Discriminative Word Alignment

Viewed from machine learning, word alignment is an interesting structured prediction problem, with the interesting angle of having small amounts of supervised and large amount of unsupervised data.

Discriminative Word Alignment is the main subject of 22 publications. 17 are discussed here.

Publications

Statistical machine translation systems achieve better quality with manually labeled word alignments (Callison-Burch et al., 2004), but such data does not exist in large quantities. Discriminative word alignment methods typically generate statistics over a large unlabeled corpus which may have been aligned with some baseline method such as the IBM models, which form the basis for features that are optimized during machine learning over a much smaller labeled corpus. Fraser and Marcu (2007) extend their generative model that allows many-to-many alignments by a discriminative optimization step that uses small amounts of labeled data. Discriminative approaches may use the perceptron algorithm (Moore, 2005; Moore et al., 2006), maximum entropy models (Ittycheriah and Roukos, 2005), neural networks (Ayan et al., 2005), max-margin methods (Taskar et al., 2005), boosting (Wu and Wang, 2005; Wu et al., 2006), support vector machines (Cherry and Lin, 2006), conditional random fields (Blunsom and Cohn, 2006; Niehues and Vogel, 2008) or MIRA (Venkatapathy and Joshi, 2007). Such methods allow the integration of features such as a more flexible fertility model and interactions between consecutive words (Lacoste-Julien et al., 2006). Especially smaller parallel corpora benefit from more attention to less frequent words (Zhang et al., 2005). Discriminative models open a path to add additional features such as ITG constraint (Chao and Li, 2007). Related to the discriminative approach, posterior methods use agreement in the n-best alignments to adjust alignment points (Kumar and Byrne, 2002).

Benchmarks

Discussion

Related Topics

New Publications

• Nadi Tomeh and Alexandre Allauzen and François Yvon and Guillaume Wisniewski (2010): Refining Word Alignment with Discriminative Training, Proceedings of the Ninth Conference of the Association for Machine Translation in the Americas

  DELETEIntroduction   ResearchGroups   AvailableSoftware   SpeechTranslation   SignLanguage   ComputerAidedTranslation   OtherApproaches   Deployment Data   ParallelCorpora   ComparableCorpora   Dictionaries   CorpusCleaning   SentenceAlignment   Truecasing   WordSegmentation   SpellingCorrection   SparseData   PivotLanguages   DomainAdaptation WordBasedModels   IBMModels   Symmetrization   WordAlignment     WordAlignmentBasedOnCoocurrence     WordAlignmentWithLinguisticAnnotation     WordAlignmentForSyntaxBasedModels     DiscriminativeWordAlignment     WordAlignmentCombination     WordAlignmentEvaluation     AlignmentOfSubsententialUnits   DictionariesFromComparableCorpora   LexicalChoice   MTWithoutWordAlignment PhraseBasedModels   PhraseBasedModelTraining   PhraseBasedModelEM   PhraseBasedModelRefinement   ContextFeatures   Smoothing   Paraphrasing   PruningLargeModels   SuffixArrays   ReorderingModels   PhraseBasedVsEBMT SyntaxBasedModels   InversionTransductionGrammars   HierarchicalModels   StringToTree   TreeToString   TreeToTree   BinarizingSCFG   GenerativeSyntaxModels   DependencyStructure   DeepSyntax   ParseQuality   ParallelTreebanks   SyntacticCoherence LinguisticProblems   UnknownWords   Morphology   GeneratingRichMorphology   FactoredTranslationModels   Compounds   TranslatingTenseCaseMarkers   TranslatingChunksAndClauses   DocumentLevelAspects   Transliteration     TransliterationWithFSM     TransliterationWithOtherMethods     ForwardTransliteration     TransliterationTrainingData     IntegratingTransliteration   SyntacticPrereordering   POSChunkPrereordering   SyntacticReranking   IntegratingSyntacticFeatures LanguageModels   NGramLanguageModels   TargetedLanguageModels   MorphologicalLanguageModels   VeryLargeLanguageModels Decoding   StackDecoding   ReorderingConstraints   WordBasedDecoding   FiniteStateMachines   DecodingComplexity   SyntaxModelDecoding Evaluation   EvaluationCampaigns   ManualMetrics   TaskBasedMetrics   EditRateMetrics   NGramMetrics   SyntaxBasedMetrics   CorrelationOfMetrics   TrainedMetrics   TranslationDifficulty   StatisticalSignificance MachineLearning   WordGraphs   ParameterTuning   Reranking   LargeScaleDiscriminativeTraining   MinimumBayesRisk   ConfidenceMeasures   SystemCombination   IncrementalUpdating NeuralNetworkModels   NeuralLanguageModels   AttentionModel   Training   Inference   Coverage   Vocabulary   Embeddings   MultilingualWordEmbeddings   MonolingualData   Adaptation   LinguisticAnnotation   MultilingualMultimodalMultitask   AlternativeArchitectures   AnalysisAndVisualization   NeuralComponentsInStatisticalMachineTranslation add

