergers in the mainly on ? easier to resolve the issue would hand the regulator 's competence . the rapporteur 's amendments confuse with regard to potential litigation confusion , and it would be wrong if we such a originated would give our support . i whereupon regarding these takeover , like to point out that the close relationship between the her and millions of voters in my country and millions of citizens with the equity tied by any more than austerity and pensions . such a in some member states already redress procedure concerned but not only in the field of public takeover bids , but has a much greater scope , and within the general revision of the commission relocate company law on this issue could possibly further studies . the furthermore i would remind you that it has received a previously expressed wishes of parliament at a framework directive . this resale rights represents the indispensable and inalienable rights visual artists on a figure on erlös from the weiterveräußerung towards their works . on a british lobbyists fear of loss of jobs . the council approved by compromise is therefore only be a poor substitute the original proposal the commission , the first reading in the broad support in parliament thought . i also hope to support the commission has been at least the big three main points . it concerns also at the vitality and the competitiveness of european art market . in another case would no doubt that art constitute elsewhere , i.e. in america , been sold . this amendment is acceptable only half-listened . market liberalization of postal services this reflects my proposal , mr savary . firstly : we must ensure that we in the postal services cheaper prices . reach secondly we must ensure that we have a high quality and thirdly , we have a high availability of postal services in all areas of the european union can guarantee . the legal affairs noted greater demands on the preisgrenzen for the universaldienstanbieter remailing proposes , but also at the same 150-gramm-gewichtsgrenze unanimously rejected and the draft directive 50 grammes set in motion . and finally , we cannot accept any new liberalisierungstermin long , no prior assessment has been carried out . you know how difficult this dossier is yes , it is ideologically loaded , sometimes on both sides . this step , the number of members of this house would certainly be welcomed , but for the postal services in the european union disastrous consequences . besides this on closure of outlets in the countryside lead , because this could not survive without the postal services . if we in the previous speed , we will continue 100 years , we need an open market for postal services in europe to build . madam president , i would like to make three comments . in the discussion on this new directive , we should take a particular point . that is not so and must not be too . in a fair competition can monopolists under prove that they understand their craft . but if grandmother was delighted that a brighter postman does , but also to a high quality of postal services heard , then this must not make us sad , but also glad . who so badly prepared in a matter of negotiation , who requested report on the effects not presenting since 1997 , who ideologically argued - exactly the re-examined them we will only achieve if we liberalize , liberalize , liberalize - the needs are certainly not be surprised , when it comes to the nose ! mr bolkestein , the commission is the guardian of the treaties . that is so , when we were to average income from one steinreichen and one poverty-stricken identify , then certainly made a number satisfactory , but , given the fact that it to poverty-stricken people at all , there are not acceptable in social terms than can be seen . there are new angebrochen times , mr simpson . the governments of the resulted , had not been oust , but conservative or liberal-minded . my outset was clear that the commission proposal in its original form would never be accepted . because on this opening this liberalisation and we are all agreed , it is important indes the speed . the effects of the first directive were not passed , because the consequences obvious lie : job losses and deterioration in working conditions , and no forerunner blanket supplies postalischen services , particularly on the country and in working-class . so we shall slowly at one of the completing the internal key political issues , the liberalisation of postal services , progressing . this is crucial for the development of direktmarketingsektors . i appeal directly to the british conservatives . and to appealed to post , i note : if this does accepted most of them a valuable breathing space available . we can only hope that it us one day , manage to overcome and that carrying-out of selfish malefactors defeat , so that europe really justifiable . only 3 % of briefmarkts have already been liberalised . he will of the technical development and overtaken by consumers ignored , if they are no proper performance for their money received . we can only support them in these adaptation , if the opening of grows controlled and gradual after a timetable carried out . with regard to amendments nos 60 and 61 subject , i support the call for a completing the internal market to a later date , the within a reasonable time-frame to determine . the commission will adopt the same position and so will the council on the basis of the kommissionsvorschlags decision , for which it considers appropriate . parliament must now but necessitating . my second report resembles thus in many areas in the first and accepting the amendments adopted in plenary . it is true , commissioner , that we