  

  @inproceedings{AMTA-2010-Tomeh,
  author = {Nadi Tomeh and Alexandre Allauzen and Fran{\,c}ois Yvon and Guillaume Wisniewski},
  title = {Refining Word Alignment with Discriminative Training},
  url = {http://www.mt-archive.info/AMTA-2010-Tomeh.pdf},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Ninth Conference of the Association for Machine Translation in the Americas},
  location = {Denver, Colorado},
  year = 2010
  }
  Tomeh et al. (2010)
• Yang Liu and Qun Liu and Shouxun Lin (2010): Discriminative Word Alignment by Linear Modeling, Computational Linguistics

  DELETEIntroduction   ResearchGroups   AvailableSoftware   SpeechTranslation   SignLanguage   ComputerAidedTranslation   OtherApproaches   Deployment Data   ParallelCorpora   ComparableCorpora   Dictionaries   CorpusCleaning   SentenceAlignment   Truecasing   WordSegmentation   SpellingCorrection   SparseData   PivotLanguages   DomainAdaptation WordBasedModels   IBMModels   Symmetrization   WordAlignment     WordAlignmentBasedOnCoocurrence     WordAlignmentWithLinguisticAnnotation     WordAlignmentForSyntaxBasedModels     DiscriminativeWordAlignment     WordAlignmentCombination     WordAlignmentEvaluation     AlignmentOfSubsententialUnits   DictionariesFromComparableCorpora   LexicalChoice   MTWithoutWordAlignment PhraseBasedModels   PhraseBasedModelTraining   PhraseBasedModelEM   PhraseBasedModelRefinement   ContextFeatures   Smoothing   Paraphrasing   PruningLargeModels   SuffixArrays   ReorderingModels   PhraseBasedVsEBMT SyntaxBasedModels   InversionTransductionGrammars   HierarchicalModels   StringToTree   TreeToString   TreeToTree   BinarizingSCFG   GenerativeSyntaxModels   DependencyStructure   DeepSyntax   ParseQuality   ParallelTreebanks   SyntacticCoherence LinguisticProblems   UnknownWords   Morphology   GeneratingRichMorphology   FactoredTranslationModels   Compounds   TranslatingTenseCaseMarkers   TranslatingChunksAndClauses   DocumentLevelAspects   Transliteration     TransliterationWithFSM     TransliterationWithOtherMethods     ForwardTransliteration     TransliterationTrainingData     IntegratingTransliteration   SyntacticPrereordering   POSChunkPrereordering   SyntacticReranking   IntegratingSyntacticFeatures LanguageModels   NGramLanguageModels   TargetedLanguageModels   MorphologicalLanguageModels   VeryLargeLanguageModels Decoding   StackDecoding   ReorderingConstraints   WordBasedDecoding   FiniteStateMachines   DecodingComplexity   SyntaxModelDecoding Evaluation   EvaluationCampaigns   ManualMetrics   TaskBasedMetrics   EditRateMetrics   NGramMetrics   SyntaxBasedMetrics   CorrelationOfMetrics   TrainedMetrics   TranslationDifficulty   StatisticalSignificance MachineLearning   WordGraphs   ParameterTuning   Reranking   LargeScaleDiscriminativeTraining   MinimumBayesRisk   ConfidenceMeasures   SystemCombination   IncrementalUpdating NeuralNetworkModels   NeuralLanguageModels   AttentionModel   Training   Inference   Coverage   Vocabulary   Embeddings   MultilingualWordEmbeddings   MonolingualData   Adaptation   LinguisticAnnotation   MultilingualMultimodalMultitask   AlternativeArchitectures   AnalysisAndVisualization   NeuralComponentsInStatisticalMachineTranslation add

  

  @Article{CL:2010-3002,
  author = {Yang Liu and Qun Liu and Shouxun Lin},
  title = {Discriminative Word Alignment by Linear Modeling},
  journal = {Computational Linguistics},
  volume = {36},
  number = {3},
  url = {http://aclweb.org/anthology-new/J/J10/J10-3002.pdf},
  year = 2010
  }
  Liu et al. (2010)
• Liu, Yang and Xia, Tian and Xiao, Xinyan and Liu, Qun (2009): Weighted Alignment Matrices for Statistical Machine Translation, Proceedings of the 2009 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing

  DELETEIntroduction   ResearchGroups   AvailableSoftware   SpeechTranslation   SignLanguage   ComputerAidedTranslation   OtherApproaches   Deployment Data   ParallelCorpora   ComparableCorpora   Dictionaries   CorpusCleaning   SentenceAlignment   Truecasing   WordSegmentation   SpellingCorrection   SparseData   PivotLanguages   DomainAdaptation WordBasedModels   IBMModels   Symmetrization   WordAlignment     WordAlignmentBasedOnCoocurrence     WordAlignmentWithLinguisticAnnotation     WordAlignmentForSyntaxBasedModels     DiscriminativeWordAlignment     WordAlignmentCombination     WordAlignmentEvaluation     AlignmentOfSubsententialUnits   DictionariesFromComparableCorpora   LexicalChoice   MTWithoutWordAlignment PhraseBasedModels   PhraseBasedModelTraining   PhraseBasedModelEM   PhraseBasedModelRefinement   ContextFeatures   Smoothing   Paraphrasing   PruningLargeModels   SuffixArrays   ReorderingModels   PhraseBasedVsEBMT SyntaxBasedModels   InversionTransductionGrammars   HierarchicalModels   StringToTree   TreeToString   TreeToTree   BinarizingSCFG   GenerativeSyntaxModels   DependencyStructure   DeepSyntax   ParseQuality   ParallelTreebanks   SyntacticCoherence LinguisticProblems   UnknownWords   Morphology   GeneratingRichMorphology   FactoredTranslationModels   Compounds   TranslatingTenseCaseMarkers   TranslatingChunksAndClauses   DocumentLevelAspects   Transliteration     TransliterationWithFSM     TransliterationWithOtherMethods     ForwardTransliteration     TransliterationTrainingData     IntegratingTransliteration   SyntacticPrereordering   POSChunkPrereordering   SyntacticReranking   IntegratingSyntacticFeatures LanguageModels   NGramLanguageModels   TargetedLanguageModels   MorphologicalLanguageModels   VeryLargeLanguageModels Decoding   StackDecoding   ReorderingConstraints   WordBasedDecoding   FiniteStateMachines   DecodingComplexity   SyntaxModelDecoding Evaluation   EvaluationCampaigns   ManualMetrics   TaskBasedMetrics   EditRateMetrics   NGramMetrics   SyntaxBasedMetrics   CorrelationOfMetrics   TrainedMetrics   TranslationDifficulty   StatisticalSignificance MachineLearning   WordGraphs   ParameterTuning   Reranking   LargeScaleDiscriminativeTraining   MinimumBayesRisk   ConfidenceMeasures   SystemCombination   IncrementalUpdating NeuralNetworkModels   NeuralLanguageModels   AttentionModel   Training   Inference   Coverage   Vocabulary   Embeddings   MultilingualWordEmbeddings   MonolingualData   Adaptation   LinguisticAnnotation   MultilingualMultimodalMultitask   AlternativeArchitectures   AnalysisAndVisualization   NeuralComponentsInStatisticalMachineTranslation add