still have some reservations and some differences persist . mr president , commissioner , ladies and gentlemen , i should first like to congratulate the rapporteur , mr dary , the us so clearly the reform , its history and its context - which i shall not repeat - has presented . there are various regions in particular the community , in the outermost regions , a number of difficulties have to compete on to markets , and one of the few products , which are available , are precisely bananas . through the wto will chaotic situations avoided because , in the wto rules to be created , which all parties have to consider . can exaggeration to say that this issue to which heard , in all the institutions have caused utmost attention . we must unreservedly on this livelihood producers contribute since we priority buy their products . mr president , the rapporteur deserves our thanks and our recognition for his report on this difficult issue . i also thank the chairman of the groups of this house , that you tenacity and the stubbornness of members from the areas in outermost regions have accepted , so that this proposed reform of unblock discussed today in parliament and the prescribed its opinion and we will do so in good time of the next few days stattfindenden advice of the council of agriculture ministers will be finished and that 2001 with a new reform of the com for bananas can begin . in this debate has repeatedly stressed that the report by mr dary by the committee on agriculture and rural development was supported unanimously . ladies and gentlemen , i have the pleasure of informing you that a parliamentary mission to korea has on the official gallery . so it is managed by the council , a positive decision for media to achieve . report ( a5-0377 by 2000 ) by mr trakatellis on behalf of the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy on the proposal for a decision of the european parliament and council to lengthen certain community action programmes in the field of public health , with no decisions candidates entered by 96 ec , no . mr president , i would just like the opportunity , under references to the commissioner 's remarks today night at 12.15 a.m. pointing out that amendment no 1 the commission in the duty adopted . ( parliament adopted the oral amendment ) : amendment no 2 : parliament had insistence on his position and the majority submit them again should , above all the amendments to the size of the warnings , the indication of the ingredients as well as consumer protection and especially the young deal . there are some in the eyes crowley around two categories of citizens : those of you protects those and the need for economic reasons suspend the risk ? i particularly like to explain why i that export of tobacco products whose tar , nicotine content by the eu 's current maximum level beggars , and rejected the amendments to the lifting of this regulation have supported . madam president , i welcome the radical proposal , as in canada images of use to the caused by smoking preventable to demonstrate . all that i consider to be welcomed , although i do wish that - and i would like to take this opportunity reaffirm - that much more for the rapid slaughter spent . i would have preferred , if this regulation would be carried out by a regulation , because that would activities , what the citizens throughout the european union relate , better fair . the amendments tabled by mr zimmerling art to enable the european curtain and the loss of jobs mean . i also fear that few living artists from this right to a figure on erlös from the weiterveräußerung will benefit . - ( nl ) i would like to thank mr zimmerling for the effort he has spent on this complex issue . i therefore see , forced to vote against the directive . and that stabilisation and association , cards and the european investment bank will not be the main instruments of contribution the european union on economic and social development darstellen croatia . the indonesian government and the army have the duty , to guarantee the safety of its citizens and their lives to protect , irrespective of to what extent do they colours . we must therefore as quickly as possible the necessary instruments for a more effective combating of fraud involving eu create . so in the eu would create a single judicial area will , in imposed for this type identified the criminal proceedings , trial and the enforcement of judgments carried vollzogen can be . this sometimes seems to be the case . the nos 11 and 13 seek out from this system of quotas until within ten years evaluate and would not oblige the commission now , a tariff propose , and some of our trading partners , to call a tariff . as regards concerned , the recital based on the akp-präferenz refers , so we are here with 300 per tonne agree , but keep the word ' maximum ' for unnecessary . such extension from our trading hardly likely to have a chance , to be accepted . the next item is the commission 's summit us-eu . of course it is easier said than done , but we should resist the temptation to us , at these summits intensively with the problems facing our day-to-day political and economic relations to employ . i know that the american secretary albright , also this view . one of the main lessons was that the europeans a greater contribution to maintaining security in europe must make . i would be grateful if you in the spring anvisierte communication on this point would include the length and in addition , the analysis of the other side of the house requested , would also make proposals on all points , as we can achieve in future new objectives in terms of dialogues , in terms of the external cooperation , the security policy , but also pragmatic on these issues , such as the mutual recognition agreements . i know and appreciate the eba for all were arms , but would ask the commission , during the forthcoming summit opportunity to use and the united states , this initiative to invite accede . we must therefore act to this irrevocable fate to prevent that those who are waiting , as mumia abu-jamal or leonard pelletier partly years must stayed on death row . this is a meaningful proposal which we willingly take up . thank you , commissioner . i am afraid that i am moment in cross-fire my own group trace . thirdly , it must be simple formulae for levying applied , specifically the reversal of the reverse charges . the first consequence consists , one can do little , until these international framework not changed . mr president , the committee would firstly point out that the existing agreements for the eu-anbieter folgender services which are drawback : software , data-processing and computerdienste , provision of web-hosting , web-design and built upon . one has always said to me , the first rules or principles of legislators müsse read as follows : decrees no laws , which are not enforceable . fortunately their place in the report of the committee responsible , among thank the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , a number of important elements , by a combine several circumstances in the transport committee clearly too little has been supported . the same time we must however also for a revision of the agreement of chicago of 1944 , advocate a reorganization of an international level to achieve . short-term location-based advantages of a country go to the detriment of other one or other eu countries . mr president , europe should field internetnutzung in the coming decade a leading position in the world adopt . many people are wondering why , commissioner , the europeans always quickly with taxation and in the new rules are obvious . that is chicago agreement on this point hopelessly . i consider the introduction of a common vat system not as a priority and am also not the view that the introduction of a common system had long overdue . at a non-wage under 30 % achieved by the united states budgetüberschüsse of several hundred billion dollars . the vorzuziehende option is far from the european e-unternehmen precursor to them the same conditions to gain , as the american and other companies fast-moving world prevail . tax competition lies in the interests of citizens and the economy . so must be the companies from outside the union , at the same fiscal duties as the local companies in the provision of services for consumers to meet , for the purpose vat in one member state your election registrants , with the vat rate on their state of elected shops applied . so now , quite simply is not just the facts . worried about the question of source , i.e. the ground , to which the tax should apply , and the discussion on the number of countries to make them might be that the companies where registrants my understanding , will be quite arduous course and the united states to a complaint to the wto defy . but there is little sense to make a flight from london to brussels and back for example with virgin airways whole 89 poured costs , while i for eurostar , far less greenhouse gases emitted during the journey and which is much pleasant , for the same travelled around 250 poured must pay . mr president , in this debate come the old bugbear again become apparent . another of the proposals were the french presidency on taxation on local consumption , with the duty of provider of registration discussed in all member states . the european airlines would compared airlines from third countries disadvantage and that would lead preisgefüge for flights within the eu unlike the prices for intercontinental flights be abused . however seems a solution , not lead to a kapitalabfluss from europe , only in terms of the oecd and not random with einzelverhandlungen to be possible . i am aware that the members of this house controversy sometimes views represented . the result will complexity in the case of the use macroeconomic or comparable criteria avoided . i now turn to the proposal relating to mindestnormalsatz . consequently be in icao-arbeitsgruppen still no significant preparatory work carried out and said that , at the next assembly a renegotiation of the agreement of chicago ecofin is unlikely . this feeling unfortunately even today in the european public . and this last objective directive lies in the strengthening of seenotfallmanagements through the establishment of safe havens obligation , through this auslaufverbot during a strong devastated areas and through greater competences during intervened through coastal at sea in the event of serious verschmutzungsgefahr . the oil companies tell us , you have a voluntary fund . i hope that the doubts and the resistance momentum after nice decreased are and our project succeed . of course we confidence in you , if it in order to guarantee the safety at sea about , because you know , no doubt that week passes , in the same question should not be asked : ' and what unternehmt their meps to guarantee the safety and to change the rules ' ? mr president , the commission knows the on 8 november 2000 announced by the british government plans to include the introduction of a specific non-uk truck include , for example , one of the british vignette as well as by non-british transporters equally to pay if it is the roads in the uk unusable . secondly , what the president-in-office if he had originally desired , proposes , foreign lorries in aircraft , kraftverkehrsunternehmen of subsidising their own country , does this then in breach of european law ? this imbalance between the economic kind levies and taxes , the kraftverkehrsunternehmen in individual member states have to pay , distorts the conditions under which , kraftverkehrsunternehmen different nationality in the uk in competition stand . on question the use of meat-and-bone meal : for whose export exactly the same rules apply , also for the production and meat and bone meal in the european union apply , with the demand , for example specified risk material from meat and bonemeal to remove it is also included in national legislation and is rejected on 1 march 2001 in force . the jews are traitor and liar . i very much hope that we in every country in this region note that the education system tolerance and not the intolerance transported . the answer from mr monti that i had thought . question no 37 by ( h-0900 by 00 ) : furthermore the commission will propose to schutzzwecken a temporary unterstützungsmechanismus , specifically the reason is intended to korean unfair practices in the time to face up to the conclusion of initiating needs . this is a subject full drama . the verwenderindustrie for koks has overall 70 000 professionals , but this product in this sector makes only a very low kostenanteil by 2 % from . question no 40 by ( h-0889 by 00 ) : we have our proposal for the acp countries practically same time as our member states presented . incidentally , i can assure you that this initiative , not seeks to regulate this problem , since the additional quantities , in the market back , could be very low . these countries have given their situation unfortunately none autonomous verhandlungsmacht and , consequently , we must think in this case unilateral action and without compensation . this bewilligungsverfahren requesting the commission for the financial subsidies will soon be completed and the resources needed consist of ecpat 2001 . we have it here with three types of activity to do . location for the future gerichts will in the commission proposal says nothing about . i am not sure what the honourable member values with the word ' proliferation thinks . the question by mr berenguer fuster subject trademarks . i regard it as a spur to companies and new steps to ensure that spain also required immediately implements this possible . at the last question you have replied , spain had blame and you would do so , what do you remedy . this was a good explanation answer to my previous question . the directive 89 48 by eec concerns diplomas finish at least a three-year vocational training in immediately after the suggested awareness . subject : links in the nordkvark - umeå ( vasa , finland , sweden ) the traffic in strait of bothnia ( nordkvark ) will be reviewed as unprofitable , after the shipowners opportunities for tax-free-verkauf have no more . for example are in a town called me vasa in the last two years 550 jobs in particular in tourism , perhaps precisely because of the attitude of tax-free-verkaufs , has been reduced . the proposal reflects the concerns of the lisbon summit reflect , because it purpose of which the development and use digital content to support . furthermore , i call on the commission , effective and rapid modalities in the field of einholung proposals to develop . if we including only the companies beneficial for content , particularly understand meteorological geography and data which is highly desirable , of course , we must not overlook that these things on which the citizens contents more difficult for certain shape , since this on the merely for companies useful information beyond . the digital content of more than by quantity to quality by accountable , standardized and confined the social and cultural diversity . the second point , the same seems to me essential , is that we on the small and medium-sized enterprises that we look at the start-ups . but if we make a virtue from the scarcity of premonitory simply umdrehen our languages , not as barriers , but as bridges , as recognise the benefits and use , then that is the basis for the european market and a certain independence . i shall not once again to all the objectives of the programme comment : creating favourable conditions for the marketing , dissemination and exploitation european digital content to the activity stimulate employment prospects and improve the potential of the european digital content compared with the united states better use . therefore it will increasingly important , for the production of content in multilingual europe in the right to establish conditions . some of these applications are in themselves very valuable , but in other pieces better lifted . the various opinions can now be explained , the tonight 's vote does not , and if view of the strongest group in parliament not be voted on tomorrow , then i considered it for far excellently , in tomorrow 's abstimmungsrunde if the members of this house vollzählig the scene , such a request to make , rather than this evening to do . mr president , ladies and gentlemen , ladies and gentlemen and more citizens in the european union will harassed by noise . furthermore , when the evening and when the night begins , the member states can decide freely . may i therefore welcome the commission proposal , however see agree and i believe that a first step to tentatively . by so that this will reduce and prevent of environmental noise in future an essential part of the european environmental policy must be . the group of the european united left readily support his proposals , although we would like to say something firmer proven to find solutions and against those