  

  @InProceedings{liu-EtAl:2009:EMNLP3,
  author = {Liu, Yang and Xia, Tian and Xiao, Xinyan and Liu, Qun},
  title = {Weighted Alignment Matrices for Statistical Machine Translation},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2009 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  month = {August},
  address = {Singapore},
  publisher = {Association for Computational Linguistics},
  pages = {1017--1026},
  url = {http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/D/D09/D09-1106},
  year = 2009
  }
  Liu et al. (2009)
• Setiawan, Hendra and Dyer, Chris and Resnik, Philip (2010): Discriminative Word Alignment with a Function Word Reordering Model, Proceedings of the 2010 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing

  DELETEIntroduction   ResearchGroups   AvailableSoftware   SpeechTranslation   SignLanguage   ComputerAidedTranslation   OtherApproaches   Deployment Data   ParallelCorpora   ComparableCorpora   Dictionaries   CorpusCleaning   SentenceAlignment   Truecasing   WordSegmentation   SpellingCorrection   SparseData   PivotLanguages   DomainAdaptation WordBasedModels   IBMModels   Symmetrization   WordAlignment     WordAlignmentBasedOnCoocurrence     WordAlignmentWithLinguisticAnnotation     WordAlignmentForSyntaxBasedModels     DiscriminativeWordAlignment     WordAlignmentCombination     WordAlignmentEvaluation     AlignmentOfSubsententialUnits   DictionariesFromComparableCorpora   LexicalChoice   MTWithoutWordAlignment PhraseBasedModels   PhraseBasedModelTraining   PhraseBasedModelEM   PhraseBasedModelRefinement   ContextFeatures   Smoothing   Paraphrasing   PruningLargeModels   SuffixArrays   ReorderingModels   PhraseBasedVsEBMT SyntaxBasedModels   InversionTransductionGrammars   HierarchicalModels   StringToTree   TreeToString   TreeToTree   BinarizingSCFG   GenerativeSyntaxModels   DependencyStructure   DeepSyntax   ParseQuality   ParallelTreebanks   SyntacticCoherence LinguisticProblems   UnknownWords   Morphology   GeneratingRichMorphology   FactoredTranslationModels   Compounds   TranslatingTenseCaseMarkers   TranslatingChunksAndClauses   DocumentLevelAspects   Transliteration     TransliterationWithFSM     TransliterationWithOtherMethods     ForwardTransliteration     TransliterationTrainingData     IntegratingTransliteration   SyntacticPrereordering   POSChunkPrereordering   SyntacticReranking   IntegratingSyntacticFeatures LanguageModels   NGramLanguageModels   TargetedLanguageModels   MorphologicalLanguageModels   VeryLargeLanguageModels Decoding   StackDecoding   ReorderingConstraints   WordBasedDecoding   FiniteStateMachines   DecodingComplexity   SyntaxModelDecoding Evaluation   EvaluationCampaigns   ManualMetrics   TaskBasedMetrics   EditRateMetrics   NGramMetrics   SyntaxBasedMetrics   CorrelationOfMetrics   TrainedMetrics   TranslationDifficulty   StatisticalSignificance MachineLearning   WordGraphs   ParameterTuning   Reranking   LargeScaleDiscriminativeTraining   MinimumBayesRisk   ConfidenceMeasures   SystemCombination   IncrementalUpdating NeuralNetworkModels   NeuralLanguageModels   AttentionModel   Training   Inference   Coverage   Vocabulary   Embeddings   MultilingualWordEmbeddings   MonolingualData   Adaptation   LinguisticAnnotation   MultilingualMultimodalMultitask   AlternativeArchitectures   AnalysisAndVisualization   NeuralComponentsInStatisticalMachineTranslation add

  