tackle the noise from the propose more money . let me however still something to which bickering and to parliament in recent times in committee , apart from behind , and on scenes here and now also have to say conducted dispute . so i do not deny that my country will have enormous difficulties , the commission proposal , approve it either , because it contains a sufficient flexibility mechanism , the pledges from our forefathers revolutionise the crewed by myself as also by our foreign guests , so estimated to be maintained . i commend the report and also of the commission proposal to the house nevertheless . the second point we have daughter directives concerning the quality standards . my full support applies the need for harmonisation of noise indicators and the assessment methods , the whole area of mapping , on the drafting of action plans for the reduction of the noise and adequate protection calmer areas as well as the enlargement of margins for the public information . secondly uses this proposal for a new approach of evaluating gesamtlärmsituation in europe , and the number tatters from noise people concerned . nos 1 to 3 , 14 , 18 , 27 , 30 and 34 , 35 and 43 . accept the following amendments are acceptable in principle or in part : no . furthermore generally additives must not be used for unprocessed food - to which it has in this case that - to have been through any treatment , to a substantial change their originalzustands lead . mr president , the committee on the environment , public health and consumer policy , we have with the ppe group voted for the lannoye report , the moreover fully and entirely our depicts . nobody says that . the next item is the debate on the report by a5-372 ( 2000 ) by mr staes on behalf of parliament 's delegation in the conciliation committee on the conciliation committee joint draft directive the european parliament and council to amend the directive 95 53 by ( ec council with adherence to the implementation of official inspections . by the french presidency i therefore contracted a lucid high-profile , a very clear message to a ' up until now and not further ' translated . in lengthy negotiations in the conciliation has now found a compromise , which is acceptable : the reassurance that safeguards , the commission , have been taken so long , they remain in force until other replaced by a decision , and that the member states to commit to a fully support the commission experts during the on-the-spot investigations and to grant . i welcome this legislation . the structural funds from the eu , particularly with esf and the ministries of the resources available , must always on the development disadvantaged and poorer areas concentrated in our society . the european cities are important economic , political and socio-economic centres . a clear legislation and the careful monitoring compliance with its instruments are another . the commission is also the european parliament for the considerable support this proposal , it has command , and for the many amendments grateful . in view of the nature of the action the commission can accept amendments nos . i say this because it has to be an extremely up-to-date mechanism handelt issue , and they certainly agree with me on that day , with no passes on the subject from all kinds reasons , rightly or wrongly , however mostly incorrect in the press cursorily . the maximalisten want innovation and block progress , while the minimalisten advise them , only with a significant risk to health and environment to the precautionary inoperative , i.e. an intermediate still interviewed threshold , however , with nobody knows how this provision should be done ! the clarification of & tasks and responsibilities is a fundamental condition for the restoration of the necessary public confidence in science and also the decision-makers - in the us politicians . in these cases will precaution a sicherheitsspielraum left . we also prescribed measures in the world trade organisation , perhaps a regulation to ensure that it would , in the context of the wto is possible , based on other commitments to professions - for example within the multilateral übernommene duties - to extend the scope of the precautionary principle . it is of course , the precautionary principle to give more rechtsstabilität , with objective , as it servanda standard to anchor . the art of life consists , with these risks and insecure prudent manner . sometimes they require it to a undervalue it so much and too little , then again , what arouses our indignation . this applies to around phthalates in toys . we have the remarkable intention , toys in sweets , eis and other esswaren to ban . the same applies to request the commission valorization after a thorough risk analysis . in the resolution , the commission asked , its guidelines and the european liberal democrat apply in the drawing up its legislative proposals and in all its measures will always be taken into account , if this is necessary . a general de-minimis-schwelle leaves not determine . by the erstmalige awarding the prize to a exhortations to their fight within the union leads to the european parliament officially confirmed that any violation unconditional these rights must be combated . madam president , ladies and gentlemen above all to the citizens ' initiative ' basta ya ' thank you for your house blames the appreciation of the zuteil us today . and it will not only murder . i therefore ask you , me here to follow and confidence . ( parliament adopted the legislative resolution ) madam president , this house if it allows me , i would like an oral clarification to express my abänderungsantrag 51 . report ( a5-0334 by 2000 ) by mr garcía-margallo y marfil on behalf of the committee on economic and monetary affairs on the commission communication : taxation of kerosene [ com ( 2000 ) 110 - c5-0207 by 2000 - 2000 2114 by ( cos ) ) this agreement is made for certain companies attractive , the environment and democracy it is however negative . this salient event since our last tempestuous background is of course the bse crisis . this would clearly against the letter and spirit of the heads of state above-mentioned decisions in the thwart violated . parliament has successfully can impose a number of key priorities - including an increased use of the fight against unemployment and poverty , a number of important environmental and introductory etcetera . we have attacks against the civil side on the life programme and the european women ´ s lobby voted . the scope of the appropriation for kosovo , raises the question , however legitimate to what extent this region yugoslavia for the 2001 originally 350 million can actually start . there is no reason for a certain distributionsform tax advantages to offer . there are a definite date the actors at postal market signals and the possibility of national monopolies , be better to prepare a deregulation . leaves a lot has philosophy postal service , which features from every state explain leaves its roots and there has , with a simple , possibly with only a very small majority decision taken ausradieren ? the proposed by the commission 's borders 50 grammes with preisgrenze in half times the amount of public degressive tariff are really to dramatically and would have devastating effects on universalpostdiensten had to suppliers . so we indicate the entirety of concern , which he seeks , clearly and firmly reject . . ( sv ) we are not the view that the eu dealt with the problem postal sector should focus , even if the proposal by the committee is considerably better treatment than the original commission proposal . dary report ( a5-0374 resolution ) however must our view the small producers , on their work , planting without anybody exploiting , before the consequences of incurring extremely protected and whatever their income from cushion guaranteed . since exercising the right of freedom of expression in article 10 duties and responsibilities , which brings with it can conditions and restrictions or strafdrohungen subjected . in view of the fact that the numerical content tonnage 5 % of european gdp and 4 million jobs constitute , can only welcome such an initiative . under these conditions , the usa on their dominance in this zukunftsmarkt precisely its cohesion and unity to your credit . i also hope that this portfolios under application of subsidiaritätskriteriums goes so far , the autonomous regions and their status within the union can be maintained . we are delighted about . so be example in the above-mentioned africa-eu the national parliaments robbed of their rights last ratification , and a country , the council in the minority , we cannot say no more , if it in its negotiations interests does violated . we have repeatedly warned beware , and the expired in nice in plainly shows that a much broader agenda perhaps would have meant that this year would have absolutely no results achieved , with disastrous consequences for enlargement . . ( en ) in view of fundamental importance of the decisions it at the summit meeting in nice to galt recognition , must also be definitions , where there is tribute to recognition . else said , the parliament intends consists of control over the issues of taxation and social security to gain . in this langen folketing gestrickten council decisions offer no solid stop ; they have thick holes , by concepts such as transparency , identitätsstiftung , more democracy , the involvement of citizens or reformbewusstsein slippery appointing . we must therefore his conclusions as a result of a compromise , to look at it neither clear winner more clearly unterlegene there . on the contrary , the influence of national democracies adopted motion , because that veto will be further reduced and the european parliament more power receives . therefore musst du for this report , whose 130v after the taxation of kerosene remains limited , will be able to vote , because the tickets lead us to be increasingly cheap and thus more we can travel with this transport modes . ' ' rein not under homes , along dir could a pot on the head traps . the complexity and diversification of technological change and the structural änderungsprozesse obligatory require the involvement of all the partners local and regional level in the partnerships , embedded in the drafting of strategic concepts of regional policy for each region . we must therefore be trying to avoid all , what these three important conditions suffocate or could affect . one could say that the innovation for all players in the area of reconfigure opportunities lies . the gap between prosperous and underprivileged regions in the technological development is indeed significantly greater than during gdp . as the main argument put bureaucrats cited as you know , it insist the risk of errors . i do not know whether it was a direct consequence of this risi-initiative that today three ladies that european budget have signed , but i would be pleased if this weihnachtspräsent , that we decide , in future to women would benefit . it is also a mistake , the budget in a chapter on how to reduce , for pilot projects , new ideas for the local and urban development - with more than reasonably results - on the basis of a local level as popular community programmes such as interreg and urban envisaged . as mr rack 's very well , i have