  @InProceedings{setiawan-dyer-resnik:2010:EMNLP,
  author = {Setiawan, Hendra and Dyer, Chris and Resnik, Philip},
  title = {Discriminative Word Alignment with a Function Word Reordering Model},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2010 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  month = {October},
  address = {Cambridge, MA},
  publisher = {Association for Computational Linguistics},
  pages = {534--544},
  url = {http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/D/D10/D10-1052},
  year = 2010
  }
  Setiawan et al. (2010)
• Dyer, Chris and Clark, Jonathan H. and Lavie, Alon and Smith, Noah A. (2011): Unsupervised Word Alignment with Arbitrary Features, Proceedings of the 49th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Techologies

  DELETEIntroduction   ResearchGroups   AvailableSoftware   SpeechTranslation   SignLanguage   ComputerAidedTranslation   OtherApproaches   Deployment Data   ParallelCorpora   ComparableCorpora   Dictionaries   CorpusCleaning   SentenceAlignment   Truecasing   WordSegmentation   SpellingCorrection   SparseData   PivotLanguages   DomainAdaptation WordBasedModels   IBMModels   Symmetrization   WordAlignment     WordAlignmentBasedOnCoocurrence     WordAlignmentWithLinguisticAnnotation     WordAlignmentForSyntaxBasedModels     DiscriminativeWordAlignment     WordAlignmentCombination     WordAlignmentEvaluation     AlignmentOfSubsententialUnits   DictionariesFromComparableCorpora   LexicalChoice   MTWithoutWordAlignment PhraseBasedModels   PhraseBasedModelTraining   PhraseBasedModelEM   PhraseBasedModelRefinement   ContextFeatures   Smoothing   Paraphrasing   PruningLargeModels   SuffixArrays   ReorderingModels   PhraseBasedVsEBMT SyntaxBasedModels   InversionTransductionGrammars   HierarchicalModels   StringToTree   TreeToString   TreeToTree   BinarizingSCFG   GenerativeSyntaxModels   DependencyStructure   DeepSyntax   ParseQuality   ParallelTreebanks   SyntacticCoherence LinguisticProblems   UnknownWords   Morphology   GeneratingRichMorphology   FactoredTranslationModels   Compounds   TranslatingTenseCaseMarkers   TranslatingChunksAndClauses   DocumentLevelAspects   Transliteration     TransliterationWithFSM     TransliterationWithOtherMethods     ForwardTransliteration     TransliterationTrainingData     IntegratingTransliteration   SyntacticPrereordering   POSChunkPrereordering   SyntacticReranking   IntegratingSyntacticFeatures LanguageModels   NGramLanguageModels   TargetedLanguageModels   MorphologicalLanguageModels   VeryLargeLanguageModels Decoding   StackDecoding   ReorderingConstraints   WordBasedDecoding   FiniteStateMachines   DecodingComplexity   SyntaxModelDecoding Evaluation   EvaluationCampaigns   ManualMetrics   TaskBasedMetrics   EditRateMetrics   NGramMetrics   SyntaxBasedMetrics   CorrelationOfMetrics   TrainedMetrics   TranslationDifficulty   StatisticalSignificance MachineLearning   WordGraphs   ParameterTuning   Reranking   LargeScaleDiscriminativeTraining   MinimumBayesRisk   ConfidenceMeasures   SystemCombination   IncrementalUpdating NeuralNetworkModels   NeuralLanguageModels   AttentionModel   Training   Inference   Coverage   Vocabulary   Embeddings   MultilingualWordEmbeddings   MonolingualData   Adaptation   LinguisticAnnotation   MultilingualMultimodalMultitask   AlternativeArchitectures   AnalysisAndVisualization   NeuralComponentsInStatisticalMachineTranslation add

  

  @InProceedings{dyer-EtAl:2011:ACL-HLT2011,
  author = {Dyer, Chris and Clark, Jonathan H. and Lavie, Alon and Smith, Noah A.},
  title = {Unsupervised Word Alignment with Arbitrary Features},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 49th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Techologies},
  month = {June},
  address = {Portland, Oregon, USA},
  publisher = {Association for Computational Linguistics},
  pages = {409--419},
  url = {http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/P11-1042},
  year = 2011
  }
  Dyer et al. (2011)