voicing these regional and cohesion policy will never be a sort charity towards the poorest regions and they never will be understood as such plea . for this reason i respect in the current negotiations on the docup , apart from innovative actions - i am speaking out by wretched out - that every docup established a regional plan for access to information society , and the quality contains exports licences , apart from the scope of this mid- immediately , particularly as regards the smes , educational and even aiding the subject . mrs schroedter , mr izquierdo collado and mr ortuondo larrea have rightly raised the issue allocation . the prices for schiffneubauten have fallen dramatically in recent years and 1999 have given their policy on south korea all-time achieved . the committee had vote separately to ensure that this item on the agenda for today 's debate says . this plan is still moreover in line with the treaty . my time is not enough to go into detail out . nevertheless , we think the commission proposal , a aid for research and development , the complaint before the wto on the practice in korea - since there worked with prices will still under the costs lie - and the possibility of übergangsbeihilfen , until the complaint decided not to includes , for a perhaps more or less weak resort , but rate for a way out . at the same must korea , preferably in the oecd , by anti-dumping increase the pressure . this means that we are suffering the unemployment and the other powers-that-be that make real business with the dockyards . i believe that there are he an excellent analysis of shipbuilding in europe , which reflects the reality . this process will no quick desired results , and should go through all stages , so takes this up to two years . the mechanisms were in application , brought up in a wto procedure decision falls . i am sure that we all feel binds us now to the freedom in europe with force and strongly defend , but i would like to say that we in spain on solidarity of the members of parliament beyond its commitment need . it swam may in sicilians waters , as his nuklearherz worrying signs degradation of those elections . alarming would we have not given this situation would act as quickly as possible . in both wise on the need we point out that the two member states concerned , britain and spain , in close cooperation safest solution for the repair u-boots seek out and of course - the public at kept informed . we have allegations of directors of british kriegsflotte heard after the accident , which may not serious , and others , the opposite famous and after the damage which had considerably lengthy and complex , reparations required worried . the house is aware that it would be here , if that have been possible , so that the task zufällt me now , at its & respond . the commission is doing , to analyse these plan . it has been done , we talk so taking the real facts about options , the uk authorities and gibraltar have to cope with the problem to be . serene cooperation is the method of our union unspent . the british government handelt just as the russian government recently , when it on a submarines their came to an accident . mr president , i too would like our spanish colleagues in the light of recent tyrannicide the eta terrorist express my deepest sympathy . the commission in its answer was marked by two months ago and in its current reaction responsibly , so that grant , although the draft of the ppe-de group that has not recognized , what alongside us further bagatellisierungen has prevented the matter , to give our assent . chief minister peter has done , that caruana right when he experts which prc business him directly , this report to reporting . this is and remains our view the kohärenteste position of the interests and the safety of all parties concerned best modicum . b5-0908 by members 2000 by mrs maij-weggen and mr posselt on behalf of the ppe-de group ; 1980 were of the unhcr 3.5 million refugees cared . today we all appreciate the unhcr and humanitarian staff . mr president , the commission would be the support of the unhcr occasion 50th anniversary of its founding parliament zuteil will , of course endorse . i would like to speak on a general problem come and am referring to the speech by one . b5-0909 by 2000 by mrs pack and other members on behalf of the ppe-de group ; and that final problem , i would like to mention the terrible events , are the border between serbia and kosovo . stretch heard milosevic and not on parteitage in belgrade . our view is also a dahingehendes in kosovo rethink required that the ethnic groups respect each other , rather than to continue to mutually vendettas . ourselves without a sing eulogy to do , we can also say that the european union very quickly on the new situation responded . b5-0915 by 2000 by mr medina ortega and other members on behalf of the pse group ; b5-0918 2000 by mrs napoletano and other members on behalf of the pse group ; the chilean government to assures that general pinochet in chile would receive a fair trial , and indeed has now lost its general pinochet immunity , and the judicial authorities have a procedure initiated against him . and let me remind you , to remember that it is important now , this joint resolution , since they pinochet in chile , not to adopt , which have not managed , as he has accommodated in britain . i say this in know about this , the grundüberzeugungen the parties of the european free alliance and the greens in intersect . mr president , before i start my speech with , i wish to join the condemnation of assassination , that an elected member , and councillor of the party of catalonia , in spain , which has lost their lives . for this reason i am delighted that my group and - as i believe - the majority of our parliament should not induce leaves the drums to derive advantage to the current crisis . their lives are in highest risk . the league for human rights has been closed , their premises versiegelt and its president , moktar trifi is , as you have just heard , for 25 december trial loaded . activists , unionists , academics , journalists and students constant harassment reports on both sides of the authorities . his condition is very , very seriously . daily harassment and that zusammenschlagen of democrats are really the rule . i hope that the chilean justice system in this matter continue its independence and effectiveness demonstrated posts . as we know , the missionschefs follow the european union the political situation in country very well . i would like to finish the important role the european parliament mention , by visits of parliamentarians and public debates as of today 's public awareness and to make up our dialogue on these issues contributes . laurent gbagbo must be a genuine policy of national reconciliation , operated by adopting the concept of ivorität exiled the racist constitution change and democratic elections , which complies with no candidate will be excluded , since otherwise the risk and the secession of warlike still rising . mr president months have been the news of the ivory coast a reasoned unrest in the european public and appropriate caused concern in our parliament . conditions for are to be excluded nobody feels that the inhabited by military impeach abolished will , at the head clearly in the process restoration of democracy tables and the opinions of arranging for national reconciliation heard . it seems that the concept ivorität completely pertinent to be . now is around half a dozen them during presidents copies available . mr president , on behalf of the greens consider our resolution we also reject . mr president , i endorse the words of mr posselt on . ( the minutes were approved ) will . the member states have for the elderly new political concepts and implement respect both problem the necessary care as well as the question of cost-relatedness address , and especially for the disabled applies , their families are really not able to fully associated burdens and quite alone to bear . mr president , it is me a great pleasure , the rapporteur on behalf of the green group of the european free alliance , on the excellent report congratulate . thank better quality information , medical care , housing , better quality and pension schemes nowadays increasingly people live longer . they are all the governments of member states , the administrations of lieutenant-general provinces , and communities with the many recommendations something can start . the foundations for this lebenshaltung will in the family emphasis , in every man as a child aufwächst . very often it happens to be in recent years lifetime very seriously ill and completely helpless and all the aid will be needed . finally , i wish to say something lift care . there has also been said , women must way from working life , so that the work men have . at first sight could interpret this as many disadvantage . we are already hierfür must find ways and means . the countless active old should motivate us all , to argue for a society in which the intergenerational solidarity phrase is no ! these measures must then to the & between situations and features regarding the quality of life and the financial independence adapted . only common constant efforts can help us . it must be discretion on an individual preferences and make decisions . if someone objects the agendas of our colleague vanished come are , then he should please zurückbringen , especially the glasses , because flemming was behind you , mr fatuzzo . finally , the measures which must opportunities for the outermost regions and their logo again expressly included in the text . in addition to highlight is the animal welfare and environmentally friendly production method in europe . so it am also pleased that we in parliament this week appoint a committee for biotechnology have set up . of course institutional campaigns should be the concerted promotional above seitens only complement the large chains . if the parliament 's proposals were implemented , the majority here with three times infant - but because they are shows once again the powerlessness of parliament - that the forage with legumes , with legumes grown and could be the feeding permitted , then we would have had more grundfutter , more pulses had . this falls surely manufacturers , sellers and professional and not the european union . we will have to ask why we have missed it in the past , the industry in the european union to encourage this verfügbare money to use . of course , if we can produce food and promote the better for the environment are of the veterinary account and the world market should also like sell good , then we really fulfil the entitled , with the common agricultural policy was panic . on amendments nos 9 and 22 , where the establishment of a specific reintroduce calls , together with amendments nos 7 , 19 , 23 , 27 and where further facelift called , is to say that the commission to consider procedural conditions must be coherent . all those , point out that there are people in europe still taste , let us be quite right . mr president , it is scientifically proven that a moderate wine consumed in the best warn against cancer , heart attacks or alzheimer 's , and i could go further listed many diseases . i would like to congratulate the rapporteur for his work